|
On June 09 2013 09:17 takingbackoj wrote:Show nested quote +On June 09 2013 08:21 FabledIntegral wrote:
You can tell all the ppl bitching about power rank were not here in BW times.
I'd say every single person from BW knows not to take it as a fact, and the vast majority enjoy it. It's wholly subjective and it's very clearly obvious that it is. If you are familiar with other sports then you would know this as well. The whole point of power rankings is to ignite disagreement and debate. Ive yet to see an NFL PR in my 17 years of fandom that I didn't hate with a passion but also love reading and talking about at the same time. The only one who loses with PR's is the ranker himself. Everyone thinks hes a biased idiot no matter what.
Aww, and I was thinking the person who did the rankings was pretty smart... I agreed almost completely 
|
MVP and sOs proving their haters wrong in the WCS season 1 global finals
|
United States8477 Posts
I counted up the disagreements made in this thread:
On the debate between Soulkey and Innovation:
- Innovation > Soulkey: 39
- Soulkey > Innovation: 23
On Hero's placement in #10
- Hero deserves the spot: 20
- Hero does not deserve the spot: 10
- Kangho deserves it over Hero: 7
- Hero deserves it over Kangho: 5
- Kangho does not deserve it(Implying Hero deserves it): 3
- MVP deserves it over Hero: 8
- Hero deserves it over MVP: 10
- MVP does not deserve it(Implying Hero deserves it): 2
- Bomber deserves it over Hero 1
- TY deserves it over HerO 1
- Jangbi deserves it over HerO: 1
- Hero should have been higher: 1
On placements 3-9:
- Soulkey should have been lower: 1
- Flash should have been higher: 2
- Flash should have been lower: 6
- Flash should have been over Soulkey: 1
- Rain should have been over Flash: 3
- Rain should have been lower: 2
- Symbol should have been lower: 10
- Symbol should have been higher: 1
- Symbol should have been over Rain: 1
- RorO should have been lower: 3
- RorO should have been over Symbol: 3
- Life should have been higher: 8
- Life should have been lower: 2
- Life's placement is good: 3
- Life should have been over Flash: 1
- Life should have been over Rain: 1
- Life should have been over Symbol: 3
- Life should have been over Roro: 3
- sOs should have been lower: 2
- Parting should have been lower: 4
Others:
- Jangbi should have been in CBNC: 2
- Kangho should have been higher: 1
- Leenock should have been on the list: 1
- MVP should have been over RorO: 1
|
Bisutopia19400 Posts
On June 09 2013 14:13 monk wrote:I counted up the disagreements made in this thread: + Show Spoiler +On the debate between Soulkey and Innovation:- Innovation > Soulkey: 39
- Soulkey > Innovation: 23
On Hero's placement in #10- Hero deserves the spot: 20
- Hero does not deserve the spot: 10
- Kangho deserves it over Hero: 7
- Hero deserves it over Kangho: 5
- Kangho does not deserve it(Implying Hero deserves it): 3
- MVP deserves it over Hero: 8
- Hero deserves it over MVP: 10
- MVP does not deserve it(Implying Hero deserves it): 2
- Bomber deserves it over Hero 1
- TY deserves it over HerO 1
- Jangbi deserves it over HerO: 1
- Hero should have been higher: 1
On placements 3-9:- Soulkey should have been lower: 1
- Flash should have been higher: 2
- Flash should have been lower: 6
- Flash should have been over Soulkey: 1
- Rain should have been over Flash: 3
- Rain should have been lower: 2
- Symbol should have been lower: 10
- Symbol should have been higher: 1
- Symbol should have been over Rain: 1
- RorO should have been lower: 3
- RorO should have been over Symbol: 3
- Life should have been higher: 8
- Life should have been lower: 2
- Life's placement is good: 3
- Life should have been over Flash: 1
- Life should have been over Rain: 1
- Life should have been over Symbol: 3
- Life should have been over Roro: 3
- sOs should have been lower: 2
- Parting should have been lower: 4
Others:- Jangbi should have been in CBNC: 2
- Kangho should have been higher: 1
- Leenock should have been on the list: 1
- MVP should have been over RorO: 1
You totally disregarded the Bisu count!
|
Haha. You're crazy, monk. :D
|
I think MVP is definitely making it next month :p
|
On June 09 2013 15:49 FrostedMiniWheats wrote:
I think MVP is definitely making it next month :p
He didn't beat anyone in the top 10.
|
On June 09 2013 15:51 jalstar wrote:Show nested quote +On June 09 2013 15:49 FrostedMiniWheats wrote:
I think MVP is definitely making it next month :p He didn't beat anyone in the top 10.
He beat the #1 player twice, what do you mean?
|
The heated and (un)reasonable discussions in here makes this Power Rank a wothy successor to the SC:BW one.
Wonderful 
|
On June 09 2013 15:51 jalstar wrote:Show nested quote +On June 09 2013 15:49 FrostedMiniWheats wrote:
I think MVP is definitely making it next month :p He didn't beat anyone in the top 10.
So...?
He barely lost to the #1 and had a good run overall AND still has his EU win. That's more than I can say for some on this list currently.
|
Did MVP had an easier road to WCS S1 because he went to Europe?
|
On June 08 2013 23:21 Magbane wrote:
It seems that TL writers always try to make themselves sound like they are The fact source. Like this "power rank", which is 100% arbitrary and biased, yet they are trying to make that list sound like its somekind of fact.
What is the fucking point of that list? it has no real value. Hell, even TLPD is not good enough ranking system to define best players, its actually very bad system. According to TLPD, current best sc2 player is Life, give me a break here.
My god, you are ridiculously pissed off about this. Stop taking it so seriously.
|
United States97277 Posts
Can we talk some more about this now that the season finals are over?
|
Bogus cemented at #1 as he should have been
MVP broke into the list as far as I'm concerned.
Symbol rank down
sOs up
HerO out
|
On June 09 2013 14:13 monk wrote:I counted up the disagreements made in this thread: On the debate between Soulkey and Innovation:- Innovation > Soulkey: 39
- Soulkey > Innovation: 23
On Hero's placement in #10- Hero deserves the spot: 20
- Hero does not deserve the spot: 10
- Kangho deserves it over Hero: 7
- Hero deserves it over Kangho: 5
- Kangho does not deserve it(Implying Hero deserves it): 3
- MVP deserves it over Hero: 8
- Hero deserves it over MVP: 10
- MVP does not deserve it(Implying Hero deserves it): 2
- Bomber deserves it over Hero 1
- TY deserves it over HerO 1
- Jangbi deserves it over HerO: 1
- Hero should have been higher: 1
On placements 3-9:- Soulkey should have been lower: 1
- Flash should have been higher: 2
- Flash should have been lower: 6
- Flash should have been over Soulkey: 1
- Rain should have been over Flash: 3
- Rain should have been lower: 2
- Symbol should have been lower: 10
- Symbol should have been higher: 1
- Symbol should have been over Rain: 1
- RorO should have been lower: 3
- RorO should have been over Symbol: 3
- Life should have been higher: 8
- Life should have been lower: 2
- Life's placement is good: 3
- Life should have been over Flash: 1
- Life should have been over Rain: 1
- Life should have been over Symbol: 3
- Life should have been over Roro: 3
- sOs should have been lower: 2
- Parting should have been lower: 4
Others:- Jangbi should have been in CBNC: 2
- Kangho should have been higher: 1
- Leenock should have been on the list: 1
- MVP should have been over RorO: 1
I wonder why you didn't count my opinion ?!
|
United States8477 Posts
On June 09 2013 18:06 Otolia wrote:Show nested quote +On June 09 2013 14:13 monk wrote:I counted up the disagreements made in this thread: On the debate between Soulkey and Innovation:- Innovation > Soulkey: 39
- Soulkey > Innovation: 23
On Hero's placement in #10- Hero deserves the spot: 20
- Hero does not deserve the spot: 10
- Kangho deserves it over Hero: 7
- Hero deserves it over Kangho: 5
- Kangho does not deserve it(Implying Hero deserves it): 3
- MVP deserves it over Hero: 8
- Hero deserves it over MVP: 10
- MVP does not deserve it(Implying Hero deserves it): 2
- Bomber deserves it over Hero 1
- TY deserves it over HerO 1
- Jangbi deserves it over HerO: 1
- Hero should have been higher: 1
On placements 3-9:- Soulkey should have been lower: 1
- Flash should have been higher: 2
- Flash should have been lower: 6
- Flash should have been over Soulkey: 1
- Rain should have been over Flash: 3
- Rain should have been lower: 2
- Symbol should have been lower: 10
- Symbol should have been higher: 1
- Symbol should have been over Rain: 1
- RorO should have been lower: 3
- RorO should have been over Symbol: 3
- Life should have been higher: 8
- Life should have been lower: 2
- Life's placement is good: 3
- Life should have been over Flash: 1
- Life should have been over Rain: 1
- Life should have been over Symbol: 3
- Life should have been over Roro: 3
- sOs should have been lower: 2
- Parting should have been lower: 4
Others:- Jangbi should have been in CBNC: 2
- Kangho should have been higher: 1
- Leenock should have been on the list: 1
- MVP should have been over RorO: 1
I wonder why you didn't count my opinion ?!
Because it's a dumb opinion.
|
Vatican City State431 Posts
WCS finals proved that this Power Rank was good. All Kespa players qualified from groups and Innovation won. MVP still hasn't proved that he can beat top Kespa players. Also Proleague has the best players by far. In both WCS Korea and WCS finals 3 semi-semifinalists were Kespa players.
|
On June 09 2013 18:03 FrostedMiniWheats wrote:
Bogus cemented at #1 as he should have been
MVP broke into the list as far as I'm concerned.
Symbol rank down
sOs up
HerO out
yeah... go mvp. EU represent!
|
On June 09 2013 18:11 p14c wrote:
WCS finals proved that this Power Rank was good. All Kespa players qualified from groups and Innovation won. MVP still hasn't proved that he can beat top Kespa players.
Once again, Mvp beat Innovation twice, yes he lost the series but he was the only player at the finals to give Innovation trouble. Soulkey probably could have done the same but he's already #2 on the list and current GSL champion so that surprises no one.
|
Whilst I do think MVP (and the terran side bracket in general) had an easier run-in, I think he also deserves a place in the Power Rank above Hero. Not terribly impressed with Roro or Symbol either.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
