|
On August 27 2017 06:30 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On August 27 2017 06:29 Damdred wrote:On August 27 2017 06:25 Oatsmaster wrote:On August 27 2017 06:16 Damdred wrote:On August 27 2017 06:04 Oatsmaster wrote:On August 27 2017 06:02 Damdred wrote:
I made a post where I asked art a question and saw the will commented and it was eod.
No real time to do anything between You couldve voted instead of making that post. I guess I could have? But I had 0 time to parse any of the will. I do have a soft spot for people who make wills. And well I wasn't convinced he wasn't scum until after eod anyway and I saw his good by post and whatever. The will is pretty crappy though. So you still wanna lynch art tmr or no? Nope as shitty of a reason as I is, I think art really did think he was lynched and confirmed himself town there. Its probably not enough for dorever, by his postings tonight have been 10x better than day. So who then?
But reactions say
Look at geript slot
Skynx slot
Ruxxar
|
On August 27 2017 06:32 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On August 27 2017 06:31 Damdred wrote:On August 27 2017 06:30 Oatsmaster wrote:On August 27 2017 06:29 Damdred wrote:On August 27 2017 06:25 Oatsmaster wrote:On August 27 2017 06:16 Damdred wrote:On August 27 2017 06:04 Oatsmaster wrote:On August 27 2017 06:02 Damdred wrote:
I made a post where I asked art a question and saw the will commented and it was eod.
No real time to do anything between You couldve voted instead of making that post. I guess I could have? But I had 0 time to parse any of the will. I do have a soft spot for people who make wills. And well I wasn't convinced he wasn't scum until after eod anyway and I saw his good by post and whatever. The will is pretty crappy though. So you still wanna lynch art tmr or no? Nope as shitty of a reason as I is, I think art really did think he was lynched and confirmed himself town there. Its probably not enough for dorever, by his postings tonight have been 10x better than day. So who then? But reactions say Look at geript slot Skynx slot Ruxxar Ruxxar didnt even post since 6 hours ago
Ok? His reasoning on his vote was bad, had no real insight into the thread going on.
And honestly if you had played with rux before you would understand what I mean by activity, it's like astronomical bad do him.
But hes never rolled scum (i think) and part of me wonders if this I him just trying to get by and figure thing out.
|
Oh god that's embarrassing two games I was in and don't remember rux being in lol.
Yeah I take what I said about activity back, he had good activity in them. So nai
|
Hello, what a wonderful start of the week.
A few things as I've caught up.
1) Without a cc in this situation I would never lynch rayn, it makes no sense for mafia Ryan to be pushing for a 1 v 1 I'm this situation. He has fake claimed as both alignments and his play I think has been towny.
2) I've never seen art roll over as town a no of martyrdom as scum though, so many my original points weren't bad and I over reacted to his goodbye and list post. I'll think on that for a bit longer.
3) I still am pretty sure that ls is still town. His *trap* was something maybe I could see him do as town, but not as scum especially with art already doing the same thing
Well there is one case where I think la as scum would do that, but I think his other things in game have been in his ten meta.
Also, just tin fouling a bit. So if art is mafia (which looks likely) what is the play here to help his team?
My conjecture is that the geript/onegu slot is more important than the art slot and they need that slot alive so the next day they can push a why is rayn still alive and one of them cc him.
Totally just in my he's but I makes sense, how long will e ignore the onegu slot that still refuses.
Also if art is scum makes the vote yesterday really interesting.
|
On August 28 2017 23:11 Holyflare wrote:
If rayn is a town jailkeeper he's going to assume he's playing well and will get shot. To stop mafia shooting him then he claims a role that will now be protected.
Mafia now have to shoot someone else (me likely) now he has a chance to protect that person.
It's a poor play really but there are town explanations. I think his play has been markedly different from last game too.
It's only a poor play if rayn gets cc or they shoot cop n1.
So if they were blue reading vivax it would of been beneficial to shoot elsewhere so they don't out rayn.
Otherwise as town it's a fine wifom play that some on else I know makes all the time.
|
Just as an aside there are games where town rayn and town hf have went to near endgame.
So yeah it's a bad argument.
|
On August 28 2017 23:36 ruXxar wrote:Show nested quote +On August 28 2017 23:29 Damdred wrote:
Just as an aside there are games where town rayn and town hf have went to near endgame.
So yeah it's a bad argument. You can find examples of almost anything. How is that even supposed to be a counter argument... Do you disagree that Rayn and HF are the best NKs for scum?
Generally speaking yes.
But that's not to say they should always be shot d1, or even happen often.
Probably if neither are dead d2 Or 3 its time to worry today the argument isn't that great.
|
|
|
On August 28 2017 23:45 LightningStrike wrote:
Wait a second Rayn I must of misread one of your post but did you actually claim jailkeeper?
Are you cc him? Kind of feels like you are ls
|
I disagree with your conclusion very much. There are so many different possibilities you have to take into account.
Not the least is this argument itself.
|
Let me make this clear, if you are the jk and rayn isn't you 100% cc him and we lynch whoever.
Like it's always better to go 1 for one here.
|
|
|
What we are saying rux, is this.
Unless you have someone who cc run you don't lynch rayn. Aside from the parity claim his play is towny and makes sense for town rayn.
|
Still not lynching the claim unless we have a cc, and there at only 3-4 people who could CD and have hinted they are UK or shows real disbelief towards rayn.
|
Ok I'll boil it for both of us,
I will not lynch run or consider it until someone claims jk against him.
I think your argument towards hf and Ryan is flawed and for not take into account really any information besides your personal biases. And personally I think both are town.
|
Like at least three people have said why your argument is just incorrect currently.
Then being alive die not make them scum and you can point to other games for this.
Fake claims/people pretending to be roles happens all the time, i think what rayn did was not the best move but anyone who knows how parity works would never cc him d1. Everyone has been in the thread no one has cc rayn, he should be believed unless someone counters him.
And every game you think rayn and hf are scum (generally). Besides that fact you are biased because you have come to your conclusions and refuse to see any side but what you think is correct.
|
I dont think the second claim is worthless, no.
|
Morning,
Meh, not sure what rux is doing here. Art. Is probably the lynch but what if we do onegu/geript today before we he to the mylo point (if we do). I still think that slot is scum here.
|
Idk I think onegu slot is sick and he hasn't dissuaded me from it. Art could be Sun and your case is good, but I don't see the play here unless art is trying to save another scum member ya know?
|
I don't think I really see what hf has done this game as scum ya know? If art flips town (which I doubt at this point I think. Also f u hf for dismissing my points d1 and not sleeping me once again.) It makes the wagons forming interesting I think.
Though just means mafia were in the lazier people on the wagons or not on wagons at all.
I wish I had a gun right now to shoot onegu.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
