Newbie Student Mafia XXX - Page 11

On September 26 2019 23:01 Vivax wrote:
phoneposting for a while . BF is blowing up my mod icon joke and eywa has been snorting a bit too much coconut powder for my liking. would appreciate if he fleshed put his branch scumread with quality and not quantity.

On September 27 2019 01:10 ShoCkeyy wrote:
Can we vote Eywa?

On September 26 2019 13:58 CopCake wrote:
Lets talk GB, since you seem town.

I have been playing once in a while, last two games were bad.

On September 26 2019 19:36 Vivax wrote:
Im leaning mafia on BF for now. But Im aware that when little of value has been posted by others, I might just be paying too much attention to those who actually post.

On a reread, I found it strange that BF found it necessary to comment on nobody posting for six minutes, but mostly I found his reply to GB with the extra spaces forced. I dont see a townie reason for BF to be so distrustful within the first few posts.

GB so far looks like hes having fun so he can go to town pile. Hes a pretty good scum player but he tends to go full emo as mafia and fooled me with it in the past iirc.

FF feeling offended for the mod power thingy rubs me the wrong way too since I never suggested he actually did it. Mostly mentioned it because it was the reason I got to stare at his icon and see a pinocchio.

On September 26 2019 21:44 Eywa- wrote:

Also, the fact that he immediately is considering that I'm incorrectly voting instead of being mafia... Almost like he knows I'm town which he also has no reason to believe.

On September 26 2019 22:08 Eywa- wrote:

Agreed, unfortunately you are being lynched today.

We should probably start discussing the day 2 lynch now. If Branch flips town, you should definitely be considering me as an option.

I have some ideas for who his partner is, but I'd like to give everyone the opportunity to play.

On September 26 2019 22:18 Branch.AUT wrote:
I like what boxerfred has pasted so far. He seems to be interested in the game and looking for contributions.
I have to disagree with his GB read though. Most of what GB posted so far seems to be chatting and everything outside the game. It does indeed seem ligh hearted, but well within the range of a good scum player as far as I am concerned.

On September 26 2019 23:33 Eywa- wrote:
It is amusing though that you interpret my shit posting as an attempt to flesh out a scum read. Branch is outed scum, I really don't have to make a case for it.

On September 27 2019 01:56 FreezingFoot wrote:


This feels like you decided he is mafia before finding the arguments to it. This "perfect information" argument isn't convincing.

On September 27 2019 02:50 Eywa- wrote:


I can see where you're coming from, but you're wrong. I decided he was Mafia before posting the "arguments", but the "arguments" are not the reason that he's mafia, they are mostly just me mocking "cases".

On September 27 2019 02:53 Eywa- wrote:

It's not a huge distinction, but it is a significant one. Your post makes it seem like I was looking for arguments to justify why he was Mafia, but I'm not doing that at all. He is mafia, I'm telling you, if my track record is not enough to justify that, then I guess I would say... Sounds like you want to lose.

On September 27 2019 02:29 CopCake wrote:
I wouldnt touch Ewya this early tho GB