|
On January 06 2016 22:48 Numy wrote:Show nested quote +On January 06 2016 22:29 Seuss wrote:On January 06 2016 22:02 Parnage wrote:On January 06 2016 21:36 Ketara wrote: I don't think there's much argument really.
The Star Wars discussion has pretty much been pages and pages of us all agreeing with each other, with a couple outliers. I'm a minority opinion woo. The new film is a laughably flawed, jar jar managed to ruin star trek and star wars an achievement of some legend. Steal things from the EU, rehash episode 4, make your blockbuster on marketing and then watch it all go down the drain because your attempt at boba fett was replaced by a random stormtrooper. Flawed yes. Awesome, also yes. TR-8R is hilarious though. Whether the awesome is a bigger deal than the flaws depends on how good the follow up movies are. Star Trek was a flawed movie, but a lot of fans were okay with it up until Into Darkness was awful. The thing is Into darkness is analogus with new SW. It's just that the star trek movies were more star wars than star trek so the fans didn't want just a throwback movie. Judging by the SW reception most fans are perfectly happy with a throwback movie so I don't think it's right to compare them at all
The fans I knew were perfectly happy with the idea of a throwback movie. Khan was the worst kept secret since Snape killing Dumbledore and lots of fans were completely stoked for Benedict Cumberbatch's take on the character.
Benedict Cumberbatch was, in fact, the best part of Into Darkness but the rest was something of a hot mess. A successful hot mess, but still a hot mess.
|
On January 06 2016 23:05 Seuss wrote:Show nested quote +On January 06 2016 22:48 Numy wrote:On January 06 2016 22:29 Seuss wrote:On January 06 2016 22:02 Parnage wrote:On January 06 2016 21:36 Ketara wrote: I don't think there's much argument really.
The Star Wars discussion has pretty much been pages and pages of us all agreeing with each other, with a couple outliers. I'm a minority opinion woo. The new film is a laughably flawed, jar jar managed to ruin star trek and star wars an achievement of some legend. Steal things from the EU, rehash episode 4, make your blockbuster on marketing and then watch it all go down the drain because your attempt at boba fett was replaced by a random stormtrooper. Flawed yes. Awesome, also yes. TR-8R is hilarious though. Whether the awesome is a bigger deal than the flaws depends on how good the follow up movies are. Star Trek was a flawed movie, but a lot of fans were okay with it up until Into Darkness was awful. The thing is Into darkness is analogus with new SW. It's just that the star trek movies were more star wars than star trek so the fans didn't want just a throwback movie. Judging by the SW reception most fans are perfectly happy with a throwback movie so I don't think it's right to compare them at all The fans I knew were perfectly happy with the idea of a throwback movie. Khan was the worst kept secret since Snape killing Dumbledore and lots of fans were completely stoked for Benedict Cumberbatch's take on the character. Benedict Cumberbatch was, in fact, the best part of Into Darkness but the rest was something of a hot mess. A successful hot mess, but still a hot mess. There is a difference between a throwback movie that pays homage to the original while doing it's own take and a movie that's essentially a bastardized retelling wrapped around a star wars shell that's akin to a teenager attempt at writing. Thats what into darkness was and to an extent what star wars is. I find it hard to believe any fan wanted that kind of throwback instead of just a new telling of Khans story
|
On January 06 2016 23:13 Numy wrote:Show nested quote +On January 06 2016 23:05 Seuss wrote:On January 06 2016 22:48 Numy wrote:On January 06 2016 22:29 Seuss wrote:On January 06 2016 22:02 Parnage wrote:On January 06 2016 21:36 Ketara wrote: I don't think there's much argument really.
The Star Wars discussion has pretty much been pages and pages of us all agreeing with each other, with a couple outliers. I'm a minority opinion woo. The new film is a laughably flawed, jar jar managed to ruin star trek and star wars an achievement of some legend. Steal things from the EU, rehash episode 4, make your blockbuster on marketing and then watch it all go down the drain because your attempt at boba fett was replaced by a random stormtrooper. Flawed yes. Awesome, also yes. TR-8R is hilarious though. Whether the awesome is a bigger deal than the flaws depends on how good the follow up movies are. Star Trek was a flawed movie, but a lot of fans were okay with it up until Into Darkness was awful. The thing is Into darkness is analogus with new SW. It's just that the star trek movies were more star wars than star trek so the fans didn't want just a throwback movie. Judging by the SW reception most fans are perfectly happy with a throwback movie so I don't think it's right to compare them at all The fans I knew were perfectly happy with the idea of a throwback movie. Khan was the worst kept secret since Snape killing Dumbledore and lots of fans were completely stoked for Benedict Cumberbatch's take on the character. Benedict Cumberbatch was, in fact, the best part of Into Darkness but the rest was something of a hot mess. A successful hot mess, but still a hot mess. There is a difference between a throwback movie that pays homage to the original while doing it's own take and a movie that's essentially a bastardized retelling wrapped around a star wars shell that's akin to a teenager attempt at writing. Thats what into darkness was and to an extent what star wars is. I find it hard to believe any fan wanted that kind of throwback instead of just a new telling of Khans story
You're correct about Into Darkness, and that's why fans were disappointed. However, I don't think TFA fell into the same trap. It may have pulled lots of elements from its predecessors, but the end result was a great, flawed movie rather than a hot mess.
|
I may be a bit raving mad as I was posting at the gym during sets so my inner hatred for what JJ did to Star Trek could be clouding judgement lol. I've said it before but I enjoyed watching Star Wars, I just didn't find it particularly good and it was a bit of a disappointment to me as I hoped we'd see something more along the lines of stories like Kotor games or Jedi Knight stuff.
On a slightly unrelated note. Does anyone here kind of just blank out starring at something but your mind is completely elsewhere? That happens so often that I kind of try focus super hard to not do it at the gym. Don't want some women feeling like I'm starring at them the whole time but man it takes what little mental energy I have left to do keep from doing it. It's worse when those women that are just amazingly beautiful walk past. Like what do you do. Stare at the floor? I just want to focus on doing my exercise so half the time I'm just replaying form in my head while I wait.
|
I think that's the vast majority reaction to TFA.
We liked it. We agree it has some issues. But we still liked it.
I'll be quite happy if the next installment is a deeper movie.
|
On January 06 2016 23:43 Numy wrote: I may be a bit raving mad as I was posting at the gym during sets so my inner hatred for what JJ did to Star Trek could be clouding judgement lol. I've said it before but I enjoyed watching Star Wars, I just didn't find it particularly good and it was a bit of a disappointment to me as I hoped we'd see something more along the lines of stories like Kotor games or Jedi Knight stuff.
On a slightly unrelated note. Does anyone here kind of just blank out starring at something but your mind is completely elsewhere? That happens so often that I kind of try focus super hard to not do it at the gym. Don't want some women feeling like I'm starring at them the whole time but man it takes what little mental energy I have left to do keep from doing it. It's worse when those women that are just amazingly beautiful walk past. Like what do you do. Stare at the floor? I just want to focus on doing my exercise so half the time I'm just replaying form in my head while I wait.
I don't blame you. He really butchered Star Trek badly and I could write a treatise on everything wrong with Into Darkness. If it wasn't for Benedict Cumberbatch being Benedict Cumberbatch that movie's only redeeming quality would have been the fact that it made money.
|
Is there even a movie from a loved franchise that didn't make loads of money? Doesn't seem like it matters if something is good when it comes to making money.
|
Hence the only reason why hollywood make any new stuff is so they can make +3 of it.
|
Relevant:+ Show Spoiler +
Star Trek: Nemesis arguably bombed. I'm sure there have been plenty of other cases where beloved franchises crashed, but most of the time it's probably after they've been sequeled to death.
|
On January 06 2016 23:43 Numy wrote: I may be a bit raving mad as I was posting at the gym during sets so my inner hatred for what JJ did to Star Trek could be clouding judgement lol. I've said it before but I enjoyed watching Star Wars, I just didn't find it particularly good and it was a bit of a disappointment to me as I hoped we'd see something more along the lines of stories like Kotor games or Jedi Knight stuff.
On a slightly unrelated note. Does anyone here kind of just blank out starring at something but your mind is completely elsewhere? That happens so often that I kind of try focus super hard to not do it at the gym. Don't want some women feeling like I'm starring at them the whole time but man it takes what little mental energy I have left to do keep from doing it. It's worse when those women that are just amazingly beautiful walk past. Like what do you do. Stare at the floor? I just want to focus on doing my exercise so half the time I'm just replaying form in my head while I wait. Find a mirror and 'mire your pump.
|
I'm not a Star Trek fan, but I thought Into Darkness was a pretty stupid movie. It looked kinda cool, but the plot and a lot of plot points were just... dumb.
Out of all the movies I watched that summer, it was the worst. I even scrounged around for a pair of 3D glasses so I could see it cuz I was movie hopping and bought a regular ticket to see Fast6. Fast6 was a good movie. I watched it 3 times in theaters.
EDIT: I love how this thread is turning into the other threads I pay attention to.
|
The trailer for the next ST film looked more stupid, so there's that.
|
On January 06 2016 22:34 Ketara wrote: Oh man google image searching TR-8R is giving me some of the funniest shit I've seen in like a month.
I encourage everybody to do this. I'm so confused edit: oohhh, I got BB8 and TR-8R confused
|
MtG again : + Show Spoiler [text 'cause French spoiler] +Dimensional Infiltrator 1U Creature - Eldrazi (Rare) Devoid, flash, flying 1C: Exile the top card of target opponent's library. If it's a land card, you may return ~ to its owner's hand. 2/1 People are gushing all over it. I assume that 2 attack flyer for CMC2 is already considered decent to very good (in limited), flash is super good in blue because of all the counterspells and other instants you're going to save mana for (so if not you can EoT your creature and only lose a block). I can see when you block a big non-trample guy with this, activate its ability and hopefully hit a land to get it back to hand, so you take no damage and can EoT cast it back on board, but isn't that a bit expansive for 2UC? Or is it, again, with limited in mind, and the idea that it's still favourable odds to save 4+ damage and make it potentially repeatable in the late game?
|
On January 06 2016 21:33 Numy wrote: That's not particularly much for editing. Honestly I don't get why where's so much argument about something that is just meant to boot up the toy selling franchise again. It's not a particularly good movie. It's there for nostalgia and to get the next set of 50 movies going. It's as inoffensive a movie as you can get. I think of it merely as them doing a summary of the original Star Wars for kids that haven't seen them.
We'll see if the next ones are any better which is the real telling point. After what JJ did with Star Trek my hope isn't that high but maybe Disney will make sure he doesn't cock it up. I thought the movie was still enjoyable. I'm usually pretty good about turning off my brain and enjoying archetype character being badasses. Just too invested into SW franchise to just let poor characters slide.
|
On January 06 2016 21:33 Numy wrote: That's not particularly much for editing. Honestly I don't get why where's so much argument about something that is just meant to boot up the toy selling franchise again. It's not a particularly good movie. It's there for nostalgia and to get the next set of 50 movies going. It's as inoffensive a movie as you can get. I think of it merely as them doing a summary of the original Star Wars for kids that haven't seen them.
We'll see if the next ones are any better which is the real telling point. After what JJ did with Star Trek my hope isn't that high but maybe Disney will make sure he doesn't cock it up. I've also seen other interviews that say somewhere between 30-40 minutes. Hence me posting the conservative estimate.
|
On January 06 2016 23:43 Numy wrote: I may be a bit raving mad as I was posting at the gym during sets so my inner hatred for what JJ did to Star Trek could be clouding judgement lol. I've said it before but I enjoyed watching Star Wars, I just didn't find it particularly good and it was a bit of a disappointment to me as I hoped we'd see something more along the lines of stories like Kotor games or Jedi Knight stuff.
On a slightly unrelated note. Does anyone here kind of just blank out starring at something but your mind is completely elsewhere? That happens so often that I kind of try focus super hard to not do it at the gym. Don't want some women feeling like I'm starring at them the whole time but man it takes what little mental energy I have left to do keep from doing it. It's worse when those women that are just amazingly beautiful walk past. Like what do you do. Stare at the floor? I just want to focus on doing my exercise so half the time I'm just replaying form in my head while I wait. You're a big nerd. We should talk about something that makes you less angry. Like OGW FULL SPOILERS FRIDAY HYYYPE
|
Hmm is there anything left that's exciting? I want the new Chandra so far and maybe that Elf girls Oath.
|
United States47024 Posts
Spoiler season shows us the new cards but not any potentially exciting reprints, so there's that.
|
I know I play a lot of shitty decks but holy fuck is Flamewaker Mage the most cancer thing. I think I have a 0% winrate against it.
|
|
|
|
|
|