|
On June 13 2011 11:20 godemperor wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 11:13 avilo wrote: I read the OP. Are we really trying to bring back subtly disguised "T OP" threads and bandwagoning? It got tiring in the beta with players of each race and pros of their race encouraging bandwagoners, it's still tiring now.
In MLG, there were not as many T in the top as Z/P. In other tournaments it is different. In super tournament there ended up being a lot of Terrans. People play Terran because they like it...the entire OP seems to be trying to guide people to an inane conclusion that Terran is imbalanced because of current super tournament standings.
Standings change tournament from tournament. If it were z/z/z/z or p/p/p/p that does not mean that "why are there so many good korean zergs/protosses." It just means that those players happened to rise to the top at that current time in the game, and it could be for a variety of reasons, some having to do with balance, with maps, with the individual players, etc.
All this thread does is promote a resurgence of balance bandwagoning. Reading lots of replies in this thread, you can already see replies of that nature starting to crop up again.
Why can't people watch a SC2 tournament like the brood war players do brood war MSL/OSL matches.
It's such a relief sometimes when I enter a stream chat of a MSL match, bw teamleague, or what not and the people in chat are actually talking about the games and the players and their attributes and skills instead of "oh he plays that race, why does he play that race, it must be OP."
You never hear and read, "wow siege tanks OP." "Wow dark swarm OP." "Protoss imba." Instead you hear and read, "wow great siege tank positioning there," "wow clutch timing on the swarm," "excellent arbiter recall placement and nice stasis fields."
Maybe the thing the OP and bandwagoners can take from this thread is, "Why are there so many good korean players."
Stop trying to make the forums your own personal balance bandwagon propaganda machine. /rant
I am trying to find out why terran is dominating in Korea and not in outside of it, it was not meant to be a balance whine thread (see red text), just to figure out what is so different between the 2 scenes are that most of talents choose terran in korea. Some people see the words terran and dominating and assume its about balance, I did the best I can but it was not enough. If you choose to see this thread as a terran OP thread, I can't stop you, ,to each their own i guess.
I read the red text. Just because you put a disclaimer on it doesn't mean this thread is not what it is.
It's your perception that Terran is dominating korea. I do not think they are dominating korea, others may not think so, or they may, but if I wanted to make such a radical claim I would go find some statistics and put some effort behind it to prove it.
Hell, not even just statistics. Go into analyzing a series of games, analyze the players, their tendencies, their styles, etc. because other wise it just is completely your either semi-informed or completely uninformed opinion that all of a sudden Terran is dominating korea.
If you want to be more accurate, you can say "Terran players are dominating super tournament, why is that?" And then you can go on to propose things like the maps, player skill, etc. but all you're doing in your OP is, whether you like or not, when you get down into the nitty gritty, you're trying to make a case for Terran being OP, despite your magical red text.
Unless you actually are playing in korea, I don't think you can make such general claims that Terran is dominating just because of 1 tournament.
Some people actually read your entire OP, and regardless of your intentions it's going to get bandwagoners to be like "OH YAH HE'S RIGHT!!111!!! Terran OP!" You even "jokingly" made a balance remark in your OP, which basically is an example of what i'm talking about and really doesn't do anything other than encourage more of "oh yeah, this race is stronger than that race."
Also, i'm not buying that you don't want to bring up balance stuff when you "jokingly" felt it necessary to include this in your OP:
On June 12 2011 14:33 godemperor wrote:
Terran is OP: Reasoning: Terran requires no skills! Good reason? Sorry, my inner frustrated zerg came out.
yeah...
|
how do so many people say Terran is OP?
just because their are more terran pros doesn't mean its op, how can you guys make that correlation? go by results not by which race is more popular.
|
PlayXP tournament where ro8 was 7 terrans + Nestea. Then you have a terran showing up in nearly every GSL final. You also had terrans being the majority of players who managed to qualify for the first 3 GSL opens. This isn't an isolated incident.
Edit: Took a look at Korea GM, Top 10 is 9 terran, 1 toss. And I recall mostly seeing terran dominate the KR ladder with a few exceptions off the top of my head such as DRG topping the ladder at one point or Genius topping it during beta/release.
|
On June 13 2011 12:07 avilo wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 11:20 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 11:13 avilo wrote: I read the OP. Are we really trying to bring back subtly disguised "T OP" threads and bandwagoning? It got tiring in the beta with players of each race and pros of their race encouraging bandwagoners, it's still tiring now.
In MLG, there were not as many T in the top as Z/P. In other tournaments it is different. In super tournament there ended up being a lot of Terrans. People play Terran because they like it...the entire OP seems to be trying to guide people to an inane conclusion that Terran is imbalanced because of current super tournament standings.
Standings change tournament from tournament. If it were z/z/z/z or p/p/p/p that does not mean that "why are there so many good korean zergs/protosses." It just means that those players happened to rise to the top at that current time in the game, and it could be for a variety of reasons, some having to do with balance, with maps, with the individual players, etc.
All this thread does is promote a resurgence of balance bandwagoning. Reading lots of replies in this thread, you can already see replies of that nature starting to crop up again.
Why can't people watch a SC2 tournament like the brood war players do brood war MSL/OSL matches.
It's such a relief sometimes when I enter a stream chat of a MSL match, bw teamleague, or what not and the people in chat are actually talking about the games and the players and their attributes and skills instead of "oh he plays that race, why does he play that race, it must be OP."
You never hear and read, "wow siege tanks OP." "Wow dark swarm OP." "Protoss imba." Instead you hear and read, "wow great siege tank positioning there," "wow clutch timing on the swarm," "excellent arbiter recall placement and nice stasis fields."
Maybe the thing the OP and bandwagoners can take from this thread is, "Why are there so many good korean players."
Stop trying to make the forums your own personal balance bandwagon propaganda machine. /rant
I am trying to find out why terran is dominating in Korea and not in outside of it, it was not meant to be a balance whine thread (see red text), just to figure out what is so different between the 2 scenes are that most of talents choose terran in korea. Some people see the words terran and dominating and assume its about balance, I did the best I can but it was not enough. If you choose to see this thread as a terran OP thread, I can't stop you, ,to each their own i guess. I read the red text. Just because you put a disclaimer on it doesn't mean this thread is not what it is. It's your perception that Terran is dominating korea. I do not think they are dominating korea, others may not think so, or they may, but if I wanted to make such a radical claim I would go find some statistics and put some effort behind it to prove it. Hell, not even just statistics. Go into analyzing a series of games, analyze the players, their tendencies, their styles, etc. because other wise it just is completely your either semi-informed or completely uninformed opinion that all of a sudden Terran is dominating korea. If you want to be more accurate, you can say "Terran players are dominating super tournament, why is that?" And then you can go on to propose things like the maps, player skill, etc. but all you're doing in your OP is, whether you like or not, when you get down into the nitty gritty, you're trying to make a case for Terran being OP, despite your magical red text. Unless you actually are playing in korea, I don't think you can make such general claims that Terran is dominating just because of 1 tournament. Some people actually read your entire OP, and regardless of your intentions it's going to get bandwagoners to be like "OH YAH HE'S RIGHT!!111!!! Terran OP!" You even "jokingly" made a balance remark in your OP, which basically is an example of what i'm talking about and really doesn't do anything other than encourage more of "oh yeah, this race is stronger than that race." If you really feel that way, guess there no point arguing with you. Also no one in these 15 pages have yet to doubt the dominance of terran in Korea.
|
On June 13 2011 12:14 godemperor wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 12:07 avilo wrote:On June 13 2011 11:20 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 11:13 avilo wrote: I read the OP. Are we really trying to bring back subtly disguised "T OP" threads and bandwagoning? It got tiring in the beta with players of each race and pros of their race encouraging bandwagoners, it's still tiring now.
In MLG, there were not as many T in the top as Z/P. In other tournaments it is different. In super tournament there ended up being a lot of Terrans. People play Terran because they like it...the entire OP seems to be trying to guide people to an inane conclusion that Terran is imbalanced because of current super tournament standings.
Standings change tournament from tournament. If it were z/z/z/z or p/p/p/p that does not mean that "why are there so many good korean zergs/protosses." It just means that those players happened to rise to the top at that current time in the game, and it could be for a variety of reasons, some having to do with balance, with maps, with the individual players, etc.
All this thread does is promote a resurgence of balance bandwagoning. Reading lots of replies in this thread, you can already see replies of that nature starting to crop up again.
Why can't people watch a SC2 tournament like the brood war players do brood war MSL/OSL matches.
It's such a relief sometimes when I enter a stream chat of a MSL match, bw teamleague, or what not and the people in chat are actually talking about the games and the players and their attributes and skills instead of "oh he plays that race, why does he play that race, it must be OP."
You never hear and read, "wow siege tanks OP." "Wow dark swarm OP." "Protoss imba." Instead you hear and read, "wow great siege tank positioning there," "wow clutch timing on the swarm," "excellent arbiter recall placement and nice stasis fields."
Maybe the thing the OP and bandwagoners can take from this thread is, "Why are there so many good korean players."
Stop trying to make the forums your own personal balance bandwagon propaganda machine. /rant
I am trying to find out why terran is dominating in Korea and not in outside of it, it was not meant to be a balance whine thread (see red text), just to figure out what is so different between the 2 scenes are that most of talents choose terran in korea. Some people see the words terran and dominating and assume its about balance, I did the best I can but it was not enough. If you choose to see this thread as a terran OP thread, I can't stop you, ,to each their own i guess. I read the red text. Just because you put a disclaimer on it doesn't mean this thread is not what it is. It's your perception that Terran is dominating korea. I do not think they are dominating korea, others may not think so, or they may, but if I wanted to make such a radical claim I would go find some statistics and put some effort behind it to prove it. Hell, not even just statistics. Go into analyzing a series of games, analyze the players, their tendencies, their styles, etc. because other wise it just is completely your either semi-informed or completely uninformed opinion that all of a sudden Terran is dominating korea. If you want to be more accurate, you can say "Terran players are dominating super tournament, why is that?" And then you can go on to propose things like the maps, player skill, etc. but all you're doing in your OP is, whether you like or not, when you get down into the nitty gritty, you're trying to make a case for Terran being OP, despite your magical red text. Unless you actually are playing in korea, I don't think you can make such general claims that Terran is dominating just because of 1 tournament. Some people actually read your entire OP, and regardless of your intentions it's going to get bandwagoners to be like "OH YAH HE'S RIGHT!!111!!! Terran OP!" You even "jokingly" made a balance remark in your OP, which basically is an example of what i'm talking about and really doesn't do anything other than encourage more of "oh yeah, this race is stronger than that race." If you really feel that way, guess there no point arguing with you. Also no one in these 15 pages have yet to doubt the dominance of terran in Korea.
You just proved my point.
|
On June 13 2011 12:15 avilo wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 12:14 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 12:07 avilo wrote:On June 13 2011 11:20 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 11:13 avilo wrote: I read the OP. Are we really trying to bring back subtly disguised "T OP" threads and bandwagoning? It got tiring in the beta with players of each race and pros of their race encouraging bandwagoners, it's still tiring now.
In MLG, there were not as many T in the top as Z/P. In other tournaments it is different. In super tournament there ended up being a lot of Terrans. People play Terran because they like it...the entire OP seems to be trying to guide people to an inane conclusion that Terran is imbalanced because of current super tournament standings.
Standings change tournament from tournament. If it were z/z/z/z or p/p/p/p that does not mean that "why are there so many good korean zergs/protosses." It just means that those players happened to rise to the top at that current time in the game, and it could be for a variety of reasons, some having to do with balance, with maps, with the individual players, etc.
All this thread does is promote a resurgence of balance bandwagoning. Reading lots of replies in this thread, you can already see replies of that nature starting to crop up again.
Why can't people watch a SC2 tournament like the brood war players do brood war MSL/OSL matches.
It's such a relief sometimes when I enter a stream chat of a MSL match, bw teamleague, or what not and the people in chat are actually talking about the games and the players and their attributes and skills instead of "oh he plays that race, why does he play that race, it must be OP."
You never hear and read, "wow siege tanks OP." "Wow dark swarm OP." "Protoss imba." Instead you hear and read, "wow great siege tank positioning there," "wow clutch timing on the swarm," "excellent arbiter recall placement and nice stasis fields."
Maybe the thing the OP and bandwagoners can take from this thread is, "Why are there so many good korean players."
Stop trying to make the forums your own personal balance bandwagon propaganda machine. /rant
I am trying to find out why terran is dominating in Korea and not in outside of it, it was not meant to be a balance whine thread (see red text), just to figure out what is so different between the 2 scenes are that most of talents choose terran in korea. Some people see the words terran and dominating and assume its about balance, I did the best I can but it was not enough. If you choose to see this thread as a terran OP thread, I can't stop you, ,to each their own i guess. I read the red text. Just because you put a disclaimer on it doesn't mean this thread is not what it is. It's your perception that Terran is dominating korea. I do not think they are dominating korea, others may not think so, or they may, but if I wanted to make such a radical claim I would go find some statistics and put some effort behind it to prove it. Hell, not even just statistics. Go into analyzing a series of games, analyze the players, their tendencies, their styles, etc. because other wise it just is completely your either semi-informed or completely uninformed opinion that all of a sudden Terran is dominating korea. If you want to be more accurate, you can say "Terran players are dominating super tournament, why is that?" And then you can go on to propose things like the maps, player skill, etc. but all you're doing in your OP is, whether you like or not, when you get down into the nitty gritty, you're trying to make a case for Terran being OP, despite your magical red text. Unless you actually are playing in korea, I don't think you can make such general claims that Terran is dominating just because of 1 tournament. Some people actually read your entire OP, and regardless of your intentions it's going to get bandwagoners to be like "OH YAH HE'S RIGHT!!111!!! Terran OP!" You even "jokingly" made a balance remark in your OP, which basically is an example of what i'm talking about and really doesn't do anything other than encourage more of "oh yeah, this race is stronger than that race." If you really feel that way, guess there no point arguing with you. Also no one in these 15 pages have yet to doubt the dominance of terran in Korea. You just proved my point. Well if you think everyone else is blind i can't do much.
Writing that just made me think of this so i guess its not all bad.
"Boy, I've got vision and the rest of the world is wearing bi-focals." From Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid Such a great film, gunna end this on a positive point.
|
I like how thinking Terran is OP is being a troll, when it's entirely possible at this point in the games life cycle
|
On June 12 2011 15:06 Veritassong wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 15:03 travis wrote: Am I allowed to say what I think? lol
(if I made a list of things I thought were OP in sc2 like 75% of them would belong to terran) 65% for me of course terran units are way more cost effective. thats the point. remember, terrans mine minerals slower than other factions, due to inferior worker acceleration. so they need compensation to make up for it
|
Simple. As it is now, Terran is the most dynamic race. Protoss may be a little OP, but if you want to maximize cost/benefit, Terran is the way to go. There are more possibilities as a Terran than any other race, and the top Terran Koreans show us that
|
Protoss may be a little OP
What makes you say that
|
Wrong section - thought we were talking about BW... oh wait
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
avilo complaining about people complaining about balance may very well be the absolute pinnacle of irony.
Should this moment be bested... god help us.
|
This thread is just a disguised "Terran is OP" thread. I hope the mods close this as it does not encourage constructive discussion..
|
On June 13 2011 13:32 StarcraftMan wrote: This thread is just a disguised "Terran is OP" thread. I hope the mods close this as it does not encourage constructive discussion..
It's only as constructive as you make it to be, there were some good posts in last couple of pages regarding BW's influence on Sc2. Also your post is not very contructive
|
A lot of koreans played terran in Brood war as well, it just so happens a good number of them switch over.
At least, that's my opinion
|
Out of all three races I find that Terran has gone through the least change. Protoss went through the 4gate -> Heavy colossus VR -> High Templar -> random archons, and zergs now use infestors to a much greater extend then before along with broodlords/infestor/ling. Terrans are still kind of just stuck on rax units with medivacs and hoping to overpower with 3/3 marines/marauders.
Players like MMA who do crazy (crazy because I have no idea how you would manage it) multi-pronged drops with marines to take out key infrastructures of the opponent is kind of disguising the fact that Terran doesn't have a clear late game transition such as colossus/VR for Protoss and Infestor/Broodlord/Ultra for Zerg. Battlecruisers aren't exactly great and Thor/tank just isn't goliath/tank. In this sense Terrans who have superior upgrade timings and bio army control are dominanting their games, whereas Z/P players who can handle bio pressure can easily swing the game to their favour.
Terran isn't op, nor is any other race, but the man or woman playing the race may make it seem so.
|
I may have it wrong, but outside of the Star players, isn't the BW scene dominated mainly by Protoss?
|
On June 13 2011 13:36 godemperor wrote: Also your post is not very contructive
What is "contructive"?
|
On June 13 2011 13:32 iNcontroL wrote: avilo complaining about people complaining about balance may very well be the absolute pinnacle of irony.
LOL
|
On June 13 2011 13:32 iNcontroL wrote: avilo complaining about people complaining about balance may very well be the absolute pinnacle of irony.
Should this moment be bested... god help us.
ah there you are, I was wondering how long it would take you to comment on a random forum post of mine, making references to threads and arguments from 8+ months ago under the assumption that people are static and unchanging in their philosophies.
+ Show Spoiler +
|
|
|
|
|
|