|
On July 31 2017 20:57 Superbia wrote:
I'm also not talking about you knowing your alignment.
I'm talking about the fact that apparently (no one claimed otherwise) everyone started off with a role pm saying "you don't have a role/alignment, lol". And only got their role pm later (again, no one is claiming otherwise). WHICH SUGGESTS one of the following scenarios (excl 3rd p):
1. Both town and mafia were in the exact same scenario.
2. Only town was in the exact same scenario
You don't comment on this "unknown" role PM stuff nor the "getting a role" 24h later pm.
As town Conversion I expect the following:
"Oh 2 PMs, I must've missed the start of the game?"
"Oh wtf, one pm says I'm town but the other says I forgot my role. Wtf?"
"Let me catch up."
"Oh I see other people have this as well, this seems relevant to the game, let's comment on it"
Instead you ignore it which just seems ultra fishy for someone who JUST read his TWO (right!?) PMs and is catching up.
↑ This I like.
On July 31 2017 06:24 Conversion wrote:
wtf is happening here
sorry didn't even realize game started until just now
On July 31 2017 06:28 ruXxar wrote:Show nested quote +On July 31 2017 06:24 Conversion wrote:
wtf is happening here
sorry didn't even realize game started until just now What do you think is happening?
On July 31 2017 06:30 Conversion wrote:
so far lots of yelling about lynch vs no lynch, for some reason HF became the protagonist of papers please, and one person thinks I'm mafia bc I'm a dumbass and didn't check for when this game started
I also don't like the fact he read the entire game and came in with nothing. Got called out. And then gave a useless summarize of events.
That and the pure defensive latest posts.
##vote Conversion
|
Here are my thoughts on this game so far:
Pre 24H no one has any idea what roles they are so pretty fluffy posts aside from BTDT joking about HF being mafia from his joke claim.
Then HF starts posting Papers Please shit, game gets weird, and then progresses to scum hunting bc we know everyone has an alignment PM.
Anyways here are my reads with notes since Superbia is ignoring every argument I have against him and pushing his own
Town
BTDT. His start doesn't seem off from the one game I played with him. I'm going to shelf him as town for now
rsoultin
Superbia -- you know normally I'd peg you as scum because I don't like people using arguments that they aren't reflecting in their play, but I'm going to townread you since you seem to be tunneling on me so hard-- and that seems pretty townie.
However, the fact that someone like VayneAuthority exists, but you want to call me out on my shit posts and not him means you're either tunneling on me or not looking at anyone else post24h. Do me a favor, scum read me and move on to finding others if you're 10000% sure I'm scum like you're coming off in your posts
Sort of town
CopCake -- can you post your reads and make a non reactive post so I can think less about who's mafia for D1?
Damdred
Tumblewood -- again, pretty hesitant to call him mafia bc his sort of apathetic posting got me to lynch a doc last game
Koshi
Sort of mafia
VayneAuthority -- dude has 4 posts, was there at the beginning of the game with nothing but a vote on tictock. Hardcore lurker post24h??
dunno how to read anyone else. HF just memeing with Papers Please and typing in a foreign language (Russian) and ruxxar making somewhat not really substantial posts aside from his beggar stuff and papers please spam, but passively agreeing with people.
rels low post and mia for 15h and DF joke posting all over the place
also @BTDT and Superbia. if I'm mafia #1 who are my other two scummates? I want to see how well you can read this game since both of you seem to agree I'm playing like shit or like scum or both
|
last statement extends to anyone else.
IDGAS if you lynch me day one tbh I'll just laugh once you mislynch and come out of it with no more information than you all did at this point in the game
|
and no one wants to post except the 3 who wants to lynch one of the players who's actually bothering to reply to them on the merit that I am posting nothing substantial and was MIA the first day
woo!!
|
hey you all wanted me to be active so give me a short list of who else is scum instead of piggybacking one mistake
how about you actually help town progress by actively scumhunting and questioning obvious inactives?
|
On July 31 2017 20:57 Superbia wrote:
I'm also not talking about you knowing your alignment.
I'm talking about the fact that apparently (no one claimed otherwise) everyone started off with a role pm saying "you don't have a role/alignment, lol". And only got their role pm later (again, no one is claiming otherwise). WHICH SUGGESTS one of the following scenarios (excl 3rd p):
1. Both town and mafia were in the exact same scenario.
2. Only town was in the exact same scenario
You don't comment on this "unknown" role PM stuff nor the "getting a role" 24h later pm.
As town Conversion I expect the following:
"Oh 2 PMs, I must've missed the start of the game?"
"Oh wtf, one pm says I'm town but the other says I forgot my role. Wtf?"
"Let me catch up."
"Oh I see other people have this as well, this seems relevant to the game, let's comment on it"
Instead you ignore it which just seems ultra fishy for someone who JUST read his TWO (right!?) PMs and is catching up.
if you want to know my exact thought process I came to TL on sunday, read two PMs by the host and assumed rayn made a mistake
so can you reply why you're doing nothing else and making no other good posts unless you want to look scummy as fuck once I'm lynched and I flip town?
|
Why do you think Damdred is town? He made mostly game mechanic posts from what I remember and I disagreed with them.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
Пословица дня:
Человек, который читает новости, становится мудрым человеком, который голосует за человека с медведем.
Отправить справку.
|
On July 31 2017 21:54 Conversion wrote:Show nested quote +On July 31 2017 20:57 Superbia wrote:
I'm also not talking about you knowing your alignment.
I'm talking about the fact that apparently (no one claimed otherwise) everyone started off with a role pm saying "you don't have a role/alignment, lol". And only got their role pm later (again, no one is claiming otherwise). WHICH SUGGESTS one of the following scenarios (excl 3rd p):
1. Both town and mafia were in the exact same scenario.
2. Only town was in the exact same scenario
You don't comment on this "unknown" role PM stuff nor the "getting a role" 24h later pm.
As town Conversion I expect the following:
"Oh 2 PMs, I must've missed the start of the game?"
"Oh wtf, one pm says I'm town but the other says I forgot my role. Wtf?"
"Let me catch up."
"Oh I see other people have this as well, this seems relevant to the game, let's comment on it"
Instead you ignore it which just seems ultra fishy for someone who JUST read his TWO (right!?) PMs and is catching up.
if you want to know my exact thought process I came to TL on sunday, read two PMs by the host and assumed rayn made a mistakeso can you reply why you're doing nothing else and making no other good posts unless you want to look scummy as fuck once I'm lynched and I flip town?
That seems very unlikely if you read the game. Why would rayn make that mistake for all people... Most people didn't remember their role.
|
On July 31 2017 08:07 Damdred wrote:Show nested quote +On July 31 2017 08:02 Tictock wrote:On July 31 2017 07:44 Tumblewood wrote:
i have a role now. that is all i will say about it until further notice Do you have an opinion about how we should scum hunt so far this game? Is Ruxx right that we can throw out the first 24 hours, or do you think Cake might be onto something and scum knew their alignment right off? I am not tumble but I feel like taking a crack at this. 1) Honestly we shoudl forget about the role shenanigans that is going on and we should just try to play normally, there is a lot of times that theme'd games just devolve into a mechanics guessing game and town loses because of it. 2) Until we got our pm i think we can throw out, or ignore it. Unless a real argument could be made when as far as we know 100% of town didn't know what was going on and everything was trolling to start with.
Also is this a scumslip? Why does he say 100% of town and not 100% of all players? If mafia got a mafia role pm this is a slip. Because it contradicts his point.
|
On July 31 2017 21:55 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On July 31 2017 21:54 Conversion wrote:On July 31 2017 20:57 Superbia wrote:
I'm also not talking about you knowing your alignment.
I'm talking about the fact that apparently (no one claimed otherwise) everyone started off with a role pm saying "you don't have a role/alignment, lol". And only got their role pm later (again, no one is claiming otherwise). WHICH SUGGESTS one of the following scenarios (excl 3rd p):
1. Both town and mafia were in the exact same scenario.
2. Only town was in the exact same scenario
You don't comment on this "unknown" role PM stuff nor the "getting a role" 24h later pm.
As town Conversion I expect the following:
"Oh 2 PMs, I must've missed the start of the game?"
"Oh wtf, one pm says I'm town but the other says I forgot my role. Wtf?"
"Let me catch up."
"Oh I see other people have this as well, this seems relevant to the game, let's comment on it"
Instead you ignore it which just seems ultra fishy for someone who JUST read his TWO (right!?) PMs and is catching up.
if you want to know my exact thought process I came to TL on sunday, read two PMs by the host and assumed rayn made a mistakeso can you reply why you're doing nothing else and making no other good posts unless you want to look scummy as fuck once I'm lynched and I flip town? That seems very unlikely if you read the game. Why would rayn make that mistake for all people... Most people didn't remember their role.
Why would I know whether rayn would make that mistake or not? My first line of thought was I need to get into the game ASAP because I forgot I even joined the game for a weekend
if your argument is seriously that I am scum for missing the first 24h just move on. I literally don't care if a mistake drives town to lynch me.
answer my question instead of asking me everything. who are your other reads?
|
I also believe the not remembering your role means there are powers in play that can distribute roles. Why else bother as host? I am also not unhappy with my role so I give it a fair shot somebody gave it to me.
|
On July 31 2017 22:02 Conversion wrote:Show nested quote +On July 31 2017 21:55 Koshi wrote:On July 31 2017 21:54 Conversion wrote:On July 31 2017 20:57 Superbia wrote:
I'm also not talking about you knowing your alignment.
I'm talking about the fact that apparently (no one claimed otherwise) everyone started off with a role pm saying "you don't have a role/alignment, lol". And only got their role pm later (again, no one is claiming otherwise). WHICH SUGGESTS one of the following scenarios (excl 3rd p):
1. Both town and mafia were in the exact same scenario.
2. Only town was in the exact same scenario
You don't comment on this "unknown" role PM stuff nor the "getting a role" 24h later pm.
As town Conversion I expect the following:
"Oh 2 PMs, I must've missed the start of the game?"
"Oh wtf, one pm says I'm town but the other says I forgot my role. Wtf?"
"Let me catch up."
"Oh I see other people have this as well, this seems relevant to the game, let's comment on it"
Instead you ignore it which just seems ultra fishy for someone who JUST read his TWO (right!?) PMs and is catching up.
if you want to know my exact thought process I came to TL on sunday, read two PMs by the host and assumed rayn made a mistakeso can you reply why you're doing nothing else and making no other good posts unless you want to look scummy as fuck once I'm lynched and I flip town? That seems very unlikely if you read the game. Why would rayn make that mistake for all people... Most people didn't remember their role. Why would I know whether rayn would make that mistake or not? My first line of thought was I need to get into the game ASAP because I forgot I even joined the game for a weekend if your argument is seriously that I am scum for missing the first 24h just move on. I literally don't care if a mistake drives town to lynch me. answer my question instead of asking me everything. who are your other reads?
I didn't play the first 24hours either so I am not scumreading you for that. I am voting you for not playing the game. I like the effort you are showing now but answering some follow up questions is not a bad thing to do.
I do not feel like throwing preemptive reads out yet. Too many people have not yet played the game.
|
Hello, im lost, can anyone hear me? I need a new path just to finally be free.
I'm feeling withdrawals, who's got the LSD?
|
just lynch me thanks
don't give a shit honestly. superbia's arguments are awful, you're pushing me for actually giving reads and trying to get me to "slip" by making me run mental gymnastics on why i made a post
BTDT is probably gonna call me scum until the end of time like he did last game. got lynched and still called me scum until obs QT
I'll just laugh once I flip town and you all waste your D1 
see ya gonna pay attention to worm since being inactive is worth more than being active
|
And I can see where your reads come from, except the Damdred town read. So care to explain that?
|
is there any reason to change my vote? Tictock has like a page of filter about HF's roleplay since then and he gave a box of matches to ruxxar who is not that townie. Box of matches is bad.
|
On July 31 2017 22:07 Conversion wrote:just lynch me thanks don't give a shit honestly. superbia's arguments are awful, you're pushing me for actually giving reads and trying to get me to "slip" by making me run mental gymnastics on why i made a post BTDT is probably gonna call me scum until the end of time like he did last game. got lynched and still called me scum until obs QT I'll just laugh once I flip town and you all waste your D1 see ya gonna pay attention to worm since being inactive is worth more than being active
Well.... Getting suspicion on you is part of the game. I'll back off if you keep playing.
##unvote Conversion
##Vote Damdred
|
On July 31 2017 22:06 VayneAuthority wrote:
Hello, im lost, can anyone hear me? I need a new path just to finally be free.
I'm feeling withdrawals, who's got the LSD?
Drugs are heavily frowned upon in Arstotzka.
Do not speak of such things in my presence.
|
On July 31 2017 22:08 VayneAuthority wrote:
is there any reason to change my vote? Tictock has like a page of filter about HF's roleplay since then and he gave a box of matches to ruxxar who is not that townie. Box of matches is bad.
I was surprised he had a page of filter. I don't remember a post he made except the matches thing. But for some reason I thought that was Tumblewood. Not the worst place to keep your vote on.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
