[M][N] A Simple Game of Mafia - Page 10

On December 15 2017 23:04 Palmar wrote:

Nope, literally didn't.

I admit I did get carried away with the cop claim.

I decided to do it because I was under suspicion and the mafia RB was dead. I figured I'd draw fire (and still get the shot off) or at least just confuse the fuck out of them (this is bad HF logic, but I felt like doing it so give me a break).

Then I trolled for a little bit while waiting for damdred to answer me regarding if I didn't absolutely certainly have many shots, and forumite said this:



and I sort of thought "hey that's a great idea" and literally created the worst cop role ever imagined by humanity on the spot, just to fuck with everyone.

I kept thinking "well doesn't matter, shot mafia". I underestimated people's willingness to kill me.

So then I saw peopel actually wanted to kill me so I switched personalities, but you know, then finally I get told that my role is one-shot.

So now I'm fucked.

I blame Koshi.

On December 16 2017 10:15 Palmar wrote:

I'm going to sleep it's 1am my time, but I'm gonna help you along:

You can't see where prplhz is coming from because you're applying the minimal amount of logic to the situation.

Your thought process is:
1) Palmar is trolling and confusing people
2) That's not pro-town
3) Ergo he must be scum

The difference is that prplhz has added some actual thinking on top of this.

1) Palmar is trolling and confusing people
2) That's not pro-town
3) It's also stupid as fuck if he's mafia
4) and why would he draw attention to himself like that as SK
5) Ergo Palmar is trolling because he's an idiot and it doesn't tell us anything about his alignment.

My play makes no sense from any faction whatsoever. It literally is just that... me trolling.

The only meat on the bones you need is the fact that I shot mafia and no one is contesting it.

On December 14 2017 05:54 Conversion wrote:
I am town. I'm still going to play. I just kept my drama queen bitching to that post

if we're going by the logic of defend obvious townie because I'm mafia and I know who's town, Palmar/Forumite/Oats/Grack are four people who defended me. Palmar backed off after Koshi, called me null. Forumite said I wasn't scum, not entirely sure if he called me town. Grack called me pretty obviously town and compared my scum filter from newbie game. Oats said DF's case is bad and then died with no follow up

Oats dies, flips scum.

Palmar/Forumite/Grack. I highly doubt all 3 mafia would hedge and try to defend me. that seems weird.

I'm going to treat Forumite as confirmed town right now because having Oats die is just dumb. He could have sheeped and gotten me lynched instead.

Palmar/Grack. Both voted off wagon. I'd like to believe this is 50/50 Mafia/Town. in this current situation I like Palmar lynch more because he voted, at this point in time, my confirmed townie and just AFKed.

If we're going by 50/50 logic there still is at least another mafia. maybe 2? idk how 14 man setups work. this I'm going to have to work for, and I still don't like Eversince randomly jumping on Oats train with a disconnect in their filter and how he/she landed on oats.

Most likely it's someone in HF/Koshi/DF. This is a good place to start. I'll add Ever in there because previous reason. I can't read these three as they all have points that make them town in my eyes, but also scummy, so I'd like someone to discuss with me on who the remaining 2 scum might be

On December 18 2017 07:59 Arya321 wrote:

Why you sure that mafia shot HF over Eversince? Everyone in this game knows HF is a good player by reputation except maybe Forumite?

On December 18 2017 05:45 Forumite wrote:
So, Town Vigi, SK or a 1-shot Mafia Vigi? I´m leaning 1-Shot Mafia killpower.

Not sure what this means for doctors. We probably don´t have one.

VE, a question. I´d like to get your read on Arya based on a few observations. He was on the Oats lynch fairly early, which is good, but since I´ve seen an odd thing with his posts. He has barely been under any pressure the whole game, but talks a lot about things making him look townie. Once when being on Oats was supposed to make him townie, and how Palmar messing things up also made him townie. I think this is odd because there was never any real pressure on Arya, so why is he nervous and feels he has to point out how X or Y is a point in his favor? Almost everyone has had Arya on their Town-list from the start so there shouldn´t be any pressure on Arya to defend himself, only to find Mafia. Do you have an idea from meta?

Did Ever ever claim the result from N1?