EPTboxerfred
FF
VIVAX
Eywax-
Got’em already!
Newbie Student Mafia XXX - Page 2
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
boxerfred FF VIVAX Eywax- Got’em already! | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
On September 26 2019 07:32 CopCake wrote: Why tho? Sup GB, how have your games been since we were mafia together? I am a bit curious of your shennanigans and what not. Sup Cake! I don’t know, I haven’t been playing the game for more than 2 years, if you don’t count my attempt to play last year, where I stopped playing because I completely lost access to my account  About the reads, gut feeling. Except for epóxi-, I simply dislike the possibility that he is playing wit joy reading his role PM | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
On September 26 2019 08:23 CopCake wrote: Want me tbh? I also feel evil vibes from vivax D: IKR!? I mean, what townie would be hyped to play with me again? That’s insane! | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
| ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
On September 26 2019 10:24 Fecalfeast wrote: Lol ok I'll ignore the read on me but why have 2 people said vivax is scummy when he has actually posted more than once? Vivax has a very easy meta to read and by the end of this day or the next he will be an obvious lock read. I also wonder if I have that pic of me in the bear mask from long ago Gut feeling, basically. I can’t really explain. On September 26 2019 10:32 ShoCkeyy wrote: So GlowingBear joined after me, are you coming for me? D: Cause this is also my first game in a long time. Actually, yes, and I’m actually living inside your house. You have to clean fill your fridge more often btw, there’s a ketchup here expired since 2016 and that’s all there is. | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
On September 26 2019 13:58 CopCake wrote: Lets talk GB, since you seem town. I have been playing once in a while, last two games were bad. Alright, what do you wanna talk about? On September 26 2019 19:36 Vivax wrote: Im leaning mafia on BF for now. But Im aware that when little of value has been posted by others, I might just be paying too much attention to those who actually post. On a reread, I found it strange that BF found it necessary to comment on nobody posting for six minutes, but mostly I found his reply to GB with the extra spaces forced. I dont see a townie reason for BF to be so distrustful within the first few posts. GB so far looks like hes having fun so he can go to town pile. Hes a pretty good scum player but he tends to go full emo as mafia and fooled me with it in the past iirc. FF feeling offended for the mod power thingy rubs me the wrong way too since I never suggested he actually did it. Mostly mentioned it because it was the reason I got to stare at his icon and see a pinocchio. I had the exact opposite reaction to boxerfred's opening. I don't think FF's answer to you was alignment indicative. Also, why are you townreading me and talking about me going full emo as scum? It seems that you're trying to justify a future shift of your read on me. On September 26 2019 21:44 Eywa- wrote: Also, the fact that he immediately is considering that I'm incorrectly voting instead of being mafia... Almost like he knows I'm town which he also has no reason to believe. This feels like you decided he is mafia before finding the arguments to it. This "perfect information" argument isn't convincing. On September 26 2019 22:08 Eywa- wrote: Agreed, unfortunately you are being lynched today. We should probably start discussing the day 2 lynch now. If Branch flips town, you should definitely be considering me as an option. I have some ideas for who his partner is, but I'd like to give everyone the opportunity to play. I'd rather hear you now. Could you please share who his partner is? On September 26 2019 22:18 Branch.AUT wrote: I like what boxerfred has pasted so far. He seems to be interested in the game and looking for contributions. I have to disagree with his GB read though. Most of what GB posted so far seems to be chatting and everything outside the game. It does indeed seem ligh hearted, but well within the range of a good scum player as far as I am concerned. I'm not a good scum player. I am an okay scum player. To be fair, it's not really hard to detect me when I'm scum. I was lynched almost every game I played as scum. The point is: as scum, I usually act as a support. When I flip, people get everything wrong. Which is great . But rest assured that I'm not scum in this game.(And if I was, I wouldn't be telling you this) On September 26 2019 23:33 Eywa- wrote: It is amusing though that you interpret my shit posting as an attempt to flesh out a scum read. Branch is outed scum, I really don't have to make a case for it. Yes, you do, and this tunnel seems very fabricated. ##Vote: Eywa- | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
On September 27 2019 02:29 CopCake wrote: I wouldnt touch Ewya this early tho GB I can touch anyone I want, he was consenting, I can prove it. On September 27 2019 02:53 Eywa- wrote: It's not a huge distinction, but it is a significant one. Your post makes it seem like I was looking for arguments to justify why he was Mafia, but I'm not doing that at all. He is mafia, I'm telling you, if my track record is not enough to justify that, then I guess I would say... Sounds like you want to lose. If you're not forcing that read, I'm having a hard time to understand why you think he is mafia. Is it for meta? Please explain to me like I'm a 4 y.o.  Btw, did you read you role pm? On September 27 2019 03:39 Fecalfeast wrote: I will say that branch after the eywa baseless accusation has given me feelings. Also I'm gonna be on a sort of vacation for the next 4 days lmao i probably shouldn't have signed up but I'll grab some time when i can. No real spammers here I'll be fine Wait for me, I'll be spamming in a pinch. On September 27 2019 03:39 CopCake wrote: Because I cant read him correctly and he was right about rayn last game. And if you poke him he will be like “whatever” because he doesnt care nor engage a convo. I would say that GB is town. FF seems town. Vivax smells mafia. Shockey smells a little bit as mafia, just a little bit. I am curious about one thing with you. And Ewya is null. Cool. Why is Vivax mafia? Why shockey smells like mafia? Ewayhijole- being right on rayn isn't proof he will be right in this game. Don't you think this is weak reasoning to give up on trying to read Ewaychupazi-? On September 27 2019 05:06 Vivax wrote: This is ridiculous? You vote him out of nowhere and complain that hes dismissing you because youre supposedly good at the game. Why should he think that if youre wrong and hes town? And if hes mafia why shouldnt he dismiss you? In abstraction, you have delivered a prime example of damned if I do, damned if I dont. If you dont acknowledge that this is plain BS with a backtrack and a formal apology to the god of logic Im voting you and never unvoting. THAT'S MORE LIKE MY TOWN BUDDY VIVAX (maybe) On September 27 2019 05:21 CopCake wrote: Let him act. We can get info from that. Just saying not the best lunch atm. And who would be better? On September 27 2019 05:47 Eywa- wrote: This is not a good question, you are voting me... You want me to throw a name out, but you should be thinking... What do I react if he says ______ If the answer is the same regardless, you might as well not ask the question. If you think I'm scum, it's also pointless. I can't be sure if you're scum or not. I will always try to gather as much information as I can to sustain or change my read. I want to understand your thought process. If I can't, you're probably fabricating reads. That's the point. Who is his partner and why? | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
On September 27 2019 06:20 Eywa- wrote: If you're not sure what you're looking for, you might as well use this: random.org/lists I think my question is pretty clear. | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
On September 27 2019 06:26 Eywa- wrote: I mean, I'm all for constructive discussion, but starting from a fundamental disagreement on what is alignment indicative and what is a rather tricky place to take off from. We can start a constructive discussion as soon as you answer my questions | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
But you did THINK it. You know you did. GlowingBear, the green bear of beers! | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
##Unvote ##Vote: Branch.AUT | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
On September 27 2019 06:54 CopCake wrote: I see Vivax as mafia, that is all you are going to get from me rn. And back to work. Detective GB, 🕵🏽♀️ since I think you are town, I hope we make a better team as townmates than mafiascummates. Count on me! But now I'm going to sleep because the game is already figured out by Eywa- and I recommend you to sheep him. | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
On September 27 2019 16:00 Fecalfeast wrote: Can you give me some specific posts or thoughts that make him scummy to you or is it just a lame tone gut read Yes. He is too focused on bashing on Eywa instead of actually scum hunt. If you check their interaction, Branch opted to just defend himself from Eywa, but not actually justifying his actions. He chose to discredit Eywa, and keeps on doing this. He only appeared again in the forums once I voted him. It seems his only concern is surviving. And re-reading Eywa, although I dislike how he is playing, I could see his tunnel coming from a town perspective. He could be town. | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
We need to consolidate, anyway. | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
| ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
| ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
On September 28 2019 02:08 Tubesock wrote: I think you’re wrong here. Eywa scummed him before he did anything, there’s no actions to defend. Eywa essentially did what rayn did when he was my mason partner (scumread hydra before he posted) and Eywa scumread rayn for it too. Branch also dropped a couple reads so wasn’t always defending himself. I could be wrong, but I don't think I am now. One thing is to dismiss what Eywa said, the other is to use his whole day to just say how bad Eywa. As town, shouldn't he be trying to understand Eywa and then having a conclusion about his alignment? He never said he is town or mafia! | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
On September 28 2019 02:16 Tubesock wrote: What do people think of CopCake? I’m 180 on their reads. Not sure how someone can town Boxer, and don’t like the Vivax, Shockeyy, Branch team. I don't think you need to think of teams now TS. Just vote the scummiest. Who's the scummiest? | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
On September 28 2019 02:25 Tubesock wrote: Sure town “should” try to understand attackers alignment but I don’t think that happens very often. Usually it’s straight to OMGUS. Exactly, but he is not actually OMGUSing much, isn't it? All I know is that he said "you're wrong and everyone who thinks you're right are wrong. I won't be here today xoxo" | ||
|
FreezingFoot
457 Posts
On September 28 2019 02:29 Tubesock wrote: I’m not thinking of teams. I think that trio is more likely town. Eywa Of the wagons. I’d rather see boxer or copcake be lynched due POE. I'm comfortable in calling CopCake town for now, boxerfred is being boxerfred and his opening sounded townie to me (gut feelings) I won't lynch these guys today | ||
| ||
