Newbie Student Mafia XXVI - Page 7

On June 07 2017 18:24 Holyflare wrote:
Right but it was proven that was wrong and you still wanted to lynch him.

On June 07 2017 18:38 Holyflare wrote:
An actual reason why they're mafia? Some posts on it? A couple of lines isn't good enough because if you're town then this is the real world you should be playing in.

On June 05 2017 02:10 Tubesock wrote:
My preferred lynches are BH, btdt, then TW.

BH and TW for already stated reasons. btdt because I don't like nitpickers or martyrs. He's wrong on Conversion, if newbie excuses were the entire content of Cons post then he'd be right but Conversion posts reads and explains them.

I'm fine with HF and TW being in the same category. I mean you're HF the one who survives red checks. And I'm pretty convinced the mods messed up in generic and mislabeled your role when you died.

On June 05 2017 07:52 Tubesock wrote:
Voting btdt.

Looking at more stuff with Vivax and his progression. I didn't like his last reads and his colored vote analysis post seemed wrong.

HF could be mafia sure. I think he's needlessly making things more difficult for himself if he were.

On June 05 2017 08:05 Tubesock wrote:
I also thought deadline was 3 minutes ago.

HF, so why are you all of a sudden ready to lynch BH???

I don't want to lynch LS. But it's only cause he's LS and he makes me laugh. Haven't read him yet.

On June 07 2017 19:10 Holyflare wrote:
Also where the flying fuck has your PB is definitely mafia stance gone? Totally unexplained drop.

On June 07 2017 20:36 beentheredonethat wrote:
I don't want to lynch Vivax and I don't want to lynch Holyflare. I don't want to lynch Blazinghand. I'm paranoid about Blazinghand and Holyflare but the rational part of my mind says it's super unlikely they are scum together. If they are scum together, the game is lost anyways. BH and HF are driving the game forward. Vivax is mainly busy defending himself and blaming BH/HF being scum, and I'm of course busy with self-pity and so on.

Good thing we lynched scum D1, because if we hadn't, scum probably would be in a great position.

On June 07 2017 20:52 beentheredonethat wrote:
Okay. Thought experiment:


Assuming BH, HF, Vivax and me are all town and mafia is in the rather low volume players and having a good laugh about how town is currently screwing over itself. That leaves:

Tubesock, Tumblewood, LightningStrike, Grackaroni, ritoky, Prison Break, Conversion.

Now Tumblewood is the blue claim. The doctor. However, the nightkill was Onegu. Now keep in mind that the OP clearly says that the doctor cannot heal himself - so either scum didn't believe the doctor claim and did a potential medic dodge - or Tumblewood fakeclaimed to stay alive.

So right now, Tumblewood is un-cc'ed and the only claim. town!HF's move of "hey, not gonna tell the exact role so I don't out the "real" blue just in case" was actually really cool. Tumblewood let the whole D2 pass so far and didn't care too much about this game ALTHOUGH he's the claimed doctor and should be highly interested in finding out potential N2 heal targets, right? Mafia didn't kill him N1, so maybe he'll get another heal of. There might of course be other thinking patterns but this is one that I'd find likely to have as doctor.

Grackaroni - I'm currently putting him on the town pile. He worded exactly why I didn't want to lynch Vivax in a way that I really liked and I fully agreed with his thought process here. I quoted the post that I mean already, it's somewhere in my filter. Might be a bit too easy to townread here but I'll do it anyways.

LightningStrike - I still have no particular impression on what he's done so far. Townreads Tubesock, Grack, ritoky. He says that "HF vs. Vivax feels like town vs. scum" with a tendency to Vivax playing the scum part - what happened to that read D2? But then again, he was early to switch to fidei, plus:



I think this is a genuine town post.
His last appearance here was almost 24 hours ago so it's time for him to come back.

Tubesock has a full three pages of filter, mostly one liners that are not really amazing. I don't know why people townread that guy. But then again he was second on the Fidei wagon which should give him a lot of town cred.

In that thought experiment, our lynches should be between ritoky, Prison Break, Conversion. Those are at least the guys and gals to look into.

On June 07 2017 22:55 Conversion wrote:


I meant in your thought experiment Also your point on me was "where am I" and here I am! Honestly I was F5'ing the thread pretty hard since my last post but nothing was happening so I went away from the thread and am catching up now.

Also realized I didn't really make a lot of posts, so I guess that fits the "mafia letting town destroy themselves" so I'll try to be more active before deadline today, although from what I'm reading from the filter I still don't like Vivax's play... not sure if it's enough to autolynch him anymore but we'll see

On June 07 2017 23:20 Conversion wrote:


Hi, do you want to actually make comments instead of linking GIFs? Unlike you I'm actually trying to learn how to play games in different situations and you aren't helping.

Did you think that was a slip? I'm literally quoting what someone else said

Was that a bad thing to mention as town because it makes me look suspicious?