TL Mafia 2 [GG] - Page 302

In the case of Jtan/Nemy, there is a contradiction between the two players and therefore one is mafia and the other is innocent

On June 05 2008 11:02 ShaLLoW[baY] wrote:



Then you'd better lynch me first, because I'm "confirmed mafia" and I'm a townie; It'll show you how unreliable that fucking list is.

On June 05 2008 19:36 Alethios wrote:
Right....

So +10 posts from you Nemy without actually saying anything?

Good work.

-----------------

In regard to the contradiction... i'm going to go out on a limb here and tentatively suggest that there is only one Mr. Blond... so if say Nemy is evil on the turn (once Bockit turns red on the flop), jtan is good on the river...

On May 24 2008 02:01 Plexa wrote:
Summary of tonights findings before i sleep;

What me and associate agree on;
JimTudor is Mr Black
LTT is Mr Pink
SpiritOfTheTuna is CottonMouth
jtan as mafia
nemY is innocent (the clue we were pinning him on is shared by Alventenie ie impossible for the two to be differentiated)

What we disagree on;
Randombum vs 0cz3c for CopperHead

On May 22 2008 13:28 randombum wrote:



Plexa, your assuming mafia are stupid. You take for granted if mafia names someone, he is town, if mafia protects him, he is mafia. This is like poker where you assume if they bet they have a good hand, if they call/check they have a bad hand.

You are ignoring potential deception in which even mediocre mafia players will attempt since this is ultimately an (educated) guessing game. Clazz's posts are particularly suspect because he has been a large candidate for mafia, and his own actions have given him away, almost as if he wants to be caught. (such as clazz's: "I'm mafia") This actually LEADS me to suspect nemy.

This rivalry could have easily been a ploy between two mafia with one of them who would eventually go down protecting the other. Unless nemY has contributed something substantial that I missed then my suspicions will stay on him. (since usually thats how you identify real true townies, I mean mafia don't go handing out other mafia unless they are top suspects anyways.)

I also have suspicions of ninja since he has been a candidate, but its less substantial because clazz and unforgiven both voted him, maybe trying to save unforgiven.

All this is edited out if he flips green. (very unlikely)

Edit: LOL auto underline poker, I never knew

On June 05 2008 20:18 nemY wrote:
It's cool.

Personally I'm all for lynching Bockit then going with 0cz3z essentially following what Plexa & Ace gave us, then moving on from there

On June 05 2008 11:01 ShaLLoW[baY] wrote:
I don't really have an argument as to why I shouldn't be suspected, but I'm not Mafia. I don't even understand why I'm being suspected to be honest, and I don't know why I'm Mafia on unsoundlogic's list. If there are clues that you think point to me, please tell me, but I'm 100% innocent.

On June 06 2008 00:21 qrs wrote:

The most suspicious thing about you in my opinion is that you change your profile details like socks. At the beginning you would document that, but as people stopped paying attention, you stopped doing that. Obviously, that makes it much harder to pin any clues on you, if there are any. Just the thing that a mafioso would want to do, and therefore the thing that no townie should do. Your current profile could connect to the Wolf (crying wolf, pumping full of lead). I don't know whether you've had that profile all game. If suresh0t isn't the Wolf, you are probably my next suspect.

FWIW, at the beginning of the game, you tossed around a bunch of accusations/suspicions, most of which have proven false. (wurm, nightmare, Ghar, Plexa, SoMuchBetter,fusionsdf).

As for NemY, I don't know about him, although I find his posts suspicious, but the main clue that Camlito fingered him for is undeniable: Cottonmouth is the 15-weapon guy--that theme appears every time he kills someone. One time Mr. Blonde appears with him, and suddenly, Mr. Blonde is killing with 15 weapons too. If it's not NemY's mirror, then it's something else, but that has to be a clue.