So I have a list of everyone who abused by trading after the matches started. What's an appropriate punishment? I'm thinking either a -20 trade tax penalty or reverting all trades.

monk

United States8477 Posts

May 03 2013 22:15 GMT

#442

LOL

xxpack09

United States2160 Posts

May 03 2013 22:24 GMT

#443

-30 trade tax sounds good imho

Koerage

Netherlands1220 Posts

May 03 2013 22:33 GMT

#444

revert the trades and a -abs(x) penalty where x = amount of points gained through the trade (abs so people who did a stupid trade also lose points)
would that be possible?

R1CH

Netherlands10342 Posts

May 03 2013 23:44 GMT

#445

I'm not entering results until the trades are fixed, so we won't know any gain / loss.

Waxangel

United States33681 Posts

May 04 2013 01:01 GMT

#446

ROCK YOU LIKE A HURRICANE

Patchouli

Australia42 Posts

May 04 2013 01:08 GMT

#447

Between the options I'd lean more towards the -20 trade penalty or Koerage's suggestion so there's some definite penalty for trying to abuse, reverting trades only seems pretty lenient imo since it makes it in some cases just like they didn't try to do it at all.

crawlingchaos

Canada2025 Posts

May 04 2013 01:14 GMT

#448

Well, let this be a lesson in greed to all.

I actually traded for Hurricane before the match started, but undid my trade for Madbull after seeing that he didn't play to salvage the -1 trade tax... which somehow undid my Hurricane trade as well x.x

...do I still get punished even though I don't have the points from Hurricane anymore?

vrok

Sweden2541 Posts

May 04 2013 01:25 GMT

#449

I traded for Hurricane like 10 minutes before the broadcast started! Don't kill my FGSTL team plz! TT

StarVe

Germany13591 Posts

May 04 2013 01:25 GMT

#450

Punish them all!

Glad I already had Hurricane, no need to trade. And I can only move up after today's results, best ones possible except if I also had FXO as a team. Need Byun to all-kill tomorrow then.

StarVe

Germany13591 Posts

May 05 2013 18:50 GMT

#451

In case someone forgot, results for this week are still missing. In case you didn't have the time to do it, I'm sorry, carry on.

Taefox

1533 Posts

May 05 2013 20:20 GMT

#452

My anti-team was : MMA - Scralet and SortOf =) all of sudden they're all inactive or left Korea
sweet

edit: Sorry for posting here but my FPL team, i picked Woongjin and got Woongjin Stars -1 ? Is it a bug or sth?

StarVe

Germany13591 Posts

May 05 2013 20:42 GMT

#453

On May 06 2013 05:20 Porishan wrote:
My anti-team was : MMA - Scralet and SortOf =) all of sudden they're all inactive or left Korea
sweet

edit: Sorry for posting here but my FPL team, i picked Woongjin and got Woongjin Stars -1 ? Is it a bug or sth?

Quote from the FPL announcement thread:

Team Scoring:
+ Show Spoiler [Click to Show] +

4-0 Victory: 6 Points
4-1 Victory: 4 Points
4-2 Victory: 3 Points
4-3 Victory: 2 Points
3-4 Defeat: 1 Point
2-4 Defeat: 0 Points
1-4 Defeat: -1 Point
0-4 Defeat: -2 Points

geokilla

Canada8255 Posts

May 06 2013 00:39 GMT

#454

Because TL made a mistake, I believe TL should reverse the trades and nothing more.

Sagamantha

United States339 Posts

May 06 2013 09:01 GMT

#455

This breaks my heart. Here I was thinking that I would finally get some solid points off of trading (I traded before the matches), now no one knows what is going on

. I might cry!

Zeon0

Austria2995 Posts

May 06 2013 12:29 GMT

#456

i want an update, i got Hurricane!^^

opterown

Australia54784 Posts

May 07 2013 09:44 GMT

#457

ByuL

BBoongBBoong
(P)

Avenge <Akilon Wastes> (Z)

DongRaeGu

starters for GSTL this week!

Devolved

United States2753 Posts

May 08 2013 04:39 GMT

#458

I tried reporting the problem, but it didn't get fixed in time. People started talking about how they were making trades during the match. Even though I wanted the problem fixed, it was not fixed, so I did not want to be left behind and made a trade as well. If I get punished, whatever, but the majority of the fault lies with TL imo. GSTL starts at the same time on the same day every week. It shouldn't be that difficult to set the timer for the trades. Also, this was the second time I reported a bad timer on FGSTL trades. The first time it was fixed before the match started.

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=410901
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=406330

Mairu

United States222 Posts

May 08 2013 05:39 GMT

#459

So is fantasy gstl fucked for the rest of the season? I didn't even know about the trade mix up until checking the thread to see if anyone knew why there was no update yet :[

elmizzt

United States3309 Posts

May 08 2013 05:56 GMT

#460

It blows my mind that people can admit to cheating by taking advantage of an obvious error that will be fixed, yet still try to shove the blame off themselves.