|
On June 12 2011 23:14 Razuik wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 14:43 ptrpb wrote: In my opinion Terran just has the most flexibility and safety netting. You can choose between 400 minerals, instant detection for a couple of seconds, or instant supply unblockage, tech switching is quick and easy, bases can be reused, sensor towers for spotting drops and enemy movement, and more. When I compare the other two races to Terran, it just seems that a lot of the other race's handicaps to Terran's there seems to be less of them. Just my opinion. You say that Terran can choose between instant detection or instant supply, but you have to realize that the mule is a Terran's macro mechanic. Losing a mule is like losing a chronoboost or inject.
wow dude, i will trade a mule for 2 chronos on my probes ANY time
|
Hm.. this reminds me. I remember Byun starting with Protoss and losing every game and then when he switched to Terran, he got to the finals of Code A. lol.
I think Terran is just the most flexible race that doesn't limit your skills. You can harass in a million places at once and do a lot of damage because their units are so cost efficient whereas Zerg and Protoss don't have options to that extent.
|
Personally, I think there are alot of good terrans in KR because of the slayers team. Boxer teaches them, and thats why you have all these amazing terrans that tend to be extra strong in TvT, and a protoss with great PvT (which I dont believe fully)
|
On June 12 2011 23:08 Zarahtra wrote:In general I think it has most to do with the versatility. I mean toss and zerg are pretty gimped(not as in bad, but more predictable) by their rather linear tech tree. As a pro, I'd imagine one thing they look for is that they can create many different(deadly) builds. It's a lot easier for a terran to create a new build, focusing on x production/upgrades. It's still a good point about the micro, that I'd imagine comes into play too. Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 22:24 Ghostcom wrote:On June 12 2011 21:41 stevarius wrote:On June 12 2011 21:34 Ghostcom wrote:On June 12 2011 21:14 archonOOid wrote: Zerg have only 2 micro intensive units: mutas and banelings (splitting banelings and baneling landmines). Protoss have blinkstalkers. Terran has bioball (kiting), siegetanks, banshee, helions, reapers, ghost and vikings. A player with great unit control is rewarded 3 times more playing terran because their units allows for micro. This post is mindnumbingly stupid... How in the world do people even convince themselves of such idiocy? It's not so idiotic if you think about it. The sheer mass of zerg units vs terran units in your average mid-game battle dictates that you can't necessarily control your units to their fullest potential effectively as a zerg player. The units work well simply positioning them correctly and hitting at good angles and getting a flank. A terran; however is rewarded for intensive stutter step micro and splitting of units. It is also my belief that the terran race scales the best with multi tasking ability due to the viability of drop play and multiple-pronged attacking strategies. Many top korean terrans have put their skills on display winning games they were behind in because of this. Just look at MMA grinding his way back in games that he probably should have lost due to crippling drops and attacks. You do realise how selectively both you and the first guy I quoted pick your examples right? Every race will benefit greatly from increased multitasking. Obviously all units benefit from micro, but personally I'd say terran benefits the most. In a straight up fight, there aren't really *that* many terran units that will win. Thor, tank and the bc are really the only ones. That doesn't mean that the other units are bad(obviously not) since you can make them insanely good with great micro. I'd say fx. that rauder atleast has potential to double it's efficiency compared to 1a. The other races don't really have that kind of micro potential, except for very selected units(ignoring spellcasters, since all spellcasters obviously need some babysitting/micro) in mutas, maybe blings, phoenix(And possibly immos for focusfire, since the increased dmg is so much)
I don't understand your post:
1) What do you mean by "in a straight up fight, there aren't really *that* many terran units that will win"? I'm pretty sure a marauder beats a stalker or a sentry without any micro involved. And I dare say that blink stalkers more than double their efficency compared to normal stalkers.
2) You want to ignore all the spellcaster micro, which happens to be the major part of protoss micro. Basicly you are saying that for a micro discussion you don't want to take the other races micro into concideration - that is rather flawed won't you agree? The races utilize different types of micro, terrans with all their ranged bio is about stutterstep; protoss is about abilities and spellcasting. If your definition of micro is stutterstep, then obviously the only race to use stutterstep is going to be the most microintensive in your view, but then say that terran is race that benefits the most from stutterstep, not that they are the race that benefits the most from micro.
I see no reason to continue this discussion, it's futile as long as you are this selective. Besides I really don't think the reason a lot of pros ended up playing terran was due to such considerations, but rather the due to the dictating playstyle fitting them.
|
Terran is the best designed race - they don't have any stupid macro mechanics that would put limits on the functionality of their units, unlike Protoss or Zerg. Everything else that is good about Terran is a result of them not having Warpgates or Spawn Larvae to screw everything up for them. They also scale very well with mechanical skill and multitasking ability. Finally, their gameplay is the most varied, and the mirror matchup is the most skill-based, with no retarded BO losses or extremely powerful 1 base all-ins.
It's really not surprising that most competitive players would choose Terran.
|
On June 12 2011 23:19 2GRe-Play- wrote: Versatiles: Many strategies and u dont fall behind if one of them fail. Harrasment: the best race in this department. Dictatorial: can force macro/all in games as they want. Tech Switch: u just have to lift a building and thats all. Offensive/Defensive: the best race when it comes to this (Mules are OP) Unforgiven: Mistakes arent a problem u cant do mistakes being Z or P Units: have their purpose and u can use them all and fight with Tier1 all game long.
What?
Mistakes aren't a problem?
Have you ever seen what happens when a Terran doesn't marine split correctly against infestors / banelings? Or when he is caught unsieged? Or when his ghosts miss an EMP on the HT's?
If anything, protoss are the most resilient to little mistakes, because the the gateway/colossi ball is fairly resilient.
|
Netherlands45349 Posts
Could be a stretch, but Terran is overall more resillient against allins, bunkers(which are partly refundable) , repair wall etc.
|
On June 12 2011 23:55 Arisen wrote: They practice a lot more than European or NA Terrans, they have the best coaches available, that's really all there is to it, there's no magical key to success, it's just a LOT of practice. You might want to actually read the OP.
|
Is terran like the standard type of real time race? I've only played a little C&C back in the day but I wonder if more koreans play Terran because other games already give you the knowledge of playing a race like Terran. Zerg and Protoss play are so unique it takes a little more experimentation and willingness to understand.
|
On June 13 2011 00:41 Sarang wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 23:19 2GRe-Play- wrote: Versatiles: Many strategies and u dont fall behind if one of them fail. Harrasment: the best race in this department. Dictatorial: can force macro/all in games as they want. Tech Switch: u just have to lift a building and thats all. Offensive/Defensive: the best race when it comes to this (Mules are OP) Unforgiven: Mistakes arent a problem u cant do mistakes being Z or P Units: have their purpose and u can use them all and fight with Tier1 all game long.
What? Mistakes aren't a problem? Have you ever seen what happens when a Terran doesn't marine split correctly against infestors / banelings? Or when he is caught unsieged? Or when his ghosts miss an EMP on the HT's? If anything, protoss are the most resilient to little mistakes, because the the gateway/colossi ball is fairly resilient.
Ghosts miss emps? are you joking?
|
one reason... micro race. its way harder to master the micro of zerg or toss (thats why their macro is easier and terran has the mule that can be used after some heavy micro fights). Anyway i don't say terran is easier, just saying while the macro is horrible complicated and you need some workers with your army, they have things to make up for that and thus they can actually concentrate better on the battlefield. That doesn't mean there is no next level for terran, there is ^^. But for that the other races have to get away from this macro is enough to win stuff.
One reason might be though (not like terran is easier to learn because its the basic rts stuff ... or because best designed ... give me larva inject for ccs and let my stuff build there and i will gladly trade the mule for that). Is that around beta time terran was considered terribly overpowered (you can see this venom still in this thread). And koreans want to win, so alot considered or switched to terran because of this. (atleast if i followed some threads correctly). In short, alot of potential zerg or toss candidates were lost due to this. (loss of training time, switch to terran etc)
|
I dont think this type of topic will ever be unbiased as I see players of other race give biased opinions on the subject.
Personally I play Terran because it was the race I played in BW. I was very young (7) when I got Brood War and I started with Terran even though I did not know how to play. That has basically carried over to my SC2 "career" as I pick Terran for nostalgic reasons. Dont get my wrong, the other races are very cool as well and sometimes I play Team games just so I can experience them as well. I dont play Terran cause it is easy or mules are OP or whatever. I basically play because I chose it when I first started SC. There are also many times where I envy the mechanics of the other races. However, having all these mechanics for one race would be no fun at all.
I think most people play terran because of previously stated comments such as Boxer and Nada. I also like the diversity of Terran allowing me to do many things at once. Also tech switching is actually the FASTEST for zerg as only one building is needed to make a specific unit. Coming in this topic I knew there would be race biases and I can clearly see them.
|
I think many are interpreting this why people are choosing terran in general, but it really is just about the KOrean scene. Some may argue that Koreans are better and close to the skill cap, but I say that its hard to say that anyone is close to the skill cap when the game has only been out for bit more than 1 year.
Why is the foreign terran as dominant? There are many talented terrans in EU but if you look as the recent tournament win, they are hardly dominating. It is even more true for NA. Korean is the only place where terran are overwhelmingly strong.
I still thinkt he main reason is Brood War, people choose the race of their idol, with 4 of the 5 BW bonjwas as terran, it very likely that a BW pro turned SC2 pro stick to their race of their role model.
|
Your two poll choices are ridiculous. No, not all the best players are playing Terran, but yes there seems to be a lot of good Korean Terran players.
|
I think its because Terran has the most variety of feasible playstyles. And thus, its toughest to burn out with. I think because the campaign was Terran, Blizzard ad an easier time making making Terran fun in the multiplayer. TvT is an excellent example of this. The race is so dynamic that every single unit is viable in the matchup.
The problem with Zerg is that because its the most defensive race, its also the most frustrating to lose with. When you lose as Terran its usually because you botched an attack. You know why you lost and how you can improve. But when you lose as Zerg its usually because you made a poor decision, like droning instead of making units. Its tougher to figure out what you did wrong and how to fix it, especially with SC2's lack of early game scouting (for all races). When you're constantly on the defense its easy to burn out and cry other races are OP.
Protoss is somewhere inbetween because their core mechanics are very strong. Warpin completely negates defender's advantage, and forcefield provides instant space control anywhere on the map. However unlike Terran, their unit combinations are not very diverse. The core of your army must always be a gateway ball, and you need a robo in order to have mobile detection. Gateway+Robo is the most powerful 200/200 army in the game so unlike Zerg you can't cry other races OP, but the lack of variety means it can be less fun to play. When you're playing SC2 8+ hours a day, that means that you're especially vulnerable to burnout.
|
On June 13 2011 01:39 kNightLite wrote: I think its because Terran has the most variety of feasible playstyles. And thus, its toughest to burn out with. I think because the campaign was Terran, Blizzard spent more time making sure that Terran was fun to play in multiplayer. TvT is an excellent example of this. The race is so dynamic that every single unit is viable in the matchup.
The problem with Zerg is that because its the most defensive race, its also the most frustrating to lose with. When you lose as Terran its usually because you botched an attack. You know why you lost and how you can improve. But when you lose as Zerg its usually because you made a poor decision, like droning instead of making units. Its tougher to figure out what you did wrong and how to fix it, especially with SC2's lack of early game scouting (for all races). When you're constantly on the defense its easy to burn out and cry other races are OP.
Protoss is somewhere inbetween because their core mechanics are very strong. Warpin completely negates defender's advantage, and forcefield provides instant space control anywhere on the map. However unlike Terran, their unit combinations are not very diverse. The core of your army must always be a gateway ball, and you need a robo in order to have mobile detection. Gateway+Robo is the most powerful 200/200 army in the game so unlike Zerg you can't cry other races OP, but the lack of variety means it can be less fun to play. When you're playing SC2 8+ hours a day, that means that you're especially vulnerable to burnout.
Don't think it has anything to do with burnout. They're progamers, they're used to playing 10-12 hours a day from BW. Also, fatigue due to playing a certain race is kinda subjective.
|
Terran has the best options out of all. Best harassment : 4 hellions are wet nightmare for any opponents. Banshee is damn good follow up too. and dropships too snipe building. Best defend: fail rush? just bunker up or get tanks. Cheap units AOE even better than Protoss: ghost, nuke, thors,tanks, BCs.
|
I don't see how anyone could play protoss for 7+ hours a day or however long the Koreans practice. It just seems so mind numbingly boring from watching some of these protoss streams and tournament games. Your gameplan is pretty much "don't die until I can roll them over with this ball". That's probably an unfair statement but still... didn't several of the top Terrans play Protoss in BW but switched? Maybe toss gameplay is a factor.
|
On June 13 2011 01:36 qck wrote: Your two poll choices are ridiculous. No, not all the best players are playing Terran, but yes there seems to be a lot of good Korean Terran players. Please post a reason then, considering 70% of people disagree with you.
|
On June 12 2011 14:57 canikizu wrote: Add this reason: Terran has the most classic RTS mechanic out of 3 races (classic units queuing in rax; use a worker to build stuff, repair; distinct unit tech such as bio, mech, sky). Because Terran has such classic mechanic elements in them, it's much easier for people who somewhat play RTS before (C&C, AOE, Warcraft, Cossack...) to play. Bingo! You Sir, know your RTS'
|
|
|
|
|
|