Newbie Student Mafia XXVI - Page 32

On June 10 2017 22:36 Conversion wrote:
TW what about you? I think I remember you saying it's between PB, me l, and ritoky

and can I get an actual argument because none of you are persuading me to lynch HF over TW right now

On June 11 2017 00:15 Holyflare wrote:
This is a duper simple weighing up that I'm doing in my head to figure out the claims:

Tw - cased day 1 massive tmi and inconsistencies, didn't have answer to bh meta claimed doc instead (but somehow answered it in tiny paragraph within 10 minutes now?), afkd all game, claimed rb all game, blindly believes ritoky claim over me and shovels as much as he can in my direction with no thought

Ritoky - mediocrely towny all game, scum read ls/grack but checked btdt despite town reading (his reason was that he didn't want to lose to emotion instead of checking scum reads??), pushed some ok things, been active.


They're both shit claims but one of those claims was forced day 1 as survival instead of answering simple questions and the other was to kill tw and has been mediocrely towny all game. So yeh tw looks worse on paper.

On June 11 2017 00:43 Holyflare wrote:
Tubesock makes perfect sense with me as mafia or ritoky as mafia because he's already gone down the bussing route with fidei.

On June 11 2017 02:05 Holyflare wrote:


Yes, I would agree but then that sentiment should continue THROUGHOUT his gameplay. Why would he therefore check Grack next when he was his biggest scum read? The logic does not follow through.

On June 10 2017 23:33 Conversion wrote:
also ritoky what are your thoughts on you possibly being scum that HF mentioned?

I can't say that's not a possibility because the way I see it, it's vig doc, vig cop, or doc cop

On June 10 2017 23:49 Holyflare wrote:
No it doesn't seem like a good reason because if you read his night posts he votes LS and makes a case on him being mafia and then does the same for grack but then checks btdt who be now basically town reads because of emotion.

On June 11 2017 03:38 Holyflare wrote:
honestly I'm really surprised nobody has used the "hf keeps saying all these bad things about ritoky so he's setting up a mislynch for tomorrow" excuse yet

On June 11 2017 03:38 Holyflare wrote:
honestly I'm really surprised nobody has used the "hf keeps saying all these bad things about ritoky so he's setting up a mislynch for tomorrow" excuse yet

On June 11 2017 02:04 Prison Break wrote:


So if Tubesock is mafia with everyone, then what's the benefit in not lynching him today again?