A Classy Game of Mafia - Page 2

On March 04 2024 15:34 DarthPunk wrote:


Why are they town?

On March 04 2024 15:36 Alakaslam wrote:
Oats and DP scum for scraping the bottom of the barrel?

Do either of you even have mayor picks of your own?

This is why I prefer Rayn, on like 5 posts, to either of you.


Yeesh.

Tothesky is some dude I have never seen before.

On March 04 2024 15:37 DarthPunk wrote:


Answer my question and then I will answer yours.

On March 04 2024 15:38 DarthPunk wrote:


Why did you think DMB and Trfel were town when you invited them to the tea party?

On March 04 2024 15:51 DarthPunk wrote:


Can you explain exactly what you mean by this, how is it tangibly different to other games?

On March 04 2024 15:36 CopCake wrote:


Ok mr. Fakey pretending to solve the game

Why am i mafia or why am i town?

Who is town and who is mafia?

On March 04 2024 16:06 DarthPunk wrote:


well you already read my case pretty much.

On March 04 2024 17:08 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Cake do you think DP's reasoning for calling you mafia last game when you were actually mafia was good?

On March 04 2024 18:59 marvellosity wrote:

I find your attitude towards DP quite weird. Don’t really know if scummy weird at the moment. But you’re purposefully antagonising the highest volume poster. One who has nailed you as mafia previously. And DP doesnt look scummy. Sure that doesn’t mean he’s not scum, but it means your attitude is off. Why please?

On March 04 2024 20:54 DarthPunk wrote:


It's the exact same reason. Cakes literal first post of the game is this:



Which she later states is her 'town circle' she has not interacted in a single way with either of these players, and I know from her last mafia game that town reads too early is a mafia tell for cake.

This absolutely qualifies, further if they are town, it is also a blatant pocketing attempt.



I don't see how that has changed at all in this game compare to the previous games.



This is just wrong, in this game she was only posting roleplay about a tea party, I asked her a question, she left the thread, I asked slam about her alignment, she came back to the thread and I immediately asked her a follow up question.

Here is the progression:



she makes these two troll posts





I ask slam about her alignment when she is gone



Then she arrives back in the thread with this:







I immediately try to engage with her about the game, and she calls me out as mafia.

then makes the below reads



Which is untrue and also unfair, when she was interacting in the way that she did.



and this which is as inaccurate a statement as you can make, considering I was the person in the thread who most actively tried to determine your alignment




I literally have the most posts in the game at the point you called me mafia.
The fact you entered the thread in the manner in which you did, which is so different to the last game we played together, and then try to apply a meta read to me in about 1-2 hours of playing the game is just wrong.


By the way, none of cakes post explains three good reasons why cake is mafia.

1.) why did she come into the game town reading two other players in her first post, so strongly that she called it a 'town circle'

2.) why has she actively and blatantly avoided taking stances and playing/progressing the game (i couldn't tell you a position she holds right now apart from me being mafia and her few town reads)

3.) she makes meta reads based on completely different and absurd circumstances, strong and confident ones at that.

On March 04 2024 21:02 DarthPunk wrote:


Can you answer this please.

On March 04 2024 21:08 DarthPunk wrote:


but it holds value to me right?

Because I was feeling burned out from mafia in general, and I said this before the game started, so you can acknowledge its real to me correct?

On March 04 2024 21:05 CopCake wrote:


Tunnel me if you desire but I tend to do this.
As town and as mafia.

I tend to be like “Detective Glowing bear will your hold my hand and find mafia together?”

And stuff like “Shockey, if you were a sea animal, what would you be?” For example, shockey said a killer whale which is a beast animal and he was mafia. I think mafia kinda out themselves when asked about random stuff, like if you ask for what they are listening to, they will more likely say something heavier than what they tend to listen usually. You should try this technique sometime.

It is my own way of solving the game, there is a logic to it. I liked dumb a lot for calling you out, it felt natural.

I also liked trfel and I have a mads respect for him after last game, therefore, invited into a “town circle”.

I think the concept here is what you have trouble with. The fact they were invited doesnt mean I cant change my opinion of them which you are assuming.

If Slam told you “yes I have played with cake a lot” does it have some value to you?

On March 04 2024 21:15 DarthPunk wrote:


None of that addresses any of why you are mafia.