|
On June 13 2011 08:07 Techno wrote: The question of the thread is: why are there so many Terrans at the top of the Korean ladder, but not in the middle of the korean ladder, and why is this trend not reflected in NA?
Most people are simply using this thread to label Terran as overpowerd. Fuck you guys.
What did you expect? Seriously, bad protosses and zergs are using this thread as an excuse to whine.
All the moronic cries of "TERRAN OP!" are just useless.
Let's for the sake of the argument, say that Terran ARE overpowered.
That STILL doesn't answer why there are so many better Terrans. When MVP, Bomber, MKP, NaDa or MMA beat a protoss or a zerg, do people cry out imbalance? Apart from a few particularly stupid zerg whiners, no they don't.
That's because they're BETTER. If those players were only winning because of imbalance, people would be bitching about it.
|
i believe that Koreans really want to win more than anything else, and when sc2 came out Terrans were a very reliable and well rounded safe race. If you wanted to win many games you'd pick terran so the players who really wanted a stable career picked Terran.
They also cant switch back since it would kill their skill.
|
about the "strong in beta"
im sorry , but wasnt that ZERG?
lets see- King of beta tournament idra won Zerg. now as the game gets released,
First GSL = zerg won, fruitdealer Second GSL = zerg won, nestea
Mind you this is when the map pool was small maps like steps of war. This rambling is still confusing up to this day.
|
On June 13 2011 10:25 jinixxx123 wrote: about the "strong in beta"
im sorry , but wasnt that ZERG?
lets see- King of beta tournament idra won Zerg. now as the game gets released,
First GSL = zerg won, fruitdealer Second GSL = zerg won, nestea
Mind you this is when the map pool was small maps like steps of war. This rambling is still confusing up to this day.
Zerg wasn't op during the time you're talking about (after the roach nerf). FD and Nestea won because they were the best players at the time. FD is usually credited with being the first person to figure out how to play zerg. Nestea was just a powerhouse at the time but even then barely beat foxer who was on fire. I really think season 2 would have gone to foxer (and it almost did). The kid was on such a hot streak in season 2. Just a random no name player from the ladder who burst into the scene and stomped everyone.
|
On June 13 2011 10:25 jinixxx123 wrote: about the "strong in beta"
im sorry , but wasnt that ZERG?
lets see- King of beta tournament idra won Zerg. now as the game gets released,
First GSL = zerg won, fruitdealer Second GSL = zerg won, nestea
Mind you this is when the map pool was small maps like steps of war. This rambling is still confusing up to this day. That's why the wins by FD and to a certain extent by Nestea were so special, because by all reason a terran should have won gsl 1. (rainbow was just sooo bad in the finals)
|
So why are Korean Terrans so much better than Korean Z/P but NA Terrans aren't that much better than NA Z/P??
|
On June 13 2011 10:34 Techno wrote: So why are Korean Terrans so much better than Korean Z/P but NA Terrans aren't that much better than NA Z/P?? That is the question that im trying to ask, so far it seems to be (if you ignore all the comments not regarding koreans exclusively) that terran suite korean's aggressive style and terran was popular in BW due to the BW legends.
|
On June 13 2011 10:34 Techno wrote: So why are Korean Terrans so much better than Korean Z/P but NA Terrans aren't that much better than NA Z/P??
Just my opinion: terran is the most mechanically demanding race. In korea, where the players pride themselves upon playing 10 hours a day to fine tune those mechanics, they end up being heavily rewarded for their play.
Foreign terrans do not have the same mechanics. Honestly name me a foreign terran who can split marines like mkp and mvp or a terran who can drop 4 places at once like mma. Because foreigners lack the powerful mechanics of the koreans, they don't see the huge reward that comes with terran and thus aren't much better than NA Z/P.
I've switched around races many times since beta but have ended up with terran. If I were to give 2 words to define the races, it would be
terran: mechanics/multitasking zerg: game sense/map awareness/control and army positioning protoss: micro/execution and strategy/timing
Crap..I used more than 2 words for some -_-
|
I absolutely disagree with the reason of "We are human, terran is human, we like to play terran".
The reason I so strongly disagree is because we are living in this human world, and are trying to get away from it and have fun by playing video games. Who the hell wants to be themselves in a video game? There's two mysterious, baller races to pick, and you pick HUMAN?! It's like WoW. Who the hell picks human as their race besides people that are >12 or <40?
|
On June 13 2011 10:38 godemperor wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 10:34 Techno wrote: So why are Korean Terrans so much better than Korean Z/P but NA Terrans aren't that much better than NA Z/P?? That is the question that im trying to ask, so far it seems to be (if you ignore all the comments not regarding koreans exclusively) that terran suite korean's aggressive style and terran was popular in BW due to the BW legends. Yea man I know. Unfortunetly in the best of your efforts the thread kinda got derailed. Its a really interesting question though.
On June 13 2011 10:38 rysecake wrote: Just my opinion: terran is the most mechanically demanding race. In korea, where the players pride themselves upon playing 10 hours a day to fine tune those mechanics, they end up being heavily rewarded for their play.
I think you are right. In my mind, Terran is the best race when a good plan is executed perfectly, and is much, much worse than Zerg and Protoss when played at a North American Diamond level. The stats reflect this as well. We see Terrans being the least represented in the Diamond league with the lowest points as well. I know for myself that I struggled to advance once I hit Diamond as Terran. I had to play literally hundreds of games against Masters players before I could compete in Diamond.
|
On June 13 2011 10:46 Techno wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 10:38 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 10:34 Techno wrote: So why are Korean Terrans so much better than Korean Z/P but NA Terrans aren't that much better than NA Z/P?? That is the question that im trying to ask, so far it seems to be (if you ignore all the comments not regarding koreans exclusively) that terran suite korean's aggressive style and terran was popular in BW due to the BW legends. Yea man I know. Unfortunetly in the best of your efforts the thread kinda got derailed. Its a really interesting question though. We still made more progress than I thought possible, i thought the thread will be closed within 1 hours despite the red text I put in the OP.
|
On June 13 2011 10:51 godemperor wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 10:46 Techno wrote:On June 13 2011 10:38 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 10:34 Techno wrote: So why are Korean Terrans so much better than Korean Z/P but NA Terrans aren't that much better than NA Z/P?? That is the question that im trying to ask, so far it seems to be (if you ignore all the comments not regarding koreans exclusively) that terran suite korean's aggressive style and terran was popular in BW due to the BW legends. Yea man I know. Unfortunetly in the best of your efforts the thread kinda got derailed. Its a really interesting question though. We still made more progress than I thought possible, i thought the thread will be closed within 1 hours despite the red text I put in the OP. Frankly, I kinda already knew the answer:
Terran is the best race at the highest skill level and the lowest skill level, but isn't in between.
I just wanted to see if people agreed with this sentiment. The stats reflect this idea as well. We see Terrans dominating the top and bottom of the ladder, but not so inbetween.
However it is strange how in North America we see way more Zergs than we do in Korea, and with higher win rates as well.
|
I read the OP. Are we really trying to bring back subtly disguised "T OP" threads and bandwagoning? It got tiring in the beta with players of each race and pros of their race encouraging bandwagoners, it's still tiring now.
In MLG, there were not as many T in the top as Z/P. In other tournaments it is different. In super tournament there ended up being a lot of Terrans. People play Terran because they like it...the entire OP seems to be trying to guide people to an inane conclusion that Terran is imbalanced because of current super tournament standings.
Standings change tournament from tournament. If it were z/z/z/z or p/p/p/p that does not mean that "why are there so many good korean zergs/protosses." It just means that those players happened to rise to the top at that current time in the game, and it could be for a variety of reasons, some having to do with balance, with maps, with the individual players, etc.
All this thread does is promote a resurgence of balance bandwagoning. Reading lots of replies in this thread, you can already see replies of that nature starting to crop up again.
Why can't people watch a SC2 tournament like the brood war players do brood war MSL/OSL matches.
It's such a relief sometimes when I enter a stream chat of a MSL match, bw teamleague, or what not and the people in chat are actually talking about the games and the players and their attributes and skills instead of "oh he plays that race, why does he play that race, it must be OP."
You never hear and read, "wow siege tanks OP." "Wow dark swarm OP." "Protoss imba." Instead you hear and read, "wow great siege tank positioning there," "wow clutch timing on the swarm," "excellent arbiter recall placement and nice stasis fields."
Maybe the thing the OP and bandwagoners can take from this thread is, "Why are there so many good korean players."
Stop trying to make the forums your own personal balance bandwagon propaganda machine. /rant
|
On June 13 2011 11:13 avilo wrote: I read the OP. Are we really trying to bring back subtly disguised "T OP" threads and bandwagoning? It got tiring in the beta with players of each race and pros of their race encouraging bandwagoners, it's still tiring now.
In MLG, there were not as many T in the top as Z/P. In other tournaments it is different. In super tournament there ended up being a lot of Terrans. People play Terran because they like it...the entire OP seems to be trying to guide people to an inane conclusion that Terran is imbalanced because of current super tournament standings.
Standings change tournament from tournament. If it were z/z/z/z or p/p/p/p that does not mean that "why are there so many good korean zergs/protosses." It just means that those players happened to rise to the top at that current time in the game, and it could be for a variety of reasons, some having to do with balance, with maps, with the individual players, etc.
All this thread does is promote a resurgence of balance bandwagoning. Reading lots of replies in this thread, you can already see replies of that nature starting to crop up again.
Why can't people watch a SC2 tournament like the brood war players do brood war MSL/OSL matches.
It's such a relief sometimes when I enter a stream chat of a MSL match, bw teamleague, or what not and the people in chat are actually talking about the games and the players and their attributes and skills instead of "oh he plays that race, why does he play that race, it must be OP."
You never hear and read, "wow siege tanks OP." "Wow dark swarm OP." "Protoss imba." Instead you hear and read, "wow great siege tank positioning there," "wow clutch timing on the swarm," "excellent arbiter recall placement and nice stasis fields."
Maybe the thing the OP and bandwagoners can take from this thread is, "Why are there so many good korean players."
Stop trying to make the forums your own personal balance bandwagon propaganda machine. /rant
I am trying to find out why terran is dominating in Korea and not in outside of it, it was not meant to be a balance whine thread (see red text), just to figure out what is so different between the 2 scenes are that most of talents choose terran in korea. Some people see the words terran and dominating and assume its about balance, I did the best I can but it was not enough. If you choose to see this thread as a terran OP thread, I can't stop you, ,to each their own i guess.
|
look at the amount of great terran players compered to other races in korea and u will have your answer
|
On June 13 2011 11:13 avilo wrote: People play Terran because they like it...the entire OP seems to be trying to guide people to an inane conclusion that Terran is imbalanced because of current super tournament standings.
I understand your feelings but I think your knee jerking a little bit, because there is actually a lot of Korean Terrans at the top of the Korean Ladder, but not so in the middle of the Korean ladder or the top of the NA ladder.
There is actually an interesting discussion to be had here.
|
On June 13 2011 11:20 godemperor wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 11:13 avilo wrote: I read the OP. Are we really trying to bring back subtly disguised "T OP" threads and bandwagoning? It got tiring in the beta with players of each race and pros of their race encouraging bandwagoners, it's still tiring now.
In MLG, there were not as many T in the top as Z/P. In other tournaments it is different. In super tournament there ended up being a lot of Terrans. People play Terran because they like it...the entire OP seems to be trying to guide people to an inane conclusion that Terran is imbalanced because of current super tournament standings.
Standings change tournament from tournament. If it were z/z/z/z or p/p/p/p that does not mean that "why are there so many good korean zergs/protosses." It just means that those players happened to rise to the top at that current time in the game, and it could be for a variety of reasons, some having to do with balance, with maps, with the individual players, etc.
All this thread does is promote a resurgence of balance bandwagoning. Reading lots of replies in this thread, you can already see replies of that nature starting to crop up again.
Why can't people watch a SC2 tournament like the brood war players do brood war MSL/OSL matches.
It's such a relief sometimes when I enter a stream chat of a MSL match, bw teamleague, or what not and the people in chat are actually talking about the games and the players and their attributes and skills instead of "oh he plays that race, why does he play that race, it must be OP."
You never hear and read, "wow siege tanks OP." "Wow dark swarm OP." "Protoss imba." Instead you hear and read, "wow great siege tank positioning there," "wow clutch timing on the swarm," "excellent arbiter recall placement and nice stasis fields."
Maybe the thing the OP and bandwagoners can take from this thread is, "Why are there so many good korean players."
Stop trying to make the forums your own personal balance bandwagon propaganda machine. /rant
I am trying to find out why terran is dominating in Korea and not in outside of it, it was not meant to be a balance whine thread (see red text), just to figure out what is so different between the 2 scenes are that most of talents choose terran in korea. Some people see the words terran and dominating and assume its about balance, I did the best I can but it was not enough. If you choose to see this thread as a terran OP thread, I can't stop you, ,to each their own i guess.
I'd assume its partially because of all the Terran BW Bonjwas.
|
you only picked the best of the best for toss and zerg for chart but you picked some terrans who haven't done much
|
On June 13 2011 11:28 Drazzyo wrote: you only picked the best of the best for toss and zerg for chart but you picked some terrans who haven't done much edit: I miss read your post, see the post below mine for answer. Also why do people never read? And then ask stupid questions.
|
On June 13 2011 11:28 Drazzyo wrote: you only picked the best of the best for toss and zerg for chart but you picked some terrans who haven't done much That isn't an arbitrary chart, it is the current ELO ranking of all competitive Korean players based on official tournament wins/loses.
http://www.teamliquid.net/tlpd/sc2-korean/players
|
|
|
|
|
|