|
Valhalla18444 Posts
Close but No Cigar:
BackHo: BackHo is fucking BAD. The only existing argument for BackHo getting a Power Rank spot seems to be "how he gets results doesn't matter, simply that he gets results". That's a nice thought, and maybe if BackHo could manage to win more games than he loses I'd be more willing to look past his glaring lack of skill.
Sea: Sea's in the OSL Round of 16, crushing Pure to get there. Pretty good! He's got a creampuff Survivor group, too. However, history has a nasty tendency to repeat itself. Let's all pray for a semifinal.
Much: Much isn't playing well. I'm sure someone will come in here and argue that he beat down FirebatHero, the guy who loses to every Protoss ever, and somehow that's justification for him to be named one of the ten best players of the day. Not even close.
More to come as things are addressed in the thread!
|
United States42568 Posts
Happy with the first 8, although I'd probably shuffle Kal and BeSt up a tad and Luxury and Leta down a little. But there's not enough between the four of them for it to really make a difference. As for the final 2, we've talked that one to death already so I don't see the need to bring that argument here. But if both of them fail to shine I'll be sure to remind you of your confidence in them.
|
Forgg!!!!
Flash vs backho on wuthering heights was like a tvp textbook on its own imba flash
|
Canada7170 Posts
Thanks again for doing this Steve. Yes you're gonna get a lot of bitching for 9-10, but your reasoning is fine, and I don't have anything to refute, really.
I think there's enough reason to bump Kal off the list entirely, but I'm not about to go back and figure out exactly which dates this PR covers.
Cheers!
|
i think sea should've been #1 again 
EDIT: *ANGSTY POST ABOUT WHY FLASH SHOULD BE ABOVE JAEDONG!~!!111*
|
nice, i like the power rank just fine. I think iris does deserve that spot, as he's consistent and sometimes has monstrous play
|
I agree with the powerrank fully
|
I love you fakesteve for bringing midas back ^^
|
yay new pr
I'll definately have to check out Iris' games now that you mentioned them. I would love for Iris to climb the PR and help win me fantasy MSL
|
United States42568 Posts
Actually you're right about Kal. But I'd probably go Leta, BeSt, Luxury. It's a tricky one. We know BeSt is good and Luxury is good and we know that BeSt just beat Luxury in a close series. But equally Leta has shown far better results than either recently. It just seems like #5 is a bit high for luxury and #7 is a bit low for BeSt but there's so little in it that it's tricky.
|
huh, I didn't think iris was doing so well, although I haven't seen his recent games.
midas is 1-2 this month, I don't think he deserves the rank (and he wasn't chosen to be SKT's ace in the playoffs). I don't know who does, however.
|
A fine rank , but why Midas in top 10 i don't recall him playing at all last month or he just lost his last PL games and fail to qualify for 1 of the leagues as i can remember ??? I would rather have Mind just by the fact that he stomped JangBI in WCG and he is seeded and yet to qualify for the leagues .
|
Midas has been doing well all season.
|
i completely agree with the first 7, but i think 8-10 should go as such:
8 - Jangbi: still the best PvT around and after tieing (and then beating flash) he's showing no sign of remorse 9 - Canata: the king of TvT is certainly still around. some brilliant games at the end of this proleague season should land him this spot. 10 - EffOrt: an up and coming zerg that has been winning some nice games against Kal, FBH, etc.
|
OK HANG ON THIS IS IMPOSSIBLE
steve you love my fav player julyzerg, you share a birthday with me, you have an iron maiden pic in your profile which is my fav band and best of all time period. OK im paying for you to get the surgery we are getting married.
oh nice power rank btw
|
On August 07 2008 15:10 ShinyGerbil wrote: i completely agree with the first 7, but i think 8-10 should go as such:
8 - Jangbi: still the best PvT around and after tieing (and then beating flash) he's showing no sign of remorse 9 - Canata: the king of TvT is certainly still around. some brilliant games at the end of this proleague season should land him this spot. 10 - EffOrt: an up and coming zerg that has been winning some nice games against Kal, FBH, etc.
JangBI got himself raped by Mind in WCG not the best starcraft i've seen , but shows that Mind will be comeing in here pretty soon i would argue next month . Canata sucks all together losing to Justin in OSL offlines .
I would like to see more of Effort he is a promising zerg beating Kal in ZvP in Bo3 is not an easy task .
|
Its scary how much I...disagree with everything on this power rank. The only placements I can remotely agree with are Kal, Jaedong, and FORGG. Flash is playing too bad for 3, Julys zvt is too untested for 4, Leta has done nothing but proleague, and despite the good games, I doubt he deserves six, best took a massive drop despite his only failings to be a in a pvz that we all knew he was weak in, against july who we all knew was strong in that particular match up to an absurd degree, and Midas and Iris, while playing good- more midas than Iris- I'm not entirely convinced are quite the right choices. Though, the very bottom of the power rank hardly concerns me, so I suppose I'll let them be, but in general just...wow, I cant believe how disagree able this power rank is. It's so outrageous, I'm not even going to debate it any further.
Edit: You know what, under further consideration [its 2:30 and yes I am lazy enough not to rewrite my entire post, but just leave it there] I don't disagree with everything. There are a lot of people teetering on worthiness of the bottom of the power rank, and I suppose Iris/Midas are just as justifiable as anyone else who has had a good run. Likewise, despite the fact that I think Flash should be lower-ordinarily, there is simply no one to fill in the gap, so he stays due to the fact that we have had a slow month, and nothing can prove otherwise definitively. Leta's games have been amazing though, but I still disagree with such a high placement, and Best's being so low [despite my hatred of him] I also disagree with the lux/july order [despite my lover of July], but hey. So no, not that bad of a power rank, wacky but...well we have had a slow inconsistent month, what can be said.
|
|
good job on what i suspect was a pretty tough month to evaluate
|
On August 07 2008 15:24 Dazed_Spy wrote: Its scary how much I...disagree with everything on this power rank.
Give us your power rank then douchebag.
Edit: Your are no longer a douchebag since ur edit
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 07 2008 15:24 Dazed_Spy wrote: Its scary how much I...disagree with everything on this power rank. The only placements I can remotely agree with are Kal, Jaedong, and FORGG. Flash is playing too bad for 3, Julys zvt is too untested for 4, Leta has done nothing but proleague, and despite the good games, I doubt he deserves six, best took a massive drop despite his only failings to be a in a pvz that we all knew he was weak in, against july who we all knew was strong in that particular match up to an absurd degree, and Midas and Iris, while playing good- more midas than Iris- I'm not entirely convinced are quite the right choices. Though, the very bottom of the power rank hardly concerns me, so I suppose I'll let them be, but in general just...wow, I cant believe how disagree able this power rank is. It's so outrageous, I'm not even going to debate it any further.
Edit: You know what, under further consideration [its 2:30 and yes I am lazy enough not to rewrite my entire post, but just leave it there] I don't disagree with everything. There are a lot of people teetering on worthiness of the bottom of the power rank, and I suppose Iris/Midas are just as justifiable as anyone else who has had a good run. Likewise, despite the fact that I think Flash should be lower-ordinarily, there is simply no one to fill in the gap, so he stays due to the fact that we have had a slow month, and nothing can prove otherwise definitively. Leta's games have been amazing though, but I still disagree with such a high placement, and Best's being so low [despite my hatred of him] I also disagree with the lux/july order [despite my lover of July], but hey. So no, not that bad of a power rank, wacky but...well we have had a slow inconsistent month, what can be said.
hahahah
yeah, from your edit i can see you understand what an odd month July was
|
mind decided to start winning again in august, but that's for next rank
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 07 2008 15:35 Raiju wrote:Show nested quote +On August 07 2008 15:24 Dazed_Spy wrote: Its scary how much I...disagree with everything on this power rank. Give us your power rank then douchebag. Edit: Your are no longer a douchebag since ur edit 
tactfully disagreeing with the power rank and providing what are, in your mind, the appropriate alternatives is completely acceptable
calling someone a douchebag out of nowhere isn't, so consider this a warning -_-
|
Leta is a bit to high , i saw his games vs JD in the offlines for the OSL wasn't impress i think his TvZ is weak but that just might be JD raping him don't know ... but fucking six for just PL games . This and that i think Mind should be # 10 just for killing JangBI + noob in WCG korea, but i'm a bit biased with Mind .
|
Hum i still dont see anything new from Leta but we'll see
Also iris? really i haven't seen him play like a televised match in more or less a year? of course i dont watch religiously and hell the last iris liquid bet before the current one was a long time ago. Ionno about Forgg being on top his games vs flash, jaedong etc didn't sit right with me hes a good player but i just don't see him number one more like jaedong, forgg then flash i feel flash is losing parts of his greatness.
Also i would consider Lux to be a better vote in a game over julyzerg more or less anytime. Frankly july has always been an oddity to me he does well for bursts of times then falls apart only once i've seen his longer dominance.
I wouldn't necessarily disagree with most of the players choices except a few cough leta 6 really? but just the rank placement.
Also sea 1 to close but no cigar a friend had something to say about it "i hate steve so bad because i knew he was gonna do this... sea being 1st in the PR one month, next month, bam, close but no cigar for sea"
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
maybe your friend doesn't understand that i'm the biggest Sea fan in the world
|
United States1654 Posts
Very nice!
|
United States7488 Posts
|
Russian Federation4333 Posts
This is a very good PR. There could be an argument for putting Best or Best+Kal above Leta, but the rest is spot on.
Good job.
|
Weirdest looking power rank in a while. Out of nowhere number 1, two players who seem to be teetering towards greatness but aren't quite there yet, an oldie, and then an odd jumble of last month's players and "where the crap did he come froms?"
Surprised Lomo didn't get a close but no cigar though. He did take Flash to 5 games and given that he wasn't looking like a monster like ForGG was, that's about as good as can reasonably be expected.
|
+ Show Spoiler + fairly convinvnig victories too, even if there were some wtf moments
|
Hmmm...I was prepared to make an all-in arguement for backho but then I looked over his TLPD and realized he wasn't winning as much as I thought he was. There is potential in him, I can feel it.
Maybe you could have replaced Midas with Stork . He's won his last four games and is also on his way to a comeback.
|
On August 07 2008 14:48 Ilikestarcraft wrote: Forgg!!!!
Flash vs backho on wuthering heights was like a tvp textbook on its own imba flash othello made me go WTF.
|
Russian Federation4333 Posts
Completely forgot about Lomo. This itself is the reason he is not even in cnbc. He has been invisible since his 2-3 loss to Flash.
|
Russian Federation1208 Posts
IMHO, Kal doesn't deserve his spot. After his defeat from non-pro BByong, he should be put away from power rank.
|
stork>iris mind>midas i predict they're both going to climb higher than the last 2
|
On August 07 2008 16:28 fusionsdf wrote:+ Show Spoiler + fairly convinvnig victories too, even if there were some wtf moments
+ Show Spoiler +The goddamn Berserker is BACK.
|
I almost fully agree with PR this time 
I only have little concerns with Leta, but I haven't observed his games as much as you did. So all good. 
EDIT: But why is Iris at #8 and Lomo out? He beat the shit out of Iris couple of weeks ago.
|
Hate to say it, but I don't think Flash deserves #3. Maybe 4 or 5, but not 3. Then again, I wouldn't know how the hell to justify what I'm saying. Next month, after Flash mutilates Jaedong's withered, overnuked shell of a body in the GSI, he's gonna be #1, right?
Oh and, has anyone else noticed that, from the first PR, each month's has gotten progressively longer?
edit: good pr =P
|
On August 07 2008 17:27 xxsaznpride wrote: Hate to say it, but I don't think Flash deserves #3. Maybe 4 or 5, but not 3. Then again, I wouldn't know how the hell to justify what I'm saying. Next month, after Flash mutilates Jaedong's withered, overnuked shell of a body in the GSI, he's gonna be #1, right?
Oh and, has anyone else noticed that, from the first PR, each month's has gotten progressively longer?
edit: good pr =P
He is not going to be number #1 he is going to be # 2 , because ForGG is still playing great . He has to lose to someone to be removed from the number # 1 position . And i don't think that Flash is going to deliver a spanking of ForGG's level but we will see .
|
|
|
This is one of the better power ranks I've seen in a while (not including the one when Sea[shield] was #1).
Probably the only 2 criticisms i have are:
-Flash deserves to be higher ranked than Jaedong (Flash is in both major leagues whereas Jaedong is in only 1 of them)
-I dunno why Midas is in. I'm a fan of his and I'm happy he's in the power rank. It's just i dunno why hes in I mean if you look at his games in TLPD, he's 1-2 for the month July This is of course putting aside the fact that he's in one of the major leagues.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 07 2008 18:59 o3.power91 wrote:This is one of the better power ranks I've seen in a while (not including the one when Sea[shield] was #1). Probably the only 2 criticisms i have are: -Flash deserves to be higher ranked than Jaedong (Flash is in both major leagues whereas Jaedong is in only 1 of them) -I dunno why Midas is in. I'm a fan of his and I'm happy he's in the power rank. It's just i dunno why hes in  I mean if you look at his games in TLPD, he's 1-2 for the month July This is of course putting aside the fact that he's in one of the major leagues.
offline prelim games aren't included in the TLPD. watch those games, despite koala upsetting him, he played really really well
|
i dont like how forgg just shot up to first but im really glad that you gave the nod to leta, midas and iris im a huge fan of all these players and although leta seems to be put too high, im glad you recognized him leta has blossomed into an extremely reliable player that can be trusted with important games
|
3 Lions
United States3705 Posts
I agree with almost everything, except for Leta over BeSt, but I especially agree w/ #9
|
Fakesteve and I like the same players w-t-f!! :b
The only player I would question on the PP is Kal. He hasn't been that impressive in a while.
|
Agreeing with most of it, nice entertaining read. Good job
|
|
<3 Berserker! Now if only more CJ players can step it up. PR is nicely done I think, especially with Forgg and Leta.
|
besides congratulating you for the awesome writeup fakesteve, i wanna ask you what is your opinion on frozean? cause to me he seems only capable of bringing up some huge upsets and losing to some of the lamest players around.
|
GOGOGO leta!! 8 game winning streak and is still going!!
|
I absolutely love this power rank, with or without bias on my part
|
On August 07 2008 18:50 Seku wrote: disgusting Please ban
Anyways, Flash and July should change places in my opinion, stomping Best isnt a easy feat to accomplish. Plus Flash has been playing like he's stoned recently. Leta does not deserve such a high spot on the PR, simply because his wins were in the proleague wheras Best and Lux achieved sucesses in the individual leagues. As for the bottom of the PR, I don't care about it since there are a myriad of players who can be placed there.
|
3 Lions
United States3705 Posts
On August 07 2008 18:50 Seku wrote: disgusting WHY????
|
I kinda feel like Best should be #6 and Leta #7. Leta has been impressive yes, but only in the proleague, whereas Best has been impressive in both the proleague and the OSL, and alright in the previous OSL. Best may have not had the greatest end-of-month stats, but Leta only had good end-of-month stats, and while the latter probably means Leta will be doing well in the future, I don't think it necessarily means Best will be doing poorly in the coming future, On the other hand, Leta did beat Best during this overlapping time period of Leta rising and Best falling. Best is seeded into the OSL, and Leta will mostly likely rape his group and advance from the MSL ro36, and from there it'll be apparent who is stronger most likely. Meh the more I type this the more I see it is such a grey zone with it being a close call, so I guess this is fine.
Midas/Iris is kind of weird, but then again I can't think of someone to replace them, so they're fine I guess.
JULY FIGHTING!~
|
For once, i think i completely agree with the entire power rank. good job steve. though i'm not sure i agree about iris, but i haven't watched his games yet. now i definitely will
|
cool power rank. I'm glad to see that July can still kill it, because I was beginning to think that once players got into a slump, they were never the same.
|
On August 07 2008 16:45 Bifur wrote:IMHO, Kal doesn't deserve his spot. After his defeat from non-pro BByong, he should be put away from power rank. WCG is a nothing tournament, and dropping a game due to over confidence is completely forgivable, even more so considering we know his true pvt capabilities, ala his matches against leta and forgg.
|
Seeing Iris play well recently has been pretty sweet, given that the rest of CJ Entus isn't doing too hot at the moment.
It's kinda funny how quickly fOrGG climbed the PR and KeSPA rankings after he suddenly decided to do something useful with his 100000000 units. Hopefully he keeps this performance up into both upcoming leagues.
|
Good to see Iris and Midas on there. Also good that neither Flash or Jaedong have the top spot! Go fOrGG!
|
We need a new picture of Iris.
That picture is hideous.
|
Where is lomo? I think he should at least be in the CBNC.
I disagree with the Lux/Leta/Best order, but thats only a small bit. Those three would still be 5/6/7.
All in all nice power rank.
|
On August 08 2008 02:51 3 Lions wrote:WHY????
Probably has something to do with Iris. That's the only reason I can think of
|
9070 Posts
interesting PR, I share the same thoughts about Kal like FS. For me he is one of the reasons I'm following the scene. Not that I'm huge fan or smth, he just makes the toss entertaining to watch, and he does it at a hole new level
|
United States11390 Posts
On August 08 2008 02:51 3 Lions wrote:WHY???? He sees ForGG as the new Mind and therefore hates him. -_-
|
Great PR Steve I agree with them all I just wish there was a #11 spot for Sea after beating Pure. Not a small feat taking down Pure.
|
I think Pure deserves at least a CBNC.
But well-done. I agree with this one. It must be pretty hard doing a PR after July. Weird month.
|
|
5.6.7 are just wrong imo
5=6 7=5 &
6 = gone bye bye sea ya ... peace bitch LATER.
Backho is more worthy then leta, and I fucking HATE HIM... but fact is he is a more notable gamer now then leta and has been for what 2 months?
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
leta is a better player than backho
leta's ability to play starcraft exceeds that of backho
you think backho should be rewarded for getting trashed by good players over and over simply because he gets to play them?
|
Much beat ForGG in OSL 
Edit: Just so I'm not one lining, I agree that maybe Much didn't belong on this power rank, but I do think he could definitely replace Midas or Iris. Much has fun to watch, good consistant PvT, and his PvP isn't terrible either.
|
On August 09 2008 02:15 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: leta is a better player than backho
leta's ability to play starcraft exceeds that of backho
you think backho should be rewarded for getting trashed by good players over and over simply because he gets to play them?
Backho made it to the semi-finals of 3 different starleagues .... in a row
OSL,MSL,GOM intel classic.... umm leta hasn't ..... I hate backho alot but he is accomplished alot more then leta FOR SURE.
|
actually I checked TLPD an I'm wrong
Intel classic and OSL only....
my bad ... still better then letas no show ass.
|
On August 09 2008 02:15 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: leta is a better player than backho
leta's ability to play starcraft exceeds that of backho
you think backho should be rewarded for getting trashed by good players over and over simply because he gets to play them?
btw how does backho get to play them?
I think he earns it ... no?
|
On August 07 2008 15:18 Kuja900 wrote: OK HANG ON THIS IS IMPOSSIBLE
steve you love my fav player julyzerg, you share a birthday with me, you have an iron maiden pic in your profile which is my fav band and best of all time period. OK im paying for you to get the surgery we are getting married.
oh nice power rank btw
hmm i guess u deny my propasal, well id still let u have me if u wanted to >.>
gogo julyzerg great power rank ^_^
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 09 2008 05:56 AttackZerg wrote:Show nested quote +On August 09 2008 02:15 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: leta is a better player than backho
leta's ability to play starcraft exceeds that of backho
you think backho should be rewarded for getting trashed by good players over and over simply because he gets to play them? btw how does backho get to play them? I think he earns it ... no?
nope. cheesing soft opponents doesn't get much credit on a rank based around playing well. backho is not a good player. even with everyone freaking out about the magical "results" he's getting, he can't win more than he loses.
|
On August 09 2008 05:53 AttackZerg wrote:Show nested quote +On August 09 2008 02:15 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: Leta is a better player than BackHo
Leta's ability to play starcraft exceeds that of BackHo
you think BackHo should be rewarded for getting trashed by good players over and over simply because he gets to play them? BackHo made it to the semi-finals of 3 different starleagues .... in a row OSL,MSL,gOm intel classic.... umm Leta hasn't ..... I hate BackHo alot but he is accomplished alot more then Leta FOR SURE. BackHo is terrible, did you even watch his games vs July? His game on Hwasangbul was the dumbest game I've ever seen.
|
Bo Sung
|
On August 09 2008 07:29 DeadVessel wrote:Show nested quote +On August 09 2008 05:53 AttackZerg wrote:On August 09 2008 02:15 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: Leta is a better player than BackHo
Leta's ability to play starcraft exceeds that of BackHo
you think BackHo should be rewarded for getting trashed by good players over and over simply because he gets to play them? BackHo made it to the semi-finals of 3 different starleagues .... in a row OSL,MSL,gOm intel classic.... umm Leta hasn't ..... I hate BackHo alot but he is accomplished alot more then Leta FOR SURE. BackHo is terrible, did you even watch his games vs July? His game on Hwasangbul was the dumbest game I've ever seen. Yes Backho sucks royally against Zerg (Only one non-cheese win against Flower? though I maintain he would've done well in game 1 had he not gone for no Anti-air), but his PvP is very impressive, and his PvT is quite good. I don't think anyone can question his PvP power given his string of victories; he's shown powerful consistency in all of his matchups against P, whether or not his opponent's did poorly.
As for his PvT, Backho v Flash wasn't quite as one-sided as people make it out to be. He was relatively strong in all 3 games, with small (but major) mistakes bringing about his downfall (like building the bay in his base, *barely* losing the shuttle with 2 reavers, and droppping reavers into the mines by sheer luck). THough there was that one really dumb incident where Backho engaged the tanks after getting EMPed at a chokepoint, asides from that, Backho v Flash was far more level than say, Jaedong v Shuttle or ForGG vs Jaedong. I might dare to presume it was on the level of Best v July in the sense that the first two games were anyone's guess,
Last but not least, he gets results, which makes up for his crappy PvZ and weird decision making. Casy, who's TvP is along the lines of Backho's PvZ, has graced the power rank multiple times, so why shouldn't Backho be up for at least some consideration?
Indeed though, if Backho is considered to be terrible, then since there were many points in the games where Flash appeared to be losing, Flash shouldn't be ranked as high as 3, at least not for this month (especially in light of his abysmal performance against ForGG and his mediocre performances against memories in games 2 and 3, despite eking out a victory in the second two). Lastly, both matchups with Backho v Iris were impressive. The one on blue storm (a map if anything, biased for T in PvT) especially. Iris was still on PR when Backho defeated him, and that alone (along with some stellar reaver play) should signify that the feat required a good amount of Starcraft skill. (It didn't seem like Iris made any major mistakes).
|
On August 09 2008 07:20 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:Show nested quote +On August 09 2008 05:56 AttackZerg wrote:On August 09 2008 02:15 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: leta is a better player than backho
leta's ability to play starcraft exceeds that of backho
you think backho should be rewarded for getting trashed by good players over and over simply because he gets to play them? btw how does backho get to play them? I think he earns it ... no? nope. cheesing soft opponents doesn't get much credit on a rank based around playing well. backho is not a good player. even with everyone freaking out about the magical "results" he's getting, he can't win more than he loses.
He has been more consistent results wise then much/midis or iris.
Another another note your powerrank is about good play rather then results. Since you did point that out/I wasn't fully considering that in my backho arguement, I will relinqish my stance.
But he's results have placed him in the top10-15 players in the world in the last 2-3 months, as sad as that is.
|
I don't agree with Frogg, while he arguably was best player of July, he won't be for long. As for 9-10, maybe, there aren't better players to put there anyway
|
uhh mr.steve u said flash seeded into ro16 for both leagues but he got knocked out of osl in ro8 i believe it was and i thought only the people in the ro4 get seeded into next ro16, correct me if im wrong
|
Since Flash has already played in the ro36 in OSL we can probably assume that you're right...
|
Flash is seeded into both Ro16's because he made semis for MSL and because he qualified out of OSL Ro32 (aka ODT with a new format/name).
Anyhow... BackHo isn't terrible, in that he is a pro-gamer playing for the A-team of a strong pro-team. BackHo isn't good, in that he is a mediocre player who has the good luck to catch big names with their pants down. Even when BackHo wins, he doesn't look all that great; his opponents just happen to look worse. Plus, Stork just 2-0'd BackHo out of the WCG, so much for "consistency."
For all his supposed results, BackHo hasn't gotten past a semi-final, like ever. People want to give him credit for making it there in the first place, okay. How many games has he won in those semi-finals? As I count it... one, on Troy (~67% P winrate over Z).
As for the Casy argument- Casy has an OSL title under his belt and even beat a Protoss player in his road to the final (though to be fair, Rainbow's PvT wasn't necessarily the best either). More importantly, Casy looked GOOD while he was winning his title. BackHo never looks good and he's never won a title. BackHo has never been a legitimate championship contender. More relevant to this discussion, at no point in July was BackHo look like or play like a legitimate championship contender. At no point in July did he even make a valuable contribution to his team's Proleague playoff chances (good job losing to Haran!) fOrGG and July both won the titles to be won in July. Jaedong, Flash, Best, Luxury- these guys all had a legit shot at winning their respective leagues. Leta only played in PL during July, but he won every game he played, and secured his team a spot in the PL grand final.
As for Kal/Iris/Midas, given the small amount of games played in July, these aren't on the rank because they won a billion games; they're on the PR because their performance in July suggests that people should be on the lookout for these guys to do something in the upcoming season.
Nothing in BackHo's play in July suggests that we should watch for BackHo to make a splash or do anything with his OSL seed, or do anything particularly noteworthy other than maybe get to play yet another slumping big-name player and eek out a win with a DT rush.
|
On August 09 2008 07:29 DeadVessel wrote:Show nested quote +On August 09 2008 05:53 AttackZerg wrote:On August 09 2008 02:15 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: Leta is a better player than BackHo
Leta's ability to play starcraft exceeds that of BackHo
you think BackHo should be rewarded for getting trashed by good players over and over simply because he gets to play them? BackHo made it to the semi-finals of 3 different starleagues .... in a row OSL,MSL,gOm intel classic.... umm Leta hasn't ..... I hate BackHo alot but he is accomplished alot more then Leta FOR SURE. BackHo is terrible, did you even watch his games vs July? His game on Hwasangbul was the dumbest game I've ever seen.
Well compare to Best's performance he at least stole a game from July :D
|
United States10328 Posts
I'm not sure about ForGG at #1. Sure, he beat jaedong and flash (wow), but recently, his games have faltered a bit. Of course, I guess I'm speaking from a post-PR point of view, but I don't think ForGG will last at #1 for very long... but don't get me wrong, he is a great player. But #1... meh.
I actually haven't seen much of Leta because I don't follow proleague a lot.. but I checked him out on TLPD and... dang. Maybe #6 is a little high (I think Best is more proven in high-pressure situations), but yeah he should be on the PR. Winning THAT many games in a row... is amazing.
|
Maybe I'm wrong, but Casy beat one mediocre protoss and two terrans on his way up from the OSL, with his semifinals and finals being against Zerg players. Backho beat Ganzi (in a less than impressive game, granted), Jaedong, and Casy on his way up in both GomTV and OSL (and as mentioned before, watching most of Backho's PvT games show that Backho actually has skill in that matchup). Casy beating IntoTheRainBOw, whether by cheese or no, doesn't say any more about Casy than Backho beating Jaedong says about Backho; Casy PvT is on par with sub-B class protosses.
And of course, in the last *season*, Backho's been 8-3 against Protoss, with his two losses to stork and one against Jangbi (WCG being a less prestigious tournament anyways, but that asides). Maybe Much severely dropped the ball when he attacked his own forge with 10+ dragoons, but the other players (Bisu Stork Jangbi etc.) didn't. Watching the games (with the exception of Backho vs Much) demonstrates that Backho won with skill, and not luck. That looks like consistency to me.
I don't by any means think Backho should be up there on the PR for this month, but his contention for being on the list should be given some more consideration than just a running joke, despite the fact that his PvZ is, well, a joke.
Edit: oops, I meant season wins. Sorry.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 10 2008 05:03 SerpentFlame wrote: Maybe I'm wrong, but Casy beat one mediocre protoss and two terrans on his way up from the OSL, with his semifinals and finals being against Zerg players. Backho beat Ganzi (in a less than impressive game, granted), Jaedong, and Casy on his way up in both GomTV and OSL (and as mentioned before, watching most of Backho's PvT games show that Backho actually has skill in that matchup). Casy beating IntoTheRainBOw, whether by cheese or no, doesn't say any more about Casy than Backho beating Jaedong says about Backho; Casy PvT is on par with sub-B class protosses.
And of course, in the last month, Backho's been 8-3 against Protoss, with his two losses to stork and one against Jangbi (WCG being a less prestigious tournament anyways, but that asides). Maybe Much severely dropped the ball when he attacked his own forge with 10+ dragoons, but the other players (Bisu Stork Jangbi etc.) didn't. Watching the games (with the exception of Backho vs Much) demonstrates that Backho won with skill, and not luck. That looks like consistency to me.
I don't by any means think Backho should be up there on the PR for this month, but his contention for being on the list should be given some more consideration than just a running joke, despite the fact that his PvZ is, well, a joke.
backho has not played eleven PvPs in the last month
|
Wait, I thought he played... Jangbi - 3 Stork - 4 Bisu - 1 Much - 1 Chalrenge -1 Kal - 1 ( I heard someone mention Backho beating Kal earlier? not entirely sure this exists)
|
good TL read is thanks
re:backho, its his haircut
|
On August 10 2008 06:36 SerpentFlame wrote: Wait, I thought he played... Jangbi - 3 Stork - 4 Bisu - 1 Much - 1 Chalrenge -1 Kal - 1 ( I heard someone mention Backho beating Kal earlier? not entirely sure this exists)
Man that are Backho's all season games .. all his wins to be prеcise ...
He did not win many games last month except maybe vs Nada and Stork in the WCG and Intel classic , he is doing a good job qualifing for the leagues thought .Hmm i still think BackHO did a better job then Midas last month , but if i had to choose i would put Much at ten even if he doesn't have many games , or Mind for that matter .
Mind or Much will do 10 times better then Midas/BackHO in the upcoming leagues i would put money on that . I don't mind seeing Midas #10 thought and Berserker is a good choice for # 9 .
|
Why so few dominant protoss lately?
|
On August 11 2008 13:46 hi19hi19 wrote: Why so few dominant protoss lately?
Well Much is killing terrans and Best other tosses , but so far there is no toss to control the zerg dominance thats the terran's job .
|
BISU COME BACK!! please we need you to dominate! ^^
|
no stork? did you forget him?
+ Show Spoiler + btw, much just owned forgg and jaedong rapped flash ^^
|
On August 12 2008 08:56 ilbh wrote:no stork? did you forget him? + Show Spoiler + btw, much just owned forgg and jaedong rapped flash ^^
Good thing you posted that, or FS would have never found out.
|
On August 12 2008 08:56 ilbh wrote:no stork? did you forget him? + Show Spoiler + btw, much just owned forgg and jaedong rapped flash ^^
Forgg played 3 Bo3s in the same day, practicing for 2 match ups with diffrent maps, give him a break. He is still the best player out there and it will stay that way for a couple of months.
|
On August 12 2008 18:26 samachking wrote:Forgg played 3 Bo3s in the same day, practicing for 2 match ups with diffrent maps, give him a break. He is still the best player out there and it will stay that way for a couple of months.
I don't think he is the best player he doesn't seem too dominant when i watch his games , he has good macro but he has weaknesses too . I mean he lost to Much and almost lost to Bisu on Blue storm given he had 3 Bo3 he performed well . I think his TvP style is a little diffrent then Flash's or Minds . I think that mind has the strongest TvP . But all props goes to Much who i think has the strongest PvT around with JangBI .ForGG doesn't seem to have the spark of a true #1 , but because other players are in slumps or are just playing worse only Jaedong comes near him . Seriously Jaedong is the only competidive player for a long time now . He drops a game or two (sets unlikely but still happens ) and he still comes back and owns the next big shot who is threatening his position . ForGG being his teammate obviously has an advantage compare to Flash or other strong players because he is familiar with his timings and styles more then other Pros and that is why he had the edge in that final . And that is why he will be # 1 if he doesn't start to suck which he will sooner or later .
|
I hate to say it, but Flash doesn't look like Top5 status anymore. Then again, I didn't think he was top5 last month either so yeah...
<== not going to be a Frogg fan.
I vote that, because his ceremonies make him look like a naked asshole, that FBH is #8 on the next PR. Totally because he stripped down, because a lack of shame overshadows a relative lack of skill.
|
Russian Federation4333 Posts
In 4 days the top 2 PR spots will be determined. Jaedong and Forgg have ony WCG left to play in. It is pretty much guaranteed that JD and Forgg will get top 2. The only way Flash or Lux, the only candidates for top 2, can surpass them is by winning WCG and staying in the SLs; the 1'st I doubt they will accomplish.
|
3 Lions
United States3705 Posts
with these koreans going, korea will get Gold, Silver, and Bronze @ WCG unless they run into each other before the semifinals
|
On August 12 2008 19:31 raga4ka wrote:Show nested quote +On August 12 2008 18:26 samachking wrote:On August 12 2008 08:56 ilbh wrote:no stork? did you forget him? + Show Spoiler + btw, much just owned forgg and jaedong rapped flash ^^
Forgg played 3 Bo3s in the same day, practicing for 2 match ups with diffrent maps, give him a break. He is still the best player out there and it will stay that way for a couple of months. I don't think he is the best player he doesn't seem too dominant when i watch his games , he has good macro but he has weaknesses too . I mean he lost to Much and almost lost to Bisu on Blue storm given he had 3 Bo3 he performed well . I think his TvP style is a little diffrent then Flash's or Minds . I think that mind has the strongest TvP . But all props goes to Much who i think has the strongest PvT around with JangBI .ForGG doesn't seem to have the spark of a true #1 , but because other players are in slumps or are just playing worse only Jaedong comes near him . Seriously Jaedong is the only competidive player for a long time now . He drops a game or two (sets unlikely but still happens ) and he still comes back and owns the next big shot who is threatening his position . ForGG being his teammate obviously has an advantage compare to Flash or other strong players because he is familiar with his timings and styles more then other Pros and that is why he had the edge in that final . And that is why he will be # 1 if he doesn't start to suck which he will sooner or later . the conundrum - jaedong is probably has more of an advantage against the field than forgg, but forgg is probably a favorite over jaedong. guy is basically 75% against zerg and protoss (since the stork finals), and a favorite to beat any terran other than forgg.
|
On August 13 2008 05:55 TheTyranid wrote:In 4 days the top 2 PR spots will be determined. Jaedong and Forgg have ony WCG left to play in.  It is pretty much guaranteed that JD and Forgg will get top 2. The only way Flash or Lux, the only candidates for top 2, can surpass them is by winning WCG and staying in the SLs; the 1'st I doubt they will accomplish.
Or Much just rapeing all and skyrocketing from CNBC to first place . Now that will be epic !!!
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 13 2008 19:00 raga4ka wrote:Show nested quote +On August 13 2008 05:55 TheTyranid wrote:In 4 days the top 2 PR spots will be determined. Jaedong and Forgg have ony WCG left to play in.  It is pretty much guaranteed that JD and Forgg will get top 2. The only way Flash or Lux, the only candidates for top 2, can surpass them is by winning WCG and staying in the SLs; the 1'st I doubt they will accomplish. Or Much just rapeing all and skyrocketing from CNBC to first place . Now that will be epic !!!
much's pvt has been pretty good lately
|
Rolling over Flash and ForGG T_T
|
Stork 2:0 fOrGG
Also he avenged his freak loss to BackHo and embarrassed the hell out of Luxury.
Just throwin' that out there... 
of course he had to go and lose to Bisu
|
On August 14 2008 15:31 Pyrrhuloxia wrote:Stork 2:0 fOrGG Also he avenged his freak loss to BackHo and embarrassed the hell out of Luxury. Just throwin' that out there...  of course he had to go and lose to Bisu 
Well we saw it comeing ForGG is not dominant enough to be # 1 . He is quite dominant thought , but not # 1 in the PR for a long time .
|
On August 13 2008 05:59 3 Lions wrote: with these koreans going, korea will get Gold, Silver, and Bronze @ WCG unless they run into each other before the semifinals
It really seems that way every year. Until someone like Savior or Silent Control loses to someone like PJ or Androide
|
LOL what happened to sea? Did forgg agree to a TL attack xD
This is a joke. ForGG should not be rank number 1 (yes i've read the ranking system). PLease stop joking around witht his, give JD number 1....
|
|
ForGG has had a horribly tough schedule lately.
|
On August 15 2008 12:48 NexyNexy wrote: LOL what happened to sea? Did forgg agree to a TL attack xD
This is a joke. ForGG should not be rank number 1 (yes i've read the ranking system). PLease stop joking around witht his, give JD number 1....
FakeSteve doesn't change a rank in the middle of the month . And ForGG was #1 when he slaughtered Jaedong and everybody else last month .
|
I think forgg should still be #2 next month atleast. Losing to much and stork TvP is nothing to be ashamed of. Especially since he's been practicing for 3 leagues simultaneously. Also i don't think you can even count losing to much against him. He had to play 8 games on the same day. Gotta give the guy a break.
|
United States42568 Posts
On May 07 2008 11:07 thedeadhaji wrote: You heard it here first.
Lecaf is forcing ForGG to use micro oriented strats to improve his atrocious micro.
When he attains it, he will be monster.
|
On August 15 2008 12:48 NexyNexy wrote: LOL what happened to sea? Did forgg agree to a TL attack xD
This is a joke. ForGG should not be rank number 1 (yes i've read the ranking system). PLease stop joking around witht his, give JD number 1....
You're an idiot. If you're going to make an argument, please don't type like a drunk 3 year old.
LOL, ForGG_V_ fucking raped Flash out of OSL, did really good in Proleague, Raped JD in MSL, took out Kal in the most entertaining series of games that season, made it to Quarters of MSL.
ForGG_V_ was playing like the best player in the world at that time. Was he a little lucky? Sure. Did the map pool favor him? Absolutely? Did it take immense skill and hard work to do what he did? Yes.
Flash was playing like an infant, and Jaedong was playing just a little short of his usual dominance. However, immediately after the MSL final Jaedong resumed using the drugs that make him win every game.
|
Russian Federation4333 Posts
On August 15 2008 18:13 Tinithor wrote: I think forgg should still be #2 next month atleast. Losing to much and stork TvP is nothing to be ashamed of. Especially since he's been practicing for 3 leagues simultaneously. Also i don't think you can even count losing to much against him. He had to play 8 games on the same day. Gotta give the guy a break. The real reason why Forgg should be #2 next month is because there is no other player who deserves that spot. Flash was stomed in GSL and WCG and Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Who can take it, Leta? Much? he is hot in only 1 match up and isn't even on the PR. Forgg is a definite second.
|
On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote: Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss.
Didn't Jaedong get eliminated by a no name toss too?
|
On August 16 2008 22:27 adelarge wrote:Show nested quote +On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote: Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Didn't Jaedong get eliminated by a no name toss too?
Yeah after that he raped Flash and BEST so i don't know what to expect WTF , but no Jaedong in freaking OSL . It is gonna be boring without him . Oh well i hope July can get his white gold mouse next
|
On August 17 2008 00:31 raga4ka wrote:Show nested quote +On August 16 2008 22:27 adelarge wrote:On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote: Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Didn't Jaedong get eliminated by a no name toss too? Yeah after that he raped Flash and BEST so i don't know what to expect WTF , but no Jaedong in freaking OSL . It is gonna be boring without him . Oh well i hope July can get his white gold mouse next 
There is no white gold mouse.
|
On August 17 2008 02:50 Mindcrime wrote:Show nested quote +On August 17 2008 00:31 raga4ka wrote:On August 16 2008 22:27 adelarge wrote:On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote: Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Didn't Jaedong get eliminated by a no name toss too? Yeah after that he raped Flash and BEST so i don't know what to expect WTF , but no Jaedong in freaking OSL . It is gonna be boring without him . Oh well i hope July can get his white gold mouse next  There is no white gold mouse. plat mouse
plat != white gold but
alot of people make that mistake
|
well, in many languages, their word(s) for plat does directly translate into white gold, and white gold is a common name for gold anyways
|
On August 17 2008 04:38 Kupon3ss wrote: well, in many languages, their word(s) for plat does directly translate into white gold, and white gold is a common name for gold anyways yeah but technically white gold is an alloy of gold and a cheaper metal while plat is
plat
expensive catalyst shit
|
Russian Federation4333 Posts
On August 16 2008 22:27 adelarge wrote:Show nested quote +On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote: Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Didn't Jaedong get eliminated by a no name toss too? Doesn't matter since Jaedong is going to be 1'st next month. 
Oh and Stork is back on the PR. 
|
On August 17 2008 05:37 TheTyranid wrote:Show nested quote +On August 16 2008 22:27 adelarge wrote:On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote: Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Didn't Jaedong get eliminated by a no name toss too? Doesn't matter since Jaedong is going to be 1'st next month.  Oh and Stork is back on the PR. 
Someone suggested putting Stork on PR to FS in IRC and he told them to go die.
|
I'm a biased Jaedong fan but he's been doing incredibly well despite his loss verse forGG lately.
Just 2-0'd the 2nd best ZvZ Luxury 3-0'd Flash Beat Best
Yes, fOrgg did manage to beat Jaedong but if he loses to players like Much & Stork, I don't see how he can hold his #1 spot
|
Yeah, I think Jaedong is #1 next month.
|
On August 17 2008 04:30 SpiritoftheTuna wrote:Show nested quote +On August 17 2008 02:50 Mindcrime wrote:On August 17 2008 00:31 raga4ka wrote:On August 16 2008 22:27 adelarge wrote:On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote: Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Didn't Jaedong get eliminated by a no name toss too? Yeah after that he raped Flash and BEST so i don't know what to expect WTF , but no Jaedong in freaking OSL . It is gonna be boring without him . Oh well i hope July can get his white gold mouse next  There is no white gold mouse. plat mouse plat != white gold but alot of people make that mistake
same shit platinum mouse fighting
|
How did Luxury get put below July? -________-
|
On August 18 2008 01:53 OmgIRok wrote: How did Luxury get put below July? -________-
Because he isn't The God of WAR maybe ?
ZvP man zvp ... Back then July won the golden mouse and Luxury just couldn't live up to the expectation even to reach the finals . It is the same with BEST who should have been above both but failed .Maybe next month he will be higher then July , because of the performance this month . I would rather have July above Luxury just because he doesn't seem weak versus protoss and that is what he will be geting in his OSL group or so i hear ... Lets see if July can get a fourth one .
If i'm not mistaken Much and Bisu are in July's OSL group , and i don't have doubts in my mind that JulyZerg will either cheese or Sauron the life out ot them ...
|
Wow, your pr proved even more correct with Jaedong destroying Flash in the GOMTV final. I don't think flash is done, but I think he'll devolve into a less consistent Bisu-type character.
5 terrans, 2 protosses, and 3 zergs. And who said the maps were P weighted?
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 18 2008 04:01 thunk wrote: 5 terrans, 2 protosses, and 3 zergs. And who said the maps were P weighted?
the fact that there are five terrans on the power rank simply means that five of the best current players are terran
it doesnt say anything about the maps
|
Russian Federation4333 Posts
On August 17 2008 12:15 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Show nested quote +On August 17 2008 05:37 TheTyranid wrote:On August 16 2008 22:27 adelarge wrote:On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote: Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Didn't Jaedong get eliminated by a no name toss too? Doesn't matter since Jaedong is going to be 1'st next month.  Oh and Stork is back on the PR.  Someone suggested putting Stork on PR to FS in IRC and he told them to go die. If Stork passes MST and ODT (OSL ro 36, w/e, practically ODT), he won't have a choice.
|
On August 18 2008 04:44 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:Show nested quote +On August 18 2008 04:01 thunk wrote: 5 terrans, 2 protosses, and 3 zergs. And who said the maps were P weighted? the fact that there are five terrans on the power rank simply means that five of the best current players are terran it doesnt say anything about the maps
Yea, I'm kinda confusing this season with this season. If you throw out the last two spots (the ones you said you'd get bitching comments about) you have a decently balanced PR.
I would argue the last 2 spots but I really can't think of anyone more deserving and I haven't been watching games to argue against Iris and Midas (or in support of other players). Iris and Midas are pretty baller in their own right too so....
|
On August 18 2008 03:38 raga4ka wrote:Show nested quote +On August 18 2008 01:53 OmgIRok wrote: How did Luxury get put below July? -________-
Because he isn't The God of WAR maybe ? ZvP man zvp ... Back then July won the golden mouse and Luxury just couldn't live up to the expectation even to reach the finals . It is the same with BEST who should have been above both but failed .Maybe next month he will be higher then July , because of the performance this month . I would rather have July above Luxury just because he doesn't seem weak versus protoss and that is what he will be geting in his OSL group  or so i hear ... Lets see if July can get a fourth one  . If i'm not mistaken Much and Bisu are in July's OSL group , and i don't have doubts in my mind that JulyZerg will either cheese or Sauron the life out ot them ...
But Bisu is good PvZ! He invented Bisu build
|
On August 18 2008 16:30 OmgIRok wrote:Show nested quote +On August 18 2008 03:38 raga4ka wrote:On August 18 2008 01:53 OmgIRok wrote: How did Luxury get put below July? -________-
Because he isn't The God of WAR maybe ? ZvP man zvp ... Back then July won the golden mouse and Luxury just couldn't live up to the expectation even to reach the finals . It is the same with BEST who should have been above both but failed .Maybe next month he will be higher then July , because of the performance this month . I would rather have July above Luxury just because he doesn't seem weak versus protoss and that is what he will be geting in his OSL group  or so i hear ... Lets see if July can get a fourth one  . If i'm not mistaken Much and Bisu are in July's OSL group , and i don't have doubts in my mind that JulyZerg will either cheese or Sauron the life out ot them ... But Bisu is good PvZ! He invented Bisu build
He rearly uses it , and only vs Savior .
|
On August 18 2008 16:30 OmgIRok wrote:Show nested quote +On August 18 2008 03:38 raga4ka wrote:On August 18 2008 01:53 OmgIRok wrote: How did Luxury get put below July? -________-
Because he isn't The God of WAR maybe ? ZvP man zvp ... Back then July won the golden mouse and Luxury just couldn't live up to the expectation even to reach the finals . It is the same with BEST who should have been above both but failed .Maybe next month he will be higher then July , because of the performance this month . I would rather have July above Luxury just because he doesn't seem weak versus protoss and that is what he will be geting in his OSL group  or so i hear ... Lets see if July can get a fourth one  . If i'm not mistaken Much and Bisu are in July's OSL group , and i don't have doubts in my mind that JulyZerg will either cheese or Sauron the life out ot them ... But Bisu is good PvZ! He invented Bisu build
lolno.
|
On August 18 2008 11:10 TheTyranid wrote:Show nested quote +On August 17 2008 12:15 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On August 17 2008 05:37 TheTyranid wrote:On August 16 2008 22:27 adelarge wrote:On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote: Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Didn't Jaedong get eliminated by a no name toss too? Doesn't matter since Jaedong is going to be 1'st next month.  Oh and Stork is back on the PR.  Someone suggested putting Stork on PR to FS in IRC and he told them to go die. If Stork passes MST and ODT (OSL ro 36, w/e, practically ODT), he won't have a choice. OSL ro 36 down, MST to go!
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
there are 30 players i could name off the top of my head that i'd fully expect to bulldoze an ODT group that consists of fucking tester and dongrae
|
On August 17 2008 13:15 Februarys wrote: I'm a biased Jaedong fan but he's been doing incredibly well despite his loss verse forGG lately.
Just 2-0'd the 2nd best ZvZ Luxury 3-0'd Flash Beat Best
Yes, fOrgg did manage to beat Jaedong but if he loses to players like Much & Stork, I don't see how he can hold his #1 spot 2-0 Leta in qualifiers too
Steve may we see a TheZerg (god that handle...) appearance?
|
I wanna see Jangbi on number ten. Hes on a 8 game win streak in pvz, same pvt as always [read great], and despite getting cheesed out of the osl by light [damn him to hell] hes in the msl, will probably go far, and is genuinely strong in all match ups. He looks good enough to be 10 for me- but thats the thing, he looks good now. Jangbi is so god damn inconsistent.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 21 2008 09:40 ScarFace wrote: I wanna see Jangbi on number ten. Hes on a 8 game win streak in pvz, same pvt as always [read great], and despite getting cheesed out of the osl by light [damn him to hell] hes in the msl, will probably go far, and is genuinely strong in all match ups. He looks good enough to be 10 for me- but thats the thing, he looks good now. Jangbi is so god damn inconsistent.
yep, jangbi lately has been pulling his shit back together. we'll see how long it lasts 
|
On August 21 2008 08:26 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: there are 30 players i could name off the top of my head that i'd fully expect to bulldoze an ODT group that consists of fucking tester and dongrae both those are good players. the fact that stork won without much problem, is a sign that he has returned strong, he hasnt lost much during the last months. So either you like it or not, Stork will soon yet again become PR material
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 21 2008 18:35 ThePhan2m wrote:Show nested quote +On August 21 2008 08:26 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: there are 30 players i could name off the top of my head that i'd fully expect to bulldoze an ODT group that consists of fucking tester and dongrae both those are good players. the fact that stork won without much problem, is a sign that he has returned strong, he hasnt lost much during the last months. So either you like it or not, Stork will soon yet again become PR material 
You're a fool, Dongrae and tester are low-tier bottom feeder pros. they are awful players with an awful career spanning many years.
Look, I'll help you out. Here's 20 pros not currently on the PR that would be heavy favourites against tester and dongrae:
Sea Light Jangbi Pure Much Stork Firebathero Shine Mind Nada Yellow[ArnC] Hyuk Hyun Canata Hwasin Bisu Rock go.go Hiya TheManiaMST
|
Protoss players going down =/ meh..
|
Jangbi took a beating from Light in bo3, i want Much (uber games vs forGG) and Stork (qualified, finalist on WCG Korea, as always losing the final) on 9 and 10 spots.
|
On August 22 2008 00:05 Phradamon wrote: Jangbi took a beating from Light in bo3, i want Much (uber games vs forGG) and Stork (qualified, finalist on WCG Korea, as always losing the final) on 9 and 10 spots.
Getting cheesed twice after raping someone in a macro game is not 'taking a beating'. Its getting cheesed out of an osl, thats it.
|
I still stand by what i said that Carriers are IMPOSSIBLE to beat on Plasma. Light was VERY prepared for them by the time Jangbi had them but theres just nothing he could do with the ridges everywhere.
|
On August 22 2008 04:04 Tinithor wrote: I still stand by what i said that Carriers are IMPOSSIBLE to beat on Plasma. Light was VERY prepared for them by the time Jangbi had them but theres just nothing he could do with the ridges everywhere.
Watch it again, seriously. At the time when Jangbi starts to build his first Stargate, he is at 171 supply. Light at that time is at 127....
On any normal map, Jangbi would have roflstomped Light then and there, and been done with it. But with those ridges everywhere, protoss cannot break the terran push without either carriers, or arbiters. Flanking is impossible, and the distances are super short. Case in point, you saw how superior Stork was to Dongrae? When Stork finally managed to get into Dongrae's main, he was 150 to 70, and had put down 3 stargates + beacon. Again, on any other map, it would have been over 10 minutes earlier.
If terran cannot stop toss from getting those carriers, they are terrible, and deserve to lose.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
Plasma is actually very, very hard TvP. Don't be fooled by the current record on it, Terran will have a hellacious time winning any games against Protoss on it
|
On August 22 2008 07:05 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: Plasma is actually very, very hard TvP. Don't be fooled by the current record on it, Terran will have a hellacious time winning any games against Protoss on it Hmm, I'm not sure about the late game, but I know Terran have a huge opportunity to simply roll over the protoss before their economy gets going.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 22 2008 07:48 ScarFace wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2008 07:05 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: Plasma is actually very, very hard TvP. Don't be fooled by the current record on it, Terran will have a hellacious time winning any games against Protoss on it Hmm, I'm not sure about the late game, but I know Terran have a huge opportunity to simply roll over the protoss before their economy gets going.
That's not true. In fact, it's less true than it is on other maps.
|
Russian Federation4333 Posts
Are there going to be any more games this month besides tonights? I'm pretty sure this is the progamer vacation; they had one mid august last year. We might have a PR a week early. on time actually since FS has been posting them a week into the month lately.
|
On August 22 2008 08:09 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2008 07:48 ScarFace wrote:On August 22 2008 07:05 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: Plasma is actually very, very hard TvP. Don't be fooled by the current record on it, Terran will have a hellacious time winning any games against Protoss on it Hmm, I'm not sure about the late game, but I know Terran have a huge opportunity to simply roll over the protoss before their economy gets going. That's not true. In fact, it's less true than it is on other maps.
Why is that? From my perspective, it looks like it's a lot harder to mess with the terran before they have their tanks + siege mode, and once they have those, the eggs are pretty much no barrier at all. And then the bases are really close. Protoss doesn't have any opportunity to slow the advance like on a map such as Blue Storm.
|
On August 23 2008 23:58 errol1001 wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2008 08:09 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:On August 22 2008 07:48 ScarFace wrote:On August 22 2008 07:05 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: Plasma is actually very, very hard TvP. Don't be fooled by the current record on it, Terran will have a hellacious time winning any games against Protoss on it Hmm, I'm not sure about the late game, but I know Terran have a huge opportunity to simply roll over the protoss before their economy gets going. That's not true. In fact, it's less true than it is on other maps. Why is that? From my perspective, it looks like it's a lot harder to mess with the terran before they have their tanks + siege mode, and once they have those, the eggs are pretty much no barrier at all. And then the bases are really close. Protoss doesn't have any opportunity to slow the advance like on a map such as Blue Storm. Yeah. The mains are also so small, when the push gets going the protoss has to break it or hes going to be smashed. Its happened [or tried] in virtually every pvt game I've seen on plasma.
|
TheZerg has been pulling out some really inspiring play recently, in both the STX masters against July and Hwasin AND the OSL against Hwasin and Rumble, and Hwasin's supposed to be a TvZ specialist. TheZerg for PR 10 next month?
|
I would love to see thezerg on PR, not only did he beat Hwasin 3 times this month, but he looked damn good while he did it, too. But there have been so many who have shown strong play lately, like Much, Jangbi, Stork, Sea and Fantasy. Given that PR only have 10 spots, not everyone will get one.
|
theres too many new guys raping faces, thezergs been impressive but theres just too many who have been more impressive for him to get a spot.
next ranking is gonna be hard to judge though since alot of the top spots havent been playing much as theyre seeded past the qualifiers and there isnt any proleague.
|
stork for the next pr would be awesome his doing good lately fantasy also has shown some good signs
|
Midas has well and truly returned the love of Fakesteve. : )
|
If Fakesteve follows through on his Stork boycott for August I might have to make my own subversive PR.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 25 2008 20:02 HaXxorIzed wrote: Midas has well and truly returned the love of Fakesteve. : )
damn right, what a thrashing he gave Yellow[ArnC]
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 26 2008 02:51 Pyrrhuloxia wrote: If Fakesteve follows through on his Stork boycott for August I might have to make my own subversive PR.
there is no stork boycott, there are simply months where stork isn't on the power rank
however, next month he will be. he looks pretty good again, and has only lost to jaedong in recent memory. strong performances after several months of inadequacy.
|
I'm excited to see Midas/Stork back on the PR.
I'm curious to know what you think about FBH and by.fantasy FS?
Do you think they could warrant a CBNC?
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
FBH is a great player, but hasn't been top 10 material for quite some time. Personally I'm a huge fan, but he won't be in the top 10 next month.
Fantasy is another player I really like. I was confident he'd win his MST group, and he did. I was confident he'd win his OSL Round 1 group, and he did. However, while the ability to play at the level Fantasy plays at is to be commended, the ability to play like that through a major league is another beast altogether. Fantasy rules ass, in my mind he's one of the best Terrans around. We'll have to see where he goes in MSL/OSL. Or perhaps he'll find himself at the bottom of September's PR, depending on what the list I'm satisfied with is.
|
On August 26 2008 10:36 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: FBH is a great player, but hasn't been top 10 material for quite some time. Personally I'm a huge fan, but he won't be in the top 10 next month.
Fantasy is another player I really like. I was confident he'd win his MST group, and he did. I was confident he'd win his OSL Round 1 group, and he did. However, while the ability to play at the level Fantasy plays at is to be commended, the ability to play like that through a major league is another beast altogether. Fantasy rules ass, in my mind he's one of the best Terrans around. We'll have to see where he goes in MSL/OSL. Or perhaps he'll find himself at the bottom of September's PR, depending on what the list I'm satisfied with is.
If FBH brushes up his TvP, I feel we could see much better play out of him. Champion material? Not even, but he could probbaly make it to RO38 of any starleague. Problem is, he's probably too weathered to make a huge difference in his play now.
I agree about Fantasy, what a badass.
And Leta too, holy fuck. I'd be shocked if he wasn't in the top 4 next PR tbh.
|
On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote:Show nested quote +On August 15 2008 18:13 Tinithor wrote: I think forgg should still be #2 next month atleast. Losing to much and stork TvP is nothing to be ashamed of. Especially since he's been practicing for 3 leagues simultaneously. Also i don't think you can even count losing to much against him. He had to play 8 games on the same day. Gotta give the guy a break. The real reason why Forgg should be #2 next month is because there is no other player who deserves that spot. Flash was stomed in GSL and WCG and Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Who can take it, Leta? Much? he is hot in only 1 match up and isn't even on the PR. Forgg is a definite second.
Well that no-name toss is Tempest)Is( and he has been a pro for a long time. And did you even watch that game? Tempest is no bad player.
|
On August 27 2008 13:43 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Show nested quote +On August 26 2008 10:36 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: FBH is a great player, but hasn't been top 10 material for quite some time. Personally I'm a huge fan, but he won't be in the top 10 next month.
Fantasy is another player I really like. I was confident he'd win his MST group, and he did. I was confident he'd win his OSL Round 1 group, and he did. However, while the ability to play at the level Fantasy plays at is to be commended, the ability to play like that through a major league is another beast altogether. Fantasy rules ass, in my mind he's one of the best Terrans around. We'll have to see where he goes in MSL/OSL. Or perhaps he'll find himself at the bottom of September's PR, depending on what the list I'm satisfied with is. If FBH brushes up his TvP, I feel we could see much better play out of him. Champion material? Not even, but he could probbaly make it to RO38 of any starleague. Problem is, he's probably too weathered to make a huge difference in his play now. I agree about Fantasy, what a badass. And Leta too, holy fuck. I'd be shocked if he wasn't in the top 4 next PR tbh.
No i would rather have Much every time in the PR instead of him .
|
Russian Federation4333 Posts
On August 28 2008 00:31 Shinrei wrote:Show nested quote +On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote:On August 15 2008 18:13 Tinithor wrote: I think forgg should still be #2 next month atleast. Losing to much and stork TvP is nothing to be ashamed of. Especially since he's been practicing for 3 leagues simultaneously. Also i don't think you can even count losing to much against him. He had to play 8 games on the same day. Gotta give the guy a break. The real reason why Forgg should be #2 next month is because there is no other player who deserves that spot. Flash was stomed in GSL and WCG and Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Who can take it, Leta? Much? he is hot in only 1 match up and isn't even on the PR. Forgg is a definite second. Well that no-name toss is Tempest)Is( and he has been a pro for a long time. And did you even watch that game? Tempest is no bad player. If you have been a pro for one year and have only played 5 televized games you are a no name in my eyes when you come up against someone like Luxury.
The point of the post was that Luxury is in no contention for a top spot. Luxury was a heavy favourite against tempest and lossing to him and being eliminated from an SL is going to knock Luxury into a lower spot. So even if tempest played really well, it doesn't change the fact that Lux is going to get dropped in the rankings.
|
On August 28 2008 04:27 TheTyranid wrote:Show nested quote +On August 28 2008 00:31 Shinrei wrote:On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote:On August 15 2008 18:13 Tinithor wrote: I think forgg should still be #2 next month atleast. Losing to much and stork TvP is nothing to be ashamed of. Especially since he's been practicing for 3 leagues simultaneously. Also i don't think you can even count losing to much against him. He had to play 8 games on the same day. Gotta give the guy a break. The real reason why Forgg should be #2 next month is because there is no other player who deserves that spot. Flash was stomed in GSL and WCG and Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Who can take it, Leta? Much? he is hot in only 1 match up and isn't even on the PR. Forgg is a definite second. Well that no-name toss is Tempest)Is( and he has been a pro for a long time. And did you even watch that game? Tempest is no bad player. If you have been a pro for one year and have only played 5 televized games you are a no name in my eyes when you come up against someone like Luxury. The point of the post was that Luxury is in no contention for a top spot. Luxury was a heavy favourite against tempest and lossing to him and being eliminated from an SL is going to knock Luxury into a lower spot. So even if tempest played really well, it doesn't change the fact that Lux is going to get dropped in the rankings.
That same noname toss you are talking about 2-0'd July out of the MSL in the offline qualifiers, and July is arguablly top 3 ZvP with Luxury and Jaedong joining him.If anything this means Tempest is one player to look out for and its not Luxury's weakness.
|
On August 28 2008 05:16 samachking wrote:Show nested quote +On August 28 2008 04:27 TheTyranid wrote:On August 28 2008 00:31 Shinrei wrote:On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote:On August 15 2008 18:13 Tinithor wrote: I think forgg should still be #2 next month atleast. Losing to much and stork TvP is nothing to be ashamed of. Especially since he's been practicing for 3 leagues simultaneously. Also i don't think you can even count losing to much against him. He had to play 8 games on the same day. Gotta give the guy a break. The real reason why Forgg should be #2 next month is because there is no other player who deserves that spot. Flash was stomed in GSL and WCG and Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Who can take it, Leta? Much? he is hot in only 1 match up and isn't even on the PR. Forgg is a definite second. Well that no-name toss is Tempest)Is( and he has been a pro for a long time. And did you even watch that game? Tempest is no bad player. If you have been a pro for one year and have only played 5 televized games you are a no name in my eyes when you come up against someone like Luxury. The point of the post was that Luxury is in no contention for a top spot. Luxury was a heavy favourite against tempest and lossing to him and being eliminated from an SL is going to knock Luxury into a lower spot. So even if tempest played really well, it doesn't change the fact that Lux is going to get dropped in the rankings. That same noname toss you are talking about 2-0'd July out of the MSL in the offline qualifiers, and July is arguablly top 3 ZvP with Luxury and Jaedong joining him.If anything this means Tempest is one player to look out for and its not Luxury's weakness. I generally would agree, and Tempest certainly didn't play bad. But Luxury made several mistakes, most notably canceling his lair. Plain and simple, Luxury didn't play like the 5th best player in the world, neither in that game, or in the losers match. Failing to play your best when needed the most generally lead to demotion on the PR.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 28 2008 05:24 Fwmeh wrote:Show nested quote +On August 28 2008 05:16 samachking wrote:On August 28 2008 04:27 TheTyranid wrote:On August 28 2008 00:31 Shinrei wrote:On August 16 2008 06:31 TheTyranid wrote:On August 15 2008 18:13 Tinithor wrote: I think forgg should still be #2 next month atleast. Losing to much and stork TvP is nothing to be ashamed of. Especially since he's been practicing for 3 leagues simultaneously. Also i don't think you can even count losing to much against him. He had to play 8 games on the same day. Gotta give the guy a break. The real reason why Forgg should be #2 next month is because there is no other player who deserves that spot. Flash was stomed in GSL and WCG and Luxury just got eliminated from an SL by a no name toss. Who can take it, Leta? Much? he is hot in only 1 match up and isn't even on the PR. Forgg is a definite second. Well that no-name toss is Tempest)Is( and he has been a pro for a long time. And did you even watch that game? Tempest is no bad player. If you have been a pro for one year and have only played 5 televized games you are a no name in my eyes when you come up against someone like Luxury. The point of the post was that Luxury is in no contention for a top spot. Luxury was a heavy favourite against tempest and lossing to him and being eliminated from an SL is going to knock Luxury into a lower spot. So even if tempest played really well, it doesn't change the fact that Lux is going to get dropped in the rankings. That same noname toss you are talking about 2-0'd July out of the MSL in the offline qualifiers, and July is arguablly top 3 ZvP with Luxury and Jaedong joining him.If anything this means Tempest is one player to look out for and its not Luxury's weakness. I generally would agree, and Tempest certainly didn't play bad. But Luxury made several mistakes, most notably canceling his lair. Plain and simple, Luxury didn't play like the 5th best player in the world, neither in that game, or in the losers match. Failing to play your best when needed the most generally lead to demotion on the PR.
This is true. Tempest is worth respect, but Luxury certainly didn't play up to his ability.
And fear not, Much fans. I see a return in the future
|
Is Sea making the September power rank, or does he have to prove he can get past the Ro16 in a Starleague first? 8-2 in August and in both leagues is better than just about everyone else.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 28 2008 09:00 ShadowDrgn wrote: Is Sea making the September power rank, or does he have to prove he can get past the Ro16 in a Starleague first? 8-2 in August and in both leagues is better than just about everyone else.
Yes, Sea will be on the power rank. He destroyed basically everyone he played, and looked great doing it.
|
On August 27 2008 13:43 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Show nested quote +On August 26 2008 10:36 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: FBH is a great player, but hasn't been top 10 material for quite some time. Personally I'm a huge fan, but he won't be in the top 10 next month.
Fantasy is another player I really like. I was confident he'd win his MST group, and he did. I was confident he'd win his OSL Round 1 group, and he did. However, while the ability to play at the level Fantasy plays at is to be commended, the ability to play like that through a major league is another beast altogether. Fantasy rules ass, in my mind he's one of the best Terrans around. We'll have to see where he goes in MSL/OSL. Or perhaps he'll find himself at the bottom of September's PR, depending on what the list I'm satisfied with is. If FBH brushes up his TvP, I feel we could see much better play out of him. Champion material? Not even, but he could probbaly make it to RO38 of any starleague. Problem is, he's probably too weathered to make a huge difference in his play now. I agree about Fantasy, what a badass. And Leta too, holy fuck. I'd be shocked if he wasn't in the top 4 next PR tbh. Pssht all he needs to do is pull a casy = gg.
Forgg for the shortest 1# reign ever?
Lost quite a few as of recent memory.
|
On August 28 2008 10:47 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:Show nested quote +On August 28 2008 09:00 ShadowDrgn wrote: Is Sea making the September power rank, or does he have to prove he can get past the Ro16 in a Starleague first? 8-2 in August and in both leagues is better than just about everyone else. Yes, Sea will be on the power rank. He destroyed basically everyone he played, and looked great doing it. What about Jangbi and Kal?
;_;
|
On August 28 2008 13:39 ScarFace wrote:Show nested quote +On August 28 2008 10:47 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:On August 28 2008 09:00 ShadowDrgn wrote: Is Sea making the September power rank, or does he have to prove he can get past the Ro16 in a Starleague first? 8-2 in August and in both leagues is better than just about everyone else. Yes, Sea will be on the power rank. He destroyed basically everyone he played, and looked great doing it. What about Jangbi and Kal? ;_;
He's already hinted at Jangbi making an appearance.
There's no reason Kal would drop significantly.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
This is the most interesting month in quite a long time. There are a lot of players who are coming out of slumps, or just in general playing very well. Methinks the CBNC section will be quite full next week
|
On August 28 2008 13:39 ScarFace wrote:Show nested quote +On August 28 2008 10:47 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:On August 28 2008 09:00 ShadowDrgn wrote: Is Sea making the September power rank, or does he have to prove he can get past the Ro16 in a Starleague first? 8-2 in August and in both leagues is better than just about everyone else. Yes, Sea will be on the power rank. He destroyed basically everyone he played, and looked great doing it. What about Jangbi and Kal? ;_;
They suck :/
|
On August 28 2008 07:02 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:And fear not, Much fans. I see a return in the future 
:D :D :D
|
Much is solid, he should manage to make some appearances. : )
|
Much is so odd, hes hot one month, going far, slips just a bit- still a great player, contender for 10th, 11th, etc, and then the next month hes back to good old much. He's being doing this since like...the GSI?
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 29 2008 07:44 ScarFace wrote: Much is so odd, hes hot one month, going far, slips just a bit- still a great player, contender for 10th, 11th, etc, and then the next month hes back to good old much. He's being doing this since like...the GSI?
since 2006
|
Dealer
Sweden1368 Posts
Stork IS the 2nd player in the world atm, 2nd only to JD.
|
On August 29 2008 16:13 Dealer wrote: Stork IS the 2nd player in the world atm, 2nd only to JD. LMFAO
|
3 Lions
United States3705 Posts
On August 29 2008 16:13 Dealer wrote: Stork IS the 2nd player in the world atm, 2nd only to JD. maybe after he WINS a starleague or two
|
Well, you don't have to win anything to be second place, right?
|
On August 29 2008 16:13 Dealer wrote: Stork IS the 2nd player in the world atm, 2nd only to JD.
He's doing well. He took out ForGG and Much, and he looked great when he did it. Especially his PvP v.s Much. But his list of opponents in the OSL honestly weren't in the same class of skill that he was. Pure and simple.
I have pretty big hopes for Stork this season, but 2nd place is a stretch.
|
On August 31 2008 01:35 DoctorHelvetica wrote: I have pretty big hopes for Stork this season, but 2nd place is a stretch. there is no 2nd place that is out of Stork's reach.
|
On August 31 2008 08:19 MCMcEmcee wrote:Show nested quote +On August 31 2008 01:35 DoctorHelvetica wrote: I have pretty big hopes for Stork this season, but 2nd place is a stretch. there is no 2nd place that is out of Stork's reach.
hahahahah yesss
|
I'm just going to throw Bisu's name out there for CBNC since he has had a decent month qualifying for both leagues. Being able to take a bo3 from Iris when hes in decent form is an acheivment.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On August 31 2008 17:56 Nick_54 wrote: I'm just going to throw Bisu's name out there for CBNC since he has had a decent month qualifying for both leagues. Being able to take a bo3 from Iris when hes in decent form is an acheivment.
Yes, let there be no mistake about this. The way Iris played in August, Bisu taking him down 2-1 is a pretty big deal.
|
Looks like the CNBC will be larger then the actual Rank ...
|
when will the september power rank be up?
|
I got to say that Stork DESERVES a spot in the PR next week. so does bisu again.
also i HAVE to see Leta in like top5 in the next one. I bet Zerg will take 1 and 2. Leta will maybe 3. Then Stork
|
Leta plays really strong. top 5 defo + Show Spoiler +just watched his game vs Sea recently. Tho Sea defended really well and almost came back, Letas TvT just blew it. How he took advantage of Seas slightly wrong placed tanks and sniped couple from range including nice wraith micro at the start. That was epic.
|
Rankings will really depend on how indipendt the power rank is I would make the argument that Forgg and possibly Flash (although I don't thinks so) don't deserve a spot if you don't count previous form. Both went out in the Ro8 WCG and Forgg didn't qualify for the OSL flash did but he only has half the games to play. Flash got owned in the GOM finals. Forgg didn't play anyother games (didn't check that)
|
On September 01 2008 11:32 sillyboy_tomato wrote: I got to say that Stork DESERVES a spot in the PR next week. so does bisu again.
also i HAVE to see Leta in like top5 in the next one. I bet Zerg will take 1 and 2. Leta will maybe 3. Then Stork
No Bisu , stork maybe ...
|
I love Stork but I dunno if he's a number 2. He's definitely top 10 in August. Of course, now that I think about it, I'm not sure I can name anyone other than Jaedong that looked better in August. Flash looked terrible in GOM, maybe he looked better in quals, though. Hard to say fOrGG or Luxury is better when Stork beat them both in August. I do think Flash would beat Stork in a bo3 or bo5 if it was held today, but maybe Stork would win that if it wasn't a finals. Flash did have a much tougher road in qualifying for the OSL (had to beat EffOrt). Then again, in WCG Korea, he got demolished by Much, who got demolished by Stork. As long as Stork is somewhere in the new PR I won't accuse FakeSteve of being in denial.
|
I think you all are forgetting that I find it very unlikely Sea does not get #1 after his sign on the picture.
|
On September 02 2008 08:19 Deathwizard77 wrote:I think you all are forgetting that I find it very unlikely Sea does not get #1 after his sign on the picture.  yeah, wow, I didn't realize Sea was 8-3 in August. Losing to Calm (31% ZvT) isn't pretty, but wins against Kal and BeSt are nice.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
well against calm he went 3 port wraith
not the brightest move
|
when does the next pr arrive, steve?
|
Neeext!
Seriously, Jaedong has to be #1 now.
|
This will be a really intresting power rank with so many players playing really good atm.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On September 02 2008 22:37 Scorch wrote: when does the next pr arrive, steve?
Should be tomorrow or Friday, I'm still mulling some things over
|
let me clinch it for you, yes Jangbi and Kal DO deserve to be on the power rank
^_^
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
jangbi hasn't had a stellar month, there may be more deserving candidates
|
August was a difficult month to judge for PR, methinks. The contenders didn't really play each other all that muc
|
Dealer
Sweden1368 Posts
On August 30 2008 01:59 ScarFace wrote:Show nested quote +On August 29 2008 16:13 Dealer wrote: Stork IS the 2nd player in the world atm, 2nd only to JD. LMFAO
Name any player (Jae excluded) that played better during august.
When you fail, learn the basics about this game...
Sure, Stork had it easy in OGN quals, so did many others, and failed. Stork raped his group.
He flew past the WCG qualifier, never looked in danger from what i saw (the final was a joke fyi).
|
On September 06 2008 04:18 Dealer wrote:Show nested quote +On August 30 2008 01:59 ScarFace wrote:On August 29 2008 16:13 Dealer wrote: Stork IS the 2nd player in the world atm, 2nd only to JD. LMFAO Name any player (Jae excluded) that played better during august. When you fail, learn the basics about this game... Sure, Stork had it easy in OGN quals, so did many others, and failed. Stork raped his group. He flew past the WCG qualifier, never looked in danger from what i saw (the final was a joke fyi). I'd rather just wait for the September power rank to embarrass you.
|
3 Lions
United States3705 Posts
jaedong is first ez, with Flash or Stork in 2nd, as they are still in both leagues
|
On September 06 2008 05:23 3 Lions wrote: jaedong is first ez, with Flash or Stork in 2nd, as they are still in both leagues
I think this is a bad arguement because then I can say things like Backho is in both leagues he should be number 2.
|
The problem is the top players played very few games. Flash for instance went 0-3 against Jaedong 1-2 against Much and other than that didn't lose a game. He only played maybe 6 (2 OSL 2 WCG) Forgg won a some games in WCG (not sure how many) lost in the same round of WCG as flash and failed out of the OSL round of 36.
Even though they are definatly 2 of the best players playing since they didn't have enough games their months look really bad.
|
when you say, "jaedong 1st ez" you dont take in count that he failed to qualify to OSL?
|
On September 06 2008 10:57 ThePhan2m wrote: when you say, "jaedong 1st ez" you dont take in count that he failed to qualify to OSL? You don't take into account that A) that was last month and B)He RAPED the Shit out of everyone he faced in the WCG, no one was even close to beating. Nowhere , they were as close as the chances of me getting a CJ shirt.
|
On September 06 2008 13:32 xenero wrote:Show nested quote +On September 06 2008 10:57 ThePhan2m wrote: when you say, "jaedong 1st ez" you dont take in count that he failed to qualify to OSL? You don't take into the account that A) that was last month and B)He RAPED the Shit out of everyone he faced in the WCG, no one was even close to beating. Nowhere , they were as close as the chances of me getting a CJ shirt.
Not to mention, ForGG can't keep up his TvP against recent Protoss players...Jaedong on the other hand, his weakest matchup ZvT is still monstrous
|
So, next PR: 1. Definatelly Jaedong - bestmonth since november 2. Stork - raping shit, choking in finals 3. Flash - beating JD in All Star, in both leagues 4. Much - beat fOrGG, Flash, embarass FBH 5. Sea - walking over, loosing to Calm 6. July - some quiet games but good in WCG 7. Leta - very good 8. Luxury - 3rd in WCG, 1 league qualified, one lost 9. BeSt[HyO]- took beatings from all above 10. fOrGG - beat by Much and others
CNBC: JangBi, Bisu, Mind, GGPlay, Thezerg, RuBy, Midas YellOw[ArnC], BackHo,
|
On September 06 2008 18:54 Phradamon wrote:So, next PR: 1. Definatelly Jaedong - bestmonth since november 2. Stork - raping shit, choking in finals 3. Flash - beating JD in All Star, in both leagues 4. Much - beat fOrGG, Flash, embarass FBH 5. Sea - walking over, loosing to Calm6. July - some quiet games but good in WCG 7. Leta - very good 8. Luxury - 3rd in WCG, 1 league qualified, one lost 9. BeSt[HyO]- took beatings from all above 10. fOrGG - beat by Much and others CNBC: JangBi, Bisu, Mind, GGPlay, Thezerg, RuBy, Midas YellOw[ArnC], BackHo,
LoL i don't know if you place ForGG #10 because Much beat him or because he is in the hospital ? Much has been rapeing terrans lately i hope he starts rapeing in other MU's also ... I doubt that FakeSteve will place Stork # 2 , there is higher chance that will see Sea up there .
|
dont think there was much to rate players this month just because i got the impression there r no fuckin games played at all
|
On September 07 2008 08:38 {ToT}ColmA wrote: dont think there was much to rate players this month just because i got the impression there r no fuckin games played at all
It just seems that way because of the absence of PL, but there have been enough games to make a valued judgement.
|
On September 06 2008 18:54 Phradamon wrote:10. fOrGG - beat by Much and others
Dont forget, ForGG had 3 Bo3's to practice for on the same day. He 2-0'd BIsu and 2-1 Shark that day. Much is no noob, so its not an easy task for ForGG
|
when's the PR gonna be up? you promised two days ago and it still isn't up. Much blood will be shed if its not up soon..
|
On September 07 2008 23:55 Ohforf wrote: when's the PR gonna be up? you promised two days ago and it still isn't up. Much blood will be shed if its not up soon..
FS don't work on weekends
and btw, you might want to lay off on the threats until your post count gets a little higher
|
3 Lions
United States3705 Posts
On September 06 2008 07:46 Nick_54 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 06 2008 05:23 3 Lions wrote: jaedong is first ez, with Flash or Stork in 2nd, as they are still in both leagues I think this is a bad arguement because then I can say things like Backho is in both leagues he should be number 2. no you can't because it is not possible to compare Backho to Stork or Flash
|
On September 08 2008 03:15 3 Lions wrote:Show nested quote +On September 06 2008 07:46 Nick_54 wrote:On September 06 2008 05:23 3 Lions wrote: jaedong is first ez, with Flash or Stork in 2nd, as they are still in both leagues I think this is a bad arguement because then I can say things like Backho is in both leagues he should be number 2. no you can't because it is not possible to compare Backho to Stork or Flash
BackHO eliminated Stork in the GOM league he could do it again here . Remember he eliminated Bisu and JangBI from last OSL too . But Stork doesn't have a weak machup even his vs Zerg is miles better then BackHO . Backho's PvT is not weak he could upset Sea if he doesn't play great .
|
On September 08 2008 03:15 3 Lions wrote:Show nested quote +On September 06 2008 07:46 Nick_54 wrote:On September 06 2008 05:23 3 Lions wrote: jaedong is first ez, with Flash or Stork in 2nd, as they are still in both leagues I think this is a bad arguement because then I can say things like Backho is in both leagues he should be number 2. no you can't because it is not possible to compare Backho to Stork or Flash
I'm just saying that Stork and Flash making both leagues automatically makes them better than a player like ForGG
Edit: Hopefully time does not fly by again and we miss another month power rank.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On September 07 2008 23:55 Ohforf wrote: when's the PR gonna be up? you promised two days ago and it still isn't up. Much blood will be shed if its not up soon..
I've been working my real job and catching up with a friend who just moved back to town after two years
havent had much time for anything else the last couple of days, sorry! it'll be up soon! I'm sure as fuck not waiting until OSL starts
|
let's speculate 'bout the new ranking; my guess: 1. Jaedong 2. Stork (hot as hell: imba PvT, raped the shit out of Luxury and Much; one of the fav. in the OSL and the WCG) 3. forgg (you can't really count his loss vs. Much, very unlucky timetable) 4. Flash 5. Much (the old man is doing well again) 6. Luxury (a little shaky lately) 7. Midas 8. Sea (maybe this time he'll be able to make it to the ro4 in a league) 9. Best (not that great recently) 10. Leta CBNC: Bisu (actually we might see his comeback; impressive vs. Iris, only P who stands a chance vs. Jaedong; sad to say, group A is as difficult as the finals), July (pretty poor OSL champion, only 1 good matchup), FBH
|
July only one good match up???
uh did you not see him win his all Z group?
not to say his zvt is bad either... just wasn't really tested
|
yeah...if your going to knock July off for having "only one good match up" why the fuck is Much at number 5?
Bias ftl.
|
On September 09 2008 00:42 Polar_Bear wrote: let's speculate 'bout the new ranking; my guess: 1. Jaedong 2. Stork (hot as hell: imba PvT, raped the shit out of Luxury and Much; one of the fav. in the OSL and the WCG) 3. forgg (you can't really count his loss vs. Much, very unlucky timetable) 4. Flash 5. Much (the old man is doing well again) 6. Luxury (a little shaky lately) 7. Midas 8. Sea (maybe this time he'll be able to make it to the ro4 in a league) 9. Best (not that great recently) 10. Leta CBNC: Bisu (actually we might see his comeback; impressive vs. Iris, only P who stands a chance vs. Jaedong; sad to say, group A is as difficult as the finals), July (pretty poor OSL champion, only 1 good matchup), FBH
Leta jumps down to ten?
He's hot as FUCK right now. He dropped one game to Canata after a ten game win-streak, then proceeded to victory against Shuttle. Leta is doing better than BeSt, he's doing better than Much AND Lux.
He's amazing these days. Fantasy needs CBNC, also.
|
I hope BackHo makes CBNC this time
|
On September 08 2008 05:23 Nick_54 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 08 2008 03:15 3 Lions wrote:On September 06 2008 07:46 Nick_54 wrote:On September 06 2008 05:23 3 Lions wrote: jaedong is first ez, with Flash or Stork in 2nd, as they are still in both leagues I think this is a bad arguement because then I can say things like Backho is in both leagues he should be number 2. no you can't because it is not possible to compare Backho to Stork or Flash I'm just saying that Stork and Flash making both leagues automatically makes them better than a player like ForGG Edit: Hopefully time does not fly by again and we miss another month power rank.
This is not true. Both Stork and Flash could be eliminated by an on-fire Much. ForGG played 9 games that day, and managed get into the MSL but was 1 game away from getting into the OSL too.
You can also argue that the strength of the groups is unbalanced. Rock made it into the OSL - does that mean he's better than ForGG? No way.
Much also made it into the MSL and OSL, I think. He was the last player to be both leagues last season and yet he's never gotten top 3, ever.
Basically, the gist of my argument is that just because you're only in 1 league does not make you an inferior player.
|
On September 07 2008 23:40 o3.power91 wrote:Dont forget, ForGG had 3 Bo3's to practice for on the same day. He 2-0'd BIsu and 2-1 Shark that day. Much is no noob, so its not an easy task for ForGG
ForGG, to be fair lost one game to Shark, 2 to Much, 2 to Stork. Its not quite top material, you know, he was slopy this month, everyone in my PR deserves much more to be over Frogy (best streak, impressive manner of games, being in both leagues or having results at WCG).
|
On September 09 2008 11:57 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Show nested quote +On September 09 2008 00:42 Polar_Bear wrote: let's speculate 'bout the new ranking; my guess: 1. Jaedong 2. Stork (hot as hell: imba PvT, raped the shit out of Luxury and Much; one of the fav. in the OSL and the WCG) 3. forgg (you can't really count his loss vs. Much, very unlucky timetable) 4. Flash 5. Much (the old man is doing well again) 6. Luxury (a little shaky lately) 7. Midas 8. Sea (maybe this time he'll be able to make it to the ro4 in a league) 9. Best (not that great recently) 10. Leta CBNC: Bisu (actually we might see his comeback; impressive vs. Iris, only P who stands a chance vs. Jaedong; sad to say, group A is as difficult as the finals), July (pretty poor OSL champion, only 1 good matchup), FBH Leta jumps down to ten? He's hot as FUCK right now. He dropped one game to Canata after a ten game win-streak, then proceeded to victory against Shuttle. Leta is doing better than BeSt, he's doing better than Much AND Lux. He's amazing these days. Fantasy needs CBNC, also. He lost to JD in the OSL offlines then JD lost to han :/
|
3 Lions
United States3705 Posts
On September 08 2008 05:23 Nick_54 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 08 2008 03:15 3 Lions wrote:On September 06 2008 07:46 Nick_54 wrote:On September 06 2008 05:23 3 Lions wrote: jaedong is first ez, with Flash or Stork in 2nd, as they are still in both leagues I think this is a bad arguement because then I can say things like Backho is in both leagues he should be number 2. no you can't because it is not possible to compare Backho to Stork or Flash I'm just saying that Stork and Flash making both leagues automatically makes them better than a player like ForGG Edit: Hopefully time does not fly by again and we miss another month power rank. so are you saying that Stork is better than Jaedong? 0_o
|
On September 09 2008 23:10 raga4ka wrote:Show nested quote +On September 09 2008 11:57 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On September 09 2008 00:42 Polar_Bear wrote: let's speculate 'bout the new ranking; my guess: 1. Jaedong 2. Stork (hot as hell: imba PvT, raped the shit out of Luxury and Much; one of the fav. in the OSL and the WCG) 3. forgg (you can't really count his loss vs. Much, very unlucky timetable) 4. Flash 5. Much (the old man is doing well again) 6. Luxury (a little shaky lately) 7. Midas 8. Sea (maybe this time he'll be able to make it to the ro4 in a league) 9. Best (not that great recently) 10. Leta CBNC: Bisu (actually we might see his comeback; impressive vs. Iris, only P who stands a chance vs. Jaedong; sad to say, group A is as difficult as the finals), July (pretty poor OSL champion, only 1 good matchup), FBH Leta jumps down to ten? He's hot as FUCK right now. He dropped one game to Canata after a ten game win-streak, then proceeded to victory against Shuttle. Leta is doing better than BeSt, he's doing better than Much AND Lux. He's amazing these days. Fantasy needs CBNC, also. He lost to JD in the OSL offlines then JD lost to han :/
Losing one game to Jaedong doesn't throw you down to ten, nor does it compromise the fact that Leta is playing damn good and winning alot of games right now.
|
leta lost 2-0 to jaedong, but only one game was televised.
On September 08 2008 08:19 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: havent had much time for anything else the last couple of days, sorry! it'll be up soon! I'm sure as fuck not waiting until OSL starts :o
well, there are still a few hours.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
Hi guys, I gotta apologize. Life is hectic right now, cuz there's like a 90% chance i'm moving to the other side of the world fairly soon. I haven't even had time to play SC
|
Russian Federation4333 Posts
On September 10 2008 19:46 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:Hi guys, I gotta apologize. Life is hectic right now, cuz there's like a 90% chance i'm moving to the other side of the world fairly soon. I haven't even had time to play SC  Don't include the OSL games in the august PR.
|
argh now Much's blood will be shed....hope Forgg picks him for MSL group hehe.
|
United States10328 Posts
edit: um never mind, read fakesteve's post ;o
but still new power rank please
|
I take that back. Much shed much blood please, preferably FBH's....stop him doing that ceremony already!
|
I don't mean to seem rude or insulting, and I'm sorry for your troubles FakeSteve, but perhaps the duties of writing the PowerRank should be passed to another Administrator or Moderator?
It would be nice to have a fresh take on it regardless.
|
On September 11 2008 22:09 DoctorHelvetica wrote: I don't mean to seem rude or insulting, and I'm sorry for your troubles FakeSteve, but perhaps the duties of writing the PowerRank should be passed to another Administrator or Moderator?
It would be nice to have a fresh take on it regardless.
I agree. Suggested the same last month but an hour later the new rank was up.
Steve is fine, but since it's just for fun and it's been late like 4(?) months in a row now why not try someone else. It wouldn't be impossible to switch back, right? Also, I would personally enjoy to see how other knowledgeable players/commentators/forum veterans would do the rank.
Absolutely no offence to Steve, it's just that even good stuff gets old eventually.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
Actually for this month and next that would have been a fantastic idea. I didn't consider it, and I really have been that busy
|
So wait, is there no PR this month then ?
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On September 12 2008 09:14 Pokebunny wrote:So wait, is there no PR this month then ? 
there is! i have a few hours tonight so it'll be up.
that's tonight though, which means its still a good 8 hours before it'll be up
|
On September 12 2008 09:37 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:Show nested quote +On September 12 2008 09:14 Pokebunny wrote:So wait, is there no PR this month then ?  there is! i have a few hours tonight so it'll be up. that's tonight though, which means its still a good 8 hours before it'll be up nice Can you do me a favor, though? Can you stick Bisu at #1? Only then would I truly love you.
|
Thanks Steve :D big thanks for doing this through your issues/being busy. <3 power rank definitely waking up 10 minutes early to read it through before school tomorrow, hehe.
I'm guessing OSL week 1.1 isn't included?
|
On September 12 2008 09:37 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:Show nested quote +On September 12 2008 09:14 Pokebunny wrote:So wait, is there no PR this month then ?  there is! i have a few hours tonight so it'll be up. that's tonight though, which means its still a good 8 hours before it'll be up
Edit: TL.net time is 21:41 as I type this edit
|
On September 12 2008 10:30 tyr0 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 12 2008 09:37 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:On September 12 2008 09:14 Pokebunny wrote:So wait, is there no PR this month then ?  there is! i have a few hours tonight so it'll be up. that's tonight though, which means its still a good 8 hours before it'll be up nice Can you do me a favor, though? Can you stick Bisu at #1? Only then would I truly love you.
No bisu Much man Much .
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
GOddamnit! My flight ended up scheduled 24 hours before it was gonna be originally.
Therefore, this month's Power Rank will be written by DeadVessel! He watches as many games as I do, kid's a machine.
Again, sorry for all the delay I'm leaving for singapore at 4am edmonton local time tonight, see you all next weekend!
|
Well if its being done after the first week of OSL, Bisu for PR. He deserves it.
|
On September 13 2008 12:51 Nick_54 wrote: Well if its being done after the first week of OSL, Bisu for PR. He deserves it.
Wrong, this is for next PR, games were in september, not in august.
|
I don't see the point of writing a monthly power rank that is half a month outdated. Games already played this month should be factored in.
|
|
whats the point of asking someone to update your power rank if he is late as well =(
|
1. Jaedong - bestmonth since november 2. Stork - raping shit, choking in finals 3. Flash - beating JD in All Star, in both leagues 4. Much - beat fOrGG, Flash, embarass FBH 5. Sea - walking over, loosing to Calm 6. July - some quiet games but good in WCG 7. Leta - very good 8. Luxury - 3rd in WCG, 1 league qualified, one lost 9. BeSt[HyO]- took beatings from all above 10. fOrGG - beat by Much and others
CNBC: JangBi, Bisu, Mind, GGPlay, Thezerg, RuBy, Midas YellOw[ArnC], BackHo,
|
|
|
|