EPTQuarterly Mafia 1 - part 2 - Page 8
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
| ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
| ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
| ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
Yep when I can. Covering manager all week so hard to apply as much time as I’d like. The unvote was just shorthand for me saying I’m reconsidering. | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On August 30 2023 10:44 TankTopTiger wrote: I've been talking to Grack and he's encouraged me to keep playing. But if I do, it's not going to be in filter-diving F5 try-hard mode where I argue back and forth for hours. I'm gonna say my piece and if I die I die. I think LS is town. don't understand or agree with his reasons for reading me green. But that thing where he brought heat down on himself unnecessarily didn't feel like something he would do as red. I think lynching him is another mistake. By vibe, I think Lamp is town, I just really really don't like his blustery playstyle and would prefer to eat razorblades than read his filter. I think he's bad town, but I think he's town. Trying to shut down conversation at the lynch of D1 in order to lynch Chez for no real stated reason makes me very dismissive of his approach to the game. I don't like Marv but haven't gone through filter, I'll go into reasons why when I'm back (I'm waiting on a pick-up that's already half-hour late). His misinterpretation of my post, then insistence that DP has it wrong is just wild considering he uses the exact same argument I made in his own defense, but insists after filter diving me twice that the interpretation where I'm scared of dying with only one vote on me while Chez has all of them is the better call. Delusional if town. I still don't like DP, but understand that basically my entire read on him relies on meta from outside the game and positionally I can never really hope to lynch him. If he denies what I've said regarding his selective forgetting of our RL conversations, he confirms to me that he's scum, but ultimately until I'm dead and confirmed town nobody will ever take it seriously because it's non-verifiable. Just very quickly on this - when DP said I had misread I went back and read it over again. And I was wrong on that. I realise I hadn’t explicitly stated that yet. | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On August 30 2023 17:15 Koshi wrote: Such a good post. I also still don't like DP. DP/marv scumteam 😱😱😱 Why to all 3 statements | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
Birthday aside his investment has been below what I expect from LS. I haven’t seen any emotional incongruence from him, and it was his birthday, that’s why it’s not higher than 80. He believes math is mafia (I think?!) judging by his reaction to math’s give up post. Maybe they’re actually just mafia together and I was very wrong about math. I don’t really want to be wrong about that though. | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
| ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On August 30 2023 17:41 marvellosity wrote: LS is like 80% mafia here. For those who know my list posts, he would be in red but not bold red. Birthday aside his investment has been below what I expect from LS. I haven’t seen any emotional incongruence from him, and it was his birthday, that’s why it’s not higher than 80. He believes math is mafia (I think?!) judging by his reaction to math’s give up post. Maybe they’re actually just mafia together and I was very wrong about math. I don’t really want to be wrong about that though. Ugh, I forgot to finish the 2nd paragraph here. My point about LS/math was that he calls out math’s give up post as fake and a cop out but there’s no vote attached to it and he’s not mentioned him since. Hopefully that makes what I said after actually make sense… | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On August 30 2023 17:49 DarthPunk wrote: Ok Marv is town I think. Marv what’s your confidence interval on math should I trust your eyes more than my own here or is it a situation where it’s just a coin toss who is right?? It’s really like this. If math had continued posting like he had been posting all game I’d be sitting here telling you he was town. For aforementioned reasons. I can quote (well I’m not on a pc so I can’t) 5-10 posts I think sound very natural, confident, blasé, however you want to say it - and I think they’re very difficult to post and maintain as mafia. The problem I’m increasingly coming up against the more I think about it is that he give up post is so incongruent with any of that. He came under pressure and delivered what I thought was a nice defence to the case. But then peaced out. I’m really struggling to marry the confident, tonally excellent math with the giving up math. It feels like those 2 players can’t be the same person. So maybe they’re just not. It /is/ a lot easier to marry up a math who was only faking confidence etc, had his confidence hit by a lot of pressure, and folded. I haven’t really got a firm conclusion here tbh which I’d really like to. I’m not 80% on him anyway. | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On August 30 2023 17:51 DarthPunk wrote: tone around quitting and coming back. As an aside It would be an incredibly messed up appeal to emotion in my opinion if he does that as mafia. I have done something similar back in the day but it definitely isn’t in the wheelhouse for most people. I also don’t think it’s in his wheelhouse tbh. Why would it be messed up? You’re gonna have to humour me a little here. Folds under pressure (or however you categorise it) then feels bad for it and comes back to play to help his team. What’s so outrageous? And by ‘his team’ I mean either mafia or town, it probably holds for both. | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
iamp DMB (vig reaction) Vivax (reread him, not sure it’s like maf game) DP Koshi math (least sure of placement) Jakey TTT LS | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On August 30 2023 18:20 DarthPunk wrote: Also ttt do you think that ls should be reading you town?? It’s a very odd read cause he usually goes along with thread sentiment. You know I wanted to scumread LS for this but I struggled to as he’s actually pretty consistent with it over the course of the game | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On August 30 2023 18:49 Koshi wrote: marv or iamp I will be filtering DP in 30 mins. If you are here for feedback that would be nice. I know he is mafia and will prove it but too many people asking questions at work to do it during hours. Can’t wait for this. I’ve not been able to distinguish his play from the other games (ergo he looks town to me), but I’m really not the DP whisperer either | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On August 30 2023 19:15 JacobStrangelove wrote: Like I'm genuinely confused you're like why is ttt town also btw I've snuck my vote of him because I feel town(?) thinks hes town What’s to be confused about? Was pretty clear I was reconsidering given new events. There was no sneaking, why are you trying to portray it as such? | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On August 30 2023 19:46 Koshi wrote: All the reasons DP is mafia: 1) DP was quite active part 1. In part 2 he wasn't there at the start which is a style break. But when he came in the thread, he came in swinging. Was this overcompensating for missing the first xx hours of the game? 1a) "You want to talk iamp meta?" Why did DP misread this exchange? Why did DP misread this 3-5 times because I taunt him after he made this comment. Because he isn't reading and just looking for fights. 1b) "Are you for real with this Vivax?" So 30 mins after misreading my comment he goes into this weird fight with Vivax. Was it over the top? What triggered him? Maybe the Vivax vote on him? Why would a townie be so angry for that? Who knows. But I know that after TTT attacked DP for it, DP said Vivax looked quite townie after all. What could have happened? Coincidence? I think not. So far this looks like a case of DP being DP. When you’re done can you please summarise in text why it’s DP being mafia instead of being DP? | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On August 30 2023 19:56 DarthPunk wrote: Anyway I’m not going to really be able to defend myself much. Because , as I stated earlier I have work stuff on tomorrow and my jet lagged girlfriend wants some sleep now without phone posting. So if I get lynched here it’s unfortunate. But lynch koshi afterwards when I flip town please. He basically is claiming scum at me or he is a legit c-tier town player Either way must die. LS/koshi/math is a good place to look. Either way? Really DP? It’s literally a townie’s entire job to make this distinction | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
| ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On August 30 2023 20:29 TankTopTiger wrote: Marv trying to lynch LS. Hmmmmm... I understand and agree somewhat, but don't feel it's enough to confirm him town. Since when? Or if I’m misunderstanding, why? Choose the question that’s appropriate to what you were saying | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On August 30 2023 21:20 die_meatbaby wrote: I forgot that the vig has only one shot. Thinking of somebody who can shoot more than one time maybe explain for you my dumb reaction. You don’t have to explain yourself any further, unless you’re unhappy with the townread on you for it?  | ||
| ||
