• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
TeamLiquid Liquipedia LiquidDota LiquidLegends
EST 07:05
CET 13:05
KST 21:05
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
DH Last Chance: RO16 Group C Preview8[ASTL2] Power Rank23DH Last Chance: RO16 Group B Preview11DH Last Chance: RO16 Group A Preview12TL.net is recruiting SC2 writers29
Community News
DH Last Chance: RO8 Bracket Set24ESL Open #53: Zest doubles, MaNa wins EU13Ryung joins Team GP13Lilbow returns to SC2 joins Archangel Gaming88ESL Open #52: Zoun, HeroMarine, Zest win1
StarCraft 2
General
2021 GSL Super Tournament I (Qualifiers) The StarCraft Bible TL.net is recruiting SC2 writers ESL Open #53: Zest doubles, MaNa wins EU Star Nation - a Starcraft documentary
Tourneys
ITaX Ultimate Battles#3 - TY vs Rogue (BO.11) ITaX Trovo Series#12 - PartinG, Armani, Cure &Zoun ITaX Trovo Weekly#19 - Solar, Dream, Zest & Hurric [DH Masters 2020] Last Chance 2021 2021 NA Apprentice
Strategy
[G] PvZ Cheese: PartinG's "Adios Amigo" Build HuShang Tutorials Select Larvae + Morph unit Rapidfire [D] My Interpretation of Standard TvP
Custom Maps
Re-created map Wasteland [Q] BO Practice Custom Map Simple Questions/Answers [A] The Beginning (Populous 3 remake)
External Content
Mutation #248 Boom Town New edition of the Dank Templars SC2 newsletter! Mutation #247 Perfect Storm Welcome to the External Content forum
Brood War
General
[ASTL2] Power Rank Rus_Brain - great interview! (ENG SUB) Grant Davies leaves Blizzard BGH auto balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ StarCraft Human 'N' AI League
Tourneys
[ASTL2] Week 1 Day 2 Jeez Weekly 2020 [ASTL2] Week 1 Day 1 Coach Pupil League Season 6 (CPL 6)
Strategy
FlaSh's TvP Gas FE into 3 Tank Pressure [subbed] What is this new pvt style with no arbiters? PvP Bonyth style 2 gate 3 zealot 21 gas guide Valkyrie dmg formula?
Other Games
Heroes of the Storm
HotS: WP and Funny Moments [HotS] NA Stands Supreme
General Games
Genshin Impact - Coop RPG Cyberpunk 2077 Path of Exile Nintendo Switch Thread FF7 remake for PS4 announced
TL Mafia
[M][T] Personality Mafia: Mini Edition TL Mafia Plays: Diplomacy Personality Mini Mafia: Vote Thread TL Mafia Community Thread British Empire Mini Mafia II
Hearthstone
Is Hearthstone Gambling?
LoL General
LoL Tournaments
LoL Strategy
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Awesome Games Done Quick 2021! The Big Programming Thread Bitcoin discussion thread Dating: How's your luck?
Fan Clubs
The TY Fan Club Stats Fan Club The BoxeR Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
[Manga] One Piece [SCIFI Series] The Expanse Movie Discussion! Korean Music Discussion Anime Discussion Thread
Sports
2020 - 2021 Football Thread 2020 NFL and College Football Corona Season NBA Season 2019-2020 NHL 19-20: Hop Off my Kakko Major League Baseball 2015
Tech Support
Simple Questions Simple Answers PC for Premiere Pro and After Effects Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts Happy Birthday R1CH!
Blogs
TrapGod
EheroSC2
How Do We Improve Su…
waywardstrategy
My iPhone game
GroT
Trekkertent Saor DCF 4-season …
Tak3r
Cheeseadelphia 11 Trav…
TheRealNanMan
BattleReports.com to …
Psyonic_Reaver
Shameless self promotion/opin…
WindOw
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 1098 users

Terran expansion return of investment

Forum Index > StarCraft 2 Strategy
Post a Reply
Nilaus
Profile Joined March 2010
Denmark159 Posts
April 16 2010 13:47 GMT
#1
Introduction:
Sometimes in a game I wonder if I can afford to make an expansion. It costs the initial investment and it takes some time after it is completed before it returns sufficient minerals to pay for itself.

This can also be presented as "if the expansion can survive for X seconds I will be in a better position by expanding" (hidden expansion). This same argument can be flipped around to "if the game is finished before X seconds then I shouldn't expand" (all-in one base strategy).

So I decided to calculate it for myself and present the findings.

Some assumptions:
* No Maynard transfer (this calculation is mostly for the 3rd base where Maynarding is not always feasible)
* MULE resturns 255 min per trip (between 6 and 7 returns as it depends on the mineral patch layout)
* MULE harvested minerals are added gradually over its entire duration
* All time figures are in game time
* SCV harvesting speed 1 min / game sec
* The building SCV starts mining as soon as the CC is done
* Linear increase in harvesting as a function of the number of SCVs

I tested 2 different scenarios; without Orbital Command and with Orbital Command.

Scenario 1: Without Orbital Command:
Production: Total mineral cost, Total time, Total minerals harvested
Command Center: 400min, 100sec, 0min
+SCV: 450min, 117sec, 17min
+SCV: 500min, 134sec, 51min
+SCV: 550min, 151sec, 102min
+SCV: 600min, 168sec, 170min
+SCV: 650min, 185sec, 255min
+SCV: 700min, 202sec, 357min
+SCV: 750min, 219sec, 476min
+SCV: 800min, 236sec, 612min
+SCV: 850min, 253sec, 765min
+SCV: 900min, 270sec, 935min
+SCV: 950min, 287sec, 1122min

Scenario 2: With Orbital Command:
(use MULE whenever available):
Production: Total mineral cost, Total time, Total minerals harvested
Command Center: 400min, 100sec, 0min
+Orbital Command: 550min, 135sec, 35min
+SCV: 600min, 152sec, 103min
+SCV: 650min, 169sec, 188min
+SCV: 700min, 186sec, 290min
+SCV: 750min, 203sec, 409min
+SCV: 800min, 220sec, 545min
+SCV: 850min, 237sec, 698min
+SCV: 900min, 254sec, 868min
+SCV: 950min, 271sec, 1055min
+SCV: 1000min, 288sec, 1259min

Conclusion:
In both cases it takes about the same time for both scenarios to return the investment, which is about 260sec in game time, corresponding to 3min 7sec in real time.

It may seem odd that the Orbital Command isn't favourable, but this is primarily due to the higher investment cost. The Orbital Command is returning minerals at a much higher rate, so as usual it is a great idea to build it immediately as it doesn't affect the payback time.

TL;DR: Don't build an expansion if you can't keep it for 3 min (real time)


michiko
Profile Joined April 2010
United States75 Posts
April 16 2010 14:10 GMT
#2
*claps* *standing ovation*
shockwave.xpow
Profile Joined March 2010
31 Posts
April 16 2010 14:18 GMT
#3
Bear in mind that a CC also gives supply, so its effective cost includes both the opportunity cost of the SCV tied up building it minus the cost of supply that it gives.
JTPROG
Profile Blog Joined March 2010
United States254 Posts
April 16 2010 14:20 GMT
#4
100 out of 10 times you are going to maynard, soooooo....
inflowgaming.net
ZaaaaaM
Profile Joined March 2010
Netherlands1739 Posts
April 16 2010 14:21 GMT
#5
Thnx for the work.
Interesting but also useless. I mean, this way of thinking cant be used when playing a match.
no dude, the question
Zoltan
Profile Blog Joined March 2010
United States656 Posts
April 16 2010 14:22 GMT
#6
On April 16 2010 23:20 JTPROG wrote:
100 out of 10 times you are going to maynard, soooooo....


Just not true- On scrapyard for example its not uncommon to take gold minerals, the island minerals, or one of the blocked off minerals, before your "natural" (because its so damn hard to defend). Its hard to maynard to the islands...
'HOW LONG HAVE THOSE REAPERS BEEN KILLING MY PROBES?!?!
Plexa
Profile Blog Joined October 2005
Aotearoa38209 Posts
April 16 2010 14:25 GMT
#7
You can at least take 5 workers to the island via loading them into the CC
Administrator~ Spirit will set you free ~
Drunken.Jedi
Profile Joined June 2009
Germany426 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-04-16 14:33:44
April 16 2010 14:32 GMT
#8
The problem with those calculations is that they ignore opportunity cost. You do not at all break even after 3 minutes because instead of building the expansion, you could have invested your minerals otherwise, for instance in a bigger army or additional tech, which can either save you resources (by protecting your economy from attacks/harrassment) or cost your opponent resources (either by attacking/harrassing him or by scaring him into investing more resources into defense and less into his economy).

However, the opportunity cost varies greatly based on the current situation and is very difficult to calculate, thus it is unfortunately impossible to state in simple terms how long an expansion needs to break even. However, thanks to your calculations, we now at least know that it's always more than 3 minutes real time if your assumptions are fulfilled.
caution.slip
Profile Blog Joined June 2007
United States772 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-04-16 14:43:41
April 16 2010 14:42 GMT
#9
Nice calculations, but shouldn't all the mineral numbers be moved back a step?

Command Center: 400min, 100sec, 0min
+SCV: 450min, 117sec, 17min


You are assuming here that the SCV can mine while it's still building. Instead it should be


Scenario 1
+SCV: 1000min, 288sec, 935min
...
Scenario 2
+SCV: 1000min, 288sec, 1055min


also noting when you drop the mule would be a nice addition. Good work nevertheless.
Live, laugh, love
Nilaus
Profile Joined March 2010
Denmark159 Posts
April 16 2010 14:54 GMT
#10
On April 16 2010 23:20 JTPROG wrote:
100 out of 10 times you are going to maynard, soooooo....


I agree that this is always the case for the natural and usually the third. It is not a hard and fast rule, but more like something I've thought about.

The reason for me not to include it is that it is impossible to model Maynarding as it depends on the saturation, distance and number of SCVs transferred, so it will be impossible to get some good benchmark numbers. Island expansions cannot easily transferred to either.

Regarding the whole idea of Maynarding across the map, then I've just seen way too many replays (SC1+2) of people giving away free workers and the location of their hidden expansion by transferring workers right through a camping army.
Nilaus
Profile Joined March 2010
Denmark159 Posts
April 16 2010 14:56 GMT
#11
On April 16 2010 23:42 caution.slip wrote:
You are assuming here that the SCV can mine while it's still building. Instead it should be


This is the SCV building the CC that is mining during the construction of the first SCV.
Markwerf
Profile Joined March 2010
Netherlands3723 Posts
April 16 2010 16:22 GMT
#12
Well there are too many things simplified or neglected here to give a usefull number.

First of all the scv building it is not mining so thats a oppurtunity cost of 100 minerals if you are not saturated. If you are this oppurtunity cost lowers.

Second point is that the scv provides 11 supply. A depot gives 7 supply and costs 100 minerals + a oppurtunity cost of 35 minerals (if not saturated).

Combining points 1 and 2 you will get a real cost of 400 + 100 - 11/7 * 135 = 288
This will be slightly lower when you are saturated as the opportunity cost decreases.

Also maynarding has to be included in the time as it's 99% of the case happening.
Mining speed goes up linear up till 16 mineral workers per base and then tops with max speed at 24, with 20 minerals workers being already about 95% of max mineral mining on one base.
Given that by the time a expo finishes your mineral workers are virtually always above 16 maynarding matters alot as extra workers on the expo are way more efficient then extra workers on your main.
To calculate this you need to know the exact efficiency decrease of workers more then 16. The maynarding time can probably just be averaged for 12 secs or so given all maps.

Anyway getting a more exact payback time for a CC isnt too difficult to calculate with some extra data, the number itself will still be relatively useless as the oppurtunity cost of not making other stuff in the meantime (tech, units, etc.) is very hard to determine and gamespecific. In a situation where it's useless to attack and safe to expand this oppurtunity cost is 0 (like when he invested alot in static defense) in any other situation it's not 0 though and extremely hard to determine.

codewarrior
Profile Joined April 2010
United States52 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-05-01 23:20:18
May 01 2010 23:15 GMT
#13
Should I upgrade to an OC before I lift off, or should I use the CC to carry SCVs to my island expansion? I'll try to compare the two.

Assumptions:

80 second travel time. OC saves its starting energy and lands at the expansion with 100 energy, drops two mules upon landing.
SCVs above saturation only harvest 10% as much.
Transferred SCVs have an opportunity cost of 0.1 minerals/second while in transit.
A MULE is equal to three SCVs in minerals/second.

Blue Minerals
+ Show Spoiler +

Scenario 1: Carry 5 SCVs:
Production: Total mineral cost, Total time, Total minerals harvested
Carry 5 SCVs for 80 seconds: 40min
Command Center: 440min, 180sec, 0min
+Orbital Command: 590min, 215sec, 175min,
+SCV: 640min, 232sec, 311min
+SCV: 690min, 249sec, 464min
+SCV: 740min, 266sec, 634min
Breaks even at 276sec
+SCV: 790min, 283sec, 821min
+SCV: 840min, 300sec, 1025min
Covers the production cost of transferred SCVs at 305sec
+SCV: 890min, 317sec, 1246min
+SCV: 940min, 334sec, 1484min


In this scenario, the last 2 SCVs we load up will bring us under saturation, so they have a full carrying cost of 1min/sec each.
Scenario 2: Carry 10 SCVs:
Production: Total mineral cost, Total time, Total minerals harvested
Carry 10 SCVs for 80 seconds: 244min
Command Center: 644min, 180sec, 0min
+Orbital Command: 794min, 215sec, 350min,
+SCV: 844min, 232sec, 571min
+SCV: 894min, 249sec, 809min
Breaks even at 255sec
+SCV: 944min, 266sec, 1064min
+SCV: 994min, 283sec, 1336min
Covers the production cost of transferred SCVs at 293sec
+SCV: 1044min, 300sec, 1625min
+SCV: 1094min, 317sec, 1931min
Mineral line is saturated


Scenario 3: Flying Orbital Command:
Production: Total mineral cost, Total time, Total minerals harvested
Command Center: 400min, 100sec, 0min
+Orbital Command: 550min, 135sec, 0min
Land at 215sec
+SCV: 600min, 232sec, 102min
+SCV: 650min, 249sec, 221min
+SCV: 700min, 266sec, 357min
+SCV: 750min, 283sec, 510min
+SCV: 800min, 300sec, 680min
Extra MULE dies at 305sec
+SCV: 850min, 317sec, 816min
Breaks even at 321sec
+SCV: 900min, 334sec, 969min

Gold minerals:
+ Show Spoiler +

Assume that energy from other OCs will be used the same way each time.

Scenario 1: Carry 5 SCVs:
Production: Total mineral cost, Total time, Total minerals harvested
Carry 5 SCVs for 80 seconds: 40min
Command Center: 440min, 180sec, 0min
+Orbital Command: 590min, 215sec, 245min,
+SCV: 640min, 232sec, 435min
+SCV: 690min, 249sec, 650min
Breaks even at 252sec
+SCV: 740min, 266sec, 888min
Covers the production cost of transferred SCVs at 274sec
+SCV: 790min, 283sec, 1149min
+SCV: 840min, 300sec, 1435min
+SCV: 890min, 317sec, 1744min
+SCV: 940min, 334sec, 2078min


In this scenario, the last 2 SCVs we load up will bring us under saturation, so they have a full carrying cost of 1min/sec each.
Scenario 2: Carry 10 SCVs:
Production: Total mineral cost, Total time, Total minerals harvested
Carry 10 SCVs for 80 seconds: 244min
Command Center: 644min, 180sec, 0min
+Orbital Command: 794min, 215sec, 490min,
+SCV: 844min, 232sec, 799min
Breaks even at 235sec
+SCV: 894min, 249sec, 1133min
Covers the production cost of transferred SCVs at 266sec
+SCV: 944min, 266sec, 1490min
Mineral line is saturated
+SCV: 994min, 283sec, 1849min
+SCV: 1044min, 300sec, 2211min
+SCV: 1094min, 317sec, 2575min



Scenario 3: Flying Orbital Command:
Production: Total mineral cost, Total time, Total minerals harvested
Command Center: 400min, 100sec, 0min
+Orbital Command: 550min, 135sec, 0min
Land at 215sec
+SCV: 600min, 232sec, 143min
+SCV: 650min, 249sec, 309min
+SCV: 700min, 266sec, 500min
+SCV: 750min, 283sec, 714min
Breaks even at 288sec
+SCV: 800min, 300sec, 952min
Extra MULE dies at 305sec
+SCV: 850min, 317sec, 1142min
+SCV: 900min, 334sec, 1357min


After 215 game seconds, the CCs that loaded up SCVs are returning more minerals than the OC, constantly. Before that, the OC can only return more minerals (in the short term) by using a MULE at an established base before it lifts off. The numbers look even worse for the OC when gold minerals are considered. Also, 80 seconds of flying time is fairly long, and shorter times will favor the CC because less energy can regenerate.

Supply depot construction and MULE usage by older OCs should all be constant across these scenarios. Because SCV production may resume at an older base in order bring the mineral line back over saturation, I've marked when a CC covers the cost of producing the SCVs it carried.
Markwerf
Profile Joined March 2010
Netherlands3723 Posts
May 01 2010 23:21 GMT
#14
When you create a OC before flying, you use it just before you lift off offcourse. You don't fly and then drop the mule as you will be stockpiling energy.
Offcourse that whole calculation is totally reliant on how being able to mine at your existing base(s) compares to mining at the expansion which in your assumptions is the 'SCV above saturation only harvest 10% as much'. Considering there is nothing to base this assumption on or whatsoever the whole analysis is a bit useless.

imBLIND
Profile Blog Joined December 2006
United States2388 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-05-02 01:12:57
May 02 2010 00:57 GMT
#15
So according to this, it takes about 4 minutes game time to break even with a 1base eco after expanding. If this is true, than it takes about just as long to set up expansions as it does in bw (i think?). If blizz made timing pushes and massing stronger and faster, then they should make expanding just as fast. Time to file new balance proposal hahah

Edit: Never mind...making cc/nex/hatch build times go down would not make timing pushes weaker by enough...
im deaf
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
OlimoLeague
11:00
Week 216
ByuN vs GogojOeyLIVE!
Liquid`Crank 1299
ALGaming 623
Maynarde424
Liquipedia
AfreecaTV Starcraft Tea…
10:00
Round-robin Day 2/8
Snow vs SoulkeyLIVE!
JyJ vs Flash
BeSt vs Action
Shuttle vs free
Afreeca ASL 2269
DeathfateSCR 72
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
Liquid`Crank 1299
DeMusliM 832
Maynarde 424
PartinGtheBigBoy 368
Harstem 157
SortOf 109
StarCraft: Brood War
GuemChi 10354
Sea 6131
Bisu 3596
Calm 1938
Horang2 1818
ZerO 1478
Shuttle 1283
EffOrt 848
Flash 821
Larva 499
[ Show more ]
BeSt 438
Stork 235
Sea.KH 182
Pusan 174
firebathero 111
Rush 84
Zeus 81
hero 81
Soma 73
actioN 68
MisO 63
PianO 56
Noble 51
Snow 47
Soulkey 40
yabsab 28
Sharp 27
sorry 22
sSak 21
Free 19
BrAvO 12
Heroes of the Storm
crisheroes556
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
pimpcsgo3021
SPUNJ633
Other Games
nookyyy 367
Livibee301
OGKoka 149
wKairi39
AxAlicia13
Organizations
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
ESL CS:GO2086
StarCraft 2
ESL.tv422
OGamingTV SC2 235
SC2 Vod Archives96
Blizzard YouTube
[ Show 19 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• D4rkn0ob1k 14
• vivid_sc 7
• undefetable07
• hirohiro 2
• Genesis Gaming
• AlphaB_SC2
• Alpha X_
• aXEnki
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamez Trovo
• Laughngamez YouTube
• Matiz_pl
• Tree_Stump
SC2: Legacy of the Void
• KarlJayG
• PSISTORM Gaming
StarCraft: Brood War
• sscaitournament2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
Upcoming Events
WardiTV 2021
4h 55m
Alpha Pro Series
19h 55m
RagnaroK vs ByuN
OSC
20h 55m
WardiTV 2021
22h 55m
Genesis Legends Cup
1d 5h
Bly vs MaxPax
Cham vs souL
Vanya vs MaxPax
Bly vs souL
Bly vs Vanya
Cham vs MaxPax
Bly vs Cham
souL vs Vanya
Shinhan Tank Proleague
1d 7h
Alpha X Event
1d 18h
Nice vs Cyan
RagnaroK vs TBD
Dream vs TBD
Zoun vs TBD
Patience vs TBD
OSC
2 days
WardiTV 2021
2 days
WardiTV 2021
2 days
[ Show More ]
Genesis Legends Cup
3 days
SKillous vs MilkiCow
ArT vs SouLeer
SortOf vs MilkiCow
SouLeer vs SKillous
ArT vs MilkiCow
SortOf vs SKillous
ArT vs SKillous
SortOf vs SouLeer
Shinhan Tank Proleague
3 days
PSISTORM Gaming Misc
3 days
ITaX Trovo Weekly
3 days
Solar vs Hurricane
Dream vs Zest
WardiTV 2021
3 days
PSISTORM Gaming Misc
4 days
Cheesadelphia
4 days
The Three-Winged Angel
4 days
Alpha X Junior Champion…
4 days
ITaX Trovo Series
4 days
PartinG vs Armani
Cure vs Zoun
AfreecaTV Starcraft Tea…
4 days
Cheesadelphia
5 days
The Three-Winged Angel
5 days
La Espira
5 days
ESL Pro Tour
5 days
ITaX Ultimate Battle
6 days
TY vs Rogue
The Three-Winged Angel
6 days
ESL Pro Tour
6 days
ESL Pro Tour
6 days
AfreecaTV Starcraft Tea…
6 days
OlimoLeague
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

2020 KCM Challenge Season 4
DH Masters: Last Chance 2021
NGS Storm Division S2 Qual. 2
IEM Global Challenge

Ongoing

Ultimate Battle
Shinhan Tank Proleague S4
BWCL Season 52
ASTL Season 2
BW Jeez weekly GF 2020
KCM Race Survival 2020 Season 4
NGS Storm Division S2 Quals
Community Clash League S1

Upcoming

Rogue City Rumble
Polish Starcraft League 3
IEM Katowice 2021
2021 AfreecaTV GSL Super Tournament 1
Cheeseadelphia Winter
WardiTV 2021
Masters Clash Champ. 2021
NGS Storm Division S2 Qual. 4
MCC 2021 Qualifier 1
MCC 2021 Qualifiers
NGS Storm Division S2 Qual. 3
ESL Pro League Season 13
IEM Katowice 2021
BLAST Premier Spring Groups
DreamHack Open Jan 2021
cs_summit 7
BLAST Premier Global Final
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2021 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.