[N][M]Noir Mini Mafia - Ch. 5 - Page 4

On August 16 2020 06:52 Vivax wrote:


I like how you already start from the presumption that I ask you things in order to nail you.

And in an attempt to evade the question.

Is there a reason for you not wanting to share insights on previous scumreads?

On August 16 2020 07:43 Trfel wrote:
I do find it really interesting and suspicious that ShoCkeyy and Eywa- have not responded to the replacement and are still voting for the GTacc/Dadred slot. Doesn't make much sense to me. Even though GTacc was suspicious I don't think anyone could say he was mafia with certainty given his low activity/substance.

On August 16 2020 07:57 Trfel wrote:
Yeah, still suspicious. I feel like most people try to get a chance to evaluate the replacement first.

Unless you have a read on Dadred already, in which case I'm all ears?

On August 16 2020 09:38 Fecalfeast wrote:
I would also kill LS lmao

On August 16 2020 09:40 Vivax wrote:


Well in your case, you should know I'm on the Shockeyy wagon and don't need convincing so it looked more like you wanted to bring up those quotes to relieve some internal pressure when you feel like you're not doing enough.

On August 16 2020 09:41 Vivax wrote:


You are SO boring.

On August 16 2020 09:43 Trfel wrote:
LightningStrike is pretty easy. I think his play has been pretty abysmal this game. His anger at Fecalfeast felt off, especially with the way that he backed off of it so easily. I could maybe see him getting so upset at Fecalfeast and pushing him that recklessly, but not with the way he backed off. Furthermore, his vote for HoldenGolden made no sense for me; he was townreading HoldenGolden earlier and it felt very convenient. Also coming back at the start of Day 2 being surprised, saying "My read on HoldenGolden was wrong, I need to redo my reads list" sounds super mafia motivated. He shouldn't be surprised any more, he had a day to process the flip and reread things.

Eywa- is tougher. I don't know if Eywa- is mafia, I need to reread him. He's felt present at times and absent at other times. It doesn't help that he's really annoying me right now, and I have trouble reading players who annoy me accurately.

On August 16 2020 09:48 Trfel wrote:
I'm not really sure what you are trying to say here?

LightningStrike's post there doesn't make sense as town. I agree it's a poor play as mafia, I think he felt like he had to vote (I mean, it is in the rules) and just it came out really really forced. Aka, mafia motivated.

On August 16 2020 09:49 Dadred wrote:
Tbh the way Trfel has approached end of game hasn't been bad at all.

Wants a lunch, pushes for it wants town to consolidate to get any information.

It's town minded,there are scum reasons for doing it as well but I have a hard time seeing scum Trfel go through so much to try to advert a no lunch for another cycle.

On August 16 2020 09:50 Vivax wrote:


It's a tone thing you seem a bit too concerned with the writeup and yet there's no strong conviction.

On August 16 2020 09:57 Vivax wrote:
Then why is shockeyy so hard to lynch.

He's just throwing his vote away again.

I'd feel better with 5 on Shockeyy than I do now tbh.