|
On December 19 2015 19:00 Numy wrote:Show nested quote +On December 19 2015 17:17 Cixah wrote:On December 19 2015 17:02 Gahlo wrote:On December 19 2015 16:40 killerdog wrote:On December 19 2015 16:01 ticklishmusic wrote:On December 19 2015 15:41 Ketara wrote:On December 19 2015 15:38 ticklishmusic wrote:Saw SW7, spoilers below + Show Spoiler +You sure? + Show Spoiler + A good movie overall, 8/10. A lot of small details things are done right. Characters are good, acting is good, special effects and scenery look good. Plot was pretty lazy, basically the same as episode 4. There's one differentiating factor, and it almost feels like THEY FUCKING KILLED HAN SOLO just to be able to say the plot was different. It was totally set up though.
Random thoughts: Lmao, the rebellion is broke as shit 30 years later. Can we get some backstory about that... what happened? They had a fucking fleet at Endor. When they blew that planet up I thought it was Coruscant and almost crapped my pants. Still would have preferred the galactic capital over losing Han though Kylo Ren is a fucking piece of shit Supreme Master Snoakes is the dumbest name ever
+ Show Spoiler +Killing Han wasn't deviating from Ep4's plot at all. Han played the mentor/father figure to girlchick I forget her name. He had the same role as Obi Wan.
But we all know the reason they killed Han was because Harrison Ford told them he only wanted to be in one movie. + Show Spoiler +i mean yeah lets be real we didnt really give that much of a shit about obi wan dying
but han, we actually really liked han
but yeah, i thought it mightve been external reasons, like harrison ford almost dying
also the bad guys never learn how to properly defend a giant planet destroying superweapon do they
+ Show Spoiler +sw spoil + Show Spoiler +While it was super obvious what was going to happen, at least from the moment he walked onto the bridge, it was definitely in keeping with the earlier films :p
It's pretty funny how identical the plot is to the original too.
Random notes: Two new leads seem really good it felt like JJ had a 60 page list of references/one liners he needed to include to play to the nostalgia crowd, was getting a bit much (imo) Did the slapstick comedy really well, a ton more actually funny jokes then most action film manage to fit in, and while some fell flat, most were really well timed/executed. (The originals had nowhere near this much visual/slapstick comedy did they?) Seemed pretty self aware that it was just episode 4 remade bigger. Black guy surprisingly good with a lightsaber for a non force user, I thought non force users couldn't even use them? Girl is op as fuck, holy shit. She seems stronger then luke was at the end of all his training, and she's had the force for like 18 hours lol They went full marvel with the arch villain being a giant in a chair, (I wonder if he'll still be huge then they actually meet him, or if his hologram just has ego issues.) Liked how much actually got done in the film. A lot of movies which know they'll be part of a 3 parter seem to not really have a good conclusion to the film, but this did a very good job of being a hype, self contained movie by itself. Definitely feels like they left it ready for the sequel, but it also definitely felt like it stands on it's own as a movie.
tldr: bit cheesy, not very original, but looked incredibly pretty and (amusingly) the new actors were mostly really good, while the old guard only really seem to be there for face value. Despite the scale of what was going on, the sets were kept very real and the fight scenes felt great too.
Nowhere near best movie of all time or anything for me, but definitely a solid and enjoyable watch.
+ Show Spoiler [Stir Wares] +No, they decidedly put more humor in it than E4. I think it just might be necessary for a movie these days as opposed to the ~40 year old E4.
Making any Star Wars film must be a daunting task. They have to live up to the originals and surpass the sour taste of the prequels. The safest thing to possibly do is borrow heavily from the originals, which 7 did. I'm still iffy on how I feel about it.
Last I read, the reason why lightsabers are notoriously difficult to wield is because the pseudo physics of the blade creates a gyroscope effect. When 1 wrong move means you've cut off a limb, most people are better off not screwing around with them. Why Finn is capable, I don't know.
There's a fan theory that Rey already had jedi training, since she is Luke's daughter, but after Ben defected Luke internalized his guilt into becoming a recluse and wiped the memory from her brain and left her on Jakku. Typical with most fictional memory wipes, there are cracks that can make the whole thing come crumbling down. + Show Spoiler [STAR WARS SPOILERS] ++ Show Spoiler [No seriously i talk about everything] +Its not out of this universe to suggest that Finn is some what force aware. He lucks his way into a few situations much like Rhea does. Finn's inability to remember family/taken too soon could easily play into that.
I also wouldn't be suprised if Rhea is Snokes' Daughter/Related in some way to Luke/Leia due to her capability with the force. The "Flashback" scene where she picks up Anakin's Saber shows where someone important to her/Luke (if this part of the scene is based on Luke now holding the saber) is stabbed by Kylo as well as when shes dropped off on Dakku with someone sound very much like Kylo Ren saying "Come on we don't need them anymore."
The part that really throws a whole wrench in the situation is when Kylo says as he's Force Mind Reading, where he wants the map and says the First Order has all of the map except one piece because of the empire is a bit eerie due to the fact that the empire would have been long gone by the time this happens. Not that it matters anyway (Kylo:"I see your dream, a blue ocean, with you an Island. I will know why this is important to you.") I'm sure once Snokes steals this from Kylo/Hyperbolic time chambers him into a badass will reveal they now know where Luke is and will rush to attempt to kill/interrupt her training.
All in all, the movie was pretty good. Better than okay, and much better than the prequels. I feel like JJ did every thing he needed to do to set up the new arc as well as leave plenty of people guessing. My only real complaint is that it's basically a shot for shot remake of A New Hope. + Show Spoiler +I mean I'm a bit disappointed it's not at the story level of some of the non-movie Star Wars we've seen. It's just a retelling of the Originals. If that's what it set out to be and what people wanted then sure I guess that's ok. Personally just think the Star Wars universe can be way cooler than that and yet we never really experience how good it can be in film.
The whole map thing was also weird. If they have every place that he isn't then why aren't they just searching the gap in the map? Did I just miss some plot point there. I'm also pretty sure Finn will turn out to have the force but even then it's all kind of weird. The guy has some serious mental break down when his buddy is shot and killed but later he has no issue mowing down tons of people. Like what? I thought he'd be more remorseful and try to "save people" instead of harming them so we'd see a more pacifist Light side Jedi while Ray will be the more aggressive one.
+ Show Spoiler +I agree that Finns mental breakdown was a little forced and inconsistent with the rest of the film. I don't think it was bad though. Or not any worse than how most movies portray that sort of thing, we weren't really expecting a deeply psychological film were we? It's an actiony space opera movie, people act according to ideals, not according to how they would actually act IRL.
As for the map, that they did explain. The Empire/First Order had all of the map but the part where Luke is (not useful), and the Rebels had the part of the map where Luke is, but without the rest of the map they couldn't figure out what part of the galaxy it was in.
Why the two pieces of the map got split up and one side had one and the other didn't, or why R2D2 shut himself down and then deus ex machina'd his way back to life with the correct map piece for no fucking reason wasn't really explained, but did it really need to be? It would have been preferential I think if they'd had Han get the map from the base while he was shutting the shields down, probably. But, this is a minor quibble.
|
United States47024 Posts
On December 19 2015 17:48 Frudgey wrote: Also I've been working on a Dungeons and Dragons backstory for my undead Paladin!
There's actually an decent 3rd Edition splatbook called Libris Mortis specifically for creating Undead characters and integrating undead characters into a campaign. While a lot of the 3.5E specific stuff won't be relevant, you should check it out.
|
On December 19 2015 19:08 Ketara wrote:Show nested quote +On December 19 2015 19:00 Numy wrote:On December 19 2015 17:17 Cixah wrote:On December 19 2015 17:02 Gahlo wrote:On December 19 2015 16:40 killerdog wrote:On December 19 2015 16:01 ticklishmusic wrote:On December 19 2015 15:41 Ketara wrote:On December 19 2015 15:38 ticklishmusic wrote:Saw SW7, spoilers below + Show Spoiler +You sure? + Show Spoiler + A good movie overall, 8/10. A lot of small details things are done right. Characters are good, acting is good, special effects and scenery look good. Plot was pretty lazy, basically the same as episode 4. There's one differentiating factor, and it almost feels like THEY FUCKING KILLED HAN SOLO just to be able to say the plot was different. It was totally set up though.
Random thoughts: Lmao, the rebellion is broke as shit 30 years later. Can we get some backstory about that... what happened? They had a fucking fleet at Endor. When they blew that planet up I thought it was Coruscant and almost crapped my pants. Still would have preferred the galactic capital over losing Han though Kylo Ren is a fucking piece of shit Supreme Master Snoakes is the dumbest name ever
+ Show Spoiler +Killing Han wasn't deviating from Ep4's plot at all. Han played the mentor/father figure to girlchick I forget her name. He had the same role as Obi Wan.
But we all know the reason they killed Han was because Harrison Ford told them he only wanted to be in one movie. + Show Spoiler +i mean yeah lets be real we didnt really give that much of a shit about obi wan dying
but han, we actually really liked han
but yeah, i thought it mightve been external reasons, like harrison ford almost dying
also the bad guys never learn how to properly defend a giant planet destroying superweapon do they
+ Show Spoiler +sw spoil + Show Spoiler +While it was super obvious what was going to happen, at least from the moment he walked onto the bridge, it was definitely in keeping with the earlier films :p
It's pretty funny how identical the plot is to the original too.
Random notes: Two new leads seem really good it felt like JJ had a 60 page list of references/one liners he needed to include to play to the nostalgia crowd, was getting a bit much (imo) Did the slapstick comedy really well, a ton more actually funny jokes then most action film manage to fit in, and while some fell flat, most were really well timed/executed. (The originals had nowhere near this much visual/slapstick comedy did they?) Seemed pretty self aware that it was just episode 4 remade bigger. Black guy surprisingly good with a lightsaber for a non force user, I thought non force users couldn't even use them? Girl is op as fuck, holy shit. She seems stronger then luke was at the end of all his training, and she's had the force for like 18 hours lol They went full marvel with the arch villain being a giant in a chair, (I wonder if he'll still be huge then they actually meet him, or if his hologram just has ego issues.) Liked how much actually got done in the film. A lot of movies which know they'll be part of a 3 parter seem to not really have a good conclusion to the film, but this did a very good job of being a hype, self contained movie by itself. Definitely feels like they left it ready for the sequel, but it also definitely felt like it stands on it's own as a movie.
tldr: bit cheesy, not very original, but looked incredibly pretty and (amusingly) the new actors were mostly really good, while the old guard only really seem to be there for face value. Despite the scale of what was going on, the sets were kept very real and the fight scenes felt great too.
Nowhere near best movie of all time or anything for me, but definitely a solid and enjoyable watch.
+ Show Spoiler [Stir Wares] +No, they decidedly put more humor in it than E4. I think it just might be necessary for a movie these days as opposed to the ~40 year old E4.
Making any Star Wars film must be a daunting task. They have to live up to the originals and surpass the sour taste of the prequels. The safest thing to possibly do is borrow heavily from the originals, which 7 did. I'm still iffy on how I feel about it.
Last I read, the reason why lightsabers are notoriously difficult to wield is because the pseudo physics of the blade creates a gyroscope effect. When 1 wrong move means you've cut off a limb, most people are better off not screwing around with them. Why Finn is capable, I don't know.
There's a fan theory that Rey already had jedi training, since she is Luke's daughter, but after Ben defected Luke internalized his guilt into becoming a recluse and wiped the memory from her brain and left her on Jakku. Typical with most fictional memory wipes, there are cracks that can make the whole thing come crumbling down. + Show Spoiler [STAR WARS SPOILERS] ++ Show Spoiler [No seriously i talk about everything] +Its not out of this universe to suggest that Finn is some what force aware. He lucks his way into a few situations much like Rhea does. Finn's inability to remember family/taken too soon could easily play into that.
I also wouldn't be suprised if Rhea is Snokes' Daughter/Related in some way to Luke/Leia due to her capability with the force. The "Flashback" scene where she picks up Anakin's Saber shows where someone important to her/Luke (if this part of the scene is based on Luke now holding the saber) is stabbed by Kylo as well as when shes dropped off on Dakku with someone sound very much like Kylo Ren saying "Come on we don't need them anymore."
The part that really throws a whole wrench in the situation is when Kylo says as he's Force Mind Reading, where he wants the map and says the First Order has all of the map except one piece because of the empire is a bit eerie due to the fact that the empire would have been long gone by the time this happens. Not that it matters anyway (Kylo:"I see your dream, a blue ocean, with you an Island. I will know why this is important to you.") I'm sure once Snokes steals this from Kylo/Hyperbolic time chambers him into a badass will reveal they now know where Luke is and will rush to attempt to kill/interrupt her training.
All in all, the movie was pretty good. Better than okay, and much better than the prequels. I feel like JJ did every thing he needed to do to set up the new arc as well as leave plenty of people guessing. My only real complaint is that it's basically a shot for shot remake of A New Hope. + Show Spoiler +I mean I'm a bit disappointed it's not at the story level of some of the non-movie Star Wars we've seen. It's just a retelling of the Originals. If that's what it set out to be and what people wanted then sure I guess that's ok. Personally just think the Star Wars universe can be way cooler than that and yet we never really experience how good it can be in film.
The whole map thing was also weird. If they have every place that he isn't then why aren't they just searching the gap in the map? Did I just miss some plot point there. I'm also pretty sure Finn will turn out to have the force but even then it's all kind of weird. The guy has some serious mental break down when his buddy is shot and killed but later he has no issue mowing down tons of people. Like what? I thought he'd be more remorseful and try to "save people" instead of harming them so we'd see a more pacifist Light side Jedi while Ray will be the more aggressive one. + Show Spoiler +I agree that Finns mental breakdown was a little forced and inconsistent with the rest of the film. I don't think it was bad though. Or not any worse than how most movies portray that sort of thing, we weren't really expecting a deeply psychological film were we? It's an actiony space opera movie, people act according to ideals, not according to how they would actually act IRL.
As for the map, that they did explain. The Empire/First Order had all of the map but the part where Luke is (not useful), and the Rebels had the part of the map where Luke is, but without the rest of the map they couldn't figure out what part of the galaxy it was in.
Why the two pieces of the map got split up and one side had one and the other didn't, or why R2D2 shut himself down and then deus ex machina'd his way back to life with the correct map piece for no fucking reason wasn't really explained, but did it really need to be? It would have been preferential I think if they'd had Han get the map from the base while he was shutting the shields down, probably. But, this is a minor quibble.
+ Show Spoiler +True about Finn but I've just been watching Jessica Jones so the jarring differences in how it handles mental distress was a bit much. Should just take it for what it is, a genric coming of age fantasy story in space
I'm still not getting the map issue. R2D2 had the whole map except that piece and all the new toy bot did was slot in that map piece to show which planet he was on. If the First Order had what R2D2 had why then couldn't they just search that whole sector while trying to get the map piece?
Another thing, earlier guys were saying First Order were small but they built a freaking planet destroying planet. That takes a lot of time,money and man power. How haven't the republic/rebels heard of it? Idk the Light side always seems so massively incompetent in these movies. What happened in the 20 years for them to be worse off than they were during the Empire.
Overall it just felt like the movie was eluding to way more interesting stories that it wasn't telling and instead we got a copy of a movie that's been out for over 20 years. I don't really know how Star Wars fans can like it. Seemed more like a "sell new toys to a new generation and set up the real movies to come" than an actual movie on it's own.
|
+ Show Spoiler [SW stuff because reasons.] +Numy has the right of it. If you are and I hate to use this word because it has a seemingly negative connotation a casual fan of Star Wars you are going to enjoy this film. You might not like all of it but it's an overall enjoyable experience.
However if you're the guy like me whose read the books, grew up playing some of the classic games and just loved the Universe this film will make you realize why Lucas initially tried vary hard to stay out of the Studio system when he made the original version of this film way back in 1977.
I personally just look at it and wonder what would of happened if they had just did the Thrawn arc, or given it to Guillermo del Toro and gone for a full on Vong storyline. Instead we got a passable film that's only acceptable because it ripped off it's original.
We got Into Darknessed by abrams. What a damn shame.
At least Luke looks like a grizzled badass. As he should.
|
Cooking question:
If I use too much oil, can that overpower the taste of the vegetables/herbs in a dish?
|
On December 19 2015 20:43 Ketara wrote: Cooking question:
If I use too much oil, can that overpower the taste of the vegetables/herbs in a dish?
Yes.
Though generally if you season well and use your spices correctly, the influence shouldn't be that much. Too much oil can influence your dish in other negative ways, by influencing how your food is cooked (fried/baked) or by texture (too oily, duh).
When you are cooking foods that will release their own fats (nuts, fatter meats), use less oil than you would for veg.
|
On December 19 2015 20:43 Ketara wrote: Cooking question:
If I use too much oil, can that overpower the taste of the vegetables/herbs in a dish? Do you find deep fried vegetables overpowered?
|
Hmm.
I'm trying to figure out how to make pad ka pow, which is basically meat stir fried with holy basil.
And the basil taste is just not as strong as I want it to be.
But I think maybe instead of using more basil, I'm using too much oil and should try using less oil. It was preti oily this time.
HMMMMMMM.
|
On December 19 2015 21:00 Ketara wrote: Hmm.
I'm trying to figure out how to make pad ka pow, which is basically meat stir fried with holy basil.
And the basil taste is just not as strong as I want it to be.
But I think maybe instead of using more basil, I'm using too much oil and should try using less oil. It was preti oily this time.
HMMMMMMM. If you have meat in there you need barely any. All the flavour in the meat comes from the fat too, so why dilute that with oil~
|
On December 19 2015 19:37 Parnage wrote:+ Show Spoiler [SW stuff because reasons.] +Numy has the right of it. If you are and I hate to use this word because it has a seemingly negative connotation a casual fan of Star Wars you are going to enjoy this film. You might not like all of it but it's an overall enjoyable experience.
However if you're the guy like me whose read the books, grew up playing some of the classic games and just loved the Universe this film will make you realize why Lucas initially tried vary hard to stay out of the Studio system when he made the original version of this film way back in 1977.
I personally just look at it and wonder what would of happened if they had just did the Thrawn arc, or given it to Guillermo del Toro and gone for a full on Vong storyline. Instead we got a passable film that's only acceptable because it ripped off it's original.
We got Into Darknessed by abrams. What a damn shame.
At least Luke looks like a grizzled badass. As he should.
Yea I meant more like the hardcore guys that are immersed in it than say a casual fan like myself who likes it but isn't really that invested into the franchise. Although I love Jedi Knight and Kotor games. Would love to see the ancient Sith on the big screen. SOOOOOOOOOOO much cooler than the "sith" we get in the films.
|
On December 19 2015 17:30 AsmodeusXI wrote: Someday I'll come back and open all these tags, but for now they must remain woefully closed.
Is anyone doing anything else?
I'm partitioning my Macbook for Windows so I can play FFXIV over the holidays.
Because why not
Heading to a SG monthly out at Game Underground today. If there's a stream, I'll post here.
|
On December 19 2015 19:19 Numy wrote:Show nested quote +On December 19 2015 19:08 Ketara wrote:On December 19 2015 19:00 Numy wrote:On December 19 2015 17:17 Cixah wrote:On December 19 2015 17:02 Gahlo wrote:On December 19 2015 16:40 killerdog wrote:On December 19 2015 16:01 ticklishmusic wrote:On December 19 2015 15:41 Ketara wrote:On December 19 2015 15:38 ticklishmusic wrote:Saw SW7, spoilers below + Show Spoiler +You sure? + Show Spoiler + A good movie overall, 8/10. A lot of small details things are done right. Characters are good, acting is good, special effects and scenery look good. Plot was pretty lazy, basically the same as episode 4. There's one differentiating factor, and it almost feels like THEY FUCKING KILLED HAN SOLO just to be able to say the plot was different. It was totally set up though.
Random thoughts: Lmao, the rebellion is broke as shit 30 years later. Can we get some backstory about that... what happened? They had a fucking fleet at Endor. When they blew that planet up I thought it was Coruscant and almost crapped my pants. Still would have preferred the galactic capital over losing Han though Kylo Ren is a fucking piece of shit Supreme Master Snoakes is the dumbest name ever
+ Show Spoiler +Killing Han wasn't deviating from Ep4's plot at all. Han played the mentor/father figure to girlchick I forget her name. He had the same role as Obi Wan.
But we all know the reason they killed Han was because Harrison Ford told them he only wanted to be in one movie. + Show Spoiler +i mean yeah lets be real we didnt really give that much of a shit about obi wan dying
but han, we actually really liked han
but yeah, i thought it mightve been external reasons, like harrison ford almost dying
also the bad guys never learn how to properly defend a giant planet destroying superweapon do they
+ Show Spoiler +sw spoil + Show Spoiler +While it was super obvious what was going to happen, at least from the moment he walked onto the bridge, it was definitely in keeping with the earlier films :p
It's pretty funny how identical the plot is to the original too.
Random notes: Two new leads seem really good it felt like JJ had a 60 page list of references/one liners he needed to include to play to the nostalgia crowd, was getting a bit much (imo) Did the slapstick comedy really well, a ton more actually funny jokes then most action film manage to fit in, and while some fell flat, most were really well timed/executed. (The originals had nowhere near this much visual/slapstick comedy did they?) Seemed pretty self aware that it was just episode 4 remade bigger. Black guy surprisingly good with a lightsaber for a non force user, I thought non force users couldn't even use them? Girl is op as fuck, holy shit. She seems stronger then luke was at the end of all his training, and she's had the force for like 18 hours lol They went full marvel with the arch villain being a giant in a chair, (I wonder if he'll still be huge then they actually meet him, or if his hologram just has ego issues.) Liked how much actually got done in the film. A lot of movies which know they'll be part of a 3 parter seem to not really have a good conclusion to the film, but this did a very good job of being a hype, self contained movie by itself. Definitely feels like they left it ready for the sequel, but it also definitely felt like it stands on it's own as a movie.
tldr: bit cheesy, not very original, but looked incredibly pretty and (amusingly) the new actors were mostly really good, while the old guard only really seem to be there for face value. Despite the scale of what was going on, the sets were kept very real and the fight scenes felt great too.
Nowhere near best movie of all time or anything for me, but definitely a solid and enjoyable watch.
+ Show Spoiler [Stir Wares] +No, they decidedly put more humor in it than E4. I think it just might be necessary for a movie these days as opposed to the ~40 year old E4.
Making any Star Wars film must be a daunting task. They have to live up to the originals and surpass the sour taste of the prequels. The safest thing to possibly do is borrow heavily from the originals, which 7 did. I'm still iffy on how I feel about it.
Last I read, the reason why lightsabers are notoriously difficult to wield is because the pseudo physics of the blade creates a gyroscope effect. When 1 wrong move means you've cut off a limb, most people are better off not screwing around with them. Why Finn is capable, I don't know.
There's a fan theory that Rey already had jedi training, since she is Luke's daughter, but after Ben defected Luke internalized his guilt into becoming a recluse and wiped the memory from her brain and left her on Jakku. Typical with most fictional memory wipes, there are cracks that can make the whole thing come crumbling down. + Show Spoiler [STAR WARS SPOILERS] ++ Show Spoiler [No seriously i talk about everything] +Its not out of this universe to suggest that Finn is some what force aware. He lucks his way into a few situations much like Rhea does. Finn's inability to remember family/taken too soon could easily play into that.
I also wouldn't be suprised if Rhea is Snokes' Daughter/Related in some way to Luke/Leia due to her capability with the force. The "Flashback" scene where she picks up Anakin's Saber shows where someone important to her/Luke (if this part of the scene is based on Luke now holding the saber) is stabbed by Kylo as well as when shes dropped off on Dakku with someone sound very much like Kylo Ren saying "Come on we don't need them anymore."
The part that really throws a whole wrench in the situation is when Kylo says as he's Force Mind Reading, where he wants the map and says the First Order has all of the map except one piece because of the empire is a bit eerie due to the fact that the empire would have been long gone by the time this happens. Not that it matters anyway (Kylo:"I see your dream, a blue ocean, with you an Island. I will know why this is important to you.") I'm sure once Snokes steals this from Kylo/Hyperbolic time chambers him into a badass will reveal they now know where Luke is and will rush to attempt to kill/interrupt her training.
All in all, the movie was pretty good. Better than okay, and much better than the prequels. I feel like JJ did every thing he needed to do to set up the new arc as well as leave plenty of people guessing. My only real complaint is that it's basically a shot for shot remake of A New Hope. + Show Spoiler +I mean I'm a bit disappointed it's not at the story level of some of the non-movie Star Wars we've seen. It's just a retelling of the Originals. If that's what it set out to be and what people wanted then sure I guess that's ok. Personally just think the Star Wars universe can be way cooler than that and yet we never really experience how good it can be in film.
The whole map thing was also weird. If they have every place that he isn't then why aren't they just searching the gap in the map? Did I just miss some plot point there. I'm also pretty sure Finn will turn out to have the force but even then it's all kind of weird. The guy has some serious mental break down when his buddy is shot and killed but later he has no issue mowing down tons of people. Like what? I thought he'd be more remorseful and try to "save people" instead of harming them so we'd see a more pacifist Light side Jedi while Ray will be the more aggressive one. + Show Spoiler +I agree that Finns mental breakdown was a little forced and inconsistent with the rest of the film. I don't think it was bad though. Or not any worse than how most movies portray that sort of thing, we weren't really expecting a deeply psychological film were we? It's an actiony space opera movie, people act according to ideals, not according to how they would actually act IRL.
As for the map, that they did explain. The Empire/First Order had all of the map but the part where Luke is (not useful), and the Rebels had the part of the map where Luke is, but without the rest of the map they couldn't figure out what part of the galaxy it was in.
Why the two pieces of the map got split up and one side had one and the other didn't, or why R2D2 shut himself down and then deus ex machina'd his way back to life with the correct map piece for no fucking reason wasn't really explained, but did it really need to be? It would have been preferential I think if they'd had Han get the map from the base while he was shutting the shields down, probably. But, this is a minor quibble. + Show Spoiler +True about Finn but I've just been watching Jessica Jones so the jarring differences in how it handles mental distress was a bit much. Should just take it for what it is, a genric coming of age fantasy story in space
I'm still not getting the map issue. R2D2 had the whole map except that piece and all the new toy bot did was slot in that map piece to show which planet he was on. If the First Order had what R2D2 had why then couldn't they just search that whole sector while trying to get the map piece?
Another thing, earlier guys were saying First Order were small but they built a freaking planet destroying planet. That takes a lot of time,money and man power. How haven't the republic/rebels heard of it? Idk the Light side always seems so massively incompetent in these movies. What happened in the 20 years for them to be worse off than they were during the Empire.
Overall it just felt like the movie was eluding to way more interesting stories that it wasn't telling and instead we got a copy of a movie that's been out for over 20 years. I don't really know how Star Wars fans can like it. Seemed more like a "sell new toys to a new generation and set up the real movies to come" than an actual movie on it's own. + Show Spoiler [Star Wars] +If that map was of the whole galaxy, then that missing spot would have been light years upon light years large with thousands upon thousands of planets. That would take the Empire a large amount of time to scour, let alone a smaller organization like the First Order. Remember how much trouble they had just combing Tatooine?
The Republic isn't prepared for it because they aren't focused on the First Order. It's trying to piece the galaxy back together. The Resistance knows it exists, they just lack intelligence on it. Keep in mind that the shield around the planet was strong enough that you had to hyperspace through it if you wanted to sneak in.
|
United States15536 Posts
On December 20 2015 00:33 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On December 19 2015 17:30 AsmodeusXI wrote: Someday I'll come back and open all these tags, but for now they must remain woefully closed.
Is anyone doing anything else?
I'm partitioning my Macbook for Windows so I can play FFXIV over the holidays.
Because why not Heading to a SG monthly out at Game Underground today. If there's a stream, I'll post here.
I'm also in MA. I don't know how busy your holidays are butttttttt....
|
On December 20 2015 00:33 Gahlo wrote:Show nested quote +On December 19 2015 19:19 Numy wrote:On December 19 2015 19:08 Ketara wrote:On December 19 2015 19:00 Numy wrote:On December 19 2015 17:17 Cixah wrote:On December 19 2015 17:02 Gahlo wrote:On December 19 2015 16:40 killerdog wrote:On December 19 2015 16:01 ticklishmusic wrote:On December 19 2015 15:41 Ketara wrote:On December 19 2015 15:38 ticklishmusic wrote:Saw SW7, spoilers below + Show Spoiler +You sure? + Show Spoiler + A good movie overall, 8/10. A lot of small details things are done right. Characters are good, acting is good, special effects and scenery look good. Plot was pretty lazy, basically the same as episode 4. There's one differentiating factor, and it almost feels like THEY FUCKING KILLED HAN SOLO just to be able to say the plot was different. It was totally set up though.
Random thoughts: Lmao, the rebellion is broke as shit 30 years later. Can we get some backstory about that... what happened? They had a fucking fleet at Endor. When they blew that planet up I thought it was Coruscant and almost crapped my pants. Still would have preferred the galactic capital over losing Han though Kylo Ren is a fucking piece of shit Supreme Master Snoakes is the dumbest name ever
+ Show Spoiler +Killing Han wasn't deviating from Ep4's plot at all. Han played the mentor/father figure to girlchick I forget her name. He had the same role as Obi Wan.
But we all know the reason they killed Han was because Harrison Ford told them he only wanted to be in one movie. + Show Spoiler +i mean yeah lets be real we didnt really give that much of a shit about obi wan dying
but han, we actually really liked han
but yeah, i thought it mightve been external reasons, like harrison ford almost dying
also the bad guys never learn how to properly defend a giant planet destroying superweapon do they
+ Show Spoiler +sw spoil + Show Spoiler +While it was super obvious what was going to happen, at least from the moment he walked onto the bridge, it was definitely in keeping with the earlier films :p
It's pretty funny how identical the plot is to the original too.
Random notes: Two new leads seem really good it felt like JJ had a 60 page list of references/one liners he needed to include to play to the nostalgia crowd, was getting a bit much (imo) Did the slapstick comedy really well, a ton more actually funny jokes then most action film manage to fit in, and while some fell flat, most were really well timed/executed. (The originals had nowhere near this much visual/slapstick comedy did they?) Seemed pretty self aware that it was just episode 4 remade bigger. Black guy surprisingly good with a lightsaber for a non force user, I thought non force users couldn't even use them? Girl is op as fuck, holy shit. She seems stronger then luke was at the end of all his training, and she's had the force for like 18 hours lol They went full marvel with the arch villain being a giant in a chair, (I wonder if he'll still be huge then they actually meet him, or if his hologram just has ego issues.) Liked how much actually got done in the film. A lot of movies which know they'll be part of a 3 parter seem to not really have a good conclusion to the film, but this did a very good job of being a hype, self contained movie by itself. Definitely feels like they left it ready for the sequel, but it also definitely felt like it stands on it's own as a movie.
tldr: bit cheesy, not very original, but looked incredibly pretty and (amusingly) the new actors were mostly really good, while the old guard only really seem to be there for face value. Despite the scale of what was going on, the sets were kept very real and the fight scenes felt great too.
Nowhere near best movie of all time or anything for me, but definitely a solid and enjoyable watch.
+ Show Spoiler [Stir Wares] +No, they decidedly put more humor in it than E4. I think it just might be necessary for a movie these days as opposed to the ~40 year old E4.
Making any Star Wars film must be a daunting task. They have to live up to the originals and surpass the sour taste of the prequels. The safest thing to possibly do is borrow heavily from the originals, which 7 did. I'm still iffy on how I feel about it.
Last I read, the reason why lightsabers are notoriously difficult to wield is because the pseudo physics of the blade creates a gyroscope effect. When 1 wrong move means you've cut off a limb, most people are better off not screwing around with them. Why Finn is capable, I don't know.
There's a fan theory that Rey already had jedi training, since she is Luke's daughter, but after Ben defected Luke internalized his guilt into becoming a recluse and wiped the memory from her brain and left her on Jakku. Typical with most fictional memory wipes, there are cracks that can make the whole thing come crumbling down. + Show Spoiler [STAR WARS SPOILERS] ++ Show Spoiler [No seriously i talk about everything] +Its not out of this universe to suggest that Finn is some what force aware. He lucks his way into a few situations much like Rhea does. Finn's inability to remember family/taken too soon could easily play into that.
I also wouldn't be suprised if Rhea is Snokes' Daughter/Related in some way to Luke/Leia due to her capability with the force. The "Flashback" scene where she picks up Anakin's Saber shows where someone important to her/Luke (if this part of the scene is based on Luke now holding the saber) is stabbed by Kylo as well as when shes dropped off on Dakku with someone sound very much like Kylo Ren saying "Come on we don't need them anymore."
The part that really throws a whole wrench in the situation is when Kylo says as he's Force Mind Reading, where he wants the map and says the First Order has all of the map except one piece because of the empire is a bit eerie due to the fact that the empire would have been long gone by the time this happens. Not that it matters anyway (Kylo:"I see your dream, a blue ocean, with you an Island. I will know why this is important to you.") I'm sure once Snokes steals this from Kylo/Hyperbolic time chambers him into a badass will reveal they now know where Luke is and will rush to attempt to kill/interrupt her training.
All in all, the movie was pretty good. Better than okay, and much better than the prequels. I feel like JJ did every thing he needed to do to set up the new arc as well as leave plenty of people guessing. My only real complaint is that it's basically a shot for shot remake of A New Hope. + Show Spoiler +I mean I'm a bit disappointed it's not at the story level of some of the non-movie Star Wars we've seen. It's just a retelling of the Originals. If that's what it set out to be and what people wanted then sure I guess that's ok. Personally just think the Star Wars universe can be way cooler than that and yet we never really experience how good it can be in film.
The whole map thing was also weird. If they have every place that he isn't then why aren't they just searching the gap in the map? Did I just miss some plot point there. I'm also pretty sure Finn will turn out to have the force but even then it's all kind of weird. The guy has some serious mental break down when his buddy is shot and killed but later he has no issue mowing down tons of people. Like what? I thought he'd be more remorseful and try to "save people" instead of harming them so we'd see a more pacifist Light side Jedi while Ray will be the more aggressive one. + Show Spoiler +I agree that Finns mental breakdown was a little forced and inconsistent with the rest of the film. I don't think it was bad though. Or not any worse than how most movies portray that sort of thing, we weren't really expecting a deeply psychological film were we? It's an actiony space opera movie, people act according to ideals, not according to how they would actually act IRL.
As for the map, that they did explain. The Empire/First Order had all of the map but the part where Luke is (not useful), and the Rebels had the part of the map where Luke is, but without the rest of the map they couldn't figure out what part of the galaxy it was in.
Why the two pieces of the map got split up and one side had one and the other didn't, or why R2D2 shut himself down and then deus ex machina'd his way back to life with the correct map piece for no fucking reason wasn't really explained, but did it really need to be? It would have been preferential I think if they'd had Han get the map from the base while he was shutting the shields down, probably. But, this is a minor quibble. + Show Spoiler +True about Finn but I've just been watching Jessica Jones so the jarring differences in how it handles mental distress was a bit much. Should just take it for what it is, a genric coming of age fantasy story in space
I'm still not getting the map issue. R2D2 had the whole map except that piece and all the new toy bot did was slot in that map piece to show which planet he was on. If the First Order had what R2D2 had why then couldn't they just search that whole sector while trying to get the map piece?
Another thing, earlier guys were saying First Order were small but they built a freaking planet destroying planet. That takes a lot of time,money and man power. How haven't the republic/rebels heard of it? Idk the Light side always seems so massively incompetent in these movies. What happened in the 20 years for them to be worse off than they were during the Empire.
Overall it just felt like the movie was eluding to way more interesting stories that it wasn't telling and instead we got a copy of a movie that's been out for over 20 years. I don't really know how Star Wars fans can like it. Seemed more like a "sell new toys to a new generation and set up the real movies to come" than an actual movie on it's own. + Show Spoiler [Star Wars] +If that map was of the whole galaxy, then that missing spot would have been light years upon light years large with thousands upon thousands of planets. That would take the Empire a large amount of time to scour, let alone a smaller organization like the First Order. Remember how much trouble they had just combing Tatooine?
The Republic isn't prepared for it because they aren't focused on the First Order. It's trying to piece the galaxy back together. The Resistance knows it exists, they just lack intelligence on it. Keep in mind that the shield around the planet was strong enough that you had to hyperspace through it if you wanted to sneak in.
+ Show Spoiler +Well now The Republic is all dead. I get what you saying about why things happened but I can't help but feel that the good guys are just massively incompetent. If the First Order is as small as you mention then that begs the question on where they got the resources and man power to build this massive planet destroyer and how The Republic/Rebels didn't know about them buying stuff. I get not able able to see the actual construction due to the shielding extra but there's still all the aspects around it. Did the Empire just have all of this ready before it collapsed?
What is the actual timeline for this movie? Are these events 20 years after the last movie?
|
On December 19 2015 12:46 GhandiEAGLE wrote: Anyone else check out the new kh3 trailer? It looks so nice.... Dear god Linky?!??!?!?!?!
On December 19 2015 12:49 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On December 19 2015 12:46 GhandiEAGLE wrote: Anyone else check out the new kh3 trailer? It looks so nice.... Dear god No but I'm pretty hype for new Overwatch teaser. Before Star Wars in my theater, they played a trailer for Hearthstone, Overwatch, and Warcraft movie. I was giddy.
No Captain America trailer though. Pity, I would have liked to see it on the big screen.
|
On December 19 2015 21:00 Ketara wrote: Hmm.
I'm trying to figure out how to make pad ka pow, which is basically meat stir fried with holy basil.
And the basil taste is just not as strong as I want it to be.
But I think maybe instead of using more basil, I'm using too much oil and should try using less oil. It was preti oily this time.
HMMMMMMM.
Presence of basil taste depends not just on the other ingredients, but als on the temperature it's been in, how long, whether you use dried or fresh basil, how finely chopped the basil is. Afaik dried basil is actually more fragrant.
And when making a dish, make sure you add the herbs at the right moment. Adding basil should be one of the last things you do.
And if all that doesn't help, you can just add more basil You can never have too much basil in a dish tbh.
|
There will be a stream, but my 360 pad isn't compatible with PS4, so I'm gonna have to use a PS pad I guess, which I've never used.
|
+ Show Spoiler +On December 20 2015 03:03 jcarlsoniv wrote: There will be a stream, but my 360 pad isn't compatible with PS4, so I'm gonna have to use a PS pad I guess, which I've never used. I'm gonna have the same problem if I go to the monthly in TO.
On December 20 2015 00:52 AsmodeusXI wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2015 00:33 jcarlsoniv wrote:On December 19 2015 17:30 AsmodeusXI wrote: Someday I'll come back and open all these tags, but for now they must remain woefully closed.
Is anyone doing anything else?
I'm partitioning my Macbook for Windows so I can play FFXIV over the holidays.
Because why not Heading to a SG monthly out at Game Underground today. If there's a stream, I'll post here. I'm also in MA. I don't know how busy your holidays are butttttttt.... Also this needs to happen. Also a TO meetup needs to happen at some point.
Stream whar?
|
|
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
you can buy an adapter if you want to keep going back
|
|
|
|
|
|