|
On February 12 2018 21:56 Holyflare wrote:
The whole premise is that I voted mderg who was a scum read and didn't care about someone else's read who shared the same mderg read but I literally say mderg's play feels like last game, WHERE HE WAS TOWN. I lynched my really weak town read because he was doing shit all and all of my town reads were on him (koshi, ritoky) vs rsoul who I waivered on because she rage quit and came back and posted. So I hadn't read a single thing in the game and just sheeped my town reads as well as using a bit of bias and we lynched mafia.
His point was that you lynching mderg over rsoultin would never happen with town!HF since town!HF never lets his scum read not be his lynch, no?
I have to sort of agree with him on this one. When you think you found scum, I never see you let go of it. like ever.
|
On February 12 2018 23:32 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On February 12 2018 23:28 Conversion wrote:On February 12 2018 21:56 Holyflare wrote:
The whole premise is that I voted mderg who was a scum read and didn't care about someone else's read who shared the same mderg read but I literally say mderg's play feels like last game, WHERE HE WAS TOWN. I lynched my really weak town read because he was doing shit all and all of my town reads were on him (koshi, ritoky) vs rsoul who I waivered on because she rage quit and came back and posted. So I hadn't read a single thing in the game and just sheeped my town reads as well as using a bit of bias and we lynched mafia. His point was that you lynching mderg over rsoultin would never happen with town!HF since town!HF never lets his scum read not be his lynch, no? I have to sort of agree with him on this one. When you think you found scum, I never see you let go of it. like ever. When do I ever just ditch my scum read as mafia?
I was about to just make this point. I've only played one game when you were Mafia I think.. and that was CCCP. So I do not have a good frame of reference of your mafia games. Hmm.
|
I'm not mad at this, but I feel like I played so stupid D2 that rayn cannot possibly see me as scum.
Things to chuckle at for post game. 
Anyways, read through some filters and I could not determine much more than what rayn did. So I read his filter again, and read his big dick posts. So I will continue sheeping him.
|
[QUOTE]On February 13 2018 04:07 disformation wrote:
[QUOTE]On February 13 2018 03:18 Holyflare wrote:
[QUOTE]On February 13 2018 00:35 disformation wrote:
the thing is like if its either damdy or hf they fucked up real bad with the d1 vote.
which is of course possible, because that was not a great situation to be in and either seemed to be a bit short on time.
just have a feeling it might not be that easy.
though that is prolly paranoia. cause outside of those two...
rayn, prpl and me are pretty much 100% town.
rit was ultra chill earlier.
darth and conv dont rly make sense cause of their d1.
kinda leaves koshi?
sooo dunno. lynch damdy/hf/koshi for auto win?[/QUOTE]
Can you explain that to me? [/QUOTE]
tldr like it is kinda that:
[QUOTE]On February 13 2018 03:56 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I am just going to say i don't really care if you want to lynch Damdred first, because i believe he has almost the same chance of being scum than Holyflare. Also the fact is that whoever is mafia in this game the D1 was absolutely retarded for the mafia team so i don't buy any "this doesn't make any sense for me as mafia" from D1 because if that was a reason noone would be mafia. Except for prplhz or disformation, but that's not possible. But still always lynch prplhz if he's alive in F3 because then there is no doctor at all and it's a simple framer vs parity cop game.
I must say though, that if we go into the "this doesn't make any sense for me as mafia" then Conversion and darthfoley win the town prize.[/QUOTE]
but you also right. i'm not fully sure and should double check the why (see how bad I mixed up df's stuff at night).
conversion was early and strong on rs and even convinced trfel to vote her. then mderg come with his great post and conv jumps on him really hard. then he waffles a bit on the two and end up on mderg. I feel as scum it would make more sense for him to bus rs even harder and try to get cred from pushing her all day. also higher chance of saving the pr if he had stayed on rs.[/QUOTE]
Quick correction I ended up staying on rsoultin
|
My eyes. They bleed.
Quick correction I ended up staying on rsoultin
|
On February 13 2018 04:04 darthfoley wrote:Show nested quote +On February 13 2018 03:56 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I am just going to say i don't really care if you want to lynch Damdred first, because i believe he has almost the same chance of being scum than Holyflare. Also the fact is that whoever is mafia in this game the D1 was absolutely retarded for the mafia team so i don't buy any "this doesn't make any sense for me as mafia" from D1 because if that was a reason noone would be mafia. Except for prplhz or disformation, but that's not possible. But still always lynch prplhz if he's alive in F3 because then there is no doctor at all and it's a simple framer vs parity cop game.
I must say though, that if we go into the "this doesn't make any sense for me as mafia" then Conversion and darthfoley win the town prize. I'm biased, but I agree. I literally just got finished with a game where I tried the whole "soft bus my partner" thing and not only did we lose two mafia in three days, but I got vigi shot N1. That is the last strategy I would try to use in this game. Anyways, enough of the WIFOM. I still think the mafia is within HF/Koshi. I would be surprised if Damdred is lying about not wanting to play mafia if his dad is in the hospital. Maybe? Idk. My girlfriend left today (sadness) so I will have some time to look over some filters for the first time in like 4 days. I would really appreciate prplhz doing something for once in this game if he's actually doctor. Nothing like "confirmed" town doing literally 0 things to help the town.
Koshi's filter is the one I read the most but I have a really hard time seeing his play as mafia. As much I don't like him calling me mafia or bad or both at every opportune moment. I don't know if mafia!Koshi would spend all that time and energy yelling about how rsoultin is town if it's looking worse and worse for him to do so.. hm
|
On February 13 2018 04:13 disformation wrote:
so. both conv and darthfoley were onto both mderg and rsoultin and waffled between the two of them, but stayed on rs in the end?
and just sheeped rayn's case d2?
did I finally get it?
Yes. Well, yes for me at least. No idea what DF did.
|
Look no further than this amazing essay on why I am town, and why you should not lynch me.
On February 08 2018 07:43 Conversion wrote:
I am town. That is my defense.
|
On February 13 2018 19:34 prplhz wrote:Show nested quote +On February 13 2018 18:39 raynpelikoneet wrote:On February 13 2018 17:48 Koshi wrote:On February 12 2018 05:11 Conversion wrote:also if prplhz is mafia then I played a decent game. My first decent one On February 08 2018 00:26 Conversion wrote:
Someone (I think DF) also called out how hilarious it was that mderg commented on how he liked Mocsta for kind of knowing where he was going in the game, but also said he had a hard time really understanding his posts..
I think we centralize on prplhz/mderg/rsoul here. I'm leaning more towards prplhz/mderg, but I didn't like rsoultin's latest string of posts either. I will explain that soon. Conversion also looks good. Quoted post for sure. The thing that mostly makes Conversion town is that he was like super depressed during N1 because he was "playing badly" when his scumreads D1 were rsoultin and mderg. It would be a super twisted fake emotion as mafia to do that when you know you are 100% correct in your reads, and i am like 99,9% sure the emotion is genuine and not faked as mafia. I think he was depressed because people were scumreading him? Maybe it was more of a sarcastic "right, i'm sooooo bad even though i'm bussing my entire team, well done town". I still can't get over Show nested quote +On February 09 2018 20:56 Conversion wrote:
Why did Mocsta just post a PM? Fake or not. Wasn’t that against the rules? Weird play.. where Conversion softly calls out for a modkill for a town read of his. To me it just reads "Hey guys, shouldn't he totally be removed from the game?  Or I don't know what do you think?  "
So your logic on me being scum is because I asked if it's remotely allowed to even joke about role PMs?
|
rayn is confirmed cop
Disinfo confirmed town
prplhz is confirmed doc
I am town because I can read my role PM
DF is most less likely to be mafia with Mocsta shot (although is this WIFOM?)
I don't think Koshi is mafia with his filter.
HF/Damdred/ritoky
am I missing someone? I don't think so.
|
|
|
also assuming that this game isn't over after this lynch, who does mafia shoot? prplhz?
|
Koshi why do you have a 15 page filter.
Anyways, from half-reading it so far he's not done anything that you haven't done either, so why does that make him scum over you? Also, why would mafia!Koshi go for an all in play in trying to hard defense rsoultin like that? Why any mafia would do that is beyond me.
The only bad thing that was glaring from his filter was him zealously defending rsoultin and then suddenly saying he keeps a healthy amount of suspicion on her
|
On February 14 2018 00:39 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On February 14 2018 00:38 Conversion wrote:
Koshi why do you have a 15 page filter.
Anyways, from half-reading it so far he's not done anything that you haven't done either, so why does that make him scum over you? Also, why would mafia!Koshi go for an all in play in trying to hard defense rsoultin like that? Why any mafia would do that is beyond me.
The only bad thing that was glaring from his filter was him zealously defending rsoultin and then suddenly saying he keeps a healthy amount of suspicion on her Why are you acting like koshi is my scum read?? He's 3rd in a list and clearly would be default mafia because I'm not. If he was mafia those are the reasons why.
Okay, Damdred is your scum read. I will go read that filter now.
|
by lower I thought you meant on lower on my town <-> scum scale, not lower in suspicion. That was a misinterpretation on my end.
|
Can town explain why lynching Damdred and checking HF is a bad time?
|
On February 14 2018 00:45 Conversion wrote:
Can town explain why lynching Damdred and checking HF is a bad time?
I'm assuming it's some sort of reason why Damdred is more mafia than HF
|
er, HF more mafia than Damdred
|
On February 13 2018 03:56 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I am just going to say i don't really care if you want to lynch Damdred first, because i believe he has almost the same chance of being scum than Holyflare. Also the fact is that whoever is mafia in this game the D1 was absolutely retarded for the mafia team so i don't buy any "this doesn't make any sense for me as mafia" from D1 because if that was a reason noone would be mafia. Except for prplhz or disformation, but that's not possible. But still always lynch prplhz if he's alive in F3 because then there is no doctor at all and it's a simple framer vs parity cop game.
I must say though, that if we go into the "this doesn't make any sense for me as mafia" then Conversion and darthfoley win the town prize.
Looks like rayn doesn't care
|
HF, your case boils down to Damdred townread rsoultin all D1, then made this post:
On February 08 2018 09:19 Damdred wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 08:52 Koshi wrote:On February 08 2018 04:25 Damdred wrote:
I could probably lynch Mocsta/prp/ maybe mderg
The more I communicate with you tina the mbre i think you might be town. Mderg is a maybe he has some thinfs that look the same from last game but his scum reads are sort of meh so far.
Its difficult and im atill forming opinions atm On February 08 2018 04:52 Damdred wrote:
Heres the problem hf/df i do not thinl at this time tina is getting lynched unless hf switches and i hammer.
But we do need to consolidate at this time. For thw record tinas postings havent been bad since i got back What were you doing on Tina? Come on Damdred...... Mderg you attack and never get a satisfied answer from. rsoultin you attack and townread after talking to her. Who do you vote? rsoultin Come the fuck on bro. Koshi your answers yoi just asked are literally already in my filter. Way to cherry pick though. I grill mderg and he literally comits suicide by voting off of tina and gives himself the only shot of being lynched. I explained to tina amd df I believe in my filter I did not believe mderg would flip scum and I consolidated on tina. And out of Tina and Mderg, mderg looked more townie doing whatever and he is going to die then tina doing the same thing and not being in danger.
which you said makes no sense, as he should have townread both of them and voted elsewhere, and then all of a sudden comes to a realization that mderg/rsoultin are scum team. is there more that I'm missing aside from things you said recently?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
