Definitely wait & see on Vivax imo.
He has a nose for scum so it might be worth keeping him around.

I agree with hf that Kelsier is looking scummy. His voting post was very wet and flimsy.

Padawan, the nose for scum prophecy rarely pays dividends.

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 08 2019 09:10 GMT

#1250

Are you OK Will?

Im really concerned for you

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 08 2019 14:09 GMT

#1395

So eywa claims hindu mathematician nd somehow thought he would be recruited by mafia?

Damdred and rayn supposedly have also claimed math and never mentioned this.

Wtf is this game?

Jock
U r padawan. Its ok. Still town.

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 08 2019 14:19 GMT

#1400

On April 08 2019 03:10 Eywa- wrote:

Show nested quote +

I feel like the game is also bastard, not sure if that was initially stated -- to be honest, I didn't actually read the description.

- My role is town, but I don't win with all of town... From the looks of it, I only win with 1/3 of town.
- There is definitely recruiting, I don't know if this is cult or Mafia... I am NOT a recruiter.

This is what i dont get

Rayn / damdred / eywa all same role supposedly.

Rayn opens with needing to kill faction
Damdred expands this

Nothing in eywa talks about killing off faction

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 08 2019 14:21 GMT

#1401

On April 08 2019 23:10 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Show nested quote +

this guy is still scum

Ok bby gurl

Im town and u need me too

Sweet dreams

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 08 2019 23:21 GMT

#1510

On April 09 2019 07:35 disformation wrote:
@hf: you better not be the inquisitor. that would make me sad.

I treat this as unlikely
HF went about Day1 as per his textbook town-style.

What makes you say "the" inquisitor?

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 08 2019 23:26 GMT

#1513

Im guessing Grackeroni has been gagged for this cycle

[b][green]Is Grackeroni voteable whilst 'removed from the Repbulic'?"

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 08 2019 23:27 GMT

#1514

terrible
EBWOP

Is Grackeroni able to be voted whilst 'removed from the Republic'?

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 08 2019 23:44 GMT

#1518

On April 09 2019 07:00 rsoultin wrote:
Though Pisa is far from a crimeless Republic, the events of last night are strange enough to sweep through the populace. Some speculate that the wrongfully executed assassin found to be in the employ of the newly-formed Hindu-Arabic Council has resulted in a backlash, though that hardly explains the third dead body found with a mysterious device. Additionally, a citizen has gone missing. And another rumor circulates: that the Genoa resistance is growing.

I DONT LIKE THE IMPLICATION OF THIS

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 09 2019 00:17 GMT

#1521

This game is much harder than it seems because of the alt win-cons which leads to town lying to and hunting other town.

3 flipped factions + mafia = 4 known factions.
Role PM details and thread speculation leads to a total of 5 to 6 factions.
(1) Hindu
(2) Roman
(3) Anti-Inquisition
(4) Town 'no faction' with alt-wincon to "find someone" = HF
(4-5) Inquisition - Targetting mathematicians // mafia
(5) Mafia = Genoa

The Grack thing has enacted how HF suggested his role works.. Im not sure what to make of that.

The problem I'm seeing this game is how town KP works.
Assassin/Poisoner etc is all anti-town focused KP.
This doesn't make sense.

I suppose where I'm getting at is, I win with "town" but I have no idea what "town" is this game.
I have no idea because everything is designed that we can kill within.

And if the game is about genoa being a cultist, it makes limited sense because by the time this is evident, a lot of town Kp roles that can eliminate genoa is out of the game.

At this point my only comfortable vote would be against [UoN]Sentinel for the same reasons I articulated last night.
Otherwise, i would actually consider a no-lynch.

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 09 2019 04:05 GMT

#1526

On April 09 2019 11:47 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Whats the point of winning if you dont leave the game?

U in a qt?

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 09 2019 05:30 GMT

#1528

##Convert: FecalFeast

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 09 2019 05:37 GMT

#1531

Hihi,
FINALLY someones else

Lets work together

plus I think you town

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 09 2019 05:46 GMT

#1533

On April 08 2019 07:11 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
Oof

Realized it was too silent for scum to give up one of theirs so I wanted to change the lynch to Damdy before deadline. No guarantee he's scum either but I'd take a coinflip over "probably not"

That didn't work.

On April 08 2019 07:12 Fecalfeast wrote:
this feels not genuine to me. like you had been preparing it beforehand idk

I agree

##Vote: [UoN]Sentinel

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 09 2019 05:48 GMT

#1534

On April 09 2019 14:42 Pandain wrote:
Let's do this.

kk

Now we have more thread info, should we look into damdy? Does his perspective make sense as town at all?

I liked this in FF filter

On April 06 2019 10:20 Fecalfeast wrote:
I do wonder why damdred thinks that town is trying to kill itself and at the same time kill mafia. Seems like that would be a hugely mafia favoured setup but he doesn't even consider an alternative like multiple factions.

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 09 2019 05:50 GMT

#1535

actually. i dunno how i feel about that sentinel post

##Unvote
Lets openly explore this shit, so yeah.. agree to dig into damdy?

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 09 2019 05:55 GMT

#1539

On April 09 2019 14:53 Tumblewood wrote:
hey mocsta and pandain... wanna explain?

~~##Convert: Pandain~~
##Convert Tumblewood

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 09 2019 06:15 GMT

#1545

On April 09 2019 14:53 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Damdred cant be mafia.

Yeah I recall you made some spiel post about it

but yeah i agree this is quite reminiscient of mathematician win-con

"Heres the thing, I know town obviously has sub factions in it that wants the other sub factions to die.

For instance rayn needs me to die, I need rayn to die.

But we both more than likely win with town, personally speaking I value a general win more than a personal win.

LS I do t want to ever die."

So...
Hindu
Recruiter = LS
Assassin = MZ
Math 1 = Eywa-
Math 2 = Damdred

Roman
Recruiter = ??
Assassin = FecalFeast - No counter claim -> Assume not mafia interspersed
Math 1 = ?? Rayn ??
Math 2 = ?

Non-Inquisitor
Poisoner = Jock

Rest
Tubesock - One concern I had was #859 as prior to that I didn't think TS engaged me as if I was townread.
Holyflare - I want to believe that his appeal to emotion about anti-town role and cultist play is too low a blow for scum. So lock town.
Pandain - Lazy meta read compared to last game
Mig -
Vivax - I noted that #908 was a good post. I want to see how Vivax follows up on KSC
KSC - Nothing redeeming other than perhaps #202
TW - Seems to be counterpart of HF, as didnt claim whatever happened to Grack??
Slam - No idea
VE - His posts add up to town for me
Grack - #305 contradicts his mathematician claim.
Palmar - I'm still waiting for more
disfo - Did he send Grack away? I thought hes been pretty consistently invested all game. light town read.
Sentinel - As I mentioned before, after the shit show of last game, i woudl expect more from a town roll this game.
Mocsta - ??

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 09 2019 06:16 GMT

#1546

On April 09 2019 15:14 Tumblewood wrote:
are you tellin me these fellas just converted me and then left with no explanation

ohh man.
this was funny

i went away cos was doing a post

the convert was a joke

On April 09 2019 13:05 Fecalfeast wrote:
it's like, now i'm a perfect candidate to be converted because if i win either way who cares so I'm vowing right now that if I get converted to something I will announce it to thread

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

April 09 2019 06:19 GMT

#1548

The Roman mathematicians may have already won because so far, the only role with the title "council" is The recruiter.

Action order resolution may have resulted in LS getting a "recruit" off, but most likely it was to Eywa or Grack.
Both arent here, so the Hindu "Council" is most likely eliminated already.