|
Found it! I'm also one of the guys who strictly uses the left sidebar. First visit to the forum index in like...6 months or so now. Anyways, really excited about this 
Edit: and I just read the rules, for some reason I just saw a mafia thread and thought "oh sweet, no need to read the rules, it'll most likely be exactly like the last mafia game I played". Either way, I'm caught up now. Edit2: Confirming that I received my role.
|
I say we vote snow the first 2-3 days. Then if it seems that the mafia's getting lucky with their kills we might do fog for 2 days after that, then move on to rain for pretty much the rest of the game unless we find a strong need for an assassin to make a kill (like we somehow get a really strong lead on more than one guy).
|
Sorry about not being active. I had a few things going on these past few days and got a little too lazy to read during the little free time I had. I'm catching up on the thread right now, I remember how much inactives sucked from the last game I played, so I apologize again for this.
|
Well, I figured it was probably best for me to lie low since I didn't have much of use to mention during the course of this game. The last two mafia games I played imo I think I hurt the town more than help since I'm usually quick to jump on really crappy clues, and start bandwagons with other people. I thought that with all the other people who are seemingly inactive, I'd be safe in just lying low until I had something good to contribute. If this makes me suspicious (which I already know it does, but as I mentioned, I figured I'd be safe considering the other inactives) then I guess I'll do more to contribute, even if it doesn't do the town much good =/
|
Also, my votes for BC and ydg probably have more to do with me being quick to hop on bandwagons as well...
|
(triple posting so my edits don't make me look like I'm hiding something)
and I guess me being quick to defend myself isn't helping my case. Whatever, I don't really think there's a strong enough case for any of the current alternatives for lynching, but I'll do my best to try to dig up any clues that haven't already been revealed for others.
|
Just curious, what link to spiders are you guys talking about? I only recall in the first day post that the former Emperor's uncle had an erratic fear of spiders, not exactly linking to a mafioso.
|
Wow...this just feels as if you just want to believe I'm mafia and are grasping at straws to point the finger at me. I'm not familiar with the way Plexa creates his clues, but all of your findings seem completely out there considering you're digging all of this up from a blog asking wtf Twilight was.
Considering I don't have any counters to your argument other than questioning your clue deciphering abilities I guess I have nothing to defend myself with =/ This is kind of the reason I didn't want to say much, since I tended to come up with random conclusions based on little evidence in my last games as well.
|
After all of this...I kind of, in an odd sort of way, hope I get lynched just to see how Pyrr tries to defend himself when I don't turn up red, because honestly, with the way you're pressing for everyone to go out of their way to come after me, you'd look pretty suspicious once I'm proven innocent.
|
On July 11 2009 11:07 Foolishness wrote:Show nested quote +On July 11 2009 11:01 Falcynn wrote: After all of this...I kind of, in an odd sort of way, hope I get lynched just to see how Pyrr tries to defend himself when I don't turn up red, because honestly, with the way you're pressing for everyone to go out of their way to come after me, you'd look pretty suspicious once I'm proven innocent. That's a terrible way of thinking. As well as very suspicious. Lol, I guess how you can see that. Although I don't want to be lynched obviously, just saying it'd seem a bit funny if it did happen considering the sudden attention he's given me.
|
I'm probably also leaning heavily on voting to lynch ecomania. Again, for all of the reasons ydg already pointed out. Usually I'd say that the clues against him seem pretty crappy, but as he has nothing on his profile but his name, I think it's safe to say that the clues are about as strong as they can be without being blatantly obvious.
|
|
|
On July 16 2009 16:31 Scaramanga wrote: This is from the mystic Either chaoser, Malongo, or Lenwe are a pledge hmmmmmmmmmmm Well, it seems that chaoser and Malongo are already on the chopping block, but it might be good to examine all three anyways...which seems to have already been going on. So I'm late, but ehhhhh, maybe I can help out. First, the voting record of all three since day one (top of their respective lists) to day 6 (their current vote anyways)
+ Show Spoiler + Chaoser
L
ydg abstain
ecomania
Faronel Pyrrhuloxia
Malongo
L
TruthBringer
BloodyCobbler
ecomania
Faronel Not voted yet
Lenwe Abstain
TruthBringer
BloodyCobbler
ecomania
Faronel Chaoser
As this shows, all of them except chaoser voted for Truthbringer to be lynched. Ecomania obviously had to be lynched as the two main candidates for that day were both mafia and it'd look suspicious for them not to vote for one of them. Also this could explain his relative lack of activity (I like to think that all pledges would probably lie low since they're the most susceptible to role and vote checks), and of course I say all of this with the realization that I voted for ydg and am relatively inactive as well. I'm not completely convinced that chaoser is the pledge in this list, and I'll try to do some further analysis (when they voted for their respective lynches and some clue analysis) later to make sure we're not making a mistake with this.
|
Bah, was about to edit, then thought against it. Anyways, if we were just voting for chaoser based on those two things listed above, then it would seem like a pretty bad bandwagon, but when compared to both Lenwe and Malongo, he seems the most likely to be mafia.
As I said, I'll look into Lenwe and Malongo and see if I can find any evidence that would make them more guilty than chaoser, but if I don't find anything, then I think chaoser would be our best candidate.
|
Well, I kind of suck with clues, but here's some basic analysis of their voting times.
+ Show Spoiler + Chaoser
L(don't think Emperor vote matters since both leading candidates were green)
ydg (originally abstained when it was too close to call, with neither candidate having more than 3 votes, then Truthbringer started gaining votes quickly, and when ydg started getting close again, he voted ydg) abstain (abstained 14 hours once the vote opened, then didn't change after that)
ecomania(voted for ecomania when the voting was tied 4-4. If chaoser is mafia, then this would make sense as motbob seemed to be more useful than ecomania.)
Faronel(second to vote, and voted to lynch me. He then changed and was the first to vote Faronel, being the first on the bandwagon. Prior to this he was in the lead to be lynched.) Pyrrhuloxia
Malongo
L
TruthBringer(quickly voted for heavonearth, then switched his vote when the vote was tied between ydg and Truthbringer at 5-5)
BloodyCobbler x 2(used both votes on BC when he was behind ecomania and kuja by 3 and 4 votes respectively, bandwagon started after this)
ecomania(voted last minute when ecomania was already clearly in the lead)
Faronel(voted fairly early and didn't switch) Not voted yet
Lenwe Abstain
TruthBringer(voted Truthbringer when the votes were tied 10-10 with ydg)
Kuja900/BloodyCobbler(originally voted Kuja-Falcynn, when Kuja was far in the lead with everyone else not no further than 3 votes. Then changed his vote from me to BloodyCobbler once ecomania fell behind BC 10-12)
ecomania(voted for ecomania when he was ahead, like my reasons for Chaoser, this makes sense since motbob was more useful it seems than motbob)
Faronel(voted when Faronel was ahead of everyone by over 5 votes) Chaoser
|
On July 17 2009 04:01 iNfuNdiBuLuM wrote: look at the fucking voting
notice that so many people voting for him have not even come in the thread to say why
does this not strike anyone as weird
falcynn i know you are green why can't you see this? Bah, I don't know. I was originally hoping that I could stall long enough for people to generate some discussion and get a clear pick. Although I guess that's not happening, my gut says chaoser though and I haven't gotten any reasonable support to say otherwise.
|
Although I'll admit, the sudden bandwagon voting is disturbing me...
|
Dude, don't edit your post like that 
Before his edit he mentioned clasic, Lenwe, and someone else (I refreshed and since apparently you can't unrefresh I missed the third guy) as his primary suspects. If he does turn out innocent then this may be worth noting.
|
Sorry for the triple post, but also, if we get this one wrong, we still have a chance at winning, but we can not miss a singly lynch after this.
|
On July 17 2009 09:07 Malongo wrote: If we lynch GF then other mafia takes the rol so mafia KP will be always 2 until theres only one mafia.
Actually, I'm pretty sure God Father's dead completely if we lynch him. The role gets passed on only if the assassin killed him.
|
On July 19 2009 21:28 Shikyo wrote: Too bad there is no more chaos, I'm sure that'd be the weather of today.
EDIT: Speaking of which, the idea of chaos is pretty interesting, but it requires something else. For example, having something like a satanic priest who has whatever powers it can use(quite powerful) that can only be used during chaos. That'd be cool. Like a mafia priest whose powers activate when less than half the town votes. At which point he can activate his powers to kill two townies and a random blue dies as well. This might promote more activity to prevent this.
Of course, I say this realizing that i didn't vote either Although in my defense I didn't really have too much access to a computer in the last two days, and the time I did have I just skimmed over the posts here and decided not to vote since I wasn't sure what was going on...although I guess I could have abstained at least...
|
On July 21 2009 01:26 Malongo wrote: Far from over. -We lynch Lenwe today 5v2 -They kill 3v2 -Mystic comes foward we kill Falcynn 3v1 -They kill 2v1 -Even if the last 2 morons fail the lynch its 1v1 LOL! And the 2 last people should get a fucking hint about how to use the weather to force a check. hmmmm...just wondering, if somehow it does get to 1v1, would it then be decided by the first person to post in the voting thread?
|
Damn it, why did I have to die like that? Could've given a bit more of a fight, but no, I had to be killed by some punk kid who got a lucky jump 
Edit: anyways, I hope now my play-style this game makes some sense. I still probably played badly, but hopefully it still seems justified somewhat.
|
On July 21 2009 22:13 motbob wrote: Scara had told Pyrr that Falcynn was mystic (I think.) So we killed him and Malongo, setting up lenwe's lynch. Damn it Pyrr, you scum 
I always suspected him, but when Scara told me to trust him, and then he PM'd me saying that scara told him I figured I had no choice =/
|
On July 21 2009 15:24 Chezinu wrote: I can't believe Falcynn never checked pyrr.. I was going to right before you guys fucking killed me 
I told Pyrr that I was going to check either Malongo or Lenwe hoping that by doing so he'd let me live for another day though =/
Edit: although TBH Pyrr did play well. If it wasn't for him accusing me earlier in the game (the only reason I held a grudge against him) I probably would've trusted him 100% as well.
|
|
|
|