|
On October 24 2010 10:54 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2010 10:47 Coagulation wrote:
im DT and im checking DOCH
Medics plz save me 1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, 1 Sane Cop, 1 Doctor, 5 Townies. 1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, 7 Townies. 2 Mafia Goons, 1 Sane Cop, 6 Townies. 2 Mafia Goons, 1 Doctor, 6 Townies. There is quite possibly not a medic in this game. You are an idiot for roleclaiming.
DocH why are you so BM@me ?
What the fuck did i ever do to you? seriously ? All you have done is talk shit to me.
|
if there is not a medic i take a hit pandain is verify as green and lynch pops whatever it pops. you guys have good information to work with.
sorry im an idiot for not being experienced at mafia.
|
Day 3
As the seven survivors looked at each other suspiciously. One islander stepped forward. He was the detective. Claiming to know who caused the harm, he attempted to retake the island.
However, the islanders did not listen, and in their inactivity, they lynched annul
That night, loud bangs were heard, the survivors all hid in their tent. All but three, the detective and the two mafia. In a fight that poets would have immortalized if it occurred hundreds of years earlier, the detective held his own against the mafia. But alas, Coagulation was doomed to fail. His body was left outside of the camp, recognizable only by his golden badge.
annul the townie is dead
Coagulation the Detective is dead
Day 3 has started. It ends in 48 hours
|
|
|
On October 24 2010 10:57 Coagulation wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2010 10:54 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On October 24 2010 10:47 Coagulation wrote:
im DT and im checking DOCH
Medics plz save me 1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, 1 Sane Cop, 1 Doctor, 5 Townies. 1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, 7 Townies. 2 Mafia Goons, 1 Sane Cop, 6 Townies. 2 Mafia Goons, 1 Doctor, 6 Townies. There is quite possibly not a medic in this game. You are an idiot for roleclaiming. DocH why are you so BM@me ? What the fuck did i ever do to you? seriously ? All you have done is talk shit to me.
why would you roleclaim and depend on medic protection in a game where there is only a 25% chance of there being a medic/dt in the same game?
if you're being aggressively stupid in the thread I'll call you out. i don't have anything against you but i have something against the way you play this game and it hurts the town, obviously it did since you got yourself killed by roleclaiming : /
|
|
|
On October 24 2010 11:00 Coagulation wrote:
if there is not a medic i take a hit pandain is verify as green and lynch pops whatever it pops. you guys have good information to work with.
sorry im an idiot for not being experienced at mafia.
I play aggressively in mafia, don't take it personally. I hope you understand why you shouldn't have roleclaimed, that really has nothing to do with experienced, i just got the vibe that you didn't properly read the op or understand the way the game was constructed
|
Fuck. Got distracted by the giants game. Fail.
Well, we have one less person to check out, at least.
|
reading through the thread, I think it most likely that Dr H is mafia. He's been trying to play town against itself subtly, when you look at it.
Vote: Dr Helvetica
|
alright right now i don't need to justify actions so I'm just going to go with SFA
|
|
|
On October 24 2010 14:07 BrownBear wrote:
reading through the thread, I think it most likely that Dr H is mafia. He's been trying to play town against itself subtly, when you look at it.
Vote: Dr Helvetica
it'd be nice if you could point out how so I can tell you why you're wrong
attacking a player giving them no room to defend themself is scummy bro
|
oh fuck X(..... sorry coag :<....
VOTE## Pandain
|
On October 24 2010 15:08 NB wrote:
oh fuck X(..... sorry coag :<....
VOTE## Pandain
seriously?
he checked me. I'm clean.
how the fadoodle could I be mafia >
|
Alright, I am so confused. I have no idea what to do. If Dr. H was a normal player, I'd think he was town, but he's Dr. H and has some funky psychological mind tricks and stuff as mafia. So I'm just going to ignore him and hope that resolves itself.
I'm deciding between NB and Brownbear. Unfortunatenly I've had to use some out of game logic, but here's where that leads us.
1.Most likely, NB and Drag are not on the same team.
2.Even more likely, Brownbear and Dr. H are not on the same team.
While I hate using logic like this as its inherently uncertain and relies on what the host would do (aka, wifom), its just some musing I have. I don't think Drag is mafia, as he's usually inactive and really hasn't made any accusations, but that also could just be an inactive mafia lurking in the shadows. My utter confusion shows just how inexperienced I am, and I'm asking for Brownbear and Dr. H to start looking at some people so I can get more into thinking.
Brownbear has been less active, and should be posting more(in addition has not contributed heavily like he said he would start doing). NB has made several anti town things but I'm unsure whether that's just because he's new. Here's basically my case.
On October 23 2010 07:15 Pandain wrote:
NB
Summary: This guy is suscipcious to me. Now, he's new, so he gets a bit of leniancy, and I've explained some stuff to him, but some things stick out to me. For example, that whole "coag and Dr. H are scum buddies" He later admits there is no such obvious correlation, but how he came up with that in the first place I want to know. Also, he does the old "Lynch me, you'll find out I'm town." Which I never like, because it's just like your asking them to lynch you, but why would you do that if your town. Of course, townies do it alot, so I can't really judge this the best. His posts:+ Show Spoiler + On October 20 2010 15:37 NB wrote:Show nested quote +On October 20 2010 15:07 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
day 1 lynch is a crapshoot. our best bet is to RNG a vote and put pressure on the person who is being voted for. there really is no other way.
don't listen to any bullshit about how "we need to lynch whoever gives us the most information", that's mafia talk. it's used to draw up fake allegiances which benefit the mafia very clearly.
the more votes someone gets, the more defensive they get, the more likely they are to slip up if they're mafia.
I randomly pick [Vote]##BrownBear lololol voting on veteran players? LOLOLOL i see what you did there  [Vote]##DoctorHelvetica I can see this as a joke, with all the winky faces. But Dr. H is right, it could be an example of chainsaw defense(protecting brownbear by attacking Dr. H.) On October 20 2010 17:40 NB wrote:Show nested quote +On October 20 2010 16:08 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On October 20 2010 15:37 NB wrote:On October 20 2010 15:07 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
day 1 lynch is a crapshoot. our best bet is to RNG a vote and put pressure on the person who is being voted for. there really is no other way.
don't listen to any bullshit about how "we need to lynch whoever gives us the most information", that's mafia talk. it's used to draw up fake allegiances which benefit the mafia very clearly.
the more votes someone gets, the more defensive they get, the more likely they are to slip up if they're mafia.
I randomly pick [Vote]##BrownBear lololol voting on veteran players? LOLOLOL i see what you did there [Vote]##DoctorHelvetica the only player i don't know is lol1221 and i'm assuming it's korynne or dreamflower smurfing. also i wanted to say this to the town and this is the perfect time to do so: don't lynch people for defending other players. note in haunted mafia how veldril barely defended masq (which is reasonable cause day 1 lynch is a crapshoot anyhow) and then ended up getting lynched for it. the way mafia defend other mafia is by attacking the accuser, not by actually defending. nice chainsaw defense no, the good lesson is DO NOT PROTECT ANYONE =))... the fact that veldril should be lynched was created by me while i was the god-father xD (after masq died).... Alright, either this is an example that he's new, or this is an incrediably scummy post. In case he's new, I'll go over why medics should always protect someone. Basically, even if there is a 2/9 chance you'll protect someone who's mafia, that really doesn't matter. It's not like your helping mafia(no vigi) in any way besides protecting them, but thats the same thing as not protecting at all. With a possible two blues in this game, medics must always be protecting every night. On October 20 2010 20:18 NB wrote:Show nested quote +On October 20 2010 18:06 Coagulation wrote:On October 20 2010 17:40 NB wrote:On October 20 2010 16:08 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On October 20 2010 15:37 NB wrote:On October 20 2010 15:07 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
day 1 lynch is a crapshoot. our best bet is to RNG a vote and put pressure on the person who is being voted for. there really is no other way.
don't listen to any bullshit about how "we need to lynch whoever gives us the most information", that's mafia talk. it's used to draw up fake allegiances which benefit the mafia very clearly.
the more votes someone gets, the more defensive they get, the more likely they are to slip up if they're mafia.
I randomly pick [Vote]##BrownBear lololol voting on veteran players? LOLOLOL i see what you did there [Vote]##DoctorHelvetica the only player i don't know is lol1221 and i'm assuming it's korynne or dreamflower smurfing. also i wanted to say this to the town and this is the perfect time to do so: don't lynch people for defending other players. note in haunted mafia how veldril barely defended masq (which is reasonable cause day 1 lynch is a crapshoot anyhow) and then ended up getting lynched for it. the way mafia defend other mafia is by attacking the accuser, not by actually defending. nice chainsaw defense no, the good lesson is DO NOT PROTECT ANYONE =))... the fact that veldril should be lynched was created by me while i was the god-father xD (after masq died).... Do not protect anyone? That seems like a very anti town attitude to me.. cmon man, you all see what happened to veldril -.-... i mean u obviously should defends yourself but otherwise you would be consider as having a "teammate" and got lynch with him.... also how is it anti town? So stand out and protect a mafia is supporting town? Already discussed. I still find this scummy, but that view is tempered by the fact he's new. On October 21 2010 16:23 NB wrote:
jodogohoo got mafia ban?....
need an explanation on DrH latest post ~_~... how does that make him scum @_@... excuse me for being noob T_T asking for clarification. Nothing wrong I suppose, I need clarification all the time. On October 22 2010 07:49 NB wrote:i dun know.... the player who didnt vote yet should be a towny since he didn't communicated with anyone (aka. teammate) yet.... ~_~ it could be an afk mafia but most likely towny ~_~.... unvote##DR.H
Vote## jodogohoo good point I think, albeit it could just be an inactive mafia n.n On October 22 2010 09:41 NB wrote:
"ohhhhh shiiittttt! "(day9's voice)
jodogohoo bandwagon is formed xD Which you started, no? On October 22 2010 13:25 NB wrote:
[VOTE[##Coagulation
do i need a reason~_~? Yes, yes you do. Why would you vote without giving a reason, especially when it's pretty surprising On October 22 2010 15:07 NB wrote:
sr guys but Coag and Dr.H are kissing each other ass...
and what is the reason to lynch an afk player again? we are allowed to "miss lynch" 3 times or so but that doesnt mean we should random lynching people like that ~_~ Yeah, cause as Dr. H kindly pointed out, disagreeing with each on almost every issue is a sign of a stable bond. I do find the drag lynch somewhat surprising, as it is a little bit early, but we can also pressure him to post more. On October 22 2010 16:56 NB wrote:
here is the thing: i suggest u guys should all vote for me on day3 so that i could prove myself being a towny. after you all found out the im the towny, please lynch Dr.H and Coag since they are really kissing... I don't like this post because if he was townie: 1. Why would he want to be lynched at all 2. How would he know Dr. H and Coag are mafia. On October 23 2010 04:59 NB wrote:Show nested quote +On October 23 2010 02:26 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On October 23 2010 02:25 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On October 23 2010 01:40 BrownBear wrote:
so the smurf got targeted early. Kind of predictable, actually.
jodogohoo was town, which was unfortunate, but at the very least, we didn't kill off a more capable townie, I'm ok with that, kind of. Still don't like pointless deaths.
We aren't anywhere near LYLO yet, so we have some time to kill. The "vote drag_ to see how he responds" is ok, but we need more than that.
The coag vs NB thing - could be useful to lynch one? Of course, they could be two townies yelling at each other and letting mafia sit in the background. coag is defending pandain for no reason which pretty much means 1. he's the DT and he checked pandain 2. he's mafia and so is pandain 3. he's bad and just trusts pandain for no reason whatsoever If I had to vote between the two of them, I'd go with NB to elaborate on that NB is trying to draw up alliances between players that dont exist. a classic mafia strategy is trying to make it seem like certain players of the town are "allied together" and make them seem suspicious. lolol, you described what i did in the haunted mafia xD.... but i admit what you pointed out is true and i had a flaw in my logic ... life go on ^^ Alright, so you addmited that that was a horrible breach in logic and there is no such alliance. I have no idea how you came up with this in the first place.
In addition, he voted me even though I've been checked by coag.
##Unvote Dr. H
##Vote NB
+ Show Spoiler +so confused
|
On October 24 2010 15:23 Pandain wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2010 15:08 NB wrote:
oh fuck X(..... sorry coag :<....
VOTE## Pandain seriously? he checked me. I'm clean. how the fadoodle could I be mafia >
proof for he checking you?
|
On October 24 2010 10:48 Coagulation wrote:
in case i die
There are 5 people who are possible reds
DocH BrownBear Drag_ NB Annul
not me.
|
[Vote]##NB
Sorry I can't really be too active today. I have a lot of shit to do
I'm voting NB because he is scummy to me for the following reasons:
1. doesn't commit to his arguments
2. defense by way of attack
3. draws fake connections between players (mafia do this to either a. bus a scumbuddy to make themselves innocent, b. incriminate an innocent townie if a scumbuddy dies, c. put the FoS on 1/2 of a townie-townie alliance)
4. offers to get lynched (possible bus to save scumbuddy)
|
|
|
On October 25 2010 07:10 Pandain wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2010 10:48 Coagulation wrote:
in case i die
There are 5 people who are possible reds
DocH BrownBear Drag_ NB Annul not me.
sr man, if your name is not on the list, it means that he has not checked you YET!! and dont tell me he is detective, what if he got role blocked?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
