The mafia's having a blast, I'm sure. Even in that PM that you posted, a mafioso said he's enjoying it.

Keep it going, if just a little bit longer. Perhaps inactivity is just their strategy of not drawing fire. The two remaining two meth dealers, and two remaining zombies, on the other hand, are trying to draw mafia fire, but being blatantly obvious with their roles does them no good. With all the blues being quiet, the greens have little incentive to speak as they would give the mafia higher odds at hitting a blue (assuming the mafia eliminates them as a possible blue). And the atmosphere becomes more quiet, so that the mafia has to kill as randomly as we do (well, they have much higher odds I suppose).

Others who play stupidly are probably so drenched in shame at this point that posting is the last thing they wish to do right now (I'm referring to those who were stupid enough to give away their roles). The mafia will probably target them this night and they know they can't do anything to protect themselves.

Ver, I responded to you by PM. If you wish, we can continue our conversation in public; I have no preferences.

Back on track -- Caller, you've devoted a lot of time to this game, so don't end it prematurely. Let it keep running. It's no fun because we're getting destroyed, but I suppose we might still be able to pull it off, depending on how many blues (and mafiosos) get killed tonight.

LucasWoJ

United States936 Posts

January 16 2009 03:58 GMT

#1114

We gg.

Edit: I find it odd no one listened to your arrows when the clue was pointed out. You were basically confirming that the clue analysis was correct. I'm disappointed.

LucasWoJ

United States936 Posts

January 16 2009 04:05 GMT

#1123

And I knew Ver was mafia from the "I'm green!" and the PM in which he claimed my logic was flawed. Clearly though, there was no flaw SUPPOSING IF he were mafia.

My guess is infundumbulum was converted.

LucasWoJ

United States936 Posts

January 16 2009 04:13 GMT

#1135

Malongo just wasn't playing this one right. Here's a PM I got from him the night before I died.

Original Message:
whats your role?
if really blue/green are you connected to mm circle?
if blue/green what are your main suspects of mafia?
whos gonna get hit from vigis?
name a dt.

Was chaoser your MVP? I was wondering why he stopped posting. When were each converted, Caller?

LucasWoJ

United States936 Posts

January 16 2009 04:21 GMT

#1143

Haha, I'm referring to the convenient discrepancies where you claimed you were inactive but used an active excuse to try to disprove my unforgiven_ve logic, which could very well have been a coincidence that didn't work too well for you. (I know that made no sense, so here goes again. I sent you a PM saying unforgiven is either a blue or red. You knew he's not red and asked to see the PMs so that you could confirm whether he's blue or not. I told you that I would show them to you after that night's lynching (which I guess might have been some sort of incentive to keep me alive). He dies and you come on again about two days later (after the lynching) and point out that my logic is flawed when it clearly isn't

I suppose I went too far to say yours was incorrect. It was there. I meant to say that, basically, you were claiming to be FAR less active than you appeared to be than the impression you gave off.)

I'm rather impressed with how Incognito played his role. For the majority of the game, I was convinced he was a blue.

LucasWoJ

United States936 Posts

January 16 2009 04:27 GMT

#1144

On January 16 2009 13:18 malongo wrote:

Show nested quote +

I wasnt playing right??? hey man next time someone asks you to clear you and someone else then agree with the fucking double lynch ok??? your defence lucasjow/nevake was so fucking bad that i thought all time you were mafia. Why didnt you call for the double lynch?

My defense only seemed bad because you're bad at this game, lol. It was plain nevake was acting on impulse and I think he was convinced towards the end that I wasn't mafia either.

Why would I have called for the double lynch? lol

Looking at the roles, I feel this game was very stacked against the town. The mafia shouldn't have had more than 6 players originally in this type of game (with inactive townies). With the mole, the uncertainty, AND the GF's conversions, this game was impossible to win after the day 2 lynching didn't work out. We should have looked at the clues more though.

By the way, Ver, did mafia inform you of your role before Caller, or did you go in "clean"? haha

LucasWoJ

United States936 Posts

January 16 2009 04:44 GMT

#1156

On January 16 2009 13:38 Incognito wrote:
@ Lucas - You never even talked to me.

But I could read the things you posted on the forums. You played your role very well. I actually had a word document with everyone's name and a little note next to each. Although I didn't save it, I remember simply writing "blue? Slight chance he's green, but he's not mafia." I'm not sure how I arrived at that conclusion, but you convinced me. What role did you end up roleclaiming?

It would have sucked had the vote rigger actually been recruited by the mafia. o.o Just shows once again why the GF should never have had that ability.

LucasWoJ

United States936 Posts

January 16 2009 05:03 GMT

#1171

I wasn't in an inner-circle the entire game lol. I genuinely had no idea what nevake's + amber[light]'s roles were until minutes before the night post was up. I never spoke with nevake nor amber[light], and I only sent scaramanga a few replies to his PMs. He came out and told me he was the jack. I also thought randombum was mafia for a large portion of the game if you were insinuating that he was a part of an inner circle with me.

And there was no such thing as an inner circle this game, with the exception of chaoser/mikeymoo (and when chaoser seemed to make it obvious that he was the medic who had protected mikeymoo the night before) which is why this game was imbalanced.

I'm going to throw this out again: the reason the boondock saint thing was able to work was because of the godfather's imbalanced abilities in this game. With so much uncertainty about the number of roles, the GF can only be killed by chance.