|
On June 12 2011 22:47 cuppatea wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 22:18 Probe1 wrote:On June 12 2011 21:41 stevarius wrote:On June 12 2011 21:34 Ghostcom wrote:On June 12 2011 21:14 archonOOid wrote: Zerg have only 2 micro intensive units: mutas and banelings (splitting banelings and baneling landmines). Protoss have blinkstalkers. Terran has bioball (kiting), siegetanks, banshee, helions, reapers, ghost and vikings. A player with great unit control is rewarded 3 times more playing terran because their units allows for micro. This post is mindnumbingly stupid... How in the world do people even convince themselves of such idiocy? It's not so idiotic if you think about it. The sheer mass of zerg units vs terran units in your average mid-game battle dictates that you can't necessarily control your units to their fullest potential effectively as a zerg player. The units work well simply positioning them correctly and hitting at good angles and getting a flank. A terran; however is rewarded for intensive stutter step micro and splitting of units. It is also my belief that the terran race scales the best with multi tasking ability due to the viability of drop play and multiple-pronged attacking strategies. Many top korean terrans have put their skills on display winning games they were behind in because of this. Just look at MMA grinding his way back in games that he probably should have lost due to crippling drops and attacks. So that's why you race switched! No, jk jk  I would argue that zerglings require a different kind of micromanagement than Terran units but require it all the same. If you a move a ling/bane swarm into marines what happens? The banes get stuck in the back while the marines and zerglings collide. Flanking and positioning in my mind are more about where your army is before the attack and running zerglings around, refusing Terran the ability to stutter back is micro. The idea that any unit of Zerg can't or doesn't need to be micro'd is absurd to me. Zergling- Surrounding and cupping the rear of a marine ball (giggle) Roach- Burrow micro for hp regen (uncommon) and FF negation (very common) Baneling- chasing split marines, combined with OL's dropping on mineral lines/armies, making sure they blow up on the right target instead of being wasted on marauders/queens. Hydralisks- target firing air, spellcasters (sentries, other targets of interest) Infestors- A unit that has no attack therefore only as good as its micromanagement Mutalisks- Obviously Corruptors- Using corruption can have surprisingly effective results against colossii and immortals. Tier 3 arguments are a little weaker however. Brood lords are essentially about positioning and Ultralisks do require micromanagement or they'll clump together and center all of the damage from siege tanks into one area. To say Zerg only has a few micro intensive units is just bullshit. But that being said, I completely agree with your statement about Terran and MMA highlighting how multipronged attacks are extremely powerful. To aksfjh: You raise a valid point and I did not take your comment in the narrow scope you meant it in. My mistake. I still feel like Terran has more of a choice than Zerg when it comes to whether it will be a short or long game but I'm going to step back from this because I can't objectively state that without personal experience clouding it. I can't recall ever, in all my time of playing and watching SC2, hearing or thinking the phrase "wow, that was amazing micro from the Zerg player!" The units you listed above can be micro'd but I wouldn't describe any of them as "micro intensive". Zerg, to me, even at the highest levels, is the "macro and a-move" race.
Couldn't agree more. And that's nobody's fault but Blizzard's for designing it that way.
|
Then we simply have different definitions of micromanagement cuppatea. Every time I see a Zerg player beat a 3 gate sentry expand I think about the micro required to do it. Especially with the speed of zerglings, your're decision making has to be extremely fast and unit control spot on.
I respect that consensus that it doesn't appear that way and many zerg players do not utilize unit micro. Perhaps that is why we are not as well represented as Terrans.
|
On June 12 2011 22:50 Blizzard_torments_me wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 21:24 Blasphemi wrote:On June 12 2011 21:20 holycrapitsTony wrote:On June 12 2011 21:10 Blasphemi wrote:On June 12 2011 21:04 Blizzard_torments_me wrote:On June 12 2011 16:22 Eleaven wrote: Techno, time to leave the thread.
You simply refuse to acknowledge the privilege and advantages given to your race, other races have advantages too. But when it comes to being consistent, being able to safely wall off, and have the best all purpose unit in the game, certainly helps maintain consistent results. You have less dumb ways to die. More importantly the dumb ways to die, are based on your own actions (stimming up a ramp and being cut in half) attacking head on into a dumb choke etc.
For the other races, the most common ways to die stupidly are something terran has done to them, often un-scoutable in the first 7 mins. (whilst sitting behind a defensive posture that is foolish to engage without significant advantage Nah, I think it's time YOU leave the thread , you just simplify Terran to one of tens of aspects of the game.Go read the latest Morrow interview ,he says what he thinks about terran and zerg and makes some perfect points. Terran early game atm is simply a coinflip, especially vs zerg. You just cannot open macro and win ,it's impossible. zerg's macro mechanic is just too good.You always have to do some economic damage. Witch if zerg holds well going into mid/late game ,terran is simply fucked. One of the best all purpose unit in the game? Maybe, if enabled by your opponent, and obviously if enabled by the terran player, because marine splitting/drop timing is one of the hardest things in the game. Replies like yours just show me the ignorance some people have off this game. Go play Terran my friend , and see how easy it is. Because I bet you are one of those guys that losses a game and goes "terran is so easy" "If i'd play terran ,i'd pe grand master league" etc. I don't agree with this. MMA has been crushing Zergs recently by just flat out outplaying them in late game. Citing one player as a reason to throw out all other evidence is silly. That's like saying that NesTea is proof that Zerg is overpowered. If you would actually read, the guy i quoted said that Terran cannot open macro against a Zerg and win, which is blatantly not true as MMA does it all the time against top Zergs like July, Losira, DongRaGu and foreign Zergs like Sheth and Ret and stomps them. It's been a while since I saw him play Zerg but MVP did plenty economic openings into late game mass drop as well. Perhaps mediocre Terrans (especially the foreign ones) need to open with Helions, Banshee's or Bunkers every game to win but clearly it's not true for all Terran's. MMA also constantly dropped and did econ damage. His drop sense is incredible, it takes a really good terran to drop like that with mutas as a constant threat.
I'm a masters terran. There are 2 important timings in TvZ. The first being the original pressure (ie. 1 rax/2 rax/hellion opening harass). The 2nd being the midgame tank marine medivac push which usually comes around the 10 minute mark. If either of these don't do any damage at all, the zerg gets into a comfortable macro situation and drones up. While korean zergs do open economically, you have to realize they're good at making these timings do damage. Often even ending the game with them.
|
I'm not sure if that's what we're discussing rysecake but you're absolutely right on that.
|
I think its a metagame issue right now, that the game is close to a good balance.
Only thing that needs to go is the early marine/bunker push vs Z (11/12 but more importantly 11/11 is so fukin strong) but its more of a map issue due to short distances than game issue.
Terrans have some sweet tactic with the drop play atm. Game will probably shift in the next couple months.
|
United Kingdom787 Posts
On June 12 2011 22:18 Probe1 wrote: The idea that any unit of Zerg can't or doesn't need to be micro'd is absurd to me. Zergling- Surrounding and cupping the rear of a marine ball (giggle) Roach- Burrow micro for hp regen (uncommon) and FF negation (very common) Baneling- chasing split marines, combined with OL's dropping on mineral lines/armies, making sure they blow up on the right target instead of being wasted on marauders/queens. Hydralisks- target firing air, spellcasters (sentries, other targets of interest) Infestors- A unit that has no attack therefore only as good as its micromanagement Mutalisks- Obviously Corruptors- Using corruption can have surprisingly effective results against colossii and immortals
I would only really call the Mutalisk from that list a micro intensive unit. Infestors maybe, but all the others are pretty much 1a units.
|
On June 12 2011 22:59 Probe1 wrote: I'm not sure if that's what we're discussing rysecake but you're absolutely right on that.
Yea sorry. It's off topic but I saw someone posting about korean zergs opening economically and foreign terrans opening gimmicky hellion/banshee builds etc. Just thought I'd comment on it.
|
On June 12 2011 23:03 rysecake wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 22:59 Probe1 wrote: I'm not sure if that's what we're discussing rysecake but you're absolutely right on that. Yea sorry. It's off topic but I saw someone posting about korean zergs opening economically and foreign terrans opening gimmicky hellion/banshee builds etc. Just thought I'd comment on it.
you're spot on on what you did say though.
|
In general I think it has most to do with the versatility. I mean toss and zerg are pretty gimped(not as in bad, but more predictable) by their rather linear tech tree. As a pro, I'd imagine one thing they look for is that they can create many different(deadly) builds. It's a lot easier for a terran to create a new build, focusing on x production/upgrades.
It's still a good point about the micro, that I'd imagine comes into play too.
On June 12 2011 22:24 Ghostcom wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 21:41 stevarius wrote:On June 12 2011 21:34 Ghostcom wrote:On June 12 2011 21:14 archonOOid wrote: Zerg have only 2 micro intensive units: mutas and banelings (splitting banelings and baneling landmines). Protoss have blinkstalkers. Terran has bioball (kiting), siegetanks, banshee, helions, reapers, ghost and vikings. A player with great unit control is rewarded 3 times more playing terran because their units allows for micro. This post is mindnumbingly stupid... How in the world do people even convince themselves of such idiocy? It's not so idiotic if you think about it. The sheer mass of zerg units vs terran units in your average mid-game battle dictates that you can't necessarily control your units to their fullest potential effectively as a zerg player. The units work well simply positioning them correctly and hitting at good angles and getting a flank. A terran; however is rewarded for intensive stutter step micro and splitting of units. It is also my belief that the terran race scales the best with multi tasking ability due to the viability of drop play and multiple-pronged attacking strategies. Many top korean terrans have put their skills on display winning games they were behind in because of this. Just look at MMA grinding his way back in games that he probably should have lost due to crippling drops and attacks. You do realise how selectively both you and the first guy I quoted pick your examples right? Every race will benefit greatly from increased multitasking. Obviously all units benefit from micro, but personally I'd say terran benefits the most. In a straight up fight, there aren't really *that* many terran units that will win. Thor, tank and the bc are really the only ones. That doesn't mean that the other units are bad(obviously not) since you can make them insanely good with great micro. I'd say fx. that rauder atleast has potential to double it's efficiency compared to 1a. The other races don't really have that kind of micro potential, except for very selected units(ignoring spellcasters, since all spellcasters obviously need some babysitting/micro) in mutas, maybe blings, phoenix(And possibly immos for focusfire, since the increased dmg is so much)
|
On June 12 2011 14:43 ptrpb wrote: In my opinion Terran just has the most flexibility and safety netting. You can choose between 400 minerals, instant detection for a couple of seconds, or instant supply unblockage, tech switching is quick and easy, bases can be reused, sensor towers for spotting drops and enemy movement, and more. When I compare the other two races to Terran, it just seems that a lot of the other race's handicaps to Terran's there seems to be less of them. Just my opinion. You say that Terran can choose between instant detection or instant supply, but you have to realize that the mule is a Terran's macro mechanic. Losing a mule is like losing a chronoboost or inject.
|
Dominican Republic913 Posts
Versatiles: Many strategies and u dont fall behind if one of them fail. Harrasment: the best race in this department. Dictatorial: can force macro/all in games as they want. Tech Switch: u just have to lift a building and thats all. Offensive/Defensive: the best race when it comes to this (Mules are OP) Unforgiven: Mistakes arent a problem u cant do mistakes being Z or P Units: have their purpose and u can use them all and fight with Tier1 all game long.
|
Interesting read and all but I think you have missed one more reason of why they might of chosen terran. Because they like the race or just because they want to play it for whatever reason..
Just because there isn't 33% zerg 33% protoss 33% terran at pro level means nothing about balance - zerg and protoss can compete against terran at the top level, and that's all that really matters.
|
It just seems that many Korean programers choose Terran. Statistics show that overall Terrans don't have better winrates at the moment. Probably it`s because Terran was OP after the beta and that was the reason many Koreans chose Terrans as their main race in SC2. And they stayed with their race. Then it could just be a random occurrence.
|
i also think Terran profits the most from unit micro and high APM play.
|
I think Terran is the strongest race IF PLAYED WELL. I'm not saying Terran is the easiest race. Starcraft 2 is an EASY game, compared to the mechanical complexity of Brood War. So every progamer can play almost perfectly the Terran race and then doing better results.
|
you guys have to think why they picked terran back in the beta days, not why you should pick terran now... cuz now you see terran pro-gamers changing to zerg
|
On June 12 2011 23:33 Glioburd wrote: I think Terran is the strongest race IF PLAYED WELL. I'm not saying Terran is the easiest race. Starcraft 2 is an EASY game, compared to the mechanical complexity of Brood War. So every progamer can play almost perfectly the Terran race and then doing better results.
This isnt true, there is still a difference between the top terrans and random pros.
|
On June 12 2011 23:19 2GRe-Play- wrote: Versatiles: Many strategies and u dont fall behind if one of them fail. Harrasment: the best race in this department. Dictatorial: can force macro/all in games as they want. Tech Switch: u just have to lift a building and thats all. Offensive/Defensive: the best race when it comes to this (Mules are OP) Unforgiven: Mistakes arent a problem u cant do mistakes being Z or P Units: have their purpose and u can use them all and fight with Tier1 all game long.
This summarizes everything I want to say.
On June 12 2011 23:03 Striding Strider wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 22:18 Probe1 wrote: The idea that any unit of Zerg can't or doesn't need to be micro'd is absurd to me. Zergling- Surrounding and cupping the rear of a marine ball (giggle) Roach- Burrow micro for hp regen (uncommon) and FF negation (very common) Baneling- chasing split marines, combined with OL's dropping on mineral lines/armies, making sure they blow up on the right target instead of being wasted on marauders/queens. Hydralisks- target firing air, spellcasters (sentries, other targets of interest) Infestors- A unit that has no attack therefore only as good as its micromanagement Mutalisks- Obviously Corruptors- Using corruption can have surprisingly effective results against colossii and immortals I would only really call the Mutalisk from that list a micro intensive unit. Infestors maybe, but all the others are pretty much 1a units.
Just taking one thing, the infestor. It has no fucking attack. How can you say maybe about something that MUST be micro'd and babysat if you want it to be effective and stay alive? Please, make a list of all the Terran units that are micro intensive. As I see it Terran has to micro marines beyond doubt but having a safety net like a siege tank LETS him. Position sieges and you don't have to touch them again until its time to move up. Hellions are just as micro intensive as zerglings and marines obviously require just as much micro as a flock of mutas, if not more. But please, stop or explain how Terran requires more micro than Zerg.
|
They practice a lot more than European or NA Terrans, they have the best coaches available, that's really all there is to it, there's no magical key to success, it's just a LOT of practice.
|
I think there is one big reason why Terran is popular and overrepresented amongst the top: TvT is the most skillintensive (and fun) of all the mirrors. Having a mirror which is less luck based is very important for the topgamers as your chances of losing against a worse player in a mirror match seriously decrease. Note that to be a progamer you need to have a significantly higher then 50% winrate often, any matchup that is more luck based is bad for a progamer. For example if you have to navigate through a big tournament it can be troublesome if you face much worse players in a matchup that is close to a coinflip regardless of skill levels.
It is favorable at the top end for a race to have less luck involved in a mirror as it lets the better player advance more often => as a result that race will do better OVERALL in tournaments.
Ofcourse this isn't that big a reason but i've never seen it mentioned before and it does play a substantial role imo.
|
|
|
|
|
|