|
Russian Federation1613 Posts
Since the last chapter of SC2 trilogy is ended I think it's time to ask people what they liked the most about campaign so i created some polls about each chapter missions, about characters and common poll.
Let's have fun! 
Terran Characters
Poll: Jim Raynor★ (14) 6% ★★ (20) 8% ★★★ (67) 26% ★★★★ (86) 34% ★★★★★ (66) 26% 253 total votes Your vote: Jim Raynor (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Tychus Findlay★ (14) 6% ★★ (18) 8% ★★★ (53) 24% ★★★★ (80) 36% ★★★★★ (55) 25% 220 total votes Your vote: Tychus Findlay (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Matt Horner★ (20) 10% ★★ (28) 14% ★★★ (47) 23% ★★★★ (72) 35% ★★★★★ (40) 19% 207 total votes Your vote: Matt Horner (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Rory Swann★ (20) 11% ★★ (35) 19% ★★★ (63) 34% ★★★★ (45) 24% ★★★★★ (25) 13% 188 total votes Your vote: Rory Swann (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Egon Stetmann★ (57) 33% ★★ (57) 33% ★★★ (34) 20% ★★★★ (15) 9% ★★★★★ (8) 5% 171 total votes Your vote: Egon Stetmann (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Ariel Hanson★ (79) 47% ★★ (47) 28% ★★★ (29) 17% ★★★★ (7) 4% ★★★★★ (6) 4% 168 total votes Your vote: Ariel Hanson (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Gabriel Tosh★ (15) 8% ★★ (13) 7% ★★★ (23) 12% ★★★★ (58) 31% ★★★★★ (78) 42% 187 total votes Your vote: Gabriel Tosh (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Nova★ (14) 7% ★★ (19) 10% ★★★ (50) 26% ★★★★ (44) 23% ★★★★★ (67) 35% 194 total votes Your vote: Nova (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Mira Han★ (22) 13% ★★ (26) 15% ★★★ (58) 33% ★★★★ (37) 21% ★★★★★ (33) 19% 176 total votes Your vote: Mira Han (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Horace Warfield★ (12) 7% ★★ (13) 7% ★★★ (32) 18% ★★★★ (45) 25% ★★★★★ (77) 43% 179 total votes Your vote: Horace Warfield (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Valerian Mengsk★ (17) 10% ★★ (17) 10% ★★★ (39) 22% ★★★★ (80) 46% ★★★★★ (22) 13% 175 total votes Your vote: Valerian Mengsk (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Arcturus Mengsk★ (20) 11% ★★ (13) 7% ★★★ (25) 14% ★★★★ (48) 27% ★★★★★ (74) 41% 180 total votes Your vote: Arcturus Mengsk (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Zerg Characters
Poll: Sarah Kerrigan★ (29) 14% ★★ (43) 21% ★★★ (32) 16% ★★★★ (42) 21% ★★★★★ (58) 28% 204 total votes Your vote: Sarah Kerrigan (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Zagara★ (15) 10% ★★ (29) 18% ★★★ (53) 34% ★★★★ (40) 25% ★★★★★ (20) 13% 157 total votes Your vote: Zagara (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Izsha★ (27) 18% ★★ (44) 30% ★★★ (44) 30% ★★★★ (16) 11% ★★★★★ (15) 10% 146 total votes Your vote: Izsha (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Abathur★ (22) 11% ★★ (6) 3% ★★★ (8) 4% ★★★★ (20) 10% ★★★★★ (149) 73% 205 total votes Your vote: Abathur (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Dehaka★ (40) 26% ★★ (33) 22% ★★★ (38) 25% ★★★★ (26) 17% ★★★★★ (14) 9% 151 total votes Your vote: Dehaka (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Alexei Stukov★ (17) 10% ★★ (10) 6% ★★★ (17) 10% ★★★★ (48) 29% ★★★★★ (76) 45% 168 total votes Your vote: Alexei Stukov (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Protoss Characters
Poll: Artanis★ (12) 6% ★★ (10) 5% ★★★ (85) 40% ★★★★ (56) 26% ★★★★★ (51) 24% 214 total votes Your vote: Artanis (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Selendis★ (73) 36% ★★ (51) 25% ★★★ (37) 18% ★★★★ (26) 13% ★★★★★ (18) 9% 205 total votes Your vote: Selendis (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Karax★ (15) 10% ★★ (35) 23% ★★★ (47) 31% ★★★★ (31) 20% ★★★★★ (24) 16% 152 total votes Your vote: Karax (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Rohana★ (27) 18% ★★ (28) 19% ★★★ (41) 27% ★★★★ (36) 24% ★★★★★ (19) 13% 151 total votes Your vote: Rohana (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Vorazun★ (55) 28% ★★ (11) 6% ★★★ (35) 18% ★★★★ (76) 39% ★★★★★ (20) 10% 197 total votes Your vote: Vorazun (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Fenix/Talandar★ (23) 14% ★★ (11) 7% ★★★ (36) 22% ★★★★ (57) 35% ★★★★★ (38) 23% 165 total votes Your vote: Fenix/Talandar (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Alarak★ (28) 13% ★★ (5) 2% ★★★ (10) 5% ★★★★ (35) 17% ★★★★★ (132) 63% 210 total votes Your vote: Alarak (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Zeratul★ (11) 3% ★★ (4) 1% ★★★ (8) 2% ★★★★ (36) 9% ★★★★★ (331) 85% 390 total votes Your vote: Zeratul (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Other Characters
Poll: Emil Narud/Samir Duran★ (30) 21% ★★ (42) 30% ★★★ (45) 32% ★★★★ (18) 13% ★★★★★ (6) 4% 141 total votes Your vote: Emil Narud/Samir Duran (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Amon★ (113) 64% ★★ (24) 14% ★★★ (25) 14% ★★★★ (6) 3% ★★★★★ (8) 5% 176 total votes Your vote: Amon (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Overall thoughts
Poll: Wings of Liberty★ (8) 4% ★★ (12) 6% ★★★ (22) 12% ★★★★ (52) 27% ★★★★★ (97) 51% 191 total votes Your vote: Wings of Liberty (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Heart of the Swarm★ (20) 11% ★★ (34) 18% ★★★ (67) 36% ★★★★ (39) 21% ★★★★★ (26) 14% 186 total votes Your vote: Heart of the Swarm (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Prologue to Legacy of the Void (Whispers of Oblivion)★ (9) 5% ★★ (18) 11% ★★★ (80) 47% ★★★★ (39) 23% ★★★★★ (24) 14% 170 total votes Your vote: Prologue to Legacy of the Void (Whispers of Oblivion) (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Legacy of the Void★ (7) 4% ★★ (10) 5% ★★★ (15) 8% ★★★★ (53) 29% ★★★★★ (97) 53% 182 total votes Your vote: Legacy of the Void (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Epilogue (Into the Void)★ (48) 31% ★★ (34) 22% ★★★ (29) 19% ★★★★ (27) 17% ★★★★★ (18) 12% 156 total votes Your vote: Epilogue (Into the Void) (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
Poll: Your favourite chapterWings of Liberty (92) 42% Heart of the Swarm (23) 11% Prologue to Legacy of the Void (Whispers of Oblivion) (1) 0% Legacy of the Void (95) 43% Epilogue (Into the Void) (8) 4% 219 total votes Your vote: Your favourite chapter (Vote): Wings of Liberty
(Vote): Heart of the Swarm
(Vote): Prologue to Legacy of the Void (Whispers of Oblivion)
(Vote): Legacy of the Void
(Vote): Epilogue (Into the Void)
Poll: Starcraft 2 campaign★ (9) 4% ★★ (12) 6% ★★★ (34) 17% ★★★★ (91) 45% ★★★★★ (55) 27% 201 total votes Your vote: Starcraft 2 campaign (Vote): ★
(Vote): ★★
(Vote): ★★★
(Vote): ★★★★
(Vote): ★★★★★
|
For characters, I assume we vote solely on how they are portrayed in SC2, correct?
Also, aren't poll threads not allowed?
|
Russian Federation4295 Posts
I'd prefer to have strawpoll. Clicking on every spoiler and on every mission may be annoying
|
Russian Federation4235 Posts
Dunno what it was for, but it made me realize that over the course of the SC2 campaigns I only really liked three characters and those were Abathur, Tychus and Alarak.
|
Russian Federation1613 Posts
Ok, i got it, it was too massive...
I lightened it deleting all mission polls and deleted spoilers.
|
TL full of yay-sayers and buttlickers. sc2 story and 90% of characters, fluff, dialogues is downright shameful imo. nice gameplay tho
User was warned for this post
|
Doh dang touch screen I accidentally clicked epilogue as favorite chapter! I meant to click lotv  .
Anyways, overall I'm glad they brought Duran back for stukov to kill, but overall Duran just seemed like a wasted opportunity.
|
I think WoL storyline and gameplay was decent. HotS gameplay was a bit better, but story really sucked, also you didn't really get to feel the fun gameplay, because it was way too easy.
LotV was by far the best story and gameplay was strong as well, but epilogue story was even worse than HotS.
Alarak and Abathur is by far the best characters.
|
I think WoL Missions have been the best. Year, also alot of search and destroy, but also trains, super nova, mine x amount of that, do X at Z before enemy does Y at Z, hold a base with freaking laser, hold a base with some artefacts, save that mad tychus in the odin, use that odin, kill everything, play this hero mission...
Really, WoL Missions had a much greater design then HotS and LotV. The two missions on HotS I liked have been the Hyperion Mission and the "infest that protoss ship"-mission.
In LotV it was top of the top, no mission was outstanding even these with a twist: Kill X amout of Y to unlock/destroy/whatever Z. Almost every time. The Alarak Mission was cool, the hero mission gave hero inflation feeling and some defending missions... WoL was much stronger in that regard.
Also I liked the Hyperion much more then Spear of Adun or the Zerg ship. Using merchs have been a great adition, the upgrades from the technology bay felt much more unique then anything from Zerg or Protoss Upgrades. And the buyable upgrades just made your core army feeling op. At least when you didnt play on brutal where the game was actually brutal and not play&chill like in hots. In LotV solar core felt really stupid, I only used orbital fire abilities in extreme emergancy and the passives. Not really a choice to make for me as most of the solar core was useless for me. The Upgrades from the upgrade girl were just straight boring: No hard choice to make, no really need to swap over. After I had Dark Archons, Voids and Zelots, I couldnt care less about them.
Even the WoL story felt better, dadada Tychus is back and oh fuck, Zergs are here too. Lets grab this what they want and collect that what they want and oh, what they want is oooold and magic and strong and Zeratul wants me to find Sarah, so lets use artefact with Sarah. And yeah fuck Mengsk by the way, lets show the world his true face and oh yeah, lets fight with his son, he seems nice.
Zerg Story: Dont play with Zerg, stupid Valarian, oh lets run, nooo Jim, I WANT REVENGE, UNITE THE SWARM!!!!!!, oh some Duran/Narud here, okay. Mengsk dead, maybe some Amon here somewhere? Stupid Zeratul never telling me everything.
LotV: Invasion failed, thx Amon, lets rally some Ex Machina robot protoss and some dirty Amon lovers around me. Xel Naga ded, lets use Artefact from Terrans to kill Amon, it worked, fine.
Seriously, the story became worse with every chapter. Amon is the worst enemy ever in a videogame... zero dimensional, loses all fights after the first battle for Aiur in LotV, talks permanently about circlejerking and breaking circlejerking, really, worst Enemy ever. Even Dr. Narud was a better enemy. And he was one dimensional of following leadership. Nothing in common with BW Duran.
Oh and I liked Mira and Matt, but they didnt have enough screen time to have some character.
|
WoL campaign was so epic. Well written and everything. Missions were fun and varied.
I like the SC2 story/characters and have been waiting a long time, so I was excited to play HotS and LotV regardless, but they were obviously not as good.
Dialogue wasn't as good, cutscenes not as good, just... not as epic. It felt drawn out a bit and all the missions were the same (destroy 4-5 poorly guarded X to unlock Y).
Still enjoyed it though. Played through the campaign for like 10 hours straight haha.
|
Elentos
55594 Posts
For me it's WoL > LotV > HotS >>>>>>>> Epilogue.
Alarak, Abathur, Arcturus, Tosh and Stukov were my fav. characters.
|
I know a lot of people did not like HotS because of the story and the fact that it was very easy but I thought it was pretty good, the gameplay at least. It was the closest thing we got to Warcraft 3. Also Abathur was awesome.
|
WOL at least gave you choices on how to advance the story which effected which units you were able to produce and types of enemies you would fight. After that, it was all just follow the story on rails mode for HOTS and LOTV.
|
Fuck me, people actually like Zeratul in SC2? He was the best character in SC1, ruined completely by being turned in a loony stereotype character that wouldn't shut up about his damn prophecies. 1 star for that fellow.
Still, this was fun answering.
|
Alarak vs Abathur grand finals bo7
|
Starcraft 2 campaign gameplay-wise - 5, Story - 1; overall: 3.
|
WoL > LotV > HotS although story wise it's like the matrix movies. 1 was great, 2+3 should've never happened except for the cinematics (goliaths in zion are great)
|
The epilogue was shit. lame supersayan kerrigan vs generic evil.
(although I shed a manly tear when she came back and Raynor left with her ((( )
|
Russian Federation1613 Posts
On November 25 2015 00:57 DifuntO wrote:
I know a lot of people did not like HotS because of the story and the fact that it was very easy but I thought it was pretty good, the gameplay at least. It was the closest thing we got to Warcraft 3. Also Abathur was awesome.
Actually i like HotS the most. Cinematics, atmosphere, story are so dark and rough. It's my favourite and i like that's im not in the majority!
On November 25 2015 05:02 boxerfred wrote:The epilogue was shit. lame supersayan kerrigan vs generic evil. (although I shed a manly tear when she came back and Raynor left with her ((( )
Actually i shed a tear everytime i see Zeratul vs Artanis cinematic in LotV...
But i cry everytime i see any of the Heart of the Swarm cinematics...
|
On November 25 2015 03:12 frajen86 wrote:
Alarak vs Abathur grand finals bo7
Lol. Yes.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
