• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 23:16
CET 05:16
KST 13:16
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #238[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over4Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over Team Liquid Map Contest #23 Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon
Tourneys
Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ BW General Discussion NaDa's Body Light introduces ShieldBattery on his YouTube
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL23] Ro16 Group D - Sunday 21:00 CET [BSL23] Ro16 Group B - Saturday 21:00 CET
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
Trading/Investing Thread US Politics Mega-thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 12633 users

The LiquidLegends Lounge - Page 921

Forum Index > The Shopkeeper′s Inn
Post a Reply
Prev 1 919 920 921 922 923 1885 Next
Gahlo
Profile Joined February 2010
United States35174 Posts
Last Edited: 2016-01-06 06:12:35
January 06 2016 06:10 GMT
#18401
On January 06 2016 05:13 wei2coolman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 05:09 Eppa! wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
The helmet is there to protect him from his own insecurities. The removal is his path to dealing with them. Fuck rey kylo ren should have been the hero of the movie

+ Show Spoiler +

Would have been a pretty cool twist if we saw Kylo Ren become more attracted to the light side, and Rey become more attracted to the dark side.


+ Show Spoiler +
Novelization note: When Kylo kills Han, instead of feeling a sense of conviction he actually feels bad about it.


On January 06 2016 05:07 wei2coolman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 04:44 phyvo wrote:
On January 05 2016 15:57 wei2coolman wrote:
Finally got around to watching SW:TFA. Glad I waited a week or so to watch it. Theatre was maybe 25% filled, with no babies or little kids. Audience was pretty quiet with the occasional laughter. 10/10 movie watching experience.

On to the movie:
+ Show Spoiler +

I thought the movie was excellent, well paced, and well shot. I thought the movie should have ended with the celebration at the Resistance base, after the destruction of the Star Killer. I thought the search for Luke after left it at a pretty cheezy cliff hanger (quite literally).

The new characters were thin. Like Christian Bale in The Machinist thin. While the character goals for Rey, Finn, and Kylo were spelled out to the audience; the motivation was extremely lacking. For example, Finn wanted to escape the First Order so badly, he'd randomly free a prisoner and shoot down his own comrades? While the storm troopers were obviously brain washed (as mentioned with the "reprogramming" quip); it was also apparent the troops were more human than the clone army (mentioning of "traitor" by the troops; and the need for motivational speeches by General Hux. Also, Rey is like totally a Mary Sue. The ability to used Jedi Mind Tricks within minutes (or hours) of unlocking some inkling of the force... That's like super suspect. Also, the ability to instantly channel the force mid-fight against Kylo, a trained Force user was weird as well. As far as defeating Kylo, that was fine considering his injuries.

Also, not sure if they were trying to make Kylo seem super menacing in the early part of the film. But he felt like a 14 year old spoiled little brat for most of the film. Wasn't menacing at all either.


+ Show Spoiler +

I actually liked the movie a lot too.

Finn freeing the prisoner actually was explained in the movie. Basically, he needed a pilot. IMO he wasn't the most fleshed out dude but he was an OK character, better than Rey.

Rey is one of my nitpicks. Even if the movie did imply something as Gahlo said (although I don't think the novelization matters), it was really hard for me to catch whatever backstory she had in those weird flashbacks... or flash forwards? I honestly didn't know what the crap I was supposed to be seeing, future or past. Moreover, even if her quick grasp of the force was justified, it doesn't make her less of a Mary Sue. I mean, she's grown up Anakin: mechanical genius, genius pilot, and now genius force user. For half of the movie I thought they would give Finn force powers to have balanced characters but no, Finn just gets the power of Heart.

I liked Kylo overall. While I found him a lot less intimidating with the helmet off, I think that part of the point of the movie was that Kylo is still a pretty young kid. Snoke actually annoyed me a lot more than both Rey and Kylo for being a completely bland, generic, and uninteresting cgi big bad guy.

And all that said, I still like the movie despite these flaws.

+ Show Spoiler +
I'm just glad we got a Star Wars movie, not a JJ Abrams movie.


IMO Rey wasn't force awaken until the movie, because it's mentioned by Snoke and Kylo they felt a "new" force. As far as combat prowess, and piloting ability a lot of it could just be explained by rough childhood (always carrying the staff as self-defense). Another big problem was, there was absolutely 0 reason to have Rey use Jedi Mind Trick right away (which I assume is a finesse Force skill). Nothing would have changed plot wise if Finn and Solo found her in the interrogation room, as opposed to her roaming around aimlessly on the base. Her force development could have very easily been pushed back until the next movie. Also felt that they could have easily gone the route of uncontrolled inexperienced force user for Rey, as a reason why she defeats Kylo Ren. It makes a lot more sense if she just had insane raw untapped force control, and just surprised Kylo Ren with raw force usage (something like Force push, and pull). Instead she defeats him with light saber combat, with clean force usage of force pull on the light saber.

Not sure if anyone noticed, but the split in the land after the fight was a complete mirror to Obi Wan and Anikan when he said it was over.

The worst character for me was Kylo Ren though. Literally whiny beta male cry baby the entire movie. He never seemed menacing at all, even in the opening scene.

Also, what's the point of Captain Phasma? I don't get the hype? Female leading storm troopers? She didn't do jack shit all movie.


+ Show Spoiler +
Rey uses a mind trick, a force power most effective against the weak willed, against a stormtrooper. Stormtroopers have been canonically described as being weak willed in general. Ontop of that, they've been undergoing brainwashing by the First Order since they were taken from their families. If we're talking a human adult you're hurting to find a target less formidable than a FO trooper.

As for the Rey vs Kylo fight, it's explained a lot better in the novel. Kylo is also previously shot with a Wookie bowcaster, which is supposedly at normal strength to have enough kickback to dislocate a human arm even when used properly, and a small scuffle with Finn. He was nowhere near even decent fighting shape.




On January 06 2016 05:41 Cixah wrote:
I'mma post the song bet league tonight at 5pm my time (2hrs 20 minutes from now.)

Were gunna draft in teamspeak Friday or Saturday

Poll: Friday or Saturday

Sat at 3pm CST (2)
 
67%

Fri at 3pm CST (1)
 
33%

3 total votes

Your vote: Friday or Saturday

(Vote): Sat at 3pm CST
(Vote): Fri at 3pm CST



Other times are possible, lmk if problems.

Either days work for me, but I free up anywhere between 5-6pm EST depending on traffic.
Lord Tolkien
Profile Joined November 2012
United States12084 Posts
January 06 2016 06:27 GMT
#18402
songbet league whar
"His father is pretty juicy tbh." ~WaveofShadow
wei2coolman
Profile Joined November 2010
United States60033 Posts
January 06 2016 06:41 GMT
#18403
On January 06 2016 15:10 Gahlo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 05:13 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 05:09 Eppa! wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
The helmet is there to protect him from his own insecurities. The removal is his path to dealing with them. Fuck rey kylo ren should have been the hero of the movie

+ Show Spoiler +

Would have been a pretty cool twist if we saw Kylo Ren become more attracted to the light side, and Rey become more attracted to the dark side.


+ Show Spoiler +
Novelization note: When Kylo kills Han, instead of feeling a sense of conviction he actually feels bad about it.


Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 05:07 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 04:44 phyvo wrote:
On January 05 2016 15:57 wei2coolman wrote:
Finally got around to watching SW:TFA. Glad I waited a week or so to watch it. Theatre was maybe 25% filled, with no babies or little kids. Audience was pretty quiet with the occasional laughter. 10/10 movie watching experience.

On to the movie:
+ Show Spoiler +

I thought the movie was excellent, well paced, and well shot. I thought the movie should have ended with the celebration at the Resistance base, after the destruction of the Star Killer. I thought the search for Luke after left it at a pretty cheezy cliff hanger (quite literally).

The new characters were thin. Like Christian Bale in The Machinist thin. While the character goals for Rey, Finn, and Kylo were spelled out to the audience; the motivation was extremely lacking. For example, Finn wanted to escape the First Order so badly, he'd randomly free a prisoner and shoot down his own comrades? While the storm troopers were obviously brain washed (as mentioned with the "reprogramming" quip); it was also apparent the troops were more human than the clone army (mentioning of "traitor" by the troops; and the need for motivational speeches by General Hux. Also, Rey is like totally a Mary Sue. The ability to used Jedi Mind Tricks within minutes (or hours) of unlocking some inkling of the force... That's like super suspect. Also, the ability to instantly channel the force mid-fight against Kylo, a trained Force user was weird as well. As far as defeating Kylo, that was fine considering his injuries.

Also, not sure if they were trying to make Kylo seem super menacing in the early part of the film. But he felt like a 14 year old spoiled little brat for most of the film. Wasn't menacing at all either.


+ Show Spoiler +

I actually liked the movie a lot too.

Finn freeing the prisoner actually was explained in the movie. Basically, he needed a pilot. IMO he wasn't the most fleshed out dude but he was an OK character, better than Rey.

Rey is one of my nitpicks. Even if the movie did imply something as Gahlo said (although I don't think the novelization matters), it was really hard for me to catch whatever backstory she had in those weird flashbacks... or flash forwards? I honestly didn't know what the crap I was supposed to be seeing, future or past. Moreover, even if her quick grasp of the force was justified, it doesn't make her less of a Mary Sue. I mean, she's grown up Anakin: mechanical genius, genius pilot, and now genius force user. For half of the movie I thought they would give Finn force powers to have balanced characters but no, Finn just gets the power of Heart.

I liked Kylo overall. While I found him a lot less intimidating with the helmet off, I think that part of the point of the movie was that Kylo is still a pretty young kid. Snoke actually annoyed me a lot more than both Rey and Kylo for being a completely bland, generic, and uninteresting cgi big bad guy.

And all that said, I still like the movie despite these flaws.

+ Show Spoiler +
I'm just glad we got a Star Wars movie, not a JJ Abrams movie.


IMO Rey wasn't force awaken until the movie, because it's mentioned by Snoke and Kylo they felt a "new" force. As far as combat prowess, and piloting ability a lot of it could just be explained by rough childhood (always carrying the staff as self-defense). Another big problem was, there was absolutely 0 reason to have Rey use Jedi Mind Trick right away (which I assume is a finesse Force skill). Nothing would have changed plot wise if Finn and Solo found her in the interrogation room, as opposed to her roaming around aimlessly on the base. Her force development could have very easily been pushed back until the next movie. Also felt that they could have easily gone the route of uncontrolled inexperienced force user for Rey, as a reason why she defeats Kylo Ren. It makes a lot more sense if she just had insane raw untapped force control, and just surprised Kylo Ren with raw force usage (something like Force push, and pull). Instead she defeats him with light saber combat, with clean force usage of force pull on the light saber.

Not sure if anyone noticed, but the split in the land after the fight was a complete mirror to Obi Wan and Anikan when he said it was over.

The worst character for me was Kylo Ren though. Literally whiny beta male cry baby the entire movie. He never seemed menacing at all, even in the opening scene.

Also, what's the point of Captain Phasma? I don't get the hype? Female leading storm troopers? She didn't do jack shit all movie.


+ Show Spoiler +
Rey uses a mind trick, a force power most effective against the weak willed, against a stormtrooper. Stormtroopers have been canonically described as being weak willed in general. Ontop of that, they've been undergoing brainwashing by the First Order since they were taken from their families. If we're talking a human adult you're hurting to find a target less formidable than a FO trooper.

As for the Rey vs Kylo fight, it's explained a lot better in the novel. Kylo is also previously shot with a Wookie bowcaster, which is supposedly at normal strength to have enough kickback to dislocate a human arm even when used properly, and a small scuffle with Finn. He was nowhere near even decent fighting shape.


+ Show Spoiler +
Considering how strong Jedi's/Siths are in cannon, kylo could have an arm and a leg missing, he shouldn't of lost. I mean, i would have preferred a deus ex machina defeating kylo (aka Bane's ending a la Dark Knight Rises). I mean there was literally 0 plot reason to allow Rey to escape interrogation, and defeat Kylo Ren. What would have changed in the plot had Rey been rescued from the interrogation room by Finn and Solo? Nothing. But, NOPE. Better add the fact she's now an expert force user (using jedi mind trick w/o distracting hand motion). Oh, could have written Rey barely escaping a furious Kylo Ren, but NOPE. WE EXPERT LIGHTSABER USER NAO.

Also; one thing that really bugged me about the movie was that I didn't feel an emotional tug to Han Solo dying. That's not to say Han Solo as a character wasn't bloody fucking amazing in TFA (easily best character in TFA); but there's just felt absolutely 0 character and plot consequences from his death. I mean, for such a huge character in the movies to just die, and have 0 emotional tug, I think there's just something innately wrong with the plot set-up for that big "moment", that didn't have that tug.

Also, are we really going to fall for the bullshit of Chewy's blaster when we see in the first 5 minutes of the film he stops a blaster shot mid-air?


I really liked Max Landis's take on what could have been. Kylo going crazy after killing Han Solo, and literally taunting Rey and Finn to kill him. But as the audience you're not sure if he's taunting, or he's being serious (akin to the serial killer wants to be caught plot point).

I dunno, the more I rehash the movie in my head, the more annoyed I get at all the characters in the movies.
liftlift > tsm
Gahlo
Profile Joined February 2010
United States35174 Posts
January 06 2016 06:50 GMT
#18404
On January 06 2016 15:41 wei2coolman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 15:10 Gahlo wrote:
On January 06 2016 05:13 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 05:09 Eppa! wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
The helmet is there to protect him from his own insecurities. The removal is his path to dealing with them. Fuck rey kylo ren should have been the hero of the movie

+ Show Spoiler +

Would have been a pretty cool twist if we saw Kylo Ren become more attracted to the light side, and Rey become more attracted to the dark side.


+ Show Spoiler +
Novelization note: When Kylo kills Han, instead of feeling a sense of conviction he actually feels bad about it.


On January 06 2016 05:07 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 04:44 phyvo wrote:
On January 05 2016 15:57 wei2coolman wrote:
Finally got around to watching SW:TFA. Glad I waited a week or so to watch it. Theatre was maybe 25% filled, with no babies or little kids. Audience was pretty quiet with the occasional laughter. 10/10 movie watching experience.

On to the movie:
+ Show Spoiler +

I thought the movie was excellent, well paced, and well shot. I thought the movie should have ended with the celebration at the Resistance base, after the destruction of the Star Killer. I thought the search for Luke after left it at a pretty cheezy cliff hanger (quite literally).

The new characters were thin. Like Christian Bale in The Machinist thin. While the character goals for Rey, Finn, and Kylo were spelled out to the audience; the motivation was extremely lacking. For example, Finn wanted to escape the First Order so badly, he'd randomly free a prisoner and shoot down his own comrades? While the storm troopers were obviously brain washed (as mentioned with the "reprogramming" quip); it was also apparent the troops were more human than the clone army (mentioning of "traitor" by the troops; and the need for motivational speeches by General Hux. Also, Rey is like totally a Mary Sue. The ability to used Jedi Mind Tricks within minutes (or hours) of unlocking some inkling of the force... That's like super suspect. Also, the ability to instantly channel the force mid-fight against Kylo, a trained Force user was weird as well. As far as defeating Kylo, that was fine considering his injuries.

Also, not sure if they were trying to make Kylo seem super menacing in the early part of the film. But he felt like a 14 year old spoiled little brat for most of the film. Wasn't menacing at all either.


+ Show Spoiler +

I actually liked the movie a lot too.

Finn freeing the prisoner actually was explained in the movie. Basically, he needed a pilot. IMO he wasn't the most fleshed out dude but he was an OK character, better than Rey.

Rey is one of my nitpicks. Even if the movie did imply something as Gahlo said (although I don't think the novelization matters), it was really hard for me to catch whatever backstory she had in those weird flashbacks... or flash forwards? I honestly didn't know what the crap I was supposed to be seeing, future or past. Moreover, even if her quick grasp of the force was justified, it doesn't make her less of a Mary Sue. I mean, she's grown up Anakin: mechanical genius, genius pilot, and now genius force user. For half of the movie I thought they would give Finn force powers to have balanced characters but no, Finn just gets the power of Heart.

I liked Kylo overall. While I found him a lot less intimidating with the helmet off, I think that part of the point of the movie was that Kylo is still a pretty young kid. Snoke actually annoyed me a lot more than both Rey and Kylo for being a completely bland, generic, and uninteresting cgi big bad guy.

And all that said, I still like the movie despite these flaws.

+ Show Spoiler +
I'm just glad we got a Star Wars movie, not a JJ Abrams movie.


IMO Rey wasn't force awaken until the movie, because it's mentioned by Snoke and Kylo they felt a "new" force. As far as combat prowess, and piloting ability a lot of it could just be explained by rough childhood (always carrying the staff as self-defense). Another big problem was, there was absolutely 0 reason to have Rey use Jedi Mind Trick right away (which I assume is a finesse Force skill). Nothing would have changed plot wise if Finn and Solo found her in the interrogation room, as opposed to her roaming around aimlessly on the base. Her force development could have very easily been pushed back until the next movie. Also felt that they could have easily gone the route of uncontrolled inexperienced force user for Rey, as a reason why she defeats Kylo Ren. It makes a lot more sense if she just had insane raw untapped force control, and just surprised Kylo Ren with raw force usage (something like Force push, and pull). Instead she defeats him with light saber combat, with clean force usage of force pull on the light saber.

Not sure if anyone noticed, but the split in the land after the fight was a complete mirror to Obi Wan and Anikan when he said it was over.

The worst character for me was Kylo Ren though. Literally whiny beta male cry baby the entire movie. He never seemed menacing at all, even in the opening scene.

Also, what's the point of Captain Phasma? I don't get the hype? Female leading storm troopers? She didn't do jack shit all movie.


+ Show Spoiler +
Rey uses a mind trick, a force power most effective against the weak willed, against a stormtrooper. Stormtroopers have been canonically described as being weak willed in general. Ontop of that, they've been undergoing brainwashing by the First Order since they were taken from their families. If we're talking a human adult you're hurting to find a target less formidable than a FO trooper.

As for the Rey vs Kylo fight, it's explained a lot better in the novel. Kylo is also previously shot with a Wookie bowcaster, which is supposedly at normal strength to have enough kickback to dislocate a human arm even when used properly, and a small scuffle with Finn. He was nowhere near even decent fighting shape.


+ Show Spoiler +
Considering how strong Jedi's/Siths are in cannon, kylo could have an arm and a leg missing, he shouldn't of lost. I mean, i would have preferred a deus ex machina defeating kylo (aka Bane's ending a la Dark Knight Rises). I mean there was literally 0 plot reason to allow Rey to escape interrogation, and defeat Kylo Ren. What would have changed in the plot had Rey been rescued from the interrogation room by Finn and Solo? Nothing. But, NOPE. Better add the fact she's now an expert force user (using jedi mind trick w/o distracting hand motion). Oh, could have written Rey barely escaping a furious Kylo Ren, but NOPE. WE EXPERT LIGHTSABER USER NAO.

Also; one thing that really bugged me about the movie was that I didn't feel an emotional tug to Han Solo dying. That's not to say Han Solo as a character wasn't bloody fucking amazing in TFA (easily best character in TFA); but there's just felt absolutely 0 character and plot consequences from his death. I mean, for such a huge character in the movies to just die, and have 0 emotional tug, I think there's just something innately wrong with the plot set-up for that big "moment", that didn't have that tug.

Also, are we really going to fall for the bullshit of Chewy's blaster when we see in the first 5 minutes of the film he stops a blaster shot mid-air?


I really liked Max Landis's take on what could have been. Kylo going crazy after killing Han Solo, and literally taunting Rey and Finn to kill him. But as the audience you're not sure if he's taunting, or he's being serious (akin to the serial killer wants to be caught plot point).

I dunno, the more I rehash the movie in my head, the more annoyed I get at all the characters in the movies.

+ Show Spoiler +
Kylo Ren isn't a Sith yet, he's a dark Jedi. The problem with why Han dying doesn't hit people is because there isn't enough emotional buildup between the two characters or about them. Hur dur, novelization fills that out a bit more.
Ketara
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
United States15065 Posts
Last Edited: 2016-01-06 06:53:20
January 06 2016 06:53 GMT
#18405
I feel like a lot of Gahlo's arguments against us having issues with the Star Wars movie boils down to "Well the novelization fixes that"

That doesn't mean that it's not broken in the movie.
http://www.liquidlegends.net/forum/lol-general/502075-patch-61-league-of-legends-general-discussion?page=25#498
wei2coolman
Profile Joined November 2010
United States60033 Posts
January 06 2016 06:57 GMT
#18406
On January 06 2016 15:50 Gahlo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 15:41 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 15:10 Gahlo wrote:
On January 06 2016 05:13 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 05:09 Eppa! wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
The helmet is there to protect him from his own insecurities. The removal is his path to dealing with them. Fuck rey kylo ren should have been the hero of the movie

+ Show Spoiler +

Would have been a pretty cool twist if we saw Kylo Ren become more attracted to the light side, and Rey become more attracted to the dark side.


+ Show Spoiler +
Novelization note: When Kylo kills Han, instead of feeling a sense of conviction he actually feels bad about it.


On January 06 2016 05:07 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 04:44 phyvo wrote:
On January 05 2016 15:57 wei2coolman wrote:
Finally got around to watching SW:TFA. Glad I waited a week or so to watch it. Theatre was maybe 25% filled, with no babies or little kids. Audience was pretty quiet with the occasional laughter. 10/10 movie watching experience.

On to the movie:
+ Show Spoiler +

I thought the movie was excellent, well paced, and well shot. I thought the movie should have ended with the celebration at the Resistance base, after the destruction of the Star Killer. I thought the search for Luke after left it at a pretty cheezy cliff hanger (quite literally).

The new characters were thin. Like Christian Bale in The Machinist thin. While the character goals for Rey, Finn, and Kylo were spelled out to the audience; the motivation was extremely lacking. For example, Finn wanted to escape the First Order so badly, he'd randomly free a prisoner and shoot down his own comrades? While the storm troopers were obviously brain washed (as mentioned with the "reprogramming" quip); it was also apparent the troops were more human than the clone army (mentioning of "traitor" by the troops; and the need for motivational speeches by General Hux. Also, Rey is like totally a Mary Sue. The ability to used Jedi Mind Tricks within minutes (or hours) of unlocking some inkling of the force... That's like super suspect. Also, the ability to instantly channel the force mid-fight against Kylo, a trained Force user was weird as well. As far as defeating Kylo, that was fine considering his injuries.

Also, not sure if they were trying to make Kylo seem super menacing in the early part of the film. But he felt like a 14 year old spoiled little brat for most of the film. Wasn't menacing at all either.


+ Show Spoiler +

I actually liked the movie a lot too.

Finn freeing the prisoner actually was explained in the movie. Basically, he needed a pilot. IMO he wasn't the most fleshed out dude but he was an OK character, better than Rey.

Rey is one of my nitpicks. Even if the movie did imply something as Gahlo said (although I don't think the novelization matters), it was really hard for me to catch whatever backstory she had in those weird flashbacks... or flash forwards? I honestly didn't know what the crap I was supposed to be seeing, future or past. Moreover, even if her quick grasp of the force was justified, it doesn't make her less of a Mary Sue. I mean, she's grown up Anakin: mechanical genius, genius pilot, and now genius force user. For half of the movie I thought they would give Finn force powers to have balanced characters but no, Finn just gets the power of Heart.

I liked Kylo overall. While I found him a lot less intimidating with the helmet off, I think that part of the point of the movie was that Kylo is still a pretty young kid. Snoke actually annoyed me a lot more than both Rey and Kylo for being a completely bland, generic, and uninteresting cgi big bad guy.

And all that said, I still like the movie despite these flaws.

+ Show Spoiler +
I'm just glad we got a Star Wars movie, not a JJ Abrams movie.


IMO Rey wasn't force awaken until the movie, because it's mentioned by Snoke and Kylo they felt a "new" force. As far as combat prowess, and piloting ability a lot of it could just be explained by rough childhood (always carrying the staff as self-defense). Another big problem was, there was absolutely 0 reason to have Rey use Jedi Mind Trick right away (which I assume is a finesse Force skill). Nothing would have changed plot wise if Finn and Solo found her in the interrogation room, as opposed to her roaming around aimlessly on the base. Her force development could have very easily been pushed back until the next movie. Also felt that they could have easily gone the route of uncontrolled inexperienced force user for Rey, as a reason why she defeats Kylo Ren. It makes a lot more sense if she just had insane raw untapped force control, and just surprised Kylo Ren with raw force usage (something like Force push, and pull). Instead she defeats him with light saber combat, with clean force usage of force pull on the light saber.

Not sure if anyone noticed, but the split in the land after the fight was a complete mirror to Obi Wan and Anikan when he said it was over.

The worst character for me was Kylo Ren though. Literally whiny beta male cry baby the entire movie. He never seemed menacing at all, even in the opening scene.

Also, what's the point of Captain Phasma? I don't get the hype? Female leading storm troopers? She didn't do jack shit all movie.


+ Show Spoiler +
Rey uses a mind trick, a force power most effective against the weak willed, against a stormtrooper. Stormtroopers have been canonically described as being weak willed in general. Ontop of that, they've been undergoing brainwashing by the First Order since they were taken from their families. If we're talking a human adult you're hurting to find a target less formidable than a FO trooper.

As for the Rey vs Kylo fight, it's explained a lot better in the novel. Kylo is also previously shot with a Wookie bowcaster, which is supposedly at normal strength to have enough kickback to dislocate a human arm even when used properly, and a small scuffle with Finn. He was nowhere near even decent fighting shape.


+ Show Spoiler +
Considering how strong Jedi's/Siths are in cannon, kylo could have an arm and a leg missing, he shouldn't of lost. I mean, i would have preferred a deus ex machina defeating kylo (aka Bane's ending a la Dark Knight Rises). I mean there was literally 0 plot reason to allow Rey to escape interrogation, and defeat Kylo Ren. What would have changed in the plot had Rey been rescued from the interrogation room by Finn and Solo? Nothing. But, NOPE. Better add the fact she's now an expert force user (using jedi mind trick w/o distracting hand motion). Oh, could have written Rey barely escaping a furious Kylo Ren, but NOPE. WE EXPERT LIGHTSABER USER NAO.

Also; one thing that really bugged me about the movie was that I didn't feel an emotional tug to Han Solo dying. That's not to say Han Solo as a character wasn't bloody fucking amazing in TFA (easily best character in TFA); but there's just felt absolutely 0 character and plot consequences from his death. I mean, for such a huge character in the movies to just die, and have 0 emotional tug, I think there's just something innately wrong with the plot set-up for that big "moment", that didn't have that tug.

Also, are we really going to fall for the bullshit of Chewy's blaster when we see in the first 5 minutes of the film he stops a blaster shot mid-air?


I really liked Max Landis's take on what could have been. Kylo going crazy after killing Han Solo, and literally taunting Rey and Finn to kill him. But as the audience you're not sure if he's taunting, or he's being serious (akin to the serial killer wants to be caught plot point).

I dunno, the more I rehash the movie in my head, the more annoyed I get at all the characters in the movies.

+ Show Spoiler +
Kylo Ren isn't a Sith yet, he's a dark Jedi. The problem with why Han dying doesn't hit people is because there isn't enough emotional buildup between the two characters or about them. Hur dur, novelization fills that out a bit more.


+ Show Spoiler +
This is a serious case of: READ THE BOOK!

When this is a serious case of why THE MOVIE does a bad job with character development, and plot development.

Also, muh "not sith, but dark jedi"; still strong enough to beat the shit out of a janitor storm trooper who poops his pants at the mention of the First Order, and a newly awoken force user

liftlift > tsm
Gahlo
Profile Joined February 2010
United States35174 Posts
Last Edited: 2016-01-06 07:07:17
January 06 2016 07:02 GMT
#18407
On January 06 2016 15:53 Ketara wrote:
I feel like a lot of Gahlo's arguments against us having issues with the Star Wars movie boils down to "Well the novelization fixes that"

That doesn't mean that it's not broken in the movie.

Yeah, well right now it's as close to a directors cut there is. I'm not saying the issues are invalid. I'm just saying that the rough edges the movie has is a result of stuff getting taken out of it, not a lack of polish on it in the first place. Honestly the editing is the worst part about the movie.

There's also this really weird super literal reaction to the movie, not saying anybody here holds that, where they want everything written out for them. These same people hold the OT up to high heaven, which didn't do that, and act like the prequels are the worst things ever put to film, which did so much hand holding they severely hampered the movies.

On January 06 2016 15:57 wei2coolman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 15:50 Gahlo wrote:
On January 06 2016 15:41 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 15:10 Gahlo wrote:
On January 06 2016 05:13 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 05:09 Eppa! wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
The helmet is there to protect him from his own insecurities. The removal is his path to dealing with them. Fuck rey kylo ren should have been the hero of the movie

+ Show Spoiler +

Would have been a pretty cool twist if we saw Kylo Ren become more attracted to the light side, and Rey become more attracted to the dark side.


+ Show Spoiler +
Novelization note: When Kylo kills Han, instead of feeling a sense of conviction he actually feels bad about it.


On January 06 2016 05:07 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 04:44 phyvo wrote:
On January 05 2016 15:57 wei2coolman wrote:
Finally got around to watching SW:TFA. Glad I waited a week or so to watch it. Theatre was maybe 25% filled, with no babies or little kids. Audience was pretty quiet with the occasional laughter. 10/10 movie watching experience.

On to the movie:
+ Show Spoiler +

I thought the movie was excellent, well paced, and well shot. I thought the movie should have ended with the celebration at the Resistance base, after the destruction of the Star Killer. I thought the search for Luke after left it at a pretty cheezy cliff hanger (quite literally).

The new characters were thin. Like Christian Bale in The Machinist thin. While the character goals for Rey, Finn, and Kylo were spelled out to the audience; the motivation was extremely lacking. For example, Finn wanted to escape the First Order so badly, he'd randomly free a prisoner and shoot down his own comrades? While the storm troopers were obviously brain washed (as mentioned with the "reprogramming" quip); it was also apparent the troops were more human than the clone army (mentioning of "traitor" by the troops; and the need for motivational speeches by General Hux. Also, Rey is like totally a Mary Sue. The ability to used Jedi Mind Tricks within minutes (or hours) of unlocking some inkling of the force... That's like super suspect. Also, the ability to instantly channel the force mid-fight against Kylo, a trained Force user was weird as well. As far as defeating Kylo, that was fine considering his injuries.

Also, not sure if they were trying to make Kylo seem super menacing in the early part of the film. But he felt like a 14 year old spoiled little brat for most of the film. Wasn't menacing at all either.


+ Show Spoiler +

I actually liked the movie a lot too.

Finn freeing the prisoner actually was explained in the movie. Basically, he needed a pilot. IMO he wasn't the most fleshed out dude but he was an OK character, better than Rey.

Rey is one of my nitpicks. Even if the movie did imply something as Gahlo said (although I don't think the novelization matters), it was really hard for me to catch whatever backstory she had in those weird flashbacks... or flash forwards? I honestly didn't know what the crap I was supposed to be seeing, future or past. Moreover, even if her quick grasp of the force was justified, it doesn't make her less of a Mary Sue. I mean, she's grown up Anakin: mechanical genius, genius pilot, and now genius force user. For half of the movie I thought they would give Finn force powers to have balanced characters but no, Finn just gets the power of Heart.

I liked Kylo overall. While I found him a lot less intimidating with the helmet off, I think that part of the point of the movie was that Kylo is still a pretty young kid. Snoke actually annoyed me a lot more than both Rey and Kylo for being a completely bland, generic, and uninteresting cgi big bad guy.

And all that said, I still like the movie despite these flaws.

+ Show Spoiler +
I'm just glad we got a Star Wars movie, not a JJ Abrams movie.


IMO Rey wasn't force awaken until the movie, because it's mentioned by Snoke and Kylo they felt a "new" force. As far as combat prowess, and piloting ability a lot of it could just be explained by rough childhood (always carrying the staff as self-defense). Another big problem was, there was absolutely 0 reason to have Rey use Jedi Mind Trick right away (which I assume is a finesse Force skill). Nothing would have changed plot wise if Finn and Solo found her in the interrogation room, as opposed to her roaming around aimlessly on the base. Her force development could have very easily been pushed back until the next movie. Also felt that they could have easily gone the route of uncontrolled inexperienced force user for Rey, as a reason why she defeats Kylo Ren. It makes a lot more sense if she just had insane raw untapped force control, and just surprised Kylo Ren with raw force usage (something like Force push, and pull). Instead she defeats him with light saber combat, with clean force usage of force pull on the light saber.

Not sure if anyone noticed, but the split in the land after the fight was a complete mirror to Obi Wan and Anikan when he said it was over.

The worst character for me was Kylo Ren though. Literally whiny beta male cry baby the entire movie. He never seemed menacing at all, even in the opening scene.

Also, what's the point of Captain Phasma? I don't get the hype? Female leading storm troopers? She didn't do jack shit all movie.


+ Show Spoiler +
Rey uses a mind trick, a force power most effective against the weak willed, against a stormtrooper. Stormtroopers have been canonically described as being weak willed in general. Ontop of that, they've been undergoing brainwashing by the First Order since they were taken from their families. If we're talking a human adult you're hurting to find a target less formidable than a FO trooper.

As for the Rey vs Kylo fight, it's explained a lot better in the novel. Kylo is also previously shot with a Wookie bowcaster, which is supposedly at normal strength to have enough kickback to dislocate a human arm even when used properly, and a small scuffle with Finn. He was nowhere near even decent fighting shape.


+ Show Spoiler +
Considering how strong Jedi's/Siths are in cannon, kylo could have an arm and a leg missing, he shouldn't of lost. I mean, i would have preferred a deus ex machina defeating kylo (aka Bane's ending a la Dark Knight Rises). I mean there was literally 0 plot reason to allow Rey to escape interrogation, and defeat Kylo Ren. What would have changed in the plot had Rey been rescued from the interrogation room by Finn and Solo? Nothing. But, NOPE. Better add the fact she's now an expert force user (using jedi mind trick w/o distracting hand motion). Oh, could have written Rey barely escaping a furious Kylo Ren, but NOPE. WE EXPERT LIGHTSABER USER NAO.

Also; one thing that really bugged me about the movie was that I didn't feel an emotional tug to Han Solo dying. That's not to say Han Solo as a character wasn't bloody fucking amazing in TFA (easily best character in TFA); but there's just felt absolutely 0 character and plot consequences from his death. I mean, for such a huge character in the movies to just die, and have 0 emotional tug, I think there's just something innately wrong with the plot set-up for that big "moment", that didn't have that tug.

Also, are we really going to fall for the bullshit of Chewy's blaster when we see in the first 5 minutes of the film he stops a blaster shot mid-air?


I really liked Max Landis's take on what could have been. Kylo going crazy after killing Han Solo, and literally taunting Rey and Finn to kill him. But as the audience you're not sure if he's taunting, or he's being serious (akin to the serial killer wants to be caught plot point).

I dunno, the more I rehash the movie in my head, the more annoyed I get at all the characters in the movies.

+ Show Spoiler +
Kylo Ren isn't a Sith yet, he's a dark Jedi. The problem with why Han dying doesn't hit people is because there isn't enough emotional buildup between the two characters or about them. Hur dur, novelization fills that out a bit more.


+ Show Spoiler +
This is a serious case of: READ THE BOOK!

When this is a serious case of why THE MOVIE does a bad job with character development, and plot development.

Also, muh "not sith, but dark jedi"; still strong enough to beat the shit out of a janitor storm trooper who poops his pants at the mention of the First Order, and a newly awoken force user


+ Show Spoiler +
Yeah, and Kylo is still a fuck more trained than both of them combined and still puts up a decent fight while being majorly wounded before even getting into it. Multiple times in the movie you see one bowcaster bolt fuck up a large area. Kylo took that like a champ and is still fighting.

There is a very distinct line between a dark Jedi and a Sith. There are expectations you have when you weigh the two terms.
TheEmulator
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
28104 Posts
Last Edited: 2016-01-06 07:13:31
January 06 2016 07:11 GMT
#18408
On January 06 2016 15:41 wei2coolman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 15:10 Gahlo wrote:
On January 06 2016 05:13 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 05:09 Eppa! wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
The helmet is there to protect him from his own insecurities. The removal is his path to dealing with them. Fuck rey kylo ren should have been the hero of the movie

+ Show Spoiler +

Would have been a pretty cool twist if we saw Kylo Ren become more attracted to the light side, and Rey become more attracted to the dark side.


+ Show Spoiler +
Novelization note: When Kylo kills Han, instead of feeling a sense of conviction he actually feels bad about it.


On January 06 2016 05:07 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 04:44 phyvo wrote:
On January 05 2016 15:57 wei2coolman wrote:
Finally got around to watching SW:TFA. Glad I waited a week or so to watch it. Theatre was maybe 25% filled, with no babies or little kids. Audience was pretty quiet with the occasional laughter. 10/10 movie watching experience.

On to the movie:
+ Show Spoiler +

I thought the movie was excellent, well paced, and well shot. I thought the movie should have ended with the celebration at the Resistance base, after the destruction of the Star Killer. I thought the search for Luke after left it at a pretty cheezy cliff hanger (quite literally).

The new characters were thin. Like Christian Bale in The Machinist thin. While the character goals for Rey, Finn, and Kylo were spelled out to the audience; the motivation was extremely lacking. For example, Finn wanted to escape the First Order so badly, he'd randomly free a prisoner and shoot down his own comrades? While the storm troopers were obviously brain washed (as mentioned with the "reprogramming" quip); it was also apparent the troops were more human than the clone army (mentioning of "traitor" by the troops; and the need for motivational speeches by General Hux. Also, Rey is like totally a Mary Sue. The ability to used Jedi Mind Tricks within minutes (or hours) of unlocking some inkling of the force... That's like super suspect. Also, the ability to instantly channel the force mid-fight against Kylo, a trained Force user was weird as well. As far as defeating Kylo, that was fine considering his injuries.

Also, not sure if they were trying to make Kylo seem super menacing in the early part of the film. But he felt like a 14 year old spoiled little brat for most of the film. Wasn't menacing at all either.


+ Show Spoiler +

I actually liked the movie a lot too.

Finn freeing the prisoner actually was explained in the movie. Basically, he needed a pilot. IMO he wasn't the most fleshed out dude but he was an OK character, better than Rey.

Rey is one of my nitpicks. Even if the movie did imply something as Gahlo said (although I don't think the novelization matters), it was really hard for me to catch whatever backstory she had in those weird flashbacks... or flash forwards? I honestly didn't know what the crap I was supposed to be seeing, future or past. Moreover, even if her quick grasp of the force was justified, it doesn't make her less of a Mary Sue. I mean, she's grown up Anakin: mechanical genius, genius pilot, and now genius force user. For half of the movie I thought they would give Finn force powers to have balanced characters but no, Finn just gets the power of Heart.

I liked Kylo overall. While I found him a lot less intimidating with the helmet off, I think that part of the point of the movie was that Kylo is still a pretty young kid. Snoke actually annoyed me a lot more than both Rey and Kylo for being a completely bland, generic, and uninteresting cgi big bad guy.

And all that said, I still like the movie despite these flaws.

+ Show Spoiler +
I'm just glad we got a Star Wars movie, not a JJ Abrams movie.


IMO Rey wasn't force awaken until the movie, because it's mentioned by Snoke and Kylo they felt a "new" force. As far as combat prowess, and piloting ability a lot of it could just be explained by rough childhood (always carrying the staff as self-defense). Another big problem was, there was absolutely 0 reason to have Rey use Jedi Mind Trick right away (which I assume is a finesse Force skill). Nothing would have changed plot wise if Finn and Solo found her in the interrogation room, as opposed to her roaming around aimlessly on the base. Her force development could have very easily been pushed back until the next movie. Also felt that they could have easily gone the route of uncontrolled inexperienced force user for Rey, as a reason why she defeats Kylo Ren. It makes a lot more sense if she just had insane raw untapped force control, and just surprised Kylo Ren with raw force usage (something like Force push, and pull). Instead she defeats him with light saber combat, with clean force usage of force pull on the light saber.

Not sure if anyone noticed, but the split in the land after the fight was a complete mirror to Obi Wan and Anikan when he said it was over.

The worst character for me was Kylo Ren though. Literally whiny beta male cry baby the entire movie. He never seemed menacing at all, even in the opening scene.

Also, what's the point of Captain Phasma? I don't get the hype? Female leading storm troopers? She didn't do jack shit all movie.


+ Show Spoiler +
Rey uses a mind trick, a force power most effective against the weak willed, against a stormtrooper. Stormtroopers have been canonically described as being weak willed in general. Ontop of that, they've been undergoing brainwashing by the First Order since they were taken from their families. If we're talking a human adult you're hurting to find a target less formidable than a FO trooper.

As for the Rey vs Kylo fight, it's explained a lot better in the novel. Kylo is also previously shot with a Wookie bowcaster, which is supposedly at normal strength to have enough kickback to dislocate a human arm even when used properly, and a small scuffle with Finn. He was nowhere near even decent fighting shape.


+ Show Spoiler +
Considering how strong Jedi's/Siths are in cannon, kylo could have an arm and a leg missing, he shouldn't of lost. I mean, i would have preferred a deus ex machina defeating kylo (aka Bane's ending a la Dark Knight Rises). I mean there was literally 0 plot reason to allow Rey to escape interrogation, and defeat Kylo Ren. What would have changed in the plot had Rey been rescued from the interrogation room by Finn and Solo? Nothing. But, NOPE. Better add the fact she's now an expert force user (using jedi mind trick w/o distracting hand motion). Oh, could have written Rey barely escaping a furious Kylo Ren, but NOPE. WE EXPERT LIGHTSABER USER NAO.

Also; one thing that really bugged me about the movie was that I didn't feel an emotional tug to Han Solo dying. That's not to say Han Solo as a character wasn't bloody fucking amazing in TFA (easily best character in TFA); but there's just felt absolutely 0 character and plot consequences from his death. I mean, for such a huge character in the movies to just die, and have 0 emotional tug, I think there's just something innately wrong with the plot set-up for that big "moment", that didn't have that tug.

Also, are we really going to fall for the bullshit of Chewy's blaster when we see in the first 5 minutes of the film he stops a blaster shot mid-air?


I really liked Max Landis's take on what could have been. Kylo going crazy after killing Han Solo, and literally taunting Rey and Finn to kill him. But as the audience you're not sure if he's taunting, or he's being serious (akin to the serial killer wants to be caught plot point).

I dunno, the more I rehash the movie in my head, the more annoyed I get at all the characters in the movies.

+ Show Spoiler +
I really didn't have an issue with Chewey's shot hitting him. He wasn't paying attention at all and also just killed his own father. The situation was quite different than the start of the movie.
Administrator
Ketara
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
United States15065 Posts
January 06 2016 07:47 GMT
#18409
On January 06 2016 16:02 Gahlo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 15:53 Ketara wrote:
I feel like a lot of Gahlo's arguments against us having issues with the Star Wars movie boils down to "Well the novelization fixes that"

That doesn't mean that it's not broken in the movie.

Yeah, well right now it's as close to a directors cut there is. I'm not saying the issues are invalid. I'm just saying that the rough edges the movie has is a result of stuff getting taken out of it, not a lack of polish on it in the first place. Honestly the editing is the worst part about the movie.

There's also this really weird super literal reaction to the movie, not saying anybody here holds that, where they want everything written out for them. These same people hold the OT up to high heaven, which didn't do that, and act like the prequels are the worst things ever put to film, which did so much hand holding they severely hampered the movies.

Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 15:57 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 15:50 Gahlo wrote:
On January 06 2016 15:41 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 15:10 Gahlo wrote:
On January 06 2016 05:13 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 05:09 Eppa! wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
The helmet is there to protect him from his own insecurities. The removal is his path to dealing with them. Fuck rey kylo ren should have been the hero of the movie

+ Show Spoiler +

Would have been a pretty cool twist if we saw Kylo Ren become more attracted to the light side, and Rey become more attracted to the dark side.


+ Show Spoiler +
Novelization note: When Kylo kills Han, instead of feeling a sense of conviction he actually feels bad about it.


On January 06 2016 05:07 wei2coolman wrote:
On January 06 2016 04:44 phyvo wrote:
On January 05 2016 15:57 wei2coolman wrote:
Finally got around to watching SW:TFA. Glad I waited a week or so to watch it. Theatre was maybe 25% filled, with no babies or little kids. Audience was pretty quiet with the occasional laughter. 10/10 movie watching experience.

On to the movie:
+ Show Spoiler +

I thought the movie was excellent, well paced, and well shot. I thought the movie should have ended with the celebration at the Resistance base, after the destruction of the Star Killer. I thought the search for Luke after left it at a pretty cheezy cliff hanger (quite literally).

The new characters were thin. Like Christian Bale in The Machinist thin. While the character goals for Rey, Finn, and Kylo were spelled out to the audience; the motivation was extremely lacking. For example, Finn wanted to escape the First Order so badly, he'd randomly free a prisoner and shoot down his own comrades? While the storm troopers were obviously brain washed (as mentioned with the "reprogramming" quip); it was also apparent the troops were more human than the clone army (mentioning of "traitor" by the troops; and the need for motivational speeches by General Hux. Also, Rey is like totally a Mary Sue. The ability to used Jedi Mind Tricks within minutes (or hours) of unlocking some inkling of the force... That's like super suspect. Also, the ability to instantly channel the force mid-fight against Kylo, a trained Force user was weird as well. As far as defeating Kylo, that was fine considering his injuries.

Also, not sure if they were trying to make Kylo seem super menacing in the early part of the film. But he felt like a 14 year old spoiled little brat for most of the film. Wasn't menacing at all either.


+ Show Spoiler +

I actually liked the movie a lot too.

Finn freeing the prisoner actually was explained in the movie. Basically, he needed a pilot. IMO he wasn't the most fleshed out dude but he was an OK character, better than Rey.

Rey is one of my nitpicks. Even if the movie did imply something as Gahlo said (although I don't think the novelization matters), it was really hard for me to catch whatever backstory she had in those weird flashbacks... or flash forwards? I honestly didn't know what the crap I was supposed to be seeing, future or past. Moreover, even if her quick grasp of the force was justified, it doesn't make her less of a Mary Sue. I mean, she's grown up Anakin: mechanical genius, genius pilot, and now genius force user. For half of the movie I thought they would give Finn force powers to have balanced characters but no, Finn just gets the power of Heart.

I liked Kylo overall. While I found him a lot less intimidating with the helmet off, I think that part of the point of the movie was that Kylo is still a pretty young kid. Snoke actually annoyed me a lot more than both Rey and Kylo for being a completely bland, generic, and uninteresting cgi big bad guy.

And all that said, I still like the movie despite these flaws.

+ Show Spoiler +
I'm just glad we got a Star Wars movie, not a JJ Abrams movie.


IMO Rey wasn't force awaken until the movie, because it's mentioned by Snoke and Kylo they felt a "new" force. As far as combat prowess, and piloting ability a lot of it could just be explained by rough childhood (always carrying the staff as self-defense). Another big problem was, there was absolutely 0 reason to have Rey use Jedi Mind Trick right away (which I assume is a finesse Force skill). Nothing would have changed plot wise if Finn and Solo found her in the interrogation room, as opposed to her roaming around aimlessly on the base. Her force development could have very easily been pushed back until the next movie. Also felt that they could have easily gone the route of uncontrolled inexperienced force user for Rey, as a reason why she defeats Kylo Ren. It makes a lot more sense if she just had insane raw untapped force control, and just surprised Kylo Ren with raw force usage (something like Force push, and pull). Instead she defeats him with light saber combat, with clean force usage of force pull on the light saber.

Not sure if anyone noticed, but the split in the land after the fight was a complete mirror to Obi Wan and Anikan when he said it was over.

The worst character for me was Kylo Ren though. Literally whiny beta male cry baby the entire movie. He never seemed menacing at all, even in the opening scene.

Also, what's the point of Captain Phasma? I don't get the hype? Female leading storm troopers? She didn't do jack shit all movie.


+ Show Spoiler +
Rey uses a mind trick, a force power most effective against the weak willed, against a stormtrooper. Stormtroopers have been canonically described as being weak willed in general. Ontop of that, they've been undergoing brainwashing by the First Order since they were taken from their families. If we're talking a human adult you're hurting to find a target less formidable than a FO trooper.

As for the Rey vs Kylo fight, it's explained a lot better in the novel. Kylo is also previously shot with a Wookie bowcaster, which is supposedly at normal strength to have enough kickback to dislocate a human arm even when used properly, and a small scuffle with Finn. He was nowhere near even decent fighting shape.


+ Show Spoiler +
Considering how strong Jedi's/Siths are in cannon, kylo could have an arm and a leg missing, he shouldn't of lost. I mean, i would have preferred a deus ex machina defeating kylo (aka Bane's ending a la Dark Knight Rises). I mean there was literally 0 plot reason to allow Rey to escape interrogation, and defeat Kylo Ren. What would have changed in the plot had Rey been rescued from the interrogation room by Finn and Solo? Nothing. But, NOPE. Better add the fact she's now an expert force user (using jedi mind trick w/o distracting hand motion). Oh, could have written Rey barely escaping a furious Kylo Ren, but NOPE. WE EXPERT LIGHTSABER USER NAO.

Also; one thing that really bugged me about the movie was that I didn't feel an emotional tug to Han Solo dying. That's not to say Han Solo as a character wasn't bloody fucking amazing in TFA (easily best character in TFA); but there's just felt absolutely 0 character and plot consequences from his death. I mean, for such a huge character in the movies to just die, and have 0 emotional tug, I think there's just something innately wrong with the plot set-up for that big "moment", that didn't have that tug.

Also, are we really going to fall for the bullshit of Chewy's blaster when we see in the first 5 minutes of the film he stops a blaster shot mid-air?


I really liked Max Landis's take on what could have been. Kylo going crazy after killing Han Solo, and literally taunting Rey and Finn to kill him. But as the audience you're not sure if he's taunting, or he's being serious (akin to the serial killer wants to be caught plot point).

I dunno, the more I rehash the movie in my head, the more annoyed I get at all the characters in the movies.

+ Show Spoiler +
Kylo Ren isn't a Sith yet, he's a dark Jedi. The problem with why Han dying doesn't hit people is because there isn't enough emotional buildup between the two characters or about them. Hur dur, novelization fills that out a bit more.


+ Show Spoiler +
This is a serious case of: READ THE BOOK!

When this is a serious case of why THE MOVIE does a bad job with character development, and plot development.

Also, muh "not sith, but dark jedi"; still strong enough to beat the shit out of a janitor storm trooper who poops his pants at the mention of the First Order, and a newly awoken force user


+ Show Spoiler +
Yeah, and Kylo is still a fuck more trained than both of them combined and still puts up a decent fight while being majorly wounded before even getting into it. Multiple times in the movie you see one bowcaster bolt fuck up a large area. Kylo took that like a champ and is still fighting.

There is a very distinct line between a dark Jedi and a Sith. There are expectations you have when you weigh the two terms.


"the book is better" is not a reasonable defense of a movie, nor is a book the same as a directors cut.

Is it true that theres a lot cut out of the movie? I'd be interested in seeing a DVD version if it had extra scenes that fill the plot holes.
http://www.liquidlegends.net/forum/lol-general/502075-patch-61-league-of-legends-general-discussion?page=25#498
Gahlo
Profile Joined February 2010
United States35174 Posts
January 06 2016 12:04 GMT
#18410
In an interview JJ said they cut, conservatively, 10-20 minutes.
Numy
Profile Blog Joined June 2010
South Africa35471 Posts
Last Edited: 2016-01-06 12:35:04
January 06 2016 12:33 GMT
#18411
That's not particularly much for editing. Honestly I don't get why where's so much argument about something that is just meant to boot up the toy selling franchise again. It's not a particularly good movie. It's there for nostalgia and to get the next set of 50 movies going. It's as inoffensive a movie as you can get. I think of it merely as them doing a summary of the original Star Wars for kids that haven't seen them.

We'll see if the next ones are any better which is the real telling point. After what JJ did with Star Trek my hope isn't that high but maybe Disney will make sure he doesn't cock it up.
Ketara
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
United States15065 Posts
January 06 2016 12:36 GMT
#18412
I don't think there's much argument really.

The Star Wars discussion has pretty much been pages and pages of us all agreeing with each other, with a couple outliers.
http://www.liquidlegends.net/forum/lol-general/502075-patch-61-league-of-legends-general-discussion?page=25#498
Gahlo
Profile Joined February 2010
United States35174 Posts
January 06 2016 12:45 GMT
#18413
On January 06 2016 21:33 Numy wrote:
That's not particularly much for editing. Honestly I don't get why where's so much argument about something that is just meant to boot up the toy selling franchise again. It's not a particularly good movie. It's there for nostalgia and to get the next set of 50 movies going. It's as inoffensive a movie as you can get. I think of it merely as them doing a summary of the original Star Wars for kids that haven't seen them.

We'll see if the next ones are any better which is the real telling point. After what JJ did with Star Trek my hope isn't that high but maybe Disney will make sure he doesn't cock it up.

He isn't directing the other films. The Director for 8 is the guy that did Looper and Brick, both movies that I thoroughly enjoyed.
Parnage
Profile Blog Joined February 2010
United States7414 Posts
January 06 2016 13:02 GMT
#18414
On January 06 2016 21:36 Ketara wrote:
I don't think there's much argument really.

The Star Wars discussion has pretty much been pages and pages of us all agreeing with each other, with a couple outliers.



I'm a minority opinion woo. The new film is a laughably flawed, jar jar managed to ruin star trek and star wars an achievement of some legend. Steal things from the EU, rehash episode 4, make your blockbuster on marketing and then watch it all go down the drain because your attempt at boba fett was replaced by a random stormtrooper.
-orb- Fan. Live the Nal_rA dream. || Yordles are cool.
Alaric
Profile Joined November 2009
France45622 Posts
January 06 2016 13:04 GMT
#18415
On January 06 2016 22:02 Parnage wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 21:36 Ketara wrote:
I don't think there's much argument really.

The Star Wars discussion has pretty much been pages and pages of us all agreeing with each other, with a couple outliers.

your attempt at boba fett was replaced by a random stormtrooper.

I don't get that part?
Cant take LMS hipsters serious.
Numy
Profile Blog Joined June 2010
South Africa35471 Posts
January 06 2016 13:06 GMT
#18416
On January 06 2016 21:45 Gahlo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 21:33 Numy wrote:
That's not particularly much for editing. Honestly I don't get why where's so much argument about something that is just meant to boot up the toy selling franchise again. It's not a particularly good movie. It's there for nostalgia and to get the next set of 50 movies going. It's as inoffensive a movie as you can get. I think of it merely as them doing a summary of the original Star Wars for kids that haven't seen them.

We'll see if the next ones are any better which is the real telling point. After what JJ did with Star Trek my hope isn't that high but maybe Disney will make sure he doesn't cock it up.

He isn't directing the other films. The Director for 8 is the guy that did Looper and Brick, both movies that I thoroughly enjoyed.

Ah Disney so smart. Get JJ to do the fan wank then another guy to do real movie
Seuss
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
United States10536 Posts
Last Edited: 2016-01-06 13:31:16
January 06 2016 13:29 GMT
#18417
On January 06 2016 22:02 Parnage wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 21:36 Ketara wrote:
I don't think there's much argument really.

The Star Wars discussion has pretty much been pages and pages of us all agreeing with each other, with a couple outliers.



I'm a minority opinion woo. The new film is a laughably flawed, jar jar managed to ruin star trek and star wars an achievement of some legend. Steal things from the EU, rehash episode 4, make your blockbuster on marketing and then watch it all go down the drain because your attempt at boba fett was replaced by a random stormtrooper.


Flawed yes. Awesome, also yes. TR-8R is hilarious though.

Whether the awesome is a bigger deal than the flaws depends on how good the follow up movies are. Star Trek was a flawed movie, but a lot of fans were okay with it up until Into Darkness was awful.
"I am not able to carry all this people alone, for they are too heavy for me." -Moses (Numbers 11:14)
Ketara
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
United States15065 Posts
Last Edited: 2016-01-06 13:34:26
January 06 2016 13:34 GMT
#18418
Oh man google image searching TR-8R is giving me some of the funniest shit I've seen in like a month.

I encourage everybody to do this.
http://www.liquidlegends.net/forum/lol-general/502075-patch-61-league-of-legends-general-discussion?page=25#498
Gahlo
Profile Joined February 2010
United States35174 Posts
January 06 2016 13:45 GMT
#18419
On January 06 2016 22:04 Alaric wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 22:02 Parnage wrote:
On January 06 2016 21:36 Ketara wrote:
I don't think there's much argument really.

The Star Wars discussion has pretty much been pages and pages of us all agreeing with each other, with a couple outliers.

your attempt at boba fett was replaced by a random stormtrooper.

I don't get that part?

A lot of people are paralleling Phasma and Boba Fett, + Show Spoiler +
characters that are supposed to be bad asses but then do duffy stuff in the movie and just look lame.
Numy
Profile Blog Joined June 2010
South Africa35471 Posts
January 06 2016 13:48 GMT
#18420
On January 06 2016 22:29 Seuss wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 06 2016 22:02 Parnage wrote:
On January 06 2016 21:36 Ketara wrote:
I don't think there's much argument really.

The Star Wars discussion has pretty much been pages and pages of us all agreeing with each other, with a couple outliers.



I'm a minority opinion woo. The new film is a laughably flawed, jar jar managed to ruin star trek and star wars an achievement of some legend. Steal things from the EU, rehash episode 4, make your blockbuster on marketing and then watch it all go down the drain because your attempt at boba fett was replaced by a random stormtrooper.


Flawed yes. Awesome, also yes. TR-8R is hilarious though.

Whether the awesome is a bigger deal than the flaws depends on how good the follow up movies are. Star Trek was a flawed movie, but a lot of fans were okay with it up until Into Darkness was awful.

The thing is Into darkness is analogus with new SW. It's just that the star trek movies were more star wars than star trek so the fans didn't want just a throwback movie. Judging by the SW reception most fans are perfectly happy with a throwback movie so I don't think it's right to compare them at all
Prev 1 919 920 921 922 923 1885 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Replay Cast
08:00
SC2 Kevin Scrim
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
RuFF_SC2 204
StarCraft: Brood War
GuemChi 1397
Snow 142
sOs 24
Terrorterran 22
ZergMaN 20
LuMiX 2
Icarus 1
Zeus 0
Dota 2
NeuroSwarm129
capcasts75
Counter-Strike
Coldzera 1257
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr77
Other Games
summit1g8346
fl0m681
C9.Mang0378
PiGStarcraft251
taco 170
Maynarde116
ViBE51
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick998
BasetradeTV144
[ Show 12 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Light_VIP 36
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• masondota2816
League of Legends
• Rush519
Other Games
• Shiphtur544
Upcoming Events
Online Event
5h 44m
GSL
7h 14m
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
9h 44m
OSC
11h 44m
Replay Cast
18h 44m
KCM Race Survival
1d 5h
Ultimate Battle
1d 7h
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
2 days
BSL
2 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
3 days
[ Show More ]
IPSL
3 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
3 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
3 days
WardiTV Weekly
4 days
Kung Fu Cup
5 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
5 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.