Newbie Student Mafia XXVIII - Page 108

On February 04 2018 20:31 rsoultin wrote:
-pokes Mocsta- I want to see your townplay though :/

On February 04 2018 20:47 Mocsta wrote:
No idea what it is. I havent played since end of 2013.

I would have been classed as paranoid and overly convoluted back then. I hope that has evolved somewhat now.

On February 04 2018 20:47 Mocsta wrote:
No idea what it is. I havent played since end of 2013.

I would have been classed as paranoid and overly convoluted back then. I hope that has evolved somewhat now.

On February 04 2018 20:52 rsoultin wrote:


Maybe we'll get to see it in Globe 16 or whatever...

Also, thanks JAT! You broke my years' long mafia losing streak @.@

I am still not certain why counter claiming Damerion was so bad it couldn't been done.
- With cc: People just lynch Damerion and actually talk about serious reads on D3, jat dies N3 and there they move on.
- Without cc (what happened): People argued all D3 if to lynch Damerion or not and D4 was nothing but people calling other people toxic (i dont even know why) and autoing on Holyflare (mostly because of HF's D3 -- which was already a dumb conclusion). Ironically HF was the only player who srsly tried to play mafia on D4 but "i am not answering you because yo, you're scum"

So they actually wasted one day phase of discussion.

On February 05 2018 01:47 raynpelikoneet wrote:
jat is there a game where you have lynched an un-cc'd blue claim as vanilla town?

I still stand behind what i said in obs qt, i don't think not ccing was smart because while you gained a mislynch what ended up happening was this:


Also it was not that Mocsta's decisions for night kills were bad (aside from the obvious mistake of kiiling mderg over jat last night), it is more that noone else would never ever had killed btdt over jat in the first place (you could kill jat regardless of if jat was a veteran or btdt the doctor). Rels was never going to be mafia because Rels would never leave both Koshi and (confirmed town) jat run around in the thread for one more phase. mderg knew btdt had to be town for the roleblock so if he was mafia most likely Kelsier's shot would have never gone through. Same with Holyflare. Koshi technically could have been mafia but he looked very townie from the beginning (sadly this replacement particularly prolly cost mafia the game).

It is not that you made bad decisions, but the fact is noone else as mafia would have made those decisions and aside from all you wrote or did this should have been a reason to always lynch you. Game was basically done when Damerion got lynched and btdt claimed roleblocked. Noone else could anymore be mafia than you (or Kmatt).

On February 05 2018 02:05 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Like i said in obs, noone would ever make the "vigi is an inv role so kita wouldnt put a cop and vigi in the game" argument had Kelsier shot a townie because you can probably see how stupid that sounds in that context.

On February 05 2018 02:24 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I understand the logic i just don't agree with it.
you just had a 14-player mini with a vigi and a tracker.

Also mafia can lose the game on D1 aswell. Would have happened if people believed Damdred.

On February 05 2018 02:28 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I mean like.... to me it looked like you had to know Damerion's alignment for sure based on the way you argued about his lynch.

On February 05 2018 02:40 justanothertownie wrote:

But why would anyone belueve damdred? It's not like he presented ironclad cases. He barely gave any reasoning at all. There was 0 reason to follow his reads.

On February 05 2018 02:42 Skynx wrote:
Biggest mystery all game is how on earth did Rels got lynched.

On February 05 2018 02:47 raynpelikoneet wrote:

I didn't understand Holyflare lynch either, nor the Damdred one. Well i understand the lynches jsut as well as the Rels one i just wouldn't have done any of those.