|
On June 13 2011 03:20 godemperor wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 03:09 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:07 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 03:06 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:04 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 01:55 godemperor wrote: Sorry for using red, but I really want to stress why this dominance is not present in the NA/EU scene (both recent tournament wins and ELO show zerg and protoss are putting up a good fight).
Also I dont agree that Koreans are so close to the skill cap that it will show that terran is the best race. (games only been out for just over a year)
So why is Terran so dominant in KOREA? Some of you still do not like to read...oh well... Because the answer is obvious 70% of this posts are: Complexity and that Terran was op at that time. So why is the EU/NA terran player not as dominating? 1. There are not as many ( obviously ) 2. The race isnt imbalanced anymore (remember when Terrans won over 70% of all small tournaments according to TL stats month ago) 3. Again, not nearly as much real progamers people picked up Terran. 4. I feel like the chances of terran doing better in tournaments are higher as there they are not confronted with random all-ins as much as for example zerg. 5. Different play-style (?) 6. Quite a few of those korean players started later with sc2 when T was clearly too strong while most western players started playing instantly after release or picked their races during beta 1. why are not there not more good EN/NA terran? 2. Korean terran still dominate 3. again why? 4. that does not argue why terran are not as dominating. 5. bit general 6. most of the "newer" SC2 pro were all bw pro, in which they played terran.
1. Because they picked another race???? what kind of question is that 2. I dont see korean terrans dominate in any tournament except GSL SUPER Tournament, do you? If you can name one aside from MLG ill raise my hat to you 3. Because as i said before "Quite a few of those korean players started later with sc2 when T was clearly too strong while most western players started playing instantly after release or picked their races during " 4. 5. Yet kinda true 6. Most EU / NA pros picked up different races, e.g Incontrol, Idra, etc.
|
IMO the answer is different depending on whether you're talking about the bad Terran players (Rain, Polt, Hyperdub) or the good Terran players (MVP, Bomber, MMA)
The reason weak players like Rain, Polt and Hyperdub play Terran is probably because in the beta phase and for a short time after, Terran was the most powerful race and didnt require much thought to play (mass MMM and attack)
The reason strong players like MVP, Bomber and MMA play Terran is because of their Brood War background. The players they idolized (Boxer, Nada) played Terran, and Terran was considered the race most powerful in the hands of a skilled player in Brood War.
IMHO, of course.
There seems to have been less race-switching amongst the Koreans for some reason. Artosis, Idra and Morrow are all former foreign Terrans who switched race because they felt SC 2 Terran wasnt as rewarding for skilled players as BW Terran. The strong Korean Terran players like Nada, Boxer, MVP etc didnt see fit to do that.
|
Probably the music...... liike the brood war terran theme
|
Yes, and I honestly think that it's because of the BW legends reason. BW Terran demanding extreme amounts of attention and practice (maybe a bit more than then other races), so when the players made the switch to sc2 Terran, which is much much less demanding, they began to dominate.
I think there will be more zerg in the top 10 when HotS comes out, though.
Also, I played the beta from time to time but was much too busy for SC at the time. Was terran OP? I just remember those roaches. Those damn roaches.
|
Terran has the highest skill ceiling, the most things you can do with a lot of skill. If a player has infinite skill, he will benefit most from playing Terran. Also, they were OP in the beta, so maybe people chose them then and stuck with the race.
I'm a Zerg btw.
|
Personally I think that the Terran units are a little bit more stable than the units from the other races. Even if the unit comp isnt perfect they can still put on a great fight. This would be especially true for the marines, appart from the AoE/splash units they are a very solid unit to fall back on when your overall unit comp doesnt look as good.
|
Terran race is most versatile, especially in the opening phases. Also, the number of lategame possibilities are endless, what I don't get is why do people refuse to make sensor tower, raven and stuff they just don't do because of the idiotic MMM mixture. Seems like koreans are more flexible in thinking outside the box - yeah most of the thinking is planned ahead and practiced to perfection, but I guess terran is the race that has reached the least in percentage of potential. But what do you expect, seeing how 12 years into the game some dude discoveres in BW's ZvT that mass queens work vs terran!
|
On June 13 2011 03:24 Keula wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 03:20 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 03:09 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:07 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 03:06 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:04 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 01:55 godemperor wrote: Sorry for using red, but I really want to stress why this dominance is not present in the NA/EU scene (both recent tournament wins and ELO show zerg and protoss are putting up a good fight).
Also I dont agree that Koreans are so close to the skill cap that it will show that terran is the best race. (games only been out for just over a year)
So why is Terran so dominant in KOREA? Some of you still do not like to read...oh well... Because the answer is obvious 70% of this posts are: Complexity and that Terran was op at that time. So why is the EU/NA terran player not as dominating? 1. There are not as many ( obviously ) 2. The race isnt imbalanced anymore (remember when Terrans won over 70% of all small tournaments according to TL stats month ago) 3. Again, not nearly as much real progamers people picked up Terran. 4. I feel like the chances of terran doing better in tournaments are higher as there they are not confronted with random all-ins as much as for example zerg. 5. Different play-style (?) 6. Quite a few of those korean players started later with sc2 when T was clearly too strong while most western players started playing instantly after release or picked their races during beta 1. why are not there not more good EN/NA terran? 2. Korean terran still dominate 3. again why? 4. that does not argue why terran are not as dominating. 5. bit general 6. most of the "newer" SC2 pro were all bw pro, in which they played terran. 1. Because they picked another race???? what kind of question is that 2. I dont see korean terrans dominate in any tournament except GSL SUPER Tournament, do you? If you can name one aside from MLG ill raise my hat to you 3. Because as i said before "Quite a few of those korean players started later with sc2 when T was clearly too strong while most western players started playing instantly after release or picked their races during " 4. 5. Yet kinda true 6. Most EU / NA pros picked up different races, e.g Incontrol, Idra, etc.
What to do to pick up the strongest race in a future Blizzard RTS ? + Show Spoiler +Wait for Idra to pick his race, and don't pick that one. Then wait for him to whine about a certain race in particular and pick THAT one
|
Terran requires precise unit control, with good multitasking, positioning and game sense. Although people say Zerg requires the most apm, the amount of actual multitasking and micro is minimal compared to Terran. Terran positioning with marine tank against Zerg, whilst doing a double pronged attack, whilst macroing, pressuring creep, is much harder to do than injects and creep, hence why most NA/EU Terran struggle (e.g. MLG Columbus). Korean Terrans have really high APM, and are used to the Macro game style.
I find that EU Terrans like to open an expand into blue flame into banshee or something similar, but this is not as solid as the korean Terran openings. Foreign Terrans complain about infestors and aren't the best at defending muta harass.
|
I think I would have noted that Terran seems to have the most forgiving early game. Moderate sized MM balls and infinite repair bunkers can keep you safe from quite a bit. You can build a OC early in your base and still pay it off through mules/ double scvs temporarily. You can pursue a lot more dangerous allin or super agro pushes due to mules and your primary dps being through marine balls. You are built with detection.
Also atleast TvP it seems that Terran meta game has put some serious constraints in the way of what you can face in early pressure or tech choices.
I think strength early-> midgame meant that terran looked a great deal more solid in super aggressive Korea early on.
I also think they have a ton of viable compositions but that's probably less of a reason for the player distribution story.
|
On June 12 2011 15:03 GwSC wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 15:02 Techno wrote:Also, having by far the best early game harassment options and early scouting ability means Terran is the safest race to play in the early game. - TL Lurker I think terran has fundamental problems in the early game in a luck based way that patches won't be able to correct any time soon. - Morrow Care to make a point rather than just posting a quote of Morrow that doesn't even specifically address that post?
He made the point that he disagrees. I thought it was pretty clear. Both quotes address the same period of game play with the same race. Specifically addressed in my opinion.
I play Terran because of siege tanks. Best unit concept ever IMNHO.
|
On June 13 2011 03:44 MindRush wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 03:24 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:20 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 03:09 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:07 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 03:06 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:04 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 01:55 godemperor wrote: Sorry for using red, but I really want to stress why this dominance is not present in the NA/EU scene (both recent tournament wins and ELO show zerg and protoss are putting up a good fight).
Also I dont agree that Koreans are so close to the skill cap that it will show that terran is the best race. (games only been out for just over a year)
So why is Terran so dominant in KOREA? Some of you still do not like to read...oh well... Because the answer is obvious 70% of this posts are: Complexity and that Terran was op at that time. So why is the EU/NA terran player not as dominating? 1. There are not as many ( obviously ) 2. The race isnt imbalanced anymore (remember when Terrans won over 70% of all small tournaments according to TL stats month ago) 3. Again, not nearly as much real progamers people picked up Terran. 4. I feel like the chances of terran doing better in tournaments are higher as there they are not confronted with random all-ins as much as for example zerg. 5. Different play-style (?) 6. Quite a few of those korean players started later with sc2 when T was clearly too strong while most western players started playing instantly after release or picked their races during beta 1. why are not there not more good EN/NA terran? 2. Korean terran still dominate 3. again why? 4. that does not argue why terran are not as dominating. 5. bit general 6. most of the "newer" SC2 pro were all bw pro, in which they played terran. 1. Because they picked another race???? what kind of question is that 2. I dont see korean terrans dominate in any tournament except GSL SUPER Tournament, do you? If you can name one aside from MLG ill raise my hat to you 3. Because as i said before "Quite a few of those korean players started later with sc2 when T was clearly too strong while most western players started playing instantly after release or picked their races during " 4. 5. Yet kinda true 6. Most EU / NA pros picked up different races, e.g Incontrol, Idra, etc. What to do to pick up the strongest race in a future Blizzard RTS ? + Show Spoiler +Wait for Idra to pick his race, and don't pick that one. Then wait for him to whine about a certain race in particular and pick THAT one
+ Show Spoiler +Idra played terran in SC:BW
|
On June 13 2011 03:44 MindRush wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 03:24 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:20 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 03:09 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:07 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 03:06 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:04 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 01:55 godemperor wrote: Sorry for using red, but I really want to stress why this dominance is not present in the NA/EU scene (both recent tournament wins and ELO show zerg and protoss are putting up a good fight).
Also I dont agree that Koreans are so close to the skill cap that it will show that terran is the best race. (games only been out for just over a year)
So why is Terran so dominant in KOREA? Some of you still do not like to read...oh well... Because the answer is obvious 70% of this posts are: Complexity and that Terran was op at that time. So why is the EU/NA terran player not as dominating? 1. There are not as many ( obviously ) 2. The race isnt imbalanced anymore (remember when Terrans won over 70% of all small tournaments according to TL stats month ago) 3. Again, not nearly as much real progamers people picked up Terran. 4. I feel like the chances of terran doing better in tournaments are higher as there they are not confronted with random all-ins as much as for example zerg. 5. Different play-style (?) 6. Quite a few of those korean players started later with sc2 when T was clearly too strong while most western players started playing instantly after release or picked their races during beta 1. why are not there not more good EN/NA terran? 2. Korean terran still dominate 3. again why? 4. that does not argue why terran are not as dominating. 5. bit general 6. most of the "newer" SC2 pro were all bw pro, in which they played terran. 1. Because they picked another race???? what kind of question is that 2. I dont see korean terrans dominate in any tournament except GSL SUPER Tournament, do you? If you can name one aside from MLG ill raise my hat to you 3. Because as i said before "Quite a few of those korean players started later with sc2 when T was clearly too strong while most western players started playing instantly after release or picked their races during " 4. 5. Yet kinda true 6. Most EU / NA pros picked up different races, e.g Incontrol, Idra, etc. What to do to pick up the strongest race in a future Blizzard RTS ? + Show Spoiler +Wait for Idra to pick his race, and don't pick that one. Then wait for him to whine about a certain race in particular and pick THAT one
Yes, clearly Protoss has been the most successful in BW.
|
On June 13 2011 04:08 Demand2k wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 03:44 MindRush wrote:On June 13 2011 03:24 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:20 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 03:09 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:07 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 03:06 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:04 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 01:55 godemperor wrote: Sorry for using red, but I really want to stress why this dominance is not present in the NA/EU scene (both recent tournament wins and ELO show zerg and protoss are putting up a good fight).
Also I dont agree that Koreans are so close to the skill cap that it will show that terran is the best race. (games only been out for just over a year)
So why is Terran so dominant in KOREA? Some of you still do not like to read...oh well... Because the answer is obvious 70% of this posts are: Complexity and that Terran was op at that time. So why is the EU/NA terran player not as dominating? 1. There are not as many ( obviously ) 2. The race isnt imbalanced anymore (remember when Terrans won over 70% of all small tournaments according to TL stats month ago) 3. Again, not nearly as much real progamers people picked up Terran. 4. I feel like the chances of terran doing better in tournaments are higher as there they are not confronted with random all-ins as much as for example zerg. 5. Different play-style (?) 6. Quite a few of those korean players started later with sc2 when T was clearly too strong while most western players started playing instantly after release or picked their races during beta 1. why are not there not more good EN/NA terran? 2. Korean terran still dominate 3. again why? 4. that does not argue why terran are not as dominating. 5. bit general 6. most of the "newer" SC2 pro were all bw pro, in which they played terran. 1. Because they picked another race???? what kind of question is that 2. I dont see korean terrans dominate in any tournament except GSL SUPER Tournament, do you? If you can name one aside from MLG ill raise my hat to you 3. Because as i said before "Quite a few of those korean players started later with sc2 when T was clearly too strong while most western players started playing instantly after release or picked their races during " 4. 5. Yet kinda true 6. Most EU / NA pros picked up different races, e.g Incontrol, Idra, etc. What to do to pick up the strongest race in a future Blizzard RTS ? + Show Spoiler +Wait for Idra to pick his race, and don't pick that one. Then wait for him to whine about a certain race in particular and pick THAT one Outside of Korea, Protoss WAS the most successful. In Korea, they were the least successful. This is because the skill level of foreigners was lower, and therefor Protoss dominated more 'cause they're easier. At least on a low skill level. Yes, clearly Protoss has been the most successful in BW.
|
I just saw the warning in the OP, wow that was expected So here's what I can say on this topic:
sc2 Terran is the most "classic" race; its mechanics are very similar to traditional RTS games. On the other hand, Zerg's unique macro mechanics, and to a lesser extent, Protoss's warpgate and chronoboost mechanics are definitely not standard RTS mechanics. As T, you can literally play by the book, unlike Z and P. Some of the Zerg / Protoss techniques haven't been fully refined yet, like droning timings or Chronoboost usage just to name a couple. Whereas as Terran, we are on familiar ground.
Also we all know that when it comes to mechanics, korean players are masters for some reasons.
So what we see is: skilled players with strong mechanics having the opportunity to play according to standard, conventional RTS rules. korean + terran = good
From my experience when I go random for example I'm confident playing Terran because I'm used to its mechanics. The macro gameplay reminds me of older RTS such as BW and Warcraft 2.
|
On June 13 2011 03:31 Blasterion wrote: Probably the music...... liike the brood war terran theme QFT!!
|
On June 13 2011 04:37 AlBundy wrote:I just saw the warning in the OP, wow that was expected  So here's what I can say on this topic: sc2 Terran is the most "classic" race; its mechanics are very similar to traditional RTS games. On the other hand, Zerg's unique macro mechanics, and to a lesser extent, Protoss's warpgate and chronoboost mechanics are definitely not standard RTS mechanics. As T, you can literally play by the book, unlike Z and P. Some of the Zerg / Protoss techniques haven't been fully refined yet, like droning timings or Chronoboost usage just to name a couple. Whereas as Terran, we are on familiar ground. Also we all know that when it comes to mechanics, korean players are masters. So what we see is: skilled players with strong mechanics having the opportunity to play according to standard, conventional RTS rules. korean + terran = good From my experience when I go random for example I'm confident playing Terran because I'm used to its mechanics. The macro gameplay reminds me of older RTS such as BW and Warcraft 2. edit: that was not a warning, I put it up there so people dont go crazy with balance talks.
|
most potential out of micro/multitasking/bw legacy where terran was definitely was the hardest race to pick up/boxer
|
Canada13431 Posts
The ELO rankning of SC2 korean players in the Korean SC2 TLPD is based on GSL and in Korea tournaments. The early seasons of the GSL (1-3 preseason; 4) were populated extremely heavily by Terrans. This skews the ELO rankings since almost all the players in the list you Screenshotted have played every season of the GSL since Season 1. Likewise, MC and Nestea have both been in every GSL season (I think MC missed one of the seasons? Nestea didnt) and they are higher as a result.
The slayers players and bomber played very well in the GSTL allowing their ELO to rise as well to match those who have accumulated ELO since the early GSL seasons.
|
On June 13 2011 03:24 Keula wrote:Show nested quote +On June 13 2011 03:20 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 03:09 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:07 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 03:06 Keula wrote:On June 13 2011 03:04 godemperor wrote:On June 13 2011 01:55 godemperor wrote: Sorry for using red, but I really want to stress why this dominance is not present in the NA/EU scene (both recent tournament wins and ELO show zerg and protoss are putting up a good fight).
Also I dont agree that Koreans are so close to the skill cap that it will show that terran is the best race. (games only been out for just over a year)
So why is Terran so dominant in KOREA? Some of you still do not like to read...oh well... Because the answer is obvious 70% of this posts are: Complexity and that Terran was op at that time. So why is the EU/NA terran player not as dominating? 1. There are not as many ( obviously ) 2. The race isnt imbalanced anymore (remember when Terrans won over 70% of all small tournaments according to TL stats month ago) 3. Again, not nearly as much real progamers people picked up Terran. 4. I feel like the chances of terran doing better in tournaments are higher as there they are not confronted with random all-ins as much as for example zerg. 5. Different play-style (?) 6. Quite a few of those korean players started later with sc2 when T was clearly too strong while most western players started playing instantly after release or picked their races during beta 1. why are not there not more good EN/NA terran? 2. Korean terran still dominate 3. again why? 4. that does not argue why terran are not as dominating. 5. bit general 6. most of the "newer" SC2 pro were all bw pro, in which they played terran. 1. Because they picked another race???? what kind of question is that 2. I dont see korean terrans dominate in any tournament except GSL SUPER Tournament, do you? If you can name one aside from MLG ill raise my hat to you 3. Because as i said before "Quite a few of those korean players started later with sc2 when T was clearly too strong while most western players started playing instantly after release or picked their races during " 4. 5. Yet kinda true 6. Most EU / NA pros picked up different races, e.g Incontrol, Idra, etc. All the Top players right now have been playing since the Beta...there are obviously a few exceptions like Nada, but the majority just picked a race, I doubt it had anything to do with balance but rather what they liked.
2. http://www.teamliquid.net/tlpd/sc2-korean/individual-leagues
There are quite a few Terrans/Zergs having success, but for Protoss it is just MC.
I dunno, this thread feels kinda silly. People are being so defensive about their race that the vast majority of peoples arguments are being made up of nothing more than anecdotal evidence.
Statistics generally speak for themselves, it is quite mind boggling that the most played race in the game has the least amount of players doing well.
|
|
|
|
|
|