[M][N][72/24]Midnight Sun Mafia - Page 34

On May 26 2019 14:44 wherebugsgo wrote:
Alright, since everyone's asleep except me let me dump my thoughts and get opinions before I do my Sunday reflection time in time for the day to start again on Monday.

We have 3 confirmed townies if no one else claims blue:

koshi
rayn
wherebugsgo

No point in me waiting for the EON to post this now because I don't see any evidence rayn or koshi are fake claiming here and the flip was not another blue as I was suspecting, so Koshi's hit claim is 100% legit unless we have a jailer come forward later in the game. I'm:

gunsmith

that's how my role appears, even though it's Gunsmith in the OP.
Important thing to know about my role: I know whether I was roleblocked on n1 because I can check whether I have a gun after the night if I've tried to send the gun to someone. I don't have my gun anymore and so my send on n1 was successful.

to the person who received my gun on n1: Shoot VE tonight.

Now that's over with, here's my remaining thoughts:

There are 3 scum in these players:
VE/BC/HF/Calix/disformation/Artanis

That's currently the order I'd kill them, left to right.

VisceraEyes he's dead tonight unless I happened to give my gun to a scum n1. Highly doubt that though

BloodyC0bbler - very likely to be scum with VE because he's been passing on reading a lot of players, especially VE in particular. Really bad posts today. Raging on Koshi getting shot, bad play, etc. smells like he's genuinely tired of this game but it looks a lot worse to me now because unlike last game he hasn't actively helped me as much as I'd expect him to, and I think his reads are trash. He also took no stance on me vs VE and given the amount of time and number of posts I've made, it's unacceptable that he still townreads VE. I personally believe he needs to die tomorrow.

HolyFlare pretty likely to be scum here too. Given the events of the game and now that we know rayn and Koshi are town, I'll leave it to both of them to decide between HF/Calix/BC. Both ruxxar and iGrok thought he was scum and it's honestly not terribly unlikely that HF is scum given how chaotic this town has been. Even if all of the scumteam options here are disgusting like VE/BC/HF or VE/BC/Calix or (less likely IMO) VE/Calix/HF we can still easily win here.

Highly likely town
Jockmcplop - you can do this. Look at my reads but also trust your own as it gets later in the game.
Conversion - highly doubt you're scum here. iGrok saw the same thing I did on you, and so did Calix.

Townish but on the POE list:
Calix - I believe you're town but you're part of the POE list now because rayn and koshi are confirmed town and it's confirmed that koshi was shot. If you're town your job will be to figure out the one scum between HF/disfo/artanis, with a possibility of conversion, I believe. However you're probably the best lynch after HF if he flips town because you obviously would have a huge motivation to shoot Koshi, and if you're on a team with VE that would be an obvious bus opportunity as well. Sorry.
Artanis I gave you quite a pass on d2. You looked a lot better than BC to me. You also scumread BC. I actually see some of the anger tone appearing on BC so I think the meta defense case was bad (and this makes HF look way worse as well) especially because if BC is scum here he's playing with VE, and if HF is scum with him then the defense on BC wasn't real. However you didn't really agree with me on VE so that's a minus in my book on you. Once VE flips red on the daypost I hope you can pull out a lynch of BC or HF tomorrow without getting mislynched if you are indeed town here.
disformation - I believe you're town as well but at this point I don't remember exactly why. You're my least certain read here and you need to start taking really hard stances on which pair of scum teammates VE has, otherwise you might be lynchbait.

+ Show Spoiler +

On May 26 2019 19:18 Jockmcplop wrote:


Did you miss when I tried to save iGrock with a BC vote switch and got shut down cos everyone's pussywhipped by hf???

On May 26 2019 20:12 Holyflare wrote:
Just use your gun on calix that's all I ask. She revealed she mafia.

On May 27 2019 13:06 Conversion wrote:


I’ve prepared his robes, boots, and diamond encrusted sceptre.

On May 27 2019 15:51 Calix wrote:
If you are going to kill me in triple MYLO without even considering a world where I am town then kindly let me know so I can do something else with my life three days in advance.

I don't want to do what I did in the last game I played, where I tried hard to avoid being mislynched yet ended up being killed in LYLO anyway because nobody was willing to re-evaluate.

On May 27 2019 12:16 VisceraEyes wrote:
Anyone following Koshi into oblivion, please step into line behind him in an orderly fashion. I'll be right there, I'm just preparing the map for our Lord.

On May 27 2019 16:43 Jockmcplop wrote:
I dunno calix it looks kinda like you're trying to find reasons why voting iGrock and Ruxxar doesn't make you mafia, more than trying to figure out why other people were doing what they were doing.