EPT[NASL] Announcing The Pulse (Weekly Talkshow) - Page 7
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
fer
Canada375 Posts
| ||
|
Fragile51
Netherlands15767 Posts
Again. Great first show guys! :D | ||
|
crbox
Canada1180 Posts
| ||
|
Tobblish
Sweden6404 Posts
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=392456¤tpage=6#107 Left out that I would like to see recent event scores etc because you will include that next time. | ||
|
nooboon
2602 Posts
Some criticisms: the overhead camera angle needs to be changed, the low camera shots were good but the general overhead view of the 5 casters looked weird. Also Elise's location felt really out of place. She either needed to be part of the main desk (and contribute to the discussion) or further off to the side. | ||
|
MrBitter
United States2940 Posts
On January 15 2013 04:18 Tobblish wrote: Feedback The Bad Not so updated information on all the news. - A lot of TSL members was made aware of that TSL would close down. Players didn't have salary and even had to pay to keep the house alive at some points. - Parting left ST because they wouldn't pay him a higher salary, same with Squirtle. You speculated if it was because of the $$ but the info was out there. - JD is on loan but if T8 gets a sponsor he will still remain until the end period of his contract. (Bitter hinted at he would leave EG as soon as T8 finds a sponsor) - KeSPAs relation with OGN, OGN are now only broadcasting PL on Sat/Sun and left out the other days, because they want to focus on LoL instead of SC2. - KeSPA players can only attend MLG because of their contract(outside of Korea), if they want to go to another event they have to talk with MLG. The HUGE lower UI bar covering up a lot when showing in game footage, hell it takes up 1/8 of the screen. http://i.imgur.com/RfljO.jpg <- I mean why douse it have to be this big? 0o Interact more with chat, you missed some info that was given to you via there. Don't know if Lauren is the right person for this and it felt weird having her in the corner laughing. Bo1 vs BoX, majority Team Leagues with Bo1, maybe a reason? Clutch was making a point for it but it felt like it was ignored that it was TEAM leagues that had bo1 format. Hell how would a Team league look if there was a bo3? :s Missed some pretty big team news like Col and Fnatic closing down their team houses. Axiom opening up a team house. The Good Love that you actually have all 5 and Lauren sitting at the same desk. The interaction, discussion and camera angels feels so much better. All the different personalities! The inside scoop and info you get because of your status as casters and organizes. That you include relevant media with your topic. Short movies of the HOTS changes, pictures of players etc. The "breaking news" of Parting. -------- All in all I enjoyed the show and will for sure stay up here in Sweden to watch. Would have been fun to know why KeSPA banned talking ingame  + Show Spoiler + Players psyching players? ^^ When I read your first posts I thought you were dumb. But this is very nicely formatted and you raise great points. Thank you. <3 Next show will be in two weeks, guys. I'll make sure we get an official mp3 version up somewhere, but it will be Wednesday/Thursday at the earliest. | ||
|
ThreeActPlay
United States249 Posts
| ||
|
TigerKarl
1757 Posts
-I liked that the discussions didn't get out of hand, but i want to make you aware of that you shouldn't make the discussions feel scripted. For example i liked that little videos and pictures were shown, they added a lot actually, but when Clutch talked about baseball you showed a picture fitting to that topic and it made me wonder how much this show is actually scripted beforehands. I think it's important that you find the right balance between prepared content and lively authentic discussion. -Lauren Elise was integrated in a strange way, i feel that everything she can contribute will run dry really quick in a few episodes. I'd much rather see one of the 5 guys take over the part of the community interaction, while stil giving his legit opinion on topics. You should try to invite interesting player personalities into the show, to give their opinion on things. Even though i believe that Gretorp, Bitter and Rotti can argue on a quite high level about race and pro gaming issues, the thoughts of a current professional gamer can have a value if he's got the personality to talk in such a show. -If you're planning on doing this weekly, then there might not be as much to talk about as on this week, so be aware of how to fill that with content, since the duration of this weeks show was very good. I think having a guest on can fill things nicely, but talking about the big issues of E-Sports also has a place on The Pulse, since the acting persons have enough credibility and knowlegde to talk about this. Overall a very sweet thing to give to the community, i hope it continues, improves and people appreciate it, because this definitly has a place in the SC2 scene! | ||
|
ReachTheSky
United States3294 Posts
On January 15 2013 11:20 MrBitter wrote: When I read your first posts I thought you were dumb. But this is very nicely formatted and you raise great points. Thank you. <3 Next show will be in two weeks, guys. I'll make sure we get an official mp3 version up somewhere, but it will be Wednesday/Thursday at the earliest. I'd like a daily episode, k thanks.  | ||
|
MrBitter
United States2940 Posts
On January 17 2013 01:28 TigerKarl wrote: -This was better for a first episode than i hoped and the NASL guys have shown us in the past that they respond to community feedback and have developed quite a good feeling themselves to where they can improve things. With the production value of a real studio this talk show offers something unique. -I liked that the discussions didn't get out of hand, but i want to make you aware of that you shouldn't make the discussions feel scripted. For example i liked that little videos and pictures were shown, they added a lot actually, but when Clutch talked about baseball you showed a picture fitting to that topic and it made me wonder how much this show is actually scripted beforehands. I think it's important that you find the right balance between prepared content and lively authentic discussion. -Lauren Elise was integrated in a strange way, i feel that everything she can contribute will run dry really quick in a few episodes. I'd much rather see one of the 5 guys take over the part of the community interaction, while stil giving his legit opinion on topics. You should try to invite interesting player personalities into the show, to give their opinion on things. Even though i believe that Gretorp, Bitter and Rotti can argue on a quite high level about race and pro gaming issues, the thoughts of a current professional gamer can have a value if he's got the personality to talk in such a show. -If you're planning on doing this weekly, then there might not be as much to talk about as on this week, so be aware of how to fill that with content, since the duration of this weeks show was very good. I think having a guest on can fill things nicely, but talking about the big issues of E-Sports also has a place on The Pulse, since the acting persons have enough credibility and knowlegde to talk about this. Overall a very sweet thing to give to the community, i hope it continues, improves and people appreciate it, because this definitly has a place in the SC2 scene! Re: Scripting - The show is scripted in that we know what the bullet points we are going to touch before we start. To use your example, I knew that Clutch would make the baseball reference to Proleague beforehand. What I did not know, was what other points he would make. In other words, the questions, and to some extent, the major rebuttal points are known beforehand, but the conversation is completely candid. - We're looking for better ways to use Lauren. Expect some new fresh stuff from her in future episodes. - Weekly might be a bit of a strain. Right now our plan is bi-weekly. If we can do more, we will. Time will ultimately determine how often we try and produce the show. Also: Podcast should be out today/tomorrow! | ||
|
skeldark
Germany2223 Posts
Im used to it in TV (i think its still this way, did not watch tv for years) but sad to see its the same in the sc2 community. | ||
|
StarStruck
25339 Posts
On January 15 2013 11:20 MrBitter wrote: When I read your first posts I thought you were dumb. But this is very nicely formatted and you raise great points. Thank you. <3 Next show will be in two weeks, guys. I'll make sure we get an official mp3 version up somewhere, but it will be Wednesday/Thursday at the earliest. You know I went through the comments first to see what kind of feedback people were giving before watching. I'm glad to say I didn't start watching. If you guys are going to do a news show it's kind of important to get your facts straight. I don't want to sound like an ass but it sort of defeats the purpose because you would be giving people false information which is a pretty big no-no. You read his comment and thought he was dumb... I want to know why exactly? From reading the bad section the guy was right on point when it came to the facts. Sounds like he's been paying more attention to forums whereas you guys have been busy doing your thing. At least have someone check the facts prior to the discussion. Use crypt notes. You guys don't have to do it yourselves. Delegate it to one person who has a good filter and checks the scene regularly. Shit. Tobblish sounds like a good candidate from his breakdowns from what I read. You need to have a good filter and know what's fact and fiction. Everyone needs to be on the same page. * As for Tobblish, - I've seen the chat rooms before and they're horrendous with trolls. Sure some people might provide useful information, but often than not? Noooo. Like I said delegate one person to track topics and who can get to the heart of the matter. - Best of One's are used in team leagues because of time constraints. It would simply run too long and considering OGN broadcasts PL on certain days. TV format demands it. * I'll comment on the good when I have time to tune in. | ||
|
OMGKEI
Australia590 Posts
| ||
|
Tminus____
249 Posts
 since its still one of the first few shows . | ||
|
flakmonkey
Australia254 Posts
| ||
|
ziggurat
Canada847 Posts
I would suggest that you make it a little shorter. Like maybe 45 minutes tops? You may run out of things to talk about if you try to do a 2+ hr show every week. | ||
|
MrBitter
United States2940 Posts
On January 21 2013 11:09 flakmonkey wrote: Where can we find the podcast? Sorry about delays on the podcast. We've got the mp3 ready, but the boss wants to get an RSS feed set up before we put it up for download. Hopefully this week. >.< Next Show is this Sunday at 7PM. Lots of fun stuff to discuss. Hope you all tune in. | ||
|
orllyfools
United States153 Posts
| ||
NASL.tv
699 Posts
 | ||
|
ReachTheSky
United States3294 Posts
On January 27 2013 08:09 NASL.tv wrote: Updated with Archive section and new episode information! Podcast information will be up soon, just finalizing details. Awesome! Been waiting for episode 2 since the first one aired haha. | ||
| ||
