Liquid`

Team Liquid Liquipedia

EDT 04:05
CEST 10:05
KST 17:05

Forum Sidebar

Events/Features

BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ Data needed ASL21 General Discussion Pros React To: Tulbo in Ro.16 Group A RepMastered™: replay sharing and analyzer site

Escore Tournament StarCraft Season 2 [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [ASL21] Ro16 Group A [ASL21] Ro16 Group B

Simple Questions, Simple Answers What's the deal with APM & what's its true value Any training maps people recommend? Fighting Spirit mining rates

Reappraising The Situation T…

lurker extra damage testi…

Funny Nicknames

Iranian anarchists: organize…

ASL S21 English Commentary…

Newbie Student Mafia XXX - Page 3

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 26 2019 20:56 GMT

#236

On September 26 2019 21:13 Branch.AUT wrote:

Show nested quote +

as usual, dead wrong

On September 27 2019 01:05 Fecalfeast wrote:
Eywadash is not wrong that he was right before but I'm just not convinced because induction isn't valid.

I don't like day 1 as town never have never will

@Vivax

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 26 2019 21:18 GMT

#239

On September 27 2019 06:12 Vivax wrote:
What am I supposed to do with that? Its not related to my concern?

Is your concern that Branch is scum or that I am scum reading him?

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 26 2019 21:20 GMT

#240

On September 27 2019 06:14 FreezingFoot wrote:
I can't be sure if you're scum or not. I will always try to gather as much information as I can to sustain or change my read.
I want to understand your thought process. If I can't, you're probably fabricating reads. That's the point.
Who is his partner and why?

If you're not sure what you're looking for, you might as well use this:

random.org/lists

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 26 2019 21:22 GMT

#241

On September 27 2019 05:06 Vivax wrote:
You vote him out of nowhere

Agree to disagree

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 26 2019 21:26 GMT

#242

I mean, I'm all for constructive discussion, but starting from a fundamental disagreement on what is alignment indicative and what is a rather tricky place to take off from.

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 26 2019 21:33 GMT

#248

On September 26 2019 13:58 CopCake wrote:
Lets talk GB, since you seem town.

I have been playing once in a while, last two games were bad.

On September 26 2019 18:18 boxerfred wrote:
I like that GB commits to some early reads, so town points for that. eywa feels careless, so once more town.

Besides that nothing from me.

On September 27 2019 06:28 Tubesock wrote:
i think I like GB the best so far. But it’s weird, I don’t agree with his read post. Probably just happy he is playing again.

I’ve liked a couple things Vivax has said.

Part of me wants to town Eywa- but I’m pretty certain it would be trivial for mafia!Eeya- to do what he’s been doing.

As far as I’m concerned everyone else is probably mafia.

To be honest, there is a very strange practice on this site of wringing out the obvious... Like... It's consistent and I don't really understand it.

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 26 2019 21:36 GMT

#251

On September 27 2019 06:33 Tubesock wrote:

Show nested quote +

On September 27 2019 06:31 CopCake wrote:

On September 27 2019 06:14 FreezingFoot wrote:

On September 27 2019 02:29 CopCake wrote:
I wouldnt touch Ewya this early tho GB

I can touch anyone I want, he was consenting, I can prove it.

On September 27 2019 02:53 Eywa- wrote:

On September 27 2019 02:50 Eywa- wrote:

On September 27 2019 01:56 FreezingFoot wrote:

This feels like you decided he is mafia before finding the arguments to it. This "perfect information" argument isn't convincing.

I can see where you're coming from, but you're wrong. I decided he was Mafia before posting the "arguments", but the "arguments" are not the reason that he's mafia, they are mostly just me mocking "cases".

It's not a huge distinction, but it is a significant one. Your post makes it seem like I was looking for arguments to justify why he was Mafia, but I'm not doing that at all. He is mafia, I'm telling you, if my track record is not enough to justify that, then I guess I would say... Sounds like you want to lose.

If you're not forcing that read, I'm having a hard time to understand why you think he is mafia. Is it for meta? Please explain to me like I'm a 4 y.o.

Btw, did you read you role pm?

On September 27 2019 03:39 Fecalfeast wrote:
I will say that branch after the eywa baseless accusation has given me feelings.

Also I'm gonna be on a sort of vacation for the next 4 days lmao i probably shouldn't have signed up but I'll grab some time when i can.

No real spammers here I'll be fine

Wait for me, I'll be spamming in a pinch.

On September 27 2019 03:39 CopCake wrote:
Because I cant read him correctly and he was right about rayn last game.

And if you poke him he will be like “whatever” because he doesnt care nor engage a convo.

I would say that GB is town.
FF seems town.
Vivax smells mafia.
Shockey smells a little bit as mafia, just a little bit.

I am curious about one thing with you.

And Ewya is null.

Cool. Why is Vivax mafia? Why shockey smells like mafia?
Ewayhijole- being right on rayn isn't proof he will be right in this game. Don't you think this is weak reasoning to give up on trying to read Ewaychupazi-?

On September 27 2019 05:06 Vivax wrote:

On September 26 2019 21:09 Eywa- wrote:
vote:Branch.AUT

If you guys are really nice, I might even give you his partner before I get night killed.

On September 26 2019 21:41 Eywa- wrote:
Branch dismissing me here when he has no reason to believe I'm bad at reading the game is really questionable and just adds onto the many other reasons you guys should be voting here.

This is ridiculous? You vote him out of nowhere and complain that hes dismissing you because youre supposedly good at the game.

Why should he think that if youre wrong and hes town? And if hes mafia why shouldnt he dismiss you?
In abstraction, you have delivered a prime example of damned if I do, damned if I dont.

If you dont acknowledge that this is plain BS with a backtrack and a formal apology to the god of logic Im voting you and never unvoting.

THAT'S MORE LIKE MY TOWN BUDDY VIVAX (maybe)

On September 27 2019 05:21 CopCake wrote:

On September 27 2019 05:02 ShoCkeyy wrote:

On September 27 2019 03:39 CopCake wrote:
Because I cant read him correctly and he was right about rayn last game.

And if you poke him he will be like “whatever” because he doesnt care nor engage a convo.

I would say that GB is town.
FF seems town.
Vivax smells mafia.
Shockey smells a little bit as mafia, just a little bit.

I am curious about one thing with you.

And Ewya is null.

I always smell like mafia every game I play. I just think it’s my posting style I guess... also why can’t we go after Eywa early?

Let him act. We can get info from that.

Just saying not the best lunch atm.

And who would be better?

On September 27 2019 05:47 Eywa- wrote:

On September 27 2019 01:56 FreezingFoot wrote:

I'd rather hear you now. Could you please share who his partner is?

This is not a good question, you are voting me... You want me to throw a name out, but you should be thinking...

What do I react if he says ______

If the answer is the same regardless, you might as well not ask the question. If you think I'm scum, it's also pointless.

I can't be sure if you're scum or not. I will always try to gather as much information as I can to sustain or change my read.
I want to understand your thought process. If I can't, you're probably fabricating reads. That's the point.
Who is his partner and why?

I agree that being right one game doesnt make that person the owner of the absolut truth; nevertheless in a next game you should at least read his opinion.

So I want to see his process, but rn he just acted as I remembered :D so I think he is town.

Now I need to analyze his read correctly to see if I agree ^^.

You don’t think he could be doing this as mafia?

I did and everyone thought I was town, so I won.

Then the next game everyone thought I was scum, so I lost as town despite immediately calling the scum team in a 3 player PoE.

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 26 2019 21:39 GMT

#253

On September 27 2019 06:39 Vivax wrote:

Show nested quote +

Yeah ok you had that weird prelude where you promised to announce your gosu reads.

Thats not what I take issue with, but that it looks like the only reason you had, you posted after he replied and you scumread him.

I'm not sure what you want me to say... I scum read him because he was Wolfy.

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 26 2019 21:41 GMT

#255

On September 27 2019 06:39 Tubesock wrote:

Show nested quote +

On September 27 2019 06:36 Eywa- wrote:

On September 27 2019 06:33 Tubesock wrote:

On September 27 2019 06:31 CopCake wrote:

On September 27 2019 06:14 FreezingFoot wrote:

On September 27 2019 02:29 CopCake wrote:
I wouldnt touch Ewya this early tho GB

I can touch anyone I want, he was consenting, I can prove it.

On September 27 2019 02:53 Eywa- wrote:

On September 27 2019 02:50 Eywa- wrote:

On September 27 2019 01:56 FreezingFoot wrote:

This feels like you decided he is mafia before finding the arguments to it. This "perfect information" argument isn't convincing.

I can see where you're coming from, but you're wrong. I decided he was Mafia before posting the "arguments", but the "arguments" are not the reason that he's mafia, they are mostly just me mocking "cases".

It's not a huge distinction, but it is a significant one. Your post makes it seem like I was looking for arguments to justify why he was Mafia, but I'm not doing that at all. He is mafia, I'm telling you, if my track record is not enough to justify that, then I guess I would say... Sounds like you want to lose.

If you're not forcing that read, I'm having a hard time to understand why you think he is mafia. Is it for meta? Please explain to me like I'm a 4 y.o.

Btw, did you read you role pm?

On September 27 2019 03:39 Fecalfeast wrote:
I will say that branch after the eywa baseless accusation has given me feelings.

Also I'm gonna be on a sort of vacation for the next 4 days lmao i probably shouldn't have signed up but I'll grab some time when i can.

No real spammers here I'll be fine

Wait for me, I'll be spamming in a pinch.

On September 27 2019 03:39 CopCake wrote:
Because I cant read him correctly and he was right about rayn last game.

And if you poke him he will be like “whatever” because he doesnt care nor engage a convo.

I would say that GB is town.
FF seems town.
Vivax smells mafia.
Shockey smells a little bit as mafia, just a little bit.

I am curious about one thing with you.

And Ewya is null.

Cool. Why is Vivax mafia? Why shockey smells like mafia?
Ewayhijole- being right on rayn isn't proof he will be right in this game. Don't you think this is weak reasoning to give up on trying to read Ewaychupazi-?

On September 27 2019 05:06 Vivax wrote:

On September 26 2019 21:09 Eywa- wrote:
vote:Branch.AUT

If you guys are really nice, I might even give you his partner before I get night killed.

On September 26 2019 21:41 Eywa- wrote:
Branch dismissing me here when he has no reason to believe I'm bad at reading the game is really questionable and just adds onto the many other reasons you guys should be voting here.

This is ridiculous? You vote him out of nowhere and complain that hes dismissing you because youre supposedly good at the game.

Why should he think that if youre wrong and hes town? And if hes mafia why shouldnt he dismiss you?
In abstraction, you have delivered a prime example of damned if I do, damned if I dont.

If you dont acknowledge that this is plain BS with a backtrack and a formal apology to the god of logic Im voting you and never unvoting.

THAT'S MORE LIKE MY TOWN BUDDY VIVAX (maybe)

On September 27 2019 05:21 CopCake wrote:

On September 27 2019 05:02 ShoCkeyy wrote:

On September 27 2019 03:39 CopCake wrote:
Because I cant read him correctly and he was right about rayn last game.

And if you poke him he will be like “whatever” because he doesnt care nor engage a convo.

I would say that GB is town.
FF seems town.
Vivax smells mafia.
Shockey smells a little bit as mafia, just a little bit.

I am curious about one thing with you.

And Ewya is null.

I always smell like mafia every game I play. I just think it’s my posting style I guess... also why can’t we go after Eywa early?

Let him act. We can get info from that.

Just saying not the best lunch atm.

And who would be better?

On September 27 2019 05:47 Eywa- wrote:

On September 27 2019 01:56 FreezingFoot wrote:

I'd rather hear you now. Could you please share who his partner is?

This is not a good question, you are voting me... You want me to throw a name out, but you should be thinking...

What do I react if he says ______

If the answer is the same regardless, you might as well not ask the question. If you think I'm scum, it's also pointless.

I can't be sure if you're scum or not. I will always try to gather as much information as I can to sustain or change my read.
I want to understand your thought process. If I can't, you're probably fabricating reads. That's the point.
Who is his partner and why?

I agree that being right one game doesnt make that person the owner of the absolut truth; nevertheless in a next game you should at least read his opinion.

So I want to see his process, but rn he just acted as I remembered :D so I think he is town.

Now I need to analyze his read correctly to see if I agree ^^.

You don’t think he could be doing this as mafia?

I did and everyone thought I was town, so I won.

Then the next game everyone thought I was scum, so I lost as town despite immediately calling the scum team in a 3 player PoE.

I feel pretty comfy keeping you null then.

Carry on.

Finally, someone is being reasonable.

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 26 2019 21:43 GMT

#257

I'm a bit nervous because I think my PoE is quite narrow for this stage of the game, but I am eager to flip Branch to see if I'm right.

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 26 2019 21:47 GMT

#258

On September 27 2019 06:39 Eywa- wrote:

Show nested quote +

I'm not sure what you want me to say... I scum read him because he was Wolfy.

Actually, that's not ENTIRELY true, yes he was Wolfy and you should scum read him for it, but I actually think he had a >rand chance of being scum before he posted which is very unfortunate for him.

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 27 2019 13:33 GMT

#283

So... Branch's approach to this game is to whine about a very small minority of people voting him, ask questions that have already been answered and afk till deadline.

Idk if that's his town game then I'm not impressed, I don't see how it can be.

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 27 2019 13:43 GMT

#285

On September 27 2019 22:41 CopCake wrote:

Show nested quote +

Time passed.

I couldnt read him before.

Then I noticed “normal Ewya” and I was “ah he is town”

But you are not asking me why I think GB is locked town sir.

GB is locked town

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

September 27 2019 21:09 GMT

#378

BYE

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

October 06 2019 18:20 GMT

#1947

I played poorly, I'm not sure how HF lived after the tracker claim

Eywa-

Canada4876 Posts

October 06 2019 18:20 GMT

#1948

Gg

Prev 1 2 3 All

Please or register to reply.

Live Events Refresh

Refresh

Next event in 1h 55m

[ Submit Event ]

Refresh

StarCraft: Brood War

447
Pusan

224
actioN

156
Backho

105
Aegong

49
Sharp

27
Bale

20
Larva

20
[ Show more ]

Dota 2

League of Legends

609

Counter-Strike

Super Smash Bros

hungrybox262
Mew2King59
Westballz38

Other Games

gofns589
m0e_tv389
C9.Mang0304
Trikslyr30

Organizations

Dota 2

PGL Dota 2 - Main Stream6426
PGL Dota 2 - Secondary Stream1852

Other Games

gamesdonequick756

StarCraft 2

Blizzard YouTube

StarCraft: Brood War

BSLTrovo
sctven

[ Show 11 non-featured ]

Upcoming Events

CranKy Ducklings

1h 55m

WardiTV Map Contest Tou…

2h 55m

SC Evo League

5h 25m

IPSL

7h 55m

WolFix vs nOmaD

dxtr13 vs Razz

BSL

10h 55m

UltrA vs KwarK

Gosudark vs cavapoo

dxtr13 vs HBO

Doodle vs Razz

Patches Events

13h 55m

CranKy Ducklings

15h 55m

Sparkling Tuna Cup

1d 1h

WardiTV Map Contest Tou…

1d 2h

Ladder Legends

1d 6h

Liquipedia Results

Completed

Escore Tournament S2: W3

RSL Revival: Season 4

Ongoing

CSL 2026 SPRING (S20)

IPSL Spring 2026

KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 2

StarCraft2 Community Team League 2026 Spring

WardiTV TLMC #16

Nations Cup 2026

PGL Bucharest 2026

Stake Ranked Episode 1

BLAST Open Spring 2026

ESL Pro League S23 Finals

ESL Pro League S23 Stage 1&2

PGL Cluj-Napoca 2026

IEM Kraków 2026

Upcoming

Escore Tournament S2: W4

BSL 22 Non-Korean Championship

Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals

uThermal 2v2 2026 Main Event

RSL Revival: Season 5

XSE Pro League 2026

IEM Cologne Major 2026

Stake Ranked Episode 2

CS Asia Championships 2026

Asian Champions League 2026

IEM Atlanta 2026

PGL Astana 2026

BLAST Rivals Spring 2026

1.

ByuN
2.

TY
3.

Dark
4.

Solar
5.

6.

sOs
8.

soO
9.

1.

Rain
2.

Flash
3.

5.

Bisu
6.

Mini
8.

Sidebar Settings...