EPT[GG] Red Army Mafia - Page 4
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Zato-1
Chile4253 Posts
| ||
|
Zato-1
Chile4253 Posts
 | ||
|
Zato-1
Chile4253 Posts
On August 07 2009 01:59 chaoser wrote: he means, one mafia comes out by saying he's mafia, tell everyone to send the message they got from caller saying they are mafia. only people who send in a message that has the exact same wording would be mafia Brilliant. But, what happens if this person who comes out happens to have been a townie? Congrats, you've just given a list with all the mafia names to the Town! Ah, but mafia can make sure this person who came out is, in fact, mafia- through a role check at night! (edit: even then it could be an NKVD posing as mafia) Unless, of course, it's not one person claiming to be mafia and asking all mafia to roleclaim to them. It could be five people. In which case mafia can't RC them all and it all degenerates into one, huge mess. No, mafia could not have coordinated before the election. More importantly, mafia doesn't have the benefit of having a channel where they can discuss the wisdom of roleclaiming to someone- unlike the Town. (yes, I know I'm dead >< just posting my thoughts here. I wrote a big post about it in the sticky thread of the mafia forum). | ||
|
Zato-1
Chile4253 Posts
On August 07 2009 08:10 Caller wrote: You know, for people that haven't even gotten the win conditions yet, you sure are confident Psh, now you're acting like this is your game or something. O wait. Happy Birthday ^^ | ||
|
Zato-1
Chile4253 Posts
On August 08 2009 05:40 L wrote: They should have simply skipped rolechecks and went all out rapeshit insane, might lose a few in friendly fire, but the volume of hits they can produce is absolutely prodigious. That might've worked. You know what the mafia needed, badly? Some channel of communication. By this, I mean an equivalent to this thread, where people could anonymously discuss strategy for mafia. The only info source the mafia had was this thread, so we pretty much did what people said they were expecting of us- whatever seemed to make sense. If some mafia came up with an intelligent method for dealing with PM role phishing and contacting each other through PMs safely (and I did, eventually), posting a good tactic for mafia in this thread instantly made you suspicious. I'm not sure what would've been the best way to set this communication channel up. But you can be sure Mafia won't act intelligently if there can be no discussion as to how mafia can act intelligently. | ||
|
Zato-1
Chile4253 Posts
| ||
|
Zato-1
Chile4253 Posts
On August 17 2009 08:14 coltrane wrote: who killed me? I told yoou since day 1, dont trust ace. What? Ace was one of the biggest contributors to the Town. As the field marshal, the most likely way he could die was by getting lynched, so he did his best to stay on the Town's good side, by contributing against the mafia. No one suspects him, and the fewer mafia there are the smaller the chances all his bodyguards get killed. He never did the town any harm. | ||
|
Zato-1
Chile4253 Posts
On August 17 2009 10:49 Shikyo wrote: If rebels had no victory condition the whole game was just a farce so that you could reveal your amazing nazi idea? Stupid. Aw, that's harsh. My guess is: Caller had some notion of victory conditions but didn't have them set in stone. He felt that the Town outplayed the rebels overall, so towards the end when there were very few players still left and activity was nonexistent, he just decided to end it and hand victory to the side that did better overall. His saying "soviet power wins any way because the Ukrainians are weak" is just him talking as Comrade General Caller, I'm pretty sure. Was a good game Caller, shame about the inactivity towards the end though. | ||
| ||
