Winter Warfare Mafia - Page 17

On December 18 2023 12:28 sandroba wrote:
DMB needs to die. This whole act of hyperfixating in Palmar and playing too dumb to be scum is getting old.

Palmar the only way I believe is ever town is if he is an investigative role, which is why I backed off today. At this point I'd rather he gets killed in the night, so I don't see any downside saying this. His fixation on me claiming blue in the QT could make sense I guess if he is trying to catch me since he knows he is blue and thinks he must be the only one due to balance. I can see that. Also, the way he answered my mafia vigi speculation with "Mafia doesn't have extra KP" seemed TMI in a way that if he knows he is a blue role and due to balance town has no other protective roles and mafia must have no KP.
That's pretty much the only way I can believe Palmar is town.
Need to look at rayn now, pretty stupid that he voted HF over Palmar or DMB. His DMB read is super bad, kinda like a copy of Palmar's read. Even if DMB is town the reason for town read is awful, hard to swallow those reads

On December 18 2023 13:04 sandroba wrote:
Slam, please only ever sheep me or Trfel from now on. These guys in red talk the talk but they are not walking the walk

On December 18 2023 14:16 sandroba wrote:



I don't think this vote post makes any sense, what's the analysis here? Before that she was saying Vivax might be blue.
After this, she fucks off for 23 hours and only comes back very close to deadline. Vivax started spilling his reads, here is the post DMB makes, looks like some people might be considering Chezinu for a swap:

Some hesitancy to vote Chez, claims V is still more scummy.

To her credit, she straight comes out and says this just after DP asks for a count of who is there during eod:


At that point I don't think it was clear that the counter wagon would be on me, so if she was mafia there was a risk Chezinu might be it. But she is the last one to move her vote, 15 minutes elapsed from the post she says V looks so townie to actually voting for someone else.

Vivax knew it before we all did:


Tbh I'm coming off of this less sure DMB is mafia from this D1 shit. I can see her feeling pressured to town read Vivax in that spot if they live together and Vivax knows she is online. I'll keep going

On December 18 2023 22:36 sandroba wrote:

I don't get it slam

On December 18 2023 22:46 sandroba wrote:
Not sure what happened with my text.

The response to the quote above is:

My post sentiment was more to stop sheeping aforementioned red players than requesting you to blind sheep.

On December 18 2023 23:06 die_meatbaby wrote:


I will reread the hole game something is goeing extremly wrong here. We voting Town after Town.. nightkills random as fuck especially the Koshi kill pisses me off and then this yesterday.. The fuck is wrong in this game?! Yes i am still suspicious as hell of Palmar, but of you defently as well!! Don´t try do make a town looking conversation with me because right now I am suspicious about everybody here! See you again after reread the hole game

On December 18 2023 23:15 sandroba wrote:

It doesn't help to be suspicious of everybody. At this point you have to narrow it down otherwise you will end up easily siding with scum if you are town.

On December 18 2023 23:34 marvellosity wrote:
I don’t have preconceived notions about Palmar. Okay that’s obviously not true, I do.

But HF flipping town doesn’t suddenly overturn my townread on him. Mathematically it obviously makes it more likely, but that’s it.

I know I am already looking like a fool for lynching Hf, and potentially I will look 1000x the fool for not lynching Palmar. But I can’t do something I don’t believe because I’m scared of looking the fool.

On December 18 2023 23:34 marvellosity wrote:

Why are you suspicious of sandro please?

On December 18 2023 23:36 sandroba wrote:
Reading dmb more and more and I don't want to lynch her anymore. If she is mafia she is doing a good job of looking townie, which makes me less butthurt to lose to I guess?
I'm ready to exclude her from my lynch path. Basically, now it has to be Rayn and Palmar. Rayn has some redeeming features, but overall he is flying under the radar.
I read a post by DMB where she said she always thinks Rayn is scum, then in another post further along she says she doesn't think Rayn is scummy in this game at all.
This is a huge tell that Rayn is actually scum in this game. If his normal playstyle as town make you find him scummy, but now he doesn't seem as suspicious this is a behavior modification that is totally mafia-oriented. Rayn only shows up when he is being talked about to try to diffuse suspicion off of him. He doesn't pursue his scum reads, and is very tame not to antagonize players in the thread too much, all of which are mafia-favored behaviors.

The only player I remember rayn being a bit abrasive agaisnt was Trfel with his "are you stupid" comment which felt out of character for rayn at that point seen his behavior in the thread, but if I go back in memory I do remember rayn being an abrasive townie.

On December 19 2023 01:44 marvellosity wrote:

Fleshing out is difficult.

The short answer is - I don’t think anything he wrote is fake.