|
There's also the metagaming aspect of lynching someone who acts like an idiot (same metagaming aspect behind lynching inactives): it discourages it as a mafia tactic.
It's really easy to play like an idiot in various ways and use lots of emotional appeals, regardless of alignment, and it's really easy to play the idiot defense. Just like it's really easy to just receive your role and lurk without posting content.
If we don't kill off players who try those things ... mafia will take advantage eventually.
Anyway unless you say something that demands a response I'm moving on now. Rayne looks like a good lynch (in the metagame aspect if nothing else) but we still need to look at other posters.
|
Go for it. You think I made mistakes?
I know I made mistakes.
I've nothing to hide right now. I'll call your bluff.
Shikyo wrote:
crate, the game isn't about lynching someone who "made mistakes" that you just got out of your ass, it's about lynching the mafia.
Yes and no. Yes in each individual game, but not entirely in the metagame sense. If you don't lynch stupid players then smart mafia will just act stupid and play the stupid card when called on it and they'll live. The game will eventually degrade into random finger-pointing with only clue analysis and DT and mafia-acting-like-DT roleclaims and such.
If you 14cc every game someone's going to BBS you until you stop doing it every game. It beats "standard play" but it's not the standard ... think about that for a bit. Same deal here.
|
"The lady doth protest too much, methinks"
|
hey
foolishness
i notice you didnt really contribute to this discussion other than more pointless prodding
are you going to be actually helpful?
Foolishness wrote:
You know crate, of those 8 people Shikyo has accused so far, only 2 have turned up to be townspeople, and the rest are up for grabs. I'm sure you have suspicions against one of those other 6 people as well (I know I do).
i mean, yeah, this says a whole lot huh? ... i said in my big post that i would look into ilovektf's posts again, so big stretch to say i'm suspicious mm?
mind outlining your suspicions?
preferably not just in a form where you just keep calling someone mafia till they agree to get you to shut up
And just for you Shikyo, I'll quote your post with plans so it isn't lost. No other motives on this one.
Shikyo wrote:
Everyone! After I turn up green, look up everyone who voted for me and either
a) voted for the other townie
b) didn't vote for the other person who turned red.
If they are already suspects, I suggest lynching them, or at least considering to. I suggest you forgive people like crate and JeeJee and vx70GTOJudgexv, since they're probably confused townies. However, anyone else doing that is a suspect! That's probably a good place to start trying to correct this mistake you're about to make. Also, if it seems like I'll die for sure, I'm going to PM some directions and suggestions as I'm going to sleep. Because my alignment will be confirmed if I get lynched, maybe they'll listen to me a bit more than they are right now.
After someone dies it's usually a good idea to read up on their posts anyway. At least skim them.
|
and yes foolishness
i post like this
when i talk to you
just so you can have fun with my style
i find it unspeakably amusing
|
Anyone roleclaim mafia? ^^
|
I'm following JeeJee on Rayne tbh.
|
JeeJee what's that PM you were waiting for earlier? Get it yet? Don't give us cryptic hints then fail to deliver please.
On May 25 2009 22:29 JeeJee wrote:
Ok, I'm waiting on a PM from someone, to throw out the final recommendation vote (i might have to tip my hat to the alphabet man this game after all, obscure reference)
however, for now, please everyone do the following:
vote for double lynch and vote for omg[rayne]
|
lol nevermind, i missed the post he made
|
On May 26 2009 00:36 JeeJee wrote:
already done crate
also, pm received, decision made
to recap, our plan for today
vote for double, shikyo and omg[rayne]
i regret some of the things i've done.. jayme should not have died, and shikyo shouldn't have known as much as he does right now
time to turn this town around and pull out the golden chains of justice oft promised
|
teks wrote:
All our links are so weak.
Which links do you think are weak?
|
teks wrote:
Basically all our clues. As in, we have no really obvious ones.
If you're talking about Shikyo, I just don't see how he can be mafia and not kill off a confirmed townie + a dt, even if it meant that he would have died in the process.
What does "all our clues" mean? Don't be so vague here please.
|
And teks I should be able to call you stupid for hitting zeks all game :p
|
I'm weighing Shikyo's behavior as far more important than clues. You want to follow clue analysis, go ahead. I agree with using it on inactives; we need something to go on to pick which one to hit and we can't use posts there.
How about all those clues linking to zeks? Didn't stop you last night....
Stopping you now since you whiffed last time? :p
|
|
|
This just looks like name-calling right now to me.
With the extra information I have now I'm not sure Shikyo is mafia, but I'm going to leave my vote where it is since I still think he fucked up day 2.
L : crate :: Ace : Shikyo
no the analogy isn't perfect, but it might turn out to be altogether too fitting.
lmao
|
|
|
What do you want me to post?
Who do you want me to vote for?
This is why you don't get what you want from me.
|
unless both of our lynches are red it hardly matters unless all three medics can see the mafia hitlist or something lol
|
btw if you want my medic lovin' tonight let me know
might as well roleclaim since Midori posted it publicly anyway so the mafia know (Koopie sniped this on day 1 somehow ... I knew I'd never be able to hide it from her so I just admitted it on MSN ^^)
teks if you have some sort of plan going on you can tell me
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
