EPT[N][M]Noir Mini Mafia - Ch. 5 - Page 5
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
| ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
| ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
Simply the lynch I think that has the best chance of actually happening. Lynch is better than no lynch. | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
I dunno if that makes him mafia. But I think that makes him better than a no lynch. | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
On August 16 2020 09:31 Vivax wrote: Sorry, that was poorly worded. I mean, he makes excuses for not having reads and always insists on having no thoughts about most of the game. Lemme dig up a few quotes.What do you mean he protests not having reads? As town? Doesn't sound familiar I think. | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
On June 03 2020 20:21 ShoCkeyy wrote: I don’t have reads, did you think of that? It’s D1 as I mentioned. | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
On August 16 2020 09:35 Vivax wrote: You asked, I assume you found it relevant to something. I just brought it up because I found it interesting.Don't bother with the meta. Why do you even feel like you need to dig up quotes? Trfel if you are scummy scum we can just vote you off, no need to feel forced. Typically when people ask about something, it means they want proof? | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
On August 16 2020 09:37 Eywa- wrote: Look, you've still not said why? Please enlighten us?Can we end trfel today? | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
On August 16 2020 09:38 Vivax wrote: LightningStrike is pretty easy. I think his play has been pretty abysmal this game. His anger at Fecalfeast felt off, especially with the way that he backed off of it so easily. I could maybe see him getting so upset at Fecalfeast and pushing him that recklessly, but not with the way he backed off. Furthermore, his vote for HoldenGolden made no sense for me; he was townreading HoldenGolden earlier and it felt very convenient. Also coming back at the start of Day 2 being surprised, saying "My read on HoldenGolden was wrong, I need to redo my reads list" sounds super mafia motivated. He shouldn't be surprised any more, he had a day to process the flip and reread things.Trfel starting from your list post, could you tell me where you're at with the eywa and LS reads? Just a few lines of thought on why you think they're mafia, if you don't mind. Eywa- is tougher. I don't know if Eywa- is mafia, I need to reread him. He's felt present at times and absent at other times. It doesn't help that he's really annoying me right now, and I have trouble reading players who annoy me accurately. | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
On August 16 2020 09:40 Vivax wrote: You can think that if you want. But the quotes I were bringing up weren't trying to convince you that ShoCkeyy is mafia or even suspicious. I just assumed that because you were asking about it you cared about it enough that you'd want to see what I meant, is all.Well in your case, you should know I'm on the Shockeyy wagon and don't need convincing so it looked more like you wanted to bring up those quotes to relieve some internal pressure when you feel like you're not doing enough. | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
On August 16 2020 09:43 Eywa- wrote: I assume you're talking about my questioning?Honestly, I think the aimless vague questioning that goes on is detrimental to town.  But yeah, I know that's not a popular take here. First, I don't think I've been doing too much questioning this game. Second, the questions I have asked are either very early on in the game (where I think it's good to do most anything, really...) or have a direct purpose. Feel free to ask about any question I've asked, and I can show you the purpose behind it. Or would those be aimless and vague questions that hurt town? | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
On August 16 2020 09:46 Eywa- wrote: I'm not really sure what you are trying to say here?You can't think that the vote on HoldenGolden has any scum motivation, if LS is mafia, he just sits there and lets HoldenGolden go over and says "told you so, now sheep me you idiots". Like, this is the type of thing that IF town, you CANNOT post. It's just absolutely mind-boggling. LightningStrike's post there doesn't make sense as town. I agree it's a poor play as mafia, I think he felt like he had to vote (I mean, it is in the rules) and just it came out really really forced. Aka, mafia motivated. | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
On August 16 2020 09:46 Vivax wrote: I mean, I'm pretty ticked off but at least it'd probably be better than a no lynch. Just really irritated because, as always, no one has a decent reason why I'm mafia but no one cares.I have a sudden urge to vote Trfel with you guys, maybe it's just me but those posts don't feel too organic to me. Trfel are you serene with being voted off? | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
On August 16 2020 09:49 Trfel wrote: To add, I've been present and involved here more than most. I've been around for every deadline, I don't know if anyone else has been. I've produced more original content and explained my reads more than most of the game. Sure, I haven't been re-evaluating a ton lately but I think that's understandable given that there haven't been enough people to realistically lynch someone.I mean, I'm pretty ticked off but at least it'd probably be better than a no lynch. Just really irritated because, as always, no one has a decent reason why I'm mafia but no one cares. | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
On August 16 2020 09:50 Vivax wrote: For ShoCkeyy? Yes, I'm not very sure about his alignment at all, especially recently. I don't particularly care if you scumread me for answering your question too effectively, trying to be helpful and make sure we are on the same page.It's a tone thing you seem a bit too concerned with the writeup and yet there's no strong conviction. I also consider that an absolutely horrendous reason to scumread someone, so my comment stands. But if that's what you want to think, I won't try and stop you. | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
On August 16 2020 09:53 Vivax wrote: Yes, I've been disinterested and demotivated. I think this game's setup really is awful with an inactive group, and makes for torture to play in.Like, last time you were mafia I noticed it from you posting really detailed explanations on everything but it was obvious nothing really interested you (otherwise you'd devote more time to that). It feels like that this game too. But really, I can be wrong. Just don't want you to think that there aren't reasons for peeps to think you are mafia. There's probably reasons to think I'm too. Even if as mafia you put in the most effort even over townies it doesn't give the right not to be lynched. Of course I have no right to not be lynched, however I think I do have a right to not be lynched without valid reason. As does everyone, whenever possible. | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
On August 16 2020 09:57 Vivax wrote: Are you asking me?Then why is shockeyy so hard to lynch. He's just throwing his vote away again. I'd feel better with 5 on Shockeyy than I do now tbh. I don't know, what does that have to do with me? | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
| ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
I'm really leaning towards Eywa- and LightningStrike currently. However I know Fecalfeast and Damdred have strong mafia games, so I need to look at them again. LightningStrike mostly for aforementioned reasons. Eywa- because the more I read his filter, the less convinced I feel like he's scumhunting. He seems to care about what's going on, but he has had fewer and fewer explanations for his reads and flailings. There is very little substance behind his play. There were some tonal things I thought made him town, but those feel less important as the content is increasingly lacking. | ||
|
Trfel
7015 Posts
Going to have to look at it more deeply. I liked his play towards the later parts of Day 1 but Day 2, he felt very unfocused. Present but just chiming in, no new content or reads or explanations. I wish there were more people I could be confident in townreading. Right now it's really just Mr. Cheesecake/Onegu and likely Damdred as well. | ||
| ||
