Most people are simply using this thread to label Terran as overpowerd. Fuck you guys.
Why are there so many good Korean Terrans? - Page 15
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Techno
1900 Posts
Most people are simply using this thread to label Terran as overpowerd. Fuck you guys. | ||
|
Takezou
United States320 Posts
On June 13 2011 08:01 Sueco wrote: Terran is overrepresented in the GSL because they are a well-rounded race with basic units that are powerful enough to grant a BO win on their own against a superior player (think the OGSTop vs Nestea games). Aside from that, Terran is a swiss army knife of options, each of them potentially lethal if unscouted. I actually believe T players are among the worst in the tournament. There's a lot of middling code-A/code-S terran players that populate the leagues by snatching wins off unlucky baneling hits or split-second mistakes on forcefields. There are no real talents that can do what MC or Nestea do with their respective races. If only Nestea and MC are better than the terrans it really doesn't say much does it? | ||
|
WaZ
United States108 Posts
| ||
|
Mailing
United States3087 Posts
On June 13 2011 08:07 Techno wrote: The question of the thread is: why are there so many Terrans at the top of the Korean ladder, but not in the middle of the korean ladder, and why is this trend not reflected in NA? Most people are simply using this thread to label Terran as overpowerd. Fuck you guys. No, this thread is pointing out that terran has always had the most standout players since release basically. If you look at every top 8 from every GSL, more than 50% of them are terrans, and most GSL are usually 3T1Z or 3T1P or at least 2 terrans. There are few standout players from each race in korae right now Zerg -> NesTea / Losira / July Protoss -> MC / Alicia Terran -> MVP, MKP, TOP, MMA, Ryung, Clide, NaDa, sC, Polt, Bomber, Jinro More often than not, 2-3 of these terran make top 8, and their number is rising ![]() Nothing to do with balance, these are all good players. It just makes no sense that zerg and protoss have so few amazing players. Players like Zenio or Genius or Tester or FruitDealer tend to hit a strong opponent and fizzle out somewhere in the Ro64/32/16 | ||
|
akalarry
United States1978 Posts
| ||
|
Mailing
United States3087 Posts
![]() Though Jinro has been in a slump, he has still been in 2 (or was it 1?) RO4s and would be extremely high ranked if the 2010 GSLs counted for ranking | ||
|
Denzil
United Kingdom4193 Posts
| ||
|
Yaotzin
South Africa4280 Posts
On June 13 2011 08:24 Mailing wrote: Nothing to do with balance, these are all good players. It just makes no sense that zerg and protoss have so few amazing players. Players like Zenio or Genius or Tester or FruitDealer tend to hit a strong opponent and fizzle out somewhere in the Ro64/32/16 They are good players certainly. There's little doubt though that Terran is still the strongest race. Not by much anymore, but still. Terran is just much, much easier to be consistent at, it seems. The relative immunity to cheese/allins, the relatively stable metagame. Not sure how people can say Terran is hard really, they're clearly the easiest race to get very good at. | ||
|
Chocobo
United States1108 Posts
Pretty much everyone has tried out all of the races and gone with whichever race feels best for them. Everyone has a different style and some races fit their style better than others. Terran being stupidly OP in beta probably did affect things for beta players, it made it more likely for terran to feel like "that works for my style" when everything in general worked well for them. But I think without a doubt it's the versatility of terran that causes more people to say "that fits how I want to play this game". You can open with high pressure builds like bunker rush or hellion harrass or marine/SCV allin, or you can open with a careful, super-safe bunker and expansion build. You can harrass with banshees or try a blue flame hellion drop, without taking a big risk and leaving yourself wide open to attack... while a zerg going baneling bust or a protoss going straight to DTs is likely betting the whole game to try it. In the mid-game you can be so busy with constant marine drops while doing the usual map control and expansion. The only non-terran comparable thing is muta harrass, which can be easier to counter. In the mid to late game terran's upgrades become more and more valuable, too. They always have that core army of marines/marauders, which all benefit greatly from upgrades. An opposing army of muta/ling/infestor for instance doesn't scale upwards in power nearly as well. Having the feeling of "my units are always strong" and never having the feeling of "I'm getting outclassed by upgraded units, but I can't afford to upgrade everything" gives terran more of a playable feel to them and gets a few more players to decide that's the way to go for them. I cannot explain why this trend of terrans at the top only exists in Korea and not in NA or EU. It's not as if our top players lack the ability to take full advantage of things like marine drops. | ||
|
JustPlay
United States211 Posts
T: I want to play really well and do well as a result. I want a race with no weaknesses that can handle anything thrown at it. I want to leave very little to chance. Z: I want to be able to decisively take the lead for predicting what my opponent is doing, auto lose some of my games, auto win some of my games, and overall I feel I will come out with a higher winrate (in tournaments, against equally skilled players*) than any other race. P: I feel like I can abuse forcefield, warp ins, blink, and/or a very strong but impossible to reinforce should I lose key parts of it army to win games Air units as a whole should be reworked with BW taken in to consideration. The range and damage of something like a banshee is ridiculous when you compare it to a spore crawler, queen, or a cannon. Void rays are the only unit that sort of has it right. Mineral saturation of SC2 vs BW is bad design. It makes cheese and all-ins too strong with too solid of a follow up, and it causes economy to feel like it ramps up too slowly because it encourages super saturation instead of trying to get up more bases with ~8 dudes on them. Double gas is a big offender here too, maybe lower it to 2 guys per geyser or something. Inject Larva is bad design. Combined with SC2 saturation it makes zerg too vulnerable in the early game and their units not cost effective enough overall. It also allows zerg to pull too far ahead in a lot of situations. Protoss is designed poorly in general. Forcefield has no relevant answer for T/Z which is poor design, because it forces them to balance the race around it and P suffers as a result. They must change how forcefield works if they want protoss to be a viable race. Colossus has no place in the protoss tech tree because it invalidates nearly all of their t2.5+ tech. Whoever didn't speak up against it deserves to be fired, because at what point does "let's give protoss a unit that does what high templar do but more mobile and better, oh and it is countered by the same thing as carriers, mother ships, void rays, and phoenix" sound like a good idea? Colossus can never be balanced because it will be useless or too good, there's no middle ground on a unit that fills the same role as other units and in some cases even shares their counter. Colossus are balanced vs T/Z, but colossus are a broken unit if you are a protoss player because they are making your race suck. Forcefield is the same thing. Yeah, it's fun to use because you know you are breaking the rules and killing way more than you should be, but it's not really like that when your race MUST use it to survive the early-mid game. It's hurting you, the protoss player, with its current design. This is not a balance whine. I think it's likely that Z may be the strongest tournament race (by a few percent), but at the same time T is highly competitive because it's the traditionally strongest race in current SC2. As T you take the initiative and win the game for yourself. You can't sit back and wait, which is probably why they aren't as popular on NA/EU where you have zergs just wanting to macro to infinity or protoss trying to 200/200 1a. *hilariously, Z probably has the highest loss rate vs players who are worse than you | ||
|
godemperor
Belgium2043 Posts
On June 13 2011 08:45 Chocobo wrote: I don't buy the "role models" argument at all. How many of you chose your race solely because of what you saw someone else doing with it? I doubt very many. Many BW pro said the likes of NaDa, Boxer and iloveoov as why they chose terran, so when they made the transition to SC2, they stuck with the race. Also MKP said boxer was his inspiration in an interview in GSL2 and theBest also said he choose terran to be like NaDa in the first group choosing ceremony just to name a few example. On June 13 2011 08:45 Chocobo wrote: I cannot explain why this trend of terrans at the top only exists in Korea and not in NA or EU. It's not as if our top players lack the ability to take full advantage of things like marine drops. This is why I'm suggestion the "role-model" idea, since BW had a much bigger influence on SC2 in Korea than the foreign scene. (where many top players are WC pro) | ||
|
crabz
227 Posts
| ||
|
godemperor
Belgium2043 Posts
On June 13 2011 09:00 crabz wrote: the same reason why in bw terran was so popular between koreans Sorry, I only followed BW briefly from 08-09, can you explain bit more? Also this answer is pretty useless, since most of the SC2 fans did not actively follow BW since its orgin. | ||
|
Warpath
Canada1242 Posts
Then I became a flash fan and never considered changing from T ever again. :D | ||
|
iamho
United States3347 Posts
| ||
|
crabz
227 Posts
On June 13 2011 09:04 godemperor wrote: Sorry, I only followed BW briefly from 08-09, can you explain bit more? Also this answer is pretty useless, since most of the SC2 fans did not actively follow BW since its orgin. because of boxer koreans love terran everybody wants to be like him, look on kespa rankings T is on the top majority of the time and nobody claims imbalance there On June 13 2011 08:41 Yaotzin wrote: They are good players certainly. There's little doubt though that Terran is still the strongest race. Not by much anymore, but still. Terran is just much, much easier to be consistent at, it seems. The relative immunity to cheese/allins, the relatively stable metagame. Not sure how people can say Terran is hard really, they're clearly the easiest race to get very good at. yea toss is the weakest, pvz imba ahaha what a delusional and biased sad person you are,.cant read a single topic without seeing you whinning about something | ||
|
Syben
United States512 Posts
| ||
|
Xaoz
Germany146 Posts
On June 13 2011 09:11 crabz wrote: because of boxer koreans love terran everybody wants to be like him, look on kespa rankings T is on the top majority of the time and nobody claims imbalance there Well... in BW only Flash is imbalanced. But back to topic: Terran is just solid and safe. They have bunkers, scan and a damn strong army with marines, marauders. Terran can choose how the game is played Macro/All In like no other race. Also you can do alot with micro! Kiting/Dropping for example like with no other race. This is what makes Terran solid and very strong. | ||
|
lowercase
Canada1047 Posts
| ||
|
NickelStarCraft
26 Posts
I've notced a dichotomy in terran latley. Long before this thread, that NA Terrans suck, Euro Terrans are very competitve, but tend to lag somewhat behind their Zerg and Protoss counterparts (thorzain and to a lesser extent Kas excluded), But in Korea Terran is King. There's not a balance issue here as so many complain about. The Meta game changes so quickley that previuosly strong races become the weaker race very quickly, the recent change in PvZ with Zerg surging proves that point. The simple answere is this: 1. Pros leaving the Broodwar scene in Korea wanted to win and win fast. The race quickly identified early in SC2's history as the best was Terran. Combined with Flash ruling Broodwar as Terran, Boxer/Nada playing terran, Terran known as the "Skill" race in Broodwar. All these factors led to a huge percentage of these players playing Terran. 2. Terrans style lends itself to Korean style of play. Terrans have first strike capability with the cost effectivness and power of Bio + stim + Medvacs. With Koreans favoring a very aggressive style of play, playing terran offers many opportunities to win quickley, before Zerg or Toss can gain the upper hand. 3. Mechanics. SC2 Terran is much the same as Broodwar terran in that it offers opportunity for players with great mechanics. Theres a ton of micro involved in Marine splitting vs banelings, multiple drop harass or microing ghosts+Vikings+Bio vs Protoss Colossus ball. For Masters and Grand Masters players even, this micro is too much, and they get chewed up. But high level korean players with stellar Mechanics handle this very demanding micro/multi-tasking and win games that lesser skilled players cannot. This is not a balance issue. No more than Terran was Imbalanced in Brood War, casue it wasn't. The combination of Terran being strongest during release, terran having a histoy of champions in BW, and Terran offering opportunities with great micro/multi-tasking(A style Koreans love) has produced a flood of quality terrans inside Korea not seen anywhere else. This will taper down over time, but at the highest levels of play, because of how Terran works, it may always offer advantages to supremly skilled players that give it an edge over the other 2 races. Just my Opinion. P.S. On June 13 2011 08:01 Sueco wrote: Terran is overrepresented in the GSL because they are a well-rounded race with basic units that are powerful enough to grant a BO win on their own against a superior player (think the OGSTop vs Nestea games). Aside from that, Terran is a swiss army knife of options, each of them potentially lethal if unscouted. oGsTOP outplayed Nestea in that series. In the previous round Nestea manhandled a very skilled Terran in STBomber, and nobody cried Zerg OP. Bomber is in fact better than TOP, but TOP outplayed Nestea that day, Bomber didn't, it had nothing to do with race. When MVP or Thorzain or MC lose to a percieved less skilled player, the instant cry is not "OP". Zerg for some reason cannot control themselves or fathom Idra or Nestea losing to weaker players. It happens. Flash loses to weaker players, as does everyone. Its not balance. | ||
| ||

