On April 08 2019 04:49 Tumblewood wrote:
i have no interest in lynching MZ, eywa, rayn, or HF today. roles are a bad reason to lynch people right now because clearly no one understands how the roles work. i suggest we target the people who are scummy and inactive, because that is how mafia works.
mig, mocsta, KSC, maybe damdred are good options. no idea why we would go and kill important players this early

Vivax

22267 Posts

April 09 2019 15:12 GMT

#1705

On April 09 2019 15:15 Mocsta wrote:

Show nested quote +

Yeah I recall you made some spiel post about it

but yeah i agree this is quite reminiscient of mathematician win-con

"Heres the thing, I know town obviously has sub factions in it that wants the other sub factions to die.

For instance rayn needs me to die, I need rayn to die.

But we both more than likely win with town, personally speaking I value a general win more than a personal win.

LS I do t want to ever die."

So...
Hindu
Recruiter = LS
Assassin = MZ
Math 1 = Eywa-
Math 2 = Damdred

Roman
Recruiter = ??
Assassin = FecalFeast - No counter claim -> Assume not mafia interspersed
Math 1 = ?? Rayn ??
Math 2 = ?

Non-Inquisitor
Poisoner = Jock

Rest
Tubesock - One concern I had was #859 as prior to that I didn't think TS engaged me as if I was townread.
Holyflare - I want to believe that his appeal to emotion about anti-town role and cultist play is too low a blow for scum. So lock town.
Pandain - Lazy meta read compared to last game
Mig -
Vivax - I noted that #908 was a good post. I want to see how Vivax follows up on KSC
KSC - Nothing redeeming other than perhaps #202
TW - Seems to be counterpart of HF, as didnt claim whatever happened to Grack??
Slam - No idea
VE - His posts add up to town for me
Grack - #305 contradicts his mathematician claim.
Palmar - I'm still waiting for more
disfo - Did he send Grack away? I thought hes been pretty consistently invested all game. light town read.
Sentinel - As I mentioned before, after the shit show of last game, i woudl expect more from a town roll this game.
Mocsta - ??

I love this post, it actually brings some order into this clusterfuck.

The most interesting question to me is whether we believe that Onegu actually put the equivalent of 8 Named townies into the game or if there's mafia scattered among those sub cults. For simplicitys sake it's probably better to assume they are all town for now. So the remaining Romans should claim since Damdred is harmless to them anyway.

Vivax

22267 Posts

April 09 2019 16:12 GMT

#1756

My lynch pool atm looks this, in no particular order:

Mig - Repeatedly keeps bringing up activity for unnecessary reasons. Loose cannon style of questions that are an easy way of appearing active plus his question directed at TW.

KSC - Kinda just exists and goes along without trying to get his hands dirty too much, complained about me being on his ass when I have at most gently kicked it. Going to wait on his promise of effort.

Disformation - Also just going along, don't see him even trying to get a read on me after saying multiple times he'd take a look at my filter. Seems like he's in the comfort zone when lynch is headed for Sentinel/KSC. Keeping it in mind for associations later.

Palmar - Weekend is over and didn't see much smart stuff from him besides a push on Damdred who is probably town (as long as we go with the theory that all romans and hindus are) and one on Sentinel.

Sentinel - Just very non contributive. Have yet to see someone try to work through whether he's bad town or actually mafia. I for myself can't make that distinction. But since this is a no vig game I think it might be worth lynching him just to get a null out.

Pandain - His "cause I'm town" arguments reminded me of his scum game where he tried to push the fact really hard that he was town cause his shot on HF was good. Not a reason for me to scumread him, but I remember someone townreading him based on that post. I just don't see much that makes me lean one way or another on him.

Sentinel just has a very lynch baity feeling to him and seems like a policy lynch at this point.

I'm mostly looking at dudes for mafia who flock around rayn and HF while appearing active. Objectively disfo fits the profile the best. Has a very copycatty feeling to him. Kelsier would come second.

Vivax

22267 Posts

April 09 2019 16:15 GMT

#1759

On April 10 2019 00:48 Holyflare wrote:
I reckon rayn and palmar have been bussed. Can't recruit mafia palmar. Rayn a likely protect target.

Explains ve thing and why recruit failed. Either rayn is mafia or a bus.

What?

Vivax

22267 Posts

April 09 2019 16:23 GMT

#1766

I missed this entire VE targeting Palmar business while writing. So he targeted Palmar, and rayn got a message of his target being Roman or what?

Vivax

22267 Posts

April 09 2019 16:24 GMT

#1767

I've read through the last pages but didn't find it very comprehensive. And wtf is a helper thing. Ok, keep your faction name to yourself. But there's a difference between being a bus driver and...anything else. And bus drivers always targets two dudes.

Vivax

22267 Posts

April 09 2019 17:20 GMT

#1813

Disfo and VE are date doctors?

Prev 1 2 3 All

Please or register to reply.

Live Events Refresh