LOL indeed he wasn't. Well, I can't help it then, but every goddamn Towny who is completely inactive and does zero the whole game (I mean in this thread AND any inside circle), seriously hurts the Town just as any mafia.

I too was absolutely sure ShadowDrgn was Mafia. Now we still have a 1/2 on that list then. Try linking any clues to either Folca or Nevake.

If you have any doubts as to why I am the vigi, read the clues, it always says something about sucking out electricity.

Mynock

4492 Posts

December 23 2008 22:22 GMT

#1022

OK, Update Time!

Original 5/10 list:

malongo
ydg
kdog3683
meegrean
artanis[xp]
amber[light]
kuja900
Ver
MidnightGladius
DecafChicken

Updated list:

malongo
ydg
artanis[xp]
kuja900

THREE of the four are Mafia.

Also:

Folca
Nevake

ONE of the two is Mafia.

And I'm not going to go by clues anymore, cause I obviously can't see any logic in them at all :p I even needed help finding out my own, so... I'll just feed the Town info about any other Mafias as I get it myself.

Fishball

Canada4788 Posts

December 23 2008 22:32 GMT

#1023

The 4 people alive are on both lists.
So if we put the clues aside, technically there is a 75% chance of lynching a mafia.randomly.

Lets do it alphabetically!

Vivi57

United States6599 Posts

December 23 2008 22:37 GMT

#1024

You guys are assuming the lists are legit

Mynock

4492 Posts

December 23 2008 22:38 GMT

#1025

The KP is now only 3. If all the info we have is true (and it an only be untrue if the DT providing the info is fake and the real DT never bothered to check the thread, in which case it was a lost cause from the very beginning, lol), then this game might actually go down to the wire, with just a few Townies vs a few Mafias left

Fishball

Canada4788 Posts

December 23 2008 22:44 GMT

#1026

On December 24 2008 07:37 Vivi57 wrote:
You guys are assuming the lists are legit

Nothing is legit.
Kill them all, only the colour of blood is legit!

ShadowDrgn

United States2497 Posts

December 23 2008 23:11 GMT

#1027

Sorry for not being able to convince you that not every clue involving fire, shadows, flying, swooping, etc. links to me. This happens to me every game. GL town.

JeeJee

Canada5652 Posts

December 23 2008 23:35 GMT

#1028

Yeah some names just don't bode well for mafia

I'm half inclined to put a quote that says something akin to "and from within the shadows he jumped and stabbed with a pointed weapon, laughing as he killed his victims, watching them suffer"

good luck trying to convince people otherwise with that sig

Amber[LighT]

United States5078 Posts

December 23 2008 23:35 GMT

#1029

Well at least we got one mafia! Good Luck town in the graveyard I go

Mynock

4492 Posts

December 24 2008 00:51 GMT

#1030

On December 24 2008 08:35 Amber[LighT] wrote:
Well at least we got one mafia! Good Luck town in the graveyard I go

It was a gj from your part

We're equal with killing 1 Mafia & 1 silent Townie this game

I so wanted to say "BOOM BABY" after today tho, lol...

Mynock

4492 Posts

December 24 2008 00:53 GMT

#1031

Btw, heads-up from the DT: The clue of "fear to contempt" did not refer to JeeJee after all. The DT did a clue check, and it turned up negative.

I have no idea what to make of these clues now tho. For starter, just let's stick to the lists we have, and then see what we can work out with any new clues.

Scaramanga

Australia8093 Posts

December 24 2008 01:07 GMT

#1032

wow man he was like the 100% mafia dude

CynanMachae

Canada1459 Posts

December 24 2008 05:49 GMT

#1033

Oh wow, ShadowDragon is not mafia.

I should probably have done any of this earlier, but now that I'm at home for holidays and have time, I might as well do it now. I'm bad at clue analysis, but I can do something with numbers, so I'll try that first. So mafia kill power is 3 now. Good thing that we have 3 vigilantes left, but we really need to avoid lynching any of those >< . On the worse case, let's say we loose 3 random townies tonight (51% to hit no vigilante/someone medic-protected). We are down to 16. Lynch one mafia (75% seems good.) Still 3 KP. So next round they get 2 hits and hit a vigi. 14. We lynch one, down to 2 KP, etc. I assume that we we should take 5 rounds (so 6 nights) getting all the 4 mafias (on the worse case 6). And by stats (if the mafia was played randomly) they would get around 10 (9 left) townies, and then be down to 2 mafias. Assuming they have some info and don't hit vigilantes/someone protected or are simply lucky, they might get as much as 13 (6 left), but still be down to 1 KP. (That is assumng the votelists are correct, else we are just definitely screwed) So yea I think we can do it, because after all this we SHOULD have enough clues to get the remaining two, especially with the number of people getting lower as the game goes on.

/cheer town

I'll try to see if I can do some clue analysis to find the other two/pin-point the four on the votelists, but I'm not sure what I can find out more right now