|
On November 01 2017 23:57 ruXxar wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2017 23:51 Damdred wrote:
If there is someone I dont like, df put together a string of posts that I just didnt feel good about at points.
I do think that the auicidal nature that conversion is approaching every conversation right now hes probably just going to be town.
Like rayn and I had this talk maybe a year ago? there is this point where you just basically tell town to go fuck thwmselves and it comes off as town.
and conversion is coming off that way to me.
But I got way off track with that post meh I agree about DF. About conversion... the jury is still out. He was never this edgy as town. This game and the last is not how I remember town conversion playing.
Conversion wasn't edgy at all last game. He was wishy washy and non-committal as hell which is how I caught him. His play from last game and this game are much different.
|
It's really interesting how quickly this faux wagon built up on me. Gotta reread those pages and see who's legit and who's not. Pretty confident that Krogan is just uber town though
|
On November 02 2017 03:53 ruXxar wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 03:49 darthfoley wrote:On November 01 2017 23:57 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 23:51 Damdred wrote:
If there is someone I dont like, df put together a string of posts that I just didnt feel good about at points.
I do think that the auicidal nature that conversion is approaching every conversation right now hes probably just going to be town.
Like rayn and I had this talk maybe a year ago? there is this point where you just basically tell town to go fuck thwmselves and it comes off as town.
and conversion is coming off that way to me.
But I got way off track with that post meh I agree about DF. About conversion... the jury is still out. He was never this edgy as town. This game and the last is not how I remember town conversion playing. Conversion wasn't edgy at all last game. He was wishy washy and non-committal as hell which is how I caught him. His play from last game and this game are much different. Different, yet not similar to how I remember town conversion playing. Doesn't matter either way, I don't think the guy is mafia.
The jury is still out but you don't think the guy is mafia? So the jury is in?
lolwat
|
On November 02 2017 03:54 darthfoley wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 03:53 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:49 darthfoley wrote:On November 01 2017 23:57 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 23:51 Damdred wrote:
If there is someone I dont like, df put together a string of posts that I just didnt feel good about at points.
I do think that the auicidal nature that conversion is approaching every conversation right now hes probably just going to be town.
Like rayn and I had this talk maybe a year ago? there is this point where you just basically tell town to go fuck thwmselves and it comes off as town.
and conversion is coming off that way to me.
But I got way off track with that post meh I agree about DF. About conversion... the jury is still out. He was never this edgy as town. This game and the last is not how I remember town conversion playing. Conversion wasn't edgy at all last game. He was wishy washy and non-committal as hell which is how I caught him. His play from last game and this game are much different. Different, yet not similar to how I remember town conversion playing. Doesn't matter either way, I don't think the guy is mafia. The jury is still out but you don't think the guy is mafia? So the jury is in? lolwat
|
On November 02 2017 03:59 Oatsmaster wrote:
Tick tocks read progression just looks really odd and he is incredibly agreeable. Like he has no backbone.
+10
|
On November 02 2017 04:09 ruXxar wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 03:59 Oatsmaster wrote:On November 02 2017 03:59 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:54 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 03:53 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:49 darthfoley wrote:On November 01 2017 23:57 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 23:51 Damdred wrote:
If there is someone I dont like, df put together a string of posts that I just didnt feel good about at points.
I do think that the auicidal nature that conversion is approaching every conversation right now hes probably just going to be town.
Like rayn and I had this talk maybe a year ago? there is this point where you just basically tell town to go fuck thwmselves and it comes off as town.
and conversion is coming off that way to m e.
But I got way off track with that post meh I agree about DF. About conversion... the jury is still out. He was never this edgy as town. This game and the last is not how I remember town conversion playing. Conversion wasn't edgy at all last game. He was wishy washy and non-committal as hell which is how I caught him. His play from last game and this game are much different. Different, yet not similar to how I remember town conversion playing. Doesn't matter either way, I don't think the guy is mafia. The jury is still out but you don't think the guy is mafia? So the jury is in? lolwat Yes, the bickering between him and shockey was enough for me. Either they're both scum or theyre both town. tell me why you think that ticktoc is confirmed town? Show nested quote +On November 01 2017 23:44 ruXxar wrote:
Tick tock - I like tick tock. His string of posts shows he’s interested in having an opinion.
His thoughts are flowing well.
He’s a town lean.
I like his tone. Light hearted and jovial, the same way I play when I'm excited to roll town. His reads are good and consistent on HF and Shockey. Reads the game pretty much the same way I do, which makes it look like he doesn't have a whacky agenda. Explains his reads so that you can see where he's coming from with his thought process.
You don't see lighthearted or jovial
|
Yea I wanna hear who ruxx thinks is scum. And other people if possible
|
zen master guy completely missed the point of my post on ruxxar, also following thread sentiment. His scum reads are the same as Vivax, whose reads just follow thread sentiment, just explained in 10x as long posts.
Also @ruxx how am i being wishy washy? I'm not posting townreads lightly. I have four. How is that keeping every option open?
|
On November 02 2017 06:04 Vivax wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 03:40 darthfoley wrote:
But noted that Vivax's first scum reads are thread sentiment I'm totally going with thread sentiment if it lynches scum. Should I scumread him less cause others already did? Nice logic there. My attitude this day will be lynch schockey or feed. You can keep underhandedly defending him while calling him mafia though.
I'm not underhandedly defending him. I'm overtly defending him. His entrance was bad, and he's had a couple bad posts. His back and forth with Conversion, plus a couple "wtf?" type posts he's made changed my early scum read.
His play is right in line with what I think he is: lynch bait. How am I calling him mafia if i'm town reading him?
|
I think one of Vivax/Zen master are mafia. Not sure which
|
I just have a hard time seeing town!Vivax AFK'ing for almost 24h, then coming in with the same two scum reads as like 3-4 other people. You aren't interacting with anyone, questioning your scum reads, or anything.
On the other hand, Zen master has basically found a reason to scum read me for every post I made to fit the narrative that i'm scum. The fact that he carefully crafted one long ass post to give 25 reasons why i'm scum is actually more questionable than Vivax casually throwing out some reads.
|
On November 02 2017 05:56 ruXxar wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 04:48 darthfoley wrote:
Yea I wanna hear who ruxx thinks is scum. And other people if possible Sure. Right now you are my top scum read. 1) You're being wishy washy trying to coast by. Casting shade and town reads around you pretty lightly. You're keeping every option open, snaking your way around from read to read. 2) This post is incredibly nitpicky and trying to infuse meaning where there is none. One of the worst posts in the game. It's very over explainy and trying to siphon meaning out of very word instead of trying to understand the overall message of the post. Show nested quote +On November 01 2017 11:10 darthfoley wrote:
I dislike ruxxar's early game filter. Super fluff with no substance. Yea, sure, lots of people are posting fluff kinda. But ruxxar's gives me the vibes of feigning activity to seem interested. It's pretty easy to do early game especially, when people are dicking about.
Besides that, I have no idea why he feels the need to dictate how Damerion votes, the aggressiveness of his vote, and the subsequent commentary
Let me break down the bolded sentence for you
1) "Don't get me wrong" = apologetic, not trying to tread on anyone's toes, like scumversion last game
2) "I like your more confident approach" implies a town lean of some sort, with buddy potential
3) So he likes the confident approach, BUT it's throwing him off because it's so different from last game. So you like it... but it's throwing you off?
4) It's also "a bit too much over the top and feels forced" implying it's scummy.
So to conclude, Ruxxar likes Damerion's aggressive and confident play even though it's throwing him off but it's over the top and feels forced. So why do you like the approach if you are going to call it scummy one line later? This is a whole lot of nothing burger
Besides you there's a few people on my to watch list: Oats - for the same reason of also blowing things up and putting emphasis on worthless fact as if they were gold and had some divine scum meaning.
Damerion - I detected a change in meta behavior, need more posts to evaluate.
Shockey - I know I'm biased due to meta. The threshold for where that meta no longer holds is very thin. But still resides as town. Also the bickering with conversion tips in his favor.
HF - His damerion vote with no explanation was a red flag, but his later followup was ok. He's awfully quiet this game, but he has an excuse. Otherwise keeping an eye on him as his meta is different from last game. A bit more laid back.
Not sure how to interpret it, will need to wait until he makes a real push.
Wait, you are saying that i'm keeping my options open, but you have 4 other names on your "watch list?" aka you're watching 5/12 players in the game. If that's not keeping your options open, idk what is
|
On November 02 2017 06:14 Oatsmaster wrote:
But you disagree with the assessment that your post is swinging back and forth between calling damerion townie and scummy? Cause it looks like you totally meant that and that darth analysed it correctly.
1) damerion's posting is scummy
2) damerion's posting is townie
3) it might be either I DUNNO?!?!
That's literally what darth said. And you clearly agree with it. So how does that make darth overanalysing every little thing??
Someone get this man a fucking medal
|
Oats I really hope you're town, because if you're mafia I will hate you for at least two weeks
|
On November 02 2017 06:29 ruXxar wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 06:05 darthfoley wrote:
Also @ruxx how am i being wishy washy? I'm not posting townreads lightly. I have four. How is that keeping every option open? krogan and shockey are scum + Show Spoiler +On November 01 2017 07:47 Damdred wrote:
Idk. Scum often have trouble entering. Especially new scum. It makes sense for scum!Krogan to try and be funny by copying someone rather than having his own entrance.
Also don't like shockey's entrance ruxxar is scum + Show Spoiler +On November 01 2017 09:04 darthfoley wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2017 08:49 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 08:34 Damerion wrote:On November 01 2017 08:28 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 08:17 Damerion wrote:On November 01 2017 08:04 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 08:02 Damerion wrote:
##vote ShoCkeyy[/b
I ask and expect you all to follow me on this.
@Damdred especially you. Slow down hotshot. When did you go from being mr waffly scum reader to becoming sherlock holmes? Did the cohost of my first game forget the resounding hammer I put on the whole scum team? You have good reads, I'll give you that. You just gotta work on being more convincing. No I need name recognition, if I had a larger name associated with me I would be followed much easier. And if memory serves I did find scum last game a couple of times, just was to afk to oersue those links at the time. In any case HolyFlare is also coming across disengenous at this point. Name recognition help for sure, but it’s also about how you present yourself and your arguments. Perfect example is Lonelyclock last game. A newbie, but very solid town-read with a lot of credibility. Someone presenting themselves like that pushes a lot of weight around. Don’t get me wrong, I like your more confident approach, but it’s throwing me off because it’s so different from previous games, and it’s also a bit too much over the top and appears a bit forced. Worst post so far. Good chance of being scum Dislike ticktock + Show Spoiler +On November 01 2017 11:12 darthfoley wrote:
Oh. I also don't like Ticktock because he's distraught that we are not "in sync" 4 hours into a game. Lol. I haven't even played with you in like a year. Oats is scum + Show Spoiler +On November 01 2017 13:09 darthfoley wrote:
I'm just gonna vote you for now
##Oatsmaster Conversion is possibly scum + Show Spoiler +On November 01 2017 13:19 darthfoley wrote:
Fwiw, Conversion could definitely be a salty 2x scum roller who is sick of being pressured D1. I'm too tired to look over his filter tonight, but his hissy fit was alarming.
I don't spend my time piling on people 3 hours into a game. There are other avenues to be explored like you, and ruxxar! And maybe HF Krogan is town + Show Spoiler +On November 02 2017 03:20 darthfoley wrote:
Krogan is town Shockey is town + Show Spoiler +On November 02 2017 03:21 darthfoley wrote:
On November 01 2017 22:19 ShoCkeyy wrote:
Oats is also too sporadic in the voting thread, jumping onto who ever seems the "easiest" to vote off. Him and Damerian posting are so similar it's disgusting. I wouldn't be surprised if both of them flipped red.
Idk if a mafia posts this. I don't think so Oats is town + Show Spoiler +On November 02 2017 03:33 darthfoley wrote:
On November 02 2017 03:06 Oatsmaster wrote:
Ok rux is likely mafia, tick tock possible mafia, damdred in the same spot as tick tock.
Shockey vs conversion is tvt
thank fucking god someone else understands this Conversion is town + Show Spoiler +On November 02 2017 03:38 darthfoley wrote:
On November 02 2017 03:25 Oatsmaster wrote:
What are you scum reads Darth?
Basically retweet what you just said.
I think Conversion is town. His play is so diametrically opposed to last game. Shockey is also town for some posts that I just don't think a mafia makes-- especially a rusty mafia who hasn't played in a long time(?). I kind of have to town lean you for having a mindmeld with me. Last night I was really tired trying to lesson plan and play mafia and it wasn't a good idea. Krogan is also just obviously town
Still think ruxx is likely mafia, and I also don't like Ticktock so far, for different reasons (not the HF post). Vivax is scum + Show Spoiler +On November 02 2017 03:42 darthfoley wrote:
Throw Vivax into my scum pile for me Zen master is scum + Show Spoiler +[B]On November 02 2017 06:09 darthfoley wrote:
I think one of Vivax/Zen master are mafia. Not sure which I think it's pretty clear you're just jumping from one guy to the next with your scum reads.
You're falsely equating super duper early game reads with reads now. I got what I needed out of Krogan and Shockey to town read them.
Oatsmaster I was just being an asshole to, by the end of our spat I didn't think he was scum.
My reads are allowed to evolve. Hint: that's what happens when you don't have to fabricate read progressions
|
On November 02 2017 06:33 Holyflare wrote:
Is zen guy new? Way too much of a wall of text for a new mafia to make.
That's actually exactly what I would expect a new mafia to do
|
On November 02 2017 06:36 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 06:34 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 06:33 Holyflare wrote:
Is zen guy new? Way too much of a wall of text for a new mafia to make. That's actually exactly what I would expect a new mafia to do Well you have bad expectations then?
That's like your opinion man. What do you make of vivax and ruxxar?
|
|
|
On November 02 2017 06:40 The_Zen_Man wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 06:12 darthfoley wrote:
I just have a hard time seeing town!Vivax AFK'ing for almost 24h, then coming in with the same two scum reads as like 3-4 other people. You aren't interacting with anyone, questioning your scum reads, or anything.
On the other hand, Zen master has basically found a reason to scum read me for every post I made to fit the narrative that i'm scum. The fact that he carefully crafted one long ass post to give 25 reasons why i'm scum is actually more questionable than Vivax casually throwing out some reads. Yeah, the fact that I actually put effort into my post means im scum. But just throwing accusations without any thought behind them and jumping from wagon to wagon like you did is very town-like.
The game has to start somehow. I have thought behind them, but that doesn't mean I always have to share my thought process.
I'm more interested to hear what you think about other people in the game, and why.
|
On November 02 2017 06:51 The_Zen_Man wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 06:42 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 06:40 The_Zen_Man wrote:On November 02 2017 06:12 darthfoley wrote:
I just have a hard time seeing town!Vivax AFK'ing for almost 24h, then coming in with the same two scum reads as like 3-4 other people. You aren't interacting with anyone, questioning your scum reads, or anything.
On the other hand, Zen master has basically found a reason to scum read me for every post I made to fit the narrative that i'm scum. The fact that he carefully crafted one long ass post to give 25 reasons why i'm scum is actually more questionable than Vivax casually throwing out some reads. Yeah, the fact that I actually put effort into my post means im scum. But just throwing accusations without any thought behind them and jumping from wagon to wagon like you did is very town-like. The game has to start somehow. I have thought behind them, but that doesn't mean I always have to share my thought process. I'm more interested to hear what you think about other people in the game, and why. What? So you have thoughts but decide to not share them with other people? How are we supposed to make reads on you if you if you don't post your though process and wait for everyone else to post? This was a very scummy post.
No it wasn't. I will share my thought processes when i'm good and ready. Like I have done. I'm not waiting for other people to post. I've probably been in the top 3 for activity this game. That's also ironic considering you came in and copied reads 24h into the game.
If you have specific questions about my reads on people, feel free to ask. Otherwise, I don't feel the need to clarify things.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
