There's a huge difference between not really caring once you've won(and maybe going AFK) and outing an entire game and stopping the game for everyone else. At that point it's not about you "not caring" its about you just wanting to ruin the game.

I mean I'm not even sure if I believe you still because of how bad it is to out your team, but at this point might as well lynch KSC.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 17:13 GMT

#2696

Yeah the game was really awesome. Am still having a lot of fun.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 17:22 GMT

#2700

Kelsier role OP

Both a jailer and a cultist. Spread some love hosts!

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 17:24 GMT

#2701

If I was Kelsier I feel like I would be terrified of doing anything that would get me lynched. I would just want to keep playing the game so I could keep using my night actions.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 17:48 GMT

#2707

Actually I think Rayn truly doesn't give a fuck, but as a town and not mafia.
I really don't believe that mafia would ever recruit him for the reasons he said.
And rayn definitely started at least as town because there's no way the hosts give mafia a repeat vigilante, so this isn't some sort of mafia play to get a mislynch.

I also don't believe Kelsier has both a cultist and a jailer role. Both of those roles are amazing. In one person?

Also I truly believe that Kelsier converted Grack as part of his jailer role, because it is really weird for mafia just to randomly convert Grack of all people.

And why would mafia kelsier jail or agree to jail mafia palmar?

Also read this:

On April 12 2019 00:18 Pandain wrote:
If Kelsier is Mafia that means that he would have 100% known that he can convert grack to mafia. Basically a free +1, but in a really fucking weird way.

Do you guys think that is likely?

Finally, it's pretty convenient that the "mafia team" happen to be exactly the people rayn thought were mafia pre-claim.

I'm going back to Sentinel.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 17:49 GMT

#2709

I also genuinely don't believe, despite what he's saying, that Rayn would actually out a mafia team if he got converted.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 17:50 GMT

#2710

If Palmar is the cultist that means no one could have been recruited today because Palmar was jailed. Palmar can't be the cultist.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 17:51 GMT

#2712

All signs lead to Sentinel. Stay on course people.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 17:52 GMT

#2713

Oh shit for some reason I thought that for the last like day and night.

I still don't think he started day 1 mafia though.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 17:54 GMT

#2716

Kelsier being mafia just makes no sense to me. Disinfo what you think of my reasons above?

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 17:57 GMT

#2718

Rayn who did Kelsier say he converted night 1. Grack?

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 17:58 GMT

#2721

Rayn if what you are saying is true they are literally the most incompetant mafia team in history.

And you think Palmar is part of that team?

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 18:02 GMT

#2725

Palmar has 106 posts here in the thread and 2 in the QT?

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 19:11 GMT

#2740

Rayn claiming cop is just another way of saying he was lying about the original thing. He's not actually a cop

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 19:12 GMT

#2741

I don't think it makes him mafia. But if Sentinel ends up being mafia I think he might be a good choice for people who might be converted.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 19:15 GMT

#2743

Rayn tunnels on people. Once he makes up his mind nothing will ever change it. Last game I played with him he tunneled on Acro (town) the entire game until he got shot.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 19:16 GMT

#2744

We have to go for the cultist this night. Otherwise we might just lose if cultist can continually reuse his powers.

Sentinel is the best chance considering he's probably not a real cop.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 19:18 GMT

#2745

Kelsier might actually be mafia. But he's almost certainly not the cultist.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 12 2019 19:24 GMT

#2749

On April 13 2019 04:22 disformation wrote:

Show nested quote +

yes, we need the cultist or its gege.
i still think psamlar makes sense for cultist... but he should not have been able to convert someone this night.

down to ksc vs sent.

i agree that sent is very not cop.
question is if ksc lied about his role. eg sent could be the remover and ksc the converter. makes sense with ksc's role name?

dunno. whole bunch of them is that afk that i cant tell if they are aware enough of stuff to go for teh plays.

That's a really great question and would be pretty sick. But it's really far-forward thinking at a time they didn't have to be.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

April 13 2019 18:41 GMT

#2782

If we're trying to kill the cultist Kelsier is the last person we want to lynch. There is no way that one guy has both a jailkeeper and cultist role in one.

And if he was the cultist and that's how his role worked, why would he ever choose Grack? Why not choose someone who could be a powerful town influence? No one was talking about Grack or wanted to lynch him. It doesn't make any sense.

Kelsier could be mafia but there's no way he's the cultist.