Excellent
Good
Horrible
Average
Bad

In early, early GSL I really liked Tasteless, and didn't really like Artosis. After watching hundreds of hours of GSL, Artosis has really grown on me, and Tasteless has sunk a bit. Artosis is the only caster I've felt (in the GSL) who really, really loves the game.

I could not stand Kelly, but we're not going to get into that.

DOA and Moletrap are an interesting pair. I feel they have a long way to go in the way of chemistry, but the biggest issue I have is them trying to become Tastosis. I feel that if they develop their own casting style, that it'll get way better. Moletrap does get 'screechy'.

TheSilverfox

Sweden1928 Posts

May 18 2011 07:25 GMT

#23

There was something wrong with the poll about Tasteless so I fixed it for you:

Poll: Tasteless

Excellent! His casting makes people fear for their ladder points! (37)

38%

Excellent! His casting makes my heterosexual heart melt (33)

34%

Excellent! Tasteless is baller! (12)

12%

Excellent! His casting solves world peace! (6)

6%

Excellent! He is sooooo sexy! (5)

5%

Excellent! Of course - he's a part of Tastosis, the casting Archon! (3)

3%

Excellent! (Makes the game better with his commentary) (1)

1%

97 total votes

Your vote: Tasteless

(Vote): Excellent! His casting makes my heterosexual heart melt
(Vote): Excellent! Tasteless is baller!
(Vote): Excellent! (Makes the game better with his commentary)
(Vote): Excellent! His casting solves world peace!
(Vote): Excellent! His casting makes people fear for their ladder points!
(Vote): Excellent! He is sooooo sexy!
(Vote): Excellent! Of course - he's a part of Tastosis, the casting Archon!

absalom86

Iceland1770 Posts

May 18 2011 07:27 GMT

#24

Extra Excellent
Excellent
Bad
Good
Excellent

Mr. Nefarious

United States515 Posts

May 18 2011 07:29 GMT

#25

When DOA and Moletrap are on I watch GOMTV muted. Sorry if it's harsh, but it's true.

EchelonTee

United States5261 Posts

May 18 2011 07:30 GMT

#26

On May 18 2011 16:13 Lyter wrote:
I voted in order:
Excellent
Excellent
Bad
Average
Good

hi5 me too

eoLithic

Norway221 Posts

May 18 2011 07:30 GMT

#27

Stop bitching about caster hate. People say what they want to say and vote for what they want to vote for, lol.

OT: Artosis only one that scores and excellent with me.

aderum

Sweden1459 Posts

May 18 2011 07:33 GMT

#28

On May 18 2011 16:25 TheSilverfox wrote:
There was something wrong with the poll about Tasteless so I fixed it for you:

Poll: Tasteless

Excellent! His casting makes people fear for their ladder points! (37)

38%

Excellent! His casting makes my heterosexual heart melt (33)

34%

Excellent! Tasteless is baller! (12)

12%

Excellent! His casting solves world peace! (6)

6%

Excellent! He is sooooo sexy! (5)

5%

Excellent! Of course - he's a part of Tastosis, the casting Archon! (3)

3%

Excellent! (Makes the game better with his commentary) (1)

1%

97 total votes

Your vote: Tasteless

Deff voting for my heterosexual heart melting!

bennyaus

Australia1833 Posts

May 18 2011 07:33 GMT

#29

Moletrap and DoA have less game knowledge than Kelly, or at least Moletrap seems to. This for me puts them behind, regardless of whatever accent gripes you have. I felt that DoA/Kelly combination could've been excellent if left to ripen.

Excellent, Excellent, Average, Average, Bad.

Scorch

Austria3371 Posts

May 18 2011 07:34 GMT

#30

I think we should rather vote on casting duos instead of individual casters, as the duo is more than the sum of its parts. For instance, I don't think too highly of Tasteless as an individual caster, but together with Artosis, he is incredibly funny. When he casted together with Kelly, his own quality dwindled too I feel.

proxY_

United States1561 Posts

May 18 2011 07:34 GMT

#31

I'm actually finding that I can't deal with watching Moletrap and Doa cast, especially when Tastosis is casting the other half of the time. The drop off in skill level and drop in my enjoyment of the cast is honestly just too much.

GMonster

686 Posts

May 18 2011 07:36 GMT

#32

On May 18 2011 16:12 KMARTRULES wrote:
Anyone who votes horrible or even bad are either trolls or have really high standards, all the casters have done a great job.

That sums up my opinion. Its really getting old that if you are not Artosis, Day9 or Tasteless you suck as a caster apparently. I feel bad for Kelly because she came in when everyone just didn't want anyone but tastosis so shes been given a lot of hatred that she really doesn't deserve because everyone hopped on the "lets hate bandwagon" or hatewagon as i will now refer to it.

BLinD-RawR

ALLEYCAT BLUES51072 Posts

May 18 2011 07:36 GMT

#33

I still find it mind boggling that people don't like Moletrap's casting,but to be honest,he does really well solo and if paired with someone,he needs to be paired with diggity.

Subversion

South Africa3627 Posts

May 18 2011 07:37 GMT

#34

I think Doa definitely deserves a "good".

Average is way too harsh

He's a great play-by-play guy

rakshasa

Japan23 Posts

May 18 2011 07:39 GMT

#35

Moletrap needs to make a list of 'banned words' in order to improve the casting, in addition to not screaming so much.

E.g. no more using 'actually' in casts.

Dfgj

Singapore5922 Posts

May 18 2011 07:39 GMT

#36

On May 18 2011 16:36 GoKu` wrote:

Show nested quote +

There are people who unsubscribed or found Code-A unwatchable/uninteresting as a result of the casting. Why would they not vote below average?

Assuming everyone has to be positive about things is preachy as fuck.

Subversion

South Africa3627 Posts

May 18 2011 07:40 GMT

#37

Kelly's terrible scores are far more based on her voice than her casting anyway.

People just can't stand the accent.

kochujang

Germany1226 Posts

May 18 2011 07:41 GMT

#38

On May 18 2011 16:37 Subversion wrote:
I think Doa definitely deserves a "good".

Average is way too harsh

He's a great play-by-play guy

I concur! Doa definitely needs more love. I also love his geeky jokes

Pkol

Australia176 Posts

May 18 2011 07:42 GMT

#39

I like Doa better than Moletrap, I dunno, I get the sense Moletrap thinks hes more entitled to the job because of his BW casting, this may be true, but Doa is just so nice and has a great voice. Have to root for the nice guy :D