|
On December 20 2015 12:48 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2015 12:41 Ketara wrote:On December 20 2015 12:36 WaveofShadow wrote: So. Star Wars. Go back three pages and open all the spoilers. I just did that. + Show Spoiler +Basically agree with a lot of what people are saying back and forth. Did feel a little like pandering and remaking E4 but I can't say I minded all that much. The multitude of nonsensical/deus ex machina kinda bothered me until I realized that's essentially what all of the original films are the entire time. Overall probably better than E1-3 and that's cool. I'll enjoy not knowing 'what comes next.'
Random thoughts: Was worried (Ben?) was gonna be a whiny little bitch but his character was a little more complicated than that, even though we all knew what was coming.
Force powers way the fuck out of whack.
Why the hell is Gollum the new Emperor? I honestly hated that the most probably. Never mind not knowing where the shit these dudes came from.
+ Show Spoiler +The big baddie is from Kamino, right? He looks like he is to me....
I'm also curious is Rey and Ren are brother/sister, twins, or cousins, that isn't explained yet. The ending was also meh imo, the rest of it was good, not great, but OK.
|
On December 20 2015 12:48 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2015 12:41 Ketara wrote:On December 20 2015 12:36 WaveofShadow wrote: So. Star Wars. Go back three pages and open all the spoilers. I just did that. + Show Spoiler +Basically agree with a lot of what people are saying back and forth. Did feel a little like pandering and remaking E4 but I can't say I minded all that much. The multitude of nonsensical/deus ex machina kinda bothered me until I realized that's essentially what all of the original films are the entire time. Overall probably better than E1-3 and that's cool. I'll enjoy not knowing 'what comes next.'
Random thoughts: Was worried (Ben?) was gonna be a whiny little bitch but his character was a little more complicated than that, even though we all knew what was coming.
Force powers way the fuck out of whack.
Why the hell is Gollum the new Emperor? I honestly hated that the most probably. Never mind not knowing where the shit these dudes came from.
+ Show Spoiler +The more that I think about it the more the r2d2 thing bothers me. Because it was so unnecessary. They literally had a scene with the characters in a computer terminal room in the base where the map was. Having Han steal the map and then go confront psuedovader would not only have been more compelling, it would also be more in line with the original movie (obi wan shuts the shields down and then confronts Vader instead of reuniting with the group)
They unnecessarily had r2d2 perform a really unconvincing miracle. It was dumb.
|
starwars related with spoiler.
just curious what people think about Max Landis's thoughts? + Show Spoiler +
|
|
|
On December 20 2015 13:25 WaveofShadow wrote:It's my birthday for 30 more min, so birthday stream! Gonna stream my steammas present, Dankest Dungeon! www.twitch.tv/waveofshadow
Happy birthday! Also pretty good present. Heard very good things about it.
|
On December 20 2015 13:02 wei2coolman wrote:starwars related with spoiler. just curious what people think about Max Landis's thoughts? + Show Spoiler +https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpS6TlqgLIQ
+ Show Spoiler +
|
On December 20 2015 13:02 wei2coolman wrote:starwars related with spoiler. just curious what people think about Max Landis's thoughts? + Show Spoiler +https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpS6TlqgLIQ + Show Spoiler [SW7] +Too bad she isn't. Using the predominant theory on Rey, she is Luke's daughter. Until Ben turned to the dark side, she was being trained by her father. She's an excellent mechanic because she's been a scavanger since she was 5 on Jakku. Han warms up to her because he recognizes her, but maybe Luke told him not to say anything to her because her mind was wiped as a way to protect her.
And no, that is the way it works. Vader being Anakin still matters in E4 despite the audience not knowing it in E5. Obviously, having a role swap with a guy who grew up as a moisture farmer as opposed to a trained jedi who the Force is heavily nudging to get her abilities back.
|
More Stars Wars:
+ Show Spoiler +Completely agree as to the Mary Sueness of Rey. 100% agree.
When I was watching it I thought it was really cool when Finn came to save her and she beat up the two raiders, I was like omg yeah that's cool.
Then that was the entire movie and it sort of made it hollow.
Honestly the coolest new character was probably the pilot guy.
|
On December 20 2015 14:23 Ketara wrote:More Stars Wars: + Show Spoiler +Completely agree as to the Mary Sueness of Rey. 100% agree.
When I was watching it I thought it was really cool when Finn came to save her and she beat up the two raiders, I was like omg yeah that's cool.
Then that was the entire movie and it sort of made it hollow.
Honestly the coolest new character was probably the pilot guy. + Show Spoiler +I agree on the part of Po being cool as fuck. Was happy to see he didn't die on Jakku. For some reason I watched his Xwing when he made a re-enterance and he really fucked shit up in the background.
|
On December 20 2015 14:24 Gahlo wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2015 14:23 Ketara wrote:More Stars Wars: + Show Spoiler +Completely agree as to the Mary Sueness of Rey. 100% agree.
When I was watching it I thought it was really cool when Finn came to save her and she beat up the two raiders, I was like omg yeah that's cool.
Then that was the entire movie and it sort of made it hollow.
Honestly the coolest new character was probably the pilot guy. + Show Spoiler +I agree on the part of Po being cool as fuck. Was happy to see he didn't die on Jakku. For some reason I watched his Xwing when he made a re-enterance and he really fucked shit up in the background. + Show Spoiler +I loved his first line with Kylo at the beginning. I was actually happy that they mixed humor more into it. The prequels tried to be super serious and failed hard, I'm glad to see that the new movies know that they're just a sci fi romp and don't try to overdo it.
|
On December 20 2015 10:05 Gahlo wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2015 06:06 ticklishmusic wrote:On December 20 2015 05:52 TheEmulator wrote:On December 20 2015 03:27 Requizen wrote:On December 20 2015 03:18 ticklishmusic wrote: I really like the Star Wars of the extended universe. This new "canon" or whatever is pretty meh and a lot of the backstory hasn't been explained/ doesn't even make sense. In what's called the "legends" now, the entire birth of the new Republic and the subsequent events and conflicts made a lot more sense.
I'm also kind of salty because I was a major contributor to the Star Wars wiki and my work has all been kind of sidelined. I think it's a bit harsh to call the new canon bad after just the first movie. I think it did a good job of setting things up. I'm excited for Rogue One because Poe was really cool and I recognized a lot of the background characters that will probably show up in it. I'm excited for Episode 8 because the setup made me interested for what will happen next. And you know Disney is smart enough/money focused enough to also do tie in books that fill in the time gap. As a stand alone, Ep7 was pretty good but nothing overly special, will see a few more times because Star Wars. As an intro into the new SW universe, I thought it did a very good job. I've been interested in reading a few of the books but then I realized how many there were and had no idea where to start  The Thrawn series is pretty solid Spoilers for SW7 + Show Spoiler +But why is there a rebellion? What happened to the Republic/ Empire? Why is the capital now some random place instead of Coruscant? And why is the rebellion broke as shit? + Show Spoiler +There is no Rebellion, there is the Resistance. Think of it this way, after the Empire was toppled, the Rebellion split into two groups. One formed the New Republic and one formed the Resistance. The New Republic's goal, obviously, is to reinstate the Republic to bring back the traditional way the galaxy was ruled for thousands of years. The Resistance's goal if to fight the First Order, the largest(if not only) group of the Empire trying to get back into power.
The New Republic wasn't on Coruscant because the Senate gets hosted for periods on different systems via election. Think of it kind of like how the Olympics has different countries host the competition. By the time TFA rolls around, the Senate is on Hosnian Prime, so the First Order blows up the Hosnian system.
+ Show Spoiler +Meh, too much of a stretch to me. Like, why split up? Why isn't the new republic going balls to the walls trying to defeat these First Order people? Exactly what happened to the imperial government and bureaucracy? Why is the rebellion broke as shit that all they have is a couple dozen x-wings?
Yeah, I get that the senate moves around, but that seems like it was shoed in so they wouldn't have to blow up Coruscant,
|
|
|
On December 20 2015 10:05 Gahlo wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2015 06:06 ticklishmusic wrote:On December 20 2015 05:52 TheEmulator wrote:On December 20 2015 03:27 Requizen wrote:On December 20 2015 03:18 ticklishmusic wrote: I really like the Star Wars of the extended universe. This new "canon" or whatever is pretty meh and a lot of the backstory hasn't been explained/ doesn't even make sense. In what's called the "legends" now, the entire birth of the new Republic and the subsequent events and conflicts made a lot more sense.
I'm also kind of salty because I was a major contributor to the Star Wars wiki and my work has all been kind of sidelined. I think it's a bit harsh to call the new canon bad after just the first movie. I think it did a good job of setting things up. I'm excited for Rogue One because Poe was really cool and I recognized a lot of the background characters that will probably show up in it. I'm excited for Episode 8 because the setup made me interested for what will happen next. And you know Disney is smart enough/money focused enough to also do tie in books that fill in the time gap. As a stand alone, Ep7 was pretty good but nothing overly special, will see a few more times because Star Wars. As an intro into the new SW universe, I thought it did a very good job. I've been interested in reading a few of the books but then I realized how many there were and had no idea where to start  The Thrawn series is pretty solid Spoilers for SW7 + Show Spoiler +But why is there a rebellion? What happened to the Republic/ Empire? Why is the capital now some random place instead of Coruscant? And why is the rebellion broke as shit? + Show Spoiler +There is no Rebellion, there is the Resistance. Think of it this way, after the Empire was toppled, the Rebellion split into two groups. One formed the New Republic and one formed the Resistance. The New Republic's goal, obviously, is to reinstate the Republic to bring back the traditional way the galaxy was ruled for thousands of years. The Resistance's goal if to fight the First Order, the largest(if not only) group of the Empire trying to get back into power.
The New Republic wasn't on Coruscant because the Senate gets hosted for periods on different systems via election. Think of it kind of like how the Olympics has different countries host the competition. By the time TFA rolls around, the Senate is on Hosnian Prime, so the First Order blows up the Hosnian system. + Show Spoiler +Your logic for why there is both a Resistance and the New Republic doesn't quite make sense to me. In order for the New Republic to maintain it's order and manage it's goal it still requires a military wing. In the scenario you have lined out that would mean there are two military factions roaming around on the "good" side, New Republic's and Rebellion's. There's no reason for there to be a split of the military and all it does is create a nasty situation later as rogue military leaderships tend to not give up power after their primary reason for forming is done.
Now let's look at the Empire. So at the end of EP6 the Empire's main leadership got taken out. What happens in a military dictatorship is that after the central leadership is removed the lower level leaders tend to form their own pockets of dictatorship so the Empire should have been splintered into a multitude of would be military dictators. In order for the New Republic to become a thing they have to deal with all those would be dictators first otherwise they always at threat of being targeted so that's there their military comes in. What better way to deal with Empire lights than the people that got rid of the Empire? The Rebels/Resistance etc. are a big part of how to form a New Republic yet they aren't part of the New Republic? That doesn't make sense. You don't want a separate military group roaming around the universe while trying to build a stable democracy. If there was a split generally it'll spark a civil war between the two factions that were the rebels. Did this happen?
edit: As for the Mary Sue, well this is Star Wars. It's the light campy fantasy story that uses prophecy/destiny etc. There's always going to be deus ex and Mary sues.
|
|
|
On December 20 2015 19:20 Numy wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2015 10:05 Gahlo wrote:On December 20 2015 06:06 ticklishmusic wrote:On December 20 2015 05:52 TheEmulator wrote:On December 20 2015 03:27 Requizen wrote:On December 20 2015 03:18 ticklishmusic wrote: I really like the Star Wars of the extended universe. This new "canon" or whatever is pretty meh and a lot of the backstory hasn't been explained/ doesn't even make sense. In what's called the "legends" now, the entire birth of the new Republic and the subsequent events and conflicts made a lot more sense.
I'm also kind of salty because I was a major contributor to the Star Wars wiki and my work has all been kind of sidelined. I think it's a bit harsh to call the new canon bad after just the first movie. I think it did a good job of setting things up. I'm excited for Rogue One because Poe was really cool and I recognized a lot of the background characters that will probably show up in it. I'm excited for Episode 8 because the setup made me interested for what will happen next. And you know Disney is smart enough/money focused enough to also do tie in books that fill in the time gap. As a stand alone, Ep7 was pretty good but nothing overly special, will see a few more times because Star Wars. As an intro into the new SW universe, I thought it did a very good job. I've been interested in reading a few of the books but then I realized how many there were and had no idea where to start  The Thrawn series is pretty solid Spoilers for SW7 + Show Spoiler +But why is there a rebellion? What happened to the Republic/ Empire? Why is the capital now some random place instead of Coruscant? And why is the rebellion broke as shit? + Show Spoiler +There is no Rebellion, there is the Resistance. Think of it this way, after the Empire was toppled, the Rebellion split into two groups. One formed the New Republic and one formed the Resistance. The New Republic's goal, obviously, is to reinstate the Republic to bring back the traditional way the galaxy was ruled for thousands of years. The Resistance's goal if to fight the First Order, the largest(if not only) group of the Empire trying to get back into power.
The New Republic wasn't on Coruscant because the Senate gets hosted for periods on different systems via election. Think of it kind of like how the Olympics has different countries host the competition. By the time TFA rolls around, the Senate is on Hosnian Prime, so the First Order blows up the Hosnian system. + Show Spoiler +Your logic for why there is both a Resistance and the New Republic doesn't quite make sense to me. In order for the New Republic to maintain it's order and manage it's goal it still requires a military wing. In the scenario you have lined out that would mean there are two military factions roaming around on the "good" side, New Republic's and Rebellion's. There's no reason for there to be a split of the military and all it does is create a nasty situation later as rogue military leaderships tend to not give up power after their primary reason for forming is done.
Now let's look at the Empire. So at the end of EP6 the Empire's main leadership got taken out. What happens in a military dictatorship is that after the central leadership is removed the lower level leaders tend to form their own pockets of dictatorship so the Empire should have been splintered into a multitude of would be military dictators. In order for the New Republic to become a thing they have to deal with all those would be dictators first otherwise they always at threat of being targeted so that's there their military comes in. What better way to deal with Empire lights than the people that got rid of the Empire? The Rebels/Resistance etc. are a big part of how to form a New Republic yet they aren't part of the New Republic? That doesn't make sense. You don't want a separate military group roaming around the universe while trying to build a stable democracy. If there was a split generally it'll spark a civil war between the two factions that were the rebels. Did this happen?
edit: As for the Mary Sue, well this is Star Wars. It's the light campy fantasy story that uses prophecy/destiny etc. There's always going to be deus ex and Mary sues. + Show Spoiler [star wars] +The New Republic is trying to reinstate a system of government across an entire galaxy. Just because they have FTL travel doesn't make that easy. The New Republic had a fleet, it was just focused on defending the New Republic, hence why it was in the Hosnian system. The Resistance exist because Leia felt the couldn't just sit on their hands while threats like the First Order exist.
E7 takes place 30 years after E6. Nothing stops multiple post-Empire factions from being destroyed since then. The New Republic supports the Resistance.
|
On December 20 2015 14:10 Gahlo wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2015 13:02 wei2coolman wrote:starwars related with spoiler. just curious what people think about Max Landis's thoughts? + Show Spoiler +https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpS6TlqgLIQ + Show Spoiler [SW7] +Too bad she isn't. Using the predominant theory on Rey, she is Luke's daughter. Until Ben turned to the dark side, she was being trained by her father. She's an excellent mechanic because she's been a scavanger since she was 5 on Jakku. Han warms up to her because he recognizes her, but maybe Luke told him not to say anything to her because her mind was wiped as a way to protect her.
And no, that is the way it works. Vader being Anakin still matters in E4 despite the audience not knowing it in E5. Obviously, having a role swap with a guy who grew up as a moisture farmer as opposed to a trained jedi who the Force is heavily nudging to get her abilities back. + Show Spoiler +Just because there's a plot reason for someone to be overpowered (however tenuous it is) doesn't stop someone from being a mary sue.
Being trained by her father when she was 5 lets her control people perfectly within hours of her awakening, light saber duel a (slightly injured) fully trained jedi, and she happens to be a complete genius at technical work + she's a world champion level at parkour...
That's like the definition of mary sue
|
On December 20 2015 22:08 killerdog wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2015 14:10 Gahlo wrote:On December 20 2015 13:02 wei2coolman wrote:starwars related with spoiler. just curious what people think about Max Landis's thoughts? + Show Spoiler +https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpS6TlqgLIQ + Show Spoiler [SW7] +Too bad she isn't. Using the predominant theory on Rey, she is Luke's daughter. Until Ben turned to the dark side, she was being trained by her father. She's an excellent mechanic because she's been a scavanger since she was 5 on Jakku. Han warms up to her because he recognizes her, but maybe Luke told him not to say anything to her because her mind was wiped as a way to protect her.
And no, that is the way it works. Vader being Anakin still matters in E4 despite the audience not knowing it in E5. Obviously, having a role swap with a guy who grew up as a moisture farmer as opposed to a trained jedi who the Force is heavily nudging to get her abilities back. + Show Spoiler +Just because there's a plot reason for someone to be overpowered (however tenuous it is) doesn't stop someone from being a mary sue.
Being trained by her father when she was 5 lets her control people perfectly within hours of her awakening, light saber duel a (slightly injured) fully trained jedi, and she happens to be a complete genius at technical work + she's a world champion level at parkour...
That's like the definition of mary sue
+ Show Spoiler +Don't forget successfully outflying two of the most maneuverable fighters in Star Wars canon in a half broken ship that two minutes ago she wasn't sure would get off the ground.
|
On December 20 2015 22:25 Ketara wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2015 22:08 killerdog wrote:On December 20 2015 14:10 Gahlo wrote:On December 20 2015 13:02 wei2coolman wrote:starwars related with spoiler. just curious what people think about Max Landis's thoughts? + Show Spoiler +https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpS6TlqgLIQ + Show Spoiler [SW7] +Too bad she isn't. Using the predominant theory on Rey, she is Luke's daughter. Until Ben turned to the dark side, she was being trained by her father. She's an excellent mechanic because she's been a scavanger since she was 5 on Jakku. Han warms up to her because he recognizes her, but maybe Luke told him not to say anything to her because her mind was wiped as a way to protect her.
And no, that is the way it works. Vader being Anakin still matters in E4 despite the audience not knowing it in E5. Obviously, having a role swap with a guy who grew up as a moisture farmer as opposed to a trained jedi who the Force is heavily nudging to get her abilities back. + Show Spoiler +Just because there's a plot reason for someone to be overpowered (however tenuous it is) doesn't stop someone from being a mary sue.
Being trained by her father when she was 5 lets her control people perfectly within hours of her awakening, light saber duel a (slightly injured) fully trained jedi, and she happens to be a complete genius at technical work + she's a world champion level at parkour...
That's like the definition of mary sue + Show Spoiler +Don't forget successfully outflying two of the most maneuverable fighters in Star Wars canon in a half broken ship that two minutes ago she wasn't sure would get off the ground. + Show Spoiler +I sort of saw the whole film as basically a very high budget star wars fanfic
That is not a bad thing :p
|
On December 20 2015 22:45 killerdog wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2015 22:25 Ketara wrote:On December 20 2015 22:08 killerdog wrote:On December 20 2015 14:10 Gahlo wrote:On December 20 2015 13:02 wei2coolman wrote:starwars related with spoiler. just curious what people think about Max Landis's thoughts? + Show Spoiler +https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpS6TlqgLIQ + Show Spoiler [SW7] +Too bad she isn't. Using the predominant theory on Rey, she is Luke's daughter. Until Ben turned to the dark side, she was being trained by her father. She's an excellent mechanic because she's been a scavanger since she was 5 on Jakku. Han warms up to her because he recognizes her, but maybe Luke told him not to say anything to her because her mind was wiped as a way to protect her.
And no, that is the way it works. Vader being Anakin still matters in E4 despite the audience not knowing it in E5. Obviously, having a role swap with a guy who grew up as a moisture farmer as opposed to a trained jedi who the Force is heavily nudging to get her abilities back. + Show Spoiler +Just because there's a plot reason for someone to be overpowered (however tenuous it is) doesn't stop someone from being a mary sue.
Being trained by her father when she was 5 lets her control people perfectly within hours of her awakening, light saber duel a (slightly injured) fully trained jedi, and she happens to be a complete genius at technical work + she's a world champion level at parkour...
That's like the definition of mary sue + Show Spoiler +Don't forget successfully outflying two of the most maneuverable fighters in Star Wars canon in a half broken ship that two minutes ago she wasn't sure would get off the ground. + Show Spoiler +I sort of saw the whole film as basically a very high budget star wars fanfic
That is not a bad thing :p
+ Show Spoiler +Oh totally.
I mean, I enjoyed it a LOT.
It's just, it is what it is.
I feel like people who aren't liking it are going to not like it because they expected it to not be that.
I mean, this is the guy doing the new Star Trek movies. It's the same kind of movie.
|
On December 20 2015 23:00 Ketara wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2015 22:45 killerdog wrote:On December 20 2015 22:25 Ketara wrote:On December 20 2015 22:08 killerdog wrote:On December 20 2015 14:10 Gahlo wrote:On December 20 2015 13:02 wei2coolman wrote:starwars related with spoiler. just curious what people think about Max Landis's thoughts? + Show Spoiler +https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpS6TlqgLIQ + Show Spoiler [SW7] +Too bad she isn't. Using the predominant theory on Rey, she is Luke's daughter. Until Ben turned to the dark side, she was being trained by her father. She's an excellent mechanic because she's been a scavanger since she was 5 on Jakku. Han warms up to her because he recognizes her, but maybe Luke told him not to say anything to her because her mind was wiped as a way to protect her.
And no, that is the way it works. Vader being Anakin still matters in E4 despite the audience not knowing it in E5. Obviously, having a role swap with a guy who grew up as a moisture farmer as opposed to a trained jedi who the Force is heavily nudging to get her abilities back. + Show Spoiler +Just because there's a plot reason for someone to be overpowered (however tenuous it is) doesn't stop someone from being a mary sue.
Being trained by her father when she was 5 lets her control people perfectly within hours of her awakening, light saber duel a (slightly injured) fully trained jedi, and she happens to be a complete genius at technical work + she's a world champion level at parkour...
That's like the definition of mary sue + Show Spoiler +Don't forget successfully outflying two of the most maneuverable fighters in Star Wars canon in a half broken ship that two minutes ago she wasn't sure would get off the ground. + Show Spoiler +I sort of saw the whole film as basically a very high budget star wars fanfic
That is not a bad thing :p + Show Spoiler +Oh totally.
I mean, I enjoyed it a LOT.
It's just, it is what it is.
I feel like people who aren't liking it are going to not like it because they expected it to not be that.
I mean, this is the guy doing the new Star Trek movies. It's the same kind of movie. + Show Spoiler +I'm still salty about Star Trek movies. Fking J.J just can't help having his fan boner explode all over film making it seems.
|
|
|
|
|
|