Edit: FUCK YOU PAGE 879
The LiquidLegends Lounge - Page 879
| Forum Index > The Shopkeeper′s Inn |
|
Ketara
United States15065 Posts
Edit: FUCK YOU PAGE 879 | ||
|
killerdog
Denmark6522 Posts
Hopefully this doesn't spell the start of a relapse | ||
|
Gahlo
United States35174 Posts
On December 20 2015 23:19 Ketara wrote: I want somebody who doesn't regularly read the thread to check this page and get really, really confused. Edit: FUCK YOU PAGE 879 Get rekt m8. On December 20 2015 22:08 killerdog wrote: + Show Spoiler + Just because there's a plot reason for someone to be overpowered (however tenuous it is) doesn't stop someone from being a mary sue. Being trained by her father when she was 5 lets her control people perfectly within hours of her awakening, light saber duel a (slightly injured) fully trained jedi, and she happens to be a complete genius at technical work + she's a world champion level at parkour... That's like the definition of mary sue + Show Spoiler + You also have to keep in mind how large an impression Rey has in the Force where Snoak was able to discern her awakening from wherever the fuck he is. Also, according to Snoak, Ben isn't fully in control either. She's also been traipsing through ship graveyards since she was 5 doing scavanging work. Not hard to believe she picked stuff up over the years. The thing about Rey is that her strengths are very apparent while her flaws aren't, which doesn't allow for a lot of counterplay.(hue) On December 20 2015 22:25 Ketara wrote: + Show Spoiler + Don't forget successfully outflying two of the most maneuverable fighters in Star Wars canon in a half broken ship that two minutes ago she wasn't sure would get off the ground. + Show Spoiler + Yeah, in what was the fastest ship in the galaxy in E4 through a Super Star Destoryer she's probably spent months scavenging from. The Falcon may be a freighter, but it's crazy moded. Her calling it junk is a reflective on it being more than meets the eye and a callback to when Luke called it a bucket of bolts. | ||
|
Numy
South Africa35471 Posts
The reason some characters are able to do X/Y/Z isn't because of P/Q/T but because the story wants them to. edit: The force is generally just a "one size fits all" excuse or deus ex. The writers can do what they want with the story knowing that either themselves or others can just use "because force" as a justification for moments. It's not really "proper" justification since they purposely leave it completely vague in order to use it in this way. It's common thing in these kind of fantasy stories. The Belgariad for example uses "prophecy" as it's means for explaining any kind of plot weirdness going down. It works because that's the style of story doesn't need anything more. I always get a little annoyed when people try so hard to come up with these complex justifications when there really doesn't need to be one. People just need to accept it for what it is. | ||
|
iCanada
Canada10660 Posts
I use Excel and VBA all time to make my life easier, and have used Matlab and such in school. On December 21 2015 05:05 Numy wrote: I feel like you're making the mistake of trying to hard to justify silly moments of a story that are just there because they are cool. It's not a particularly deep movie or story that requires justification for everything it does. This kind of fantasy has never needed that nor even wants to do it. It's meant to be a genre that's deep in the "feel good" spectrum of fantasy. There's nothing wrong with this kind of fantasy, hell I was just reading The Belgariad which is one of the hallmarks of this kind of fantasy. It has fun moments that may not make a lot of sense if you think about them too hard but they aren't meant to be thought about too hard. The reason some characters are able to do X/Y/Z isn't because of P/Q/T but because the story wants them to. edit: The force is generally just a "one size fits all" excuse or deus ex. The writers can do what they want with the story knowing that either themselves or others can just use "because force" as a justification for moments. It's not really "proper" justification since they purposely leave it completely vague in order to use it in this way. It's common thing in these kind of fantasy stories. The Belgariad for example uses "prophecy" as it's means for explaining any kind of plot weirdness going down. It works because that's the style of story doesn't need anything more. I always get a little annoyed when people try so hard to come up with these complex justifications when there really doesn't need to be one. People just need to accept it for what it is. I thought about that too hard and shit dont make sense. Maybe I'm just I'm just overly logically, but I think even in the framework of a fantasy, if you are going to set out fantastical rules, then you should follow them imo. I think its lazy/bad writing to not set up a PQT for why characters can do XYZ. If you want it to be something fanatical and special, that is fine, but you cannot previously create fanatical rules and then break them, imo. It is kind of insulting to the audiences intelligence. | ||
|
Numy
South Africa35471 Posts
Let me try put it another way by using The Belgariad(Just coz it's fresh lol). So the story is your classic good vs evil coming of age. The story is always going to be about the good guys winning and Garion living happily ever after. That the reader knows from almost the beginning. So now the author has the problem of how does he still make the story interesting enough for the reader to want to keep on reading while knowing the outcome. This isn't an easy task to do and requires decent level of writing. Oh another example would be Lord of the Rings. Again we know what the ending is going to be because it's just that kind of fantasy story but the journey and the moments it has are still interesting enough to read. It's not lazy/bad writing to not have these rules perfectly defined. Some stories will just be slowed down by that while not requiring it. None of these stories set out fixed rules for their universe(Well The Belgariad kind of does but it sticks to it while using prophecy to explain all the uncanny timing). So when you say they break the rules they set I think that's wrong. They merely break what you thought were the implied rules which aren't the case. | ||
|
iCanada
Canada10660 Posts
On December 21 2015 05:52 Numy wrote: Star Wars(the movies at least) never sets up rules. They set up vague concepts that they use to make cool moments. If you don't like that then it's jut not the genre of fantasy you like. I wouldn't call it lazy/bad writing. It's more about writing for "moments" than writing for something deeper. Requiring a consistent and known rules takes a vast amount of time to set up well while still keeping the audience interested. It works for certain kinds of story and not for others. In Star Wars case the majority of the audience doesn't particularly care about universal consistent rules but instead are there for the cool moments so the writing tries to maximize this. Doing that well is good writing, it may not be the kind of writing you enjoy but calling it bad/lazy just isn't fair. It still take skill to make a good story while not having constraints on the world. I agree, thats not bad / lazy, but setting up rules and then breaking them is. Same with LotR, all magical things in that world are not well explained, but one is given the impression that Gandalf is pretty bad ass. I think that is good writing. But that is still giving a PQT for why Gandalf can do XYZ. Frodo on the other hand doesn't just realize he is the mightiest warrior in the world, he is still but a hobbit even after a ton of training and such from the rest of his group of successful, well established leaders of... well their races I guess. He's what he is, a hobbit. An impressive / special hobbit who ends up doing great things, but he isn't automatically such without a backstory. I think a lot of times it ends up kind of silly when a character just like snaps their fingers one day and realizes they are suddenly the best at absolutely everything ever despite not really having a history, especially when you have been following them since the start of a story. I think that is bad / lazy writing. I honestly haven't been following the star wars conversation, my tickets are for Tuesday; so I am not sure where this falls with respect to that. | ||
|
killerdog
Denmark6522 Posts
Also, cultural history lesson for some of you guys | ||
|
Seuss
United States10536 Posts
It's not flawless, but I'm pretty sure if I saw the original films today for the first time I wouldn't view them the same way as I do since they're so indelibly imprinted on me. | ||
|
Gahlo
United States35174 Posts
On December 21 2015 07:01 Seuss wrote: Star Wars was awesome y'all are haters. It's not flawless, but I'm pretty sure if I saw the original films today for the first time I wouldn't view them the same way as I do since they're so indelibly imprinted on me. I'd actually go as far to say it's better than E4. | ||
|
killerdog
Denmark6522 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + | ||
|
Frolossus
United States4779 Posts
On December 21 2015 05:43 iCanada wrote: What would the learning curve on picking up C/C++ and Java in my spare time be like? Which should I start with? I use Excel and VBA all time to make my life easier, and have used Matlab and such in school. I thought about that too hard and shit dont make sense. Maybe I'm just I'm just overly logically, but I think even in the framework of a fantasy, if you are going to set out fantastical rules, then you should follow them imo. I think its lazy/bad writing to not set up a PQT for why characters can do XYZ. If you want it to be something fanatical and special, that is fine, but you cannot previously create fanatical rules and then break them, imo. It is kind of insulting to the audiences intelligence. if you have no programming experience IMO start with java. the benefit of doing this is that you don't have to worry much about pointers and memory management which java usually handles on it's own. basic syntax for control structures and variables is very similar if not the same in most cases. | ||
|
ketchup
14521 Posts
On December 21 2015 08:35 killerdog wrote: So Homestorycup just redefined what it means to have an awards ceremony + Show Spoiler + Koreans know how to karaoke | ||
|
Cixah
United States11285 Posts
On December 21 2015 08:35 killerdog wrote: So Homestorycup just redefined what it means to have an awards ceremony + Show Spoiler + This is the best. I've never laughed this hard in my life. | ||
|
Parnage
United States7414 Posts
On December 21 2015 08:24 Gahlo wrote: I'd actually go as far to say it's better than E4. You are dead to me. | ||
|
wei2coolman
United States60033 Posts
On December 21 2015 05:05 Numy wrote: I feel like you're making the mistake of trying to hard to justify silly moments of a story that are just there because they are cool. It's not a particularly deep movie or story that requires justification for everything it does. This kind of fantasy has never needed that nor even wants to do it. It's meant to be a genre that's deep in the "feel good" spectrum of fantasy. There's nothing wrong with this kind of fantasy, hell I was just reading The Belgariad which is one of the hallmarks of this kind of fantasy. It has fun moments that may not make a lot of sense if you think about them too hard but they aren't meant to be thought about too hard. The reason some characters are able to do X/Y/Z isn't because of P/Q/T but because the story wants them to. edit: The force is generally just a "one size fits all" excuse or deus ex. The writers can do what they want with the story knowing that either themselves or others can just use "because force" as a justification for moments. It's not really "proper" justification since they purposely leave it completely vague in order to use it in this way. It's common thing in these kind of fantasy stories. The Belgariad for example uses "prophecy" as it's means for explaining any kind of plot weirdness going down. It works because that's the style of story doesn't need anything more. I always get a little annoyed when people try so hard to come up with these complex justifications when there really doesn't need to be one. People just need to accept it for what it is. the problem with the star wars franchise was that it wasn't entirely clear whether or not "cuz force" was a legitimate claim, or it was faith based. What we do know is that "force" has impact when a practitioner (jedi/sith) uses it, but as far as claim of "why" something happened, the viewer is sort of left clueless. | ||
|
Frudgey
Canada3367 Posts
Honestly I don't think it's that hard to be better than episode 4. Like, Mad Max is better than episode 4, in my opinion. Also I think the Dark Knight is better than any of the Star Wars movies! | ||
|
Eppa!
Sweden4641 Posts
| ||
|
ticklishmusic
United States15977 Posts
On December 21 2015 08:35 killerdog wrote: So Homestorycup just redefined what it means to have an awards ceremony + Show Spoiler + LET IT GOOOOOO LET IT GOOOO | ||
|
GhandiEAGLE
United States20754 Posts
Objectively I'd say it's far better, in terms of technical direction and especially acting talent. Whether it's more well-received or liked more is a different matter, considering the wealth of expectations the movie has inherited. | ||
| ||