I will happily sheep HF's read on Slam tomorrow and just not lynch him. I was already on that idea anyway.
I am not as happy about sheeping the marv read on Sandroba, but tbh, I kinda don't care. I can shut up and not do it.
Tomorrow we kill dmb.
Also at this point I'm thinking "well fuck, but who do I not want to lose to if mafia". The only player who hasn't really played "well" if they're mafia is dmb. Trfel and Slam would have insane scum games. rayn and marv pretty good, and sandroba has argued himself out of the guillotine twice. I will happily lose if there's 2 mafia in there.
My guess is dmb + hidden. Sandroba is the most likely from my point of view but I may just be tunneled because I'm so tired of his complete lack of listening and thinking.
If it isn't him it's super well hidden. marv, trfel, slam, you, idk. Trfel may actually be the likeliest.
On December 19 2023 07:59 Palmar wrote: Also at this point I'm thinking "well fuck, but who do I not want to lose to if mafia". The only player who hasn't really played "well" if they're mafia is dmb. Trfel and Slam would have insane scum games. rayn and marv pretty good, and sandroba has argued himself out of the guillotine twice. I will happily lose if there's 2 mafia in there.
dmb I'm not losing to.
This really is a genuine concern to me at this point.
On December 19 2023 08:08 Palmar wrote: My guess is dmb + hidden. Sandroba is the most likely from my point of view but I may just be tunneled because I'm so tired of his complete lack of listening and thinking.
If it isn't him it's super well hidden. marv, trfel, slam, you, idk. Trfel may actually be the likeliest.
why is dmb mafia according to you?
Process of elimination.
And the thought that maybe she isn't just terrible as town, maybe she is actually just mafia.
I said yesterday that my entire read on her is very much a "too stupid to be mafia" thing.
On December 19 2023 08:13 raynpelikoneet wrote: i'm having problems on who is scum, if marv thinks youre not scum and you dont thing marv is scum, then basically i agree
idk if town is allowed to last minute claim. I usually in my games make it so that it's impossible (have a silent period at the end of night but maybe allow mafia to change nk in that).
If we can last minute claim and have ANY results at all, even if it's not that helpful, they should be posted.
On December 19 2023 08:16 raynpelikoneet wrote: so basically you think she is mafia because she thinks youre mafia?
Well no
She's dragging up 11 year old games to try to meta read people
Her reads have been atrocious through the game.
She hardly comments on a bunch of players in the game.
Much of her accusations against me is illogical. She claims that I'm just playing "insane mafia game", but somehow she caught me immediately on day 1. How is that insane?
All this CAN be explained by terrible town, but it can also just be a bit newbie mafia.
On December 19 2023 08:16 raynpelikoneet wrote: so basically you think she is mafia because she thinks youre mafia?
Well no
She's dragging up 11 year old games to try to meta read people
Her reads have been atrocious through the game.
She hardly comments on a bunch of players in the game.
Much of her accusations against me is illogical. She claims that I'm just playing "insane mafia game", but somehow she caught me immediately on day 1. How is that insane?
All this CAN be explained by terrible town, but it can also just be a bit newbie mafia.
okay so,
you are saying she can be newbie mafia or newbie town (which she is). which is it? it looks like youre very hesitant to make a stance on what you should.
Yeah I haven't been very successful this game at this.
You waver, understandable. I don't expect everyone to have marv's level of insight into how I play.
The people that piss me off are the ones that aren't even willing to entertain the notion that maybe listening to him, of which you aren't a part. In fact your waffling on the idea is pretty townie.
If marv is town I'm town If marv is mafia I'm DEFINITELY town
EPT![[image loading]](https://imgur.com/0azsG8x)
![[image loading]](https://i.imgur.com/0azsG8x.png)
