Newbie Student Mafia XXVIII - Page 8

On January 28 2018 06:10 beentheredonethat wrote:

Okay, so who are in danger of being lynched and who is ranked highest on this list, for you?

On January 28 2018 06:29 beentheredonethat wrote:
just for the record, as long as jat's alive, I'll vote him over everyone else. Toxicity and ignorance is not exactly something I'm interested in.

On January 28 2018 06:29 beentheredonethat wrote:
now this is classic btdt

On January 28 2018 06:36 Holyflare wrote:


oho ho

On January 28 2018 06:58 beentheredonethat wrote:

I have not been toxic in this game. Ive been toxic before but what youre doing all this game is being hostile and ad hom towards me. I asked you to stop it, you refused. So youre either scum trying to tilt me or an asshole. Id prefer the first thing since this is a game where we (and the newbies!) Are supposed to have fun. If you as a veteran choose to act how you do without a reason, it gives a shitty impression of tje tl.net playerbase. So i really hope for you youre scum.

On January 28 2018 07:02 Holyflare wrote:
Let's just chill out and drop it. No more talk about not game related stuff please. Talk about who is mafia other than me because otherwise you're wasting time.

On January 28 2018 13:35 Holyflare wrote:


I don't think Damerion responds to a partner like this with more evidence to clarify a read to justify his damdred wagon. It seems as though he is doing what he can to convince mderg in this situation.

It's weak but its something to me.

On January 28 2018 21:56 Holyflare wrote:


I didn't agree with the Damerion read on Damdred, at all. I didn't particularly care for the meta. I cared about Damdred's reaction and his follow up to who he was pushing. A couple of things made it reallllyyyy unlikely he was town for me:

1. His acceptance of the meta. I just thought it was an insane coincidence that he accepted that it was true and conveniently wanted to change it to the detriment of his town game within one or two games. I thought accepting it essentially confirmed him mafia and he was just scared of Damerion's push because from my experience Damerion has always been correct.

Then even if I looked past the above I read DF's filter and he was pushing similar things to myself. Mocsta, Damdred etc. Damdred's scum read of choice was df and he was essentially appealing to emotions instead of ever really pushing DF. I think he had just one sentence on DF the entire game.

I don't know why you'd expect me to trust rsoultin's read of damdred which was entirely tone that I didn't agree with over my own logic based one though.



2. That's not entirely true. I was uncooperative because she tried to paint me as mafia for things that just occurred during day to day life such as being at work and only speaking up when I got home. When we got past that and posted about Damerion we just had differing opinions. I explained my read and she explained hers. She posted a case on him and to be frank I didn't really read much of it. Time, effort etc. It was only when she actually explained away my point that he used the meta too early etc and the fact he never posted about anyone else since that I really just realised I shouldn't defend him.

3. Damerion's claim was an entirely ego based thing. I've spent the game being contradictory and when he finally returned and I see the claim I'm just happy I was "correct" on my read. No, I didn't really think about the whole calling it in the thread thing and nor did I really care if he died or was rbd. I also did not read the op at all and thought there could be a framer and rb to balance it (I talk through this). When btdt claimed being rbd I just thought he was a jk and at that point I knew jk/cop/vig isn't right and I thought that btdt didn't claim rb day 2 because he was blue and they weren't announced. Turns out they were notified, he wasn't blue etc etc. I kept my vote on Damerion after because I asked for his reads and he was unable to provide them. He also didn't play like he was afraid of a rb and I didn't think he'd check btdt either.

On January 28 2018 22:14 Holyflare wrote:
What do you think of Mocsta? He seems to always want to be on the right side of what's happening and have his own different opinion and it bugs me. It feels quite unnatural in a way imo.