Newbie Student Mafia XXVI - Page 28

On June 10 2017 07:16 Tumblewood wrote:
hf, i have a question for you:
(correct me if i'm wrong to assume your skepticism was related to your role)
why did being vig make you skeptical of my claim?

On June 10 2017 07:19 Holyflare wrote:


Because of several reasons:

You claimed to save yourself from lynch.

You claimed instead of answering the most simple bh meta question in all of existence.

I'm good at this game.

You dropped off the face of the earth after claiming despite saying you're going to try this game.

All of your tmi day 1 was off.

On June 10 2017 07:22 Tumblewood wrote:

that's clearly wrong?
pre-claim your lynch pool was grack, btdt, ts, pb, conv, but you should have a strong suspicion that there's a cop in the game with two checks reducing that pool by up to three. post-claim you have one, maybe 2 lynches set up for you among people who weren't even in consideration and your pool outside of that is still three people. as mafia you gained mislynches from that play.

On June 10 2017 07:30 Tubesock wrote:


Uhm how does that make sense?

On June 10 2017 08:14 Tubesock wrote:


I'm pretty biased right now, but yeah could be fake pushing LS (he did say he was trolling him) and I definitely see LS getting pissed HF is busing him. And LS can fake the rage too, he did it in one of his scum games a bit ago. Was towned because he used CAPSLOCK once.

But I don't think HF is really the type to bus both partners d1. So, I'm trying to read and think about his conviction of really wanting to lynch LS or just motivating him to post more and get townread.

On June 10 2017 08:19 Prison Break wrote:


He protected TW

If HF flips vig, people will think HF got rb'd so TW was lying

By saying he didn't fire, TW could still be rb'd

So despite HF thinking TW is mafia now, this is extremely townie to do

On June 10 2017 08:35 Tumblewood wrote:
ok, another glaring question mark in your claim: why were you so suspicious of me, with no CC, that you based your whole strategy around making sure i died in case i was scum?

On June 10 2017 08:58 Tumblewood wrote:
so this is what's really going on

if HF is town:
advantages of claiming:
*crickets*

disadvantages of claiming:
- effectively gives up any chance of shooting someone

Never gonna shoot someone if we lose a mislynch

- if i'm scum, forces the other blue to claim unnecessarily early, denying a potential cop check

Narrows down lynch list because they have 2 checks and would be one of the players I'm not sure about


- if i'm blue, allows scum to make a play and potentially lynch both of us

Your fault for being crap all game and doing nothing.

OR

if HF is mafia:


advantages of claiming:
- lynches one, potentially two blues
True dat

- forces the other blue to out themselves early
True dat.

disadvantages of claiming:
- dies earlier than he might have otherwise
Main reason why i would never do it. I like to carry 100% of my games.


pick one

On June 10 2017 09:38 Tumblewood wrote:

what do you mean, i made my bed by choosing to never question ritoky? ritoky's actions are indicative of an actual cop reacting to checks and to the game around you. your actions are indicative of scum trying to set up a fakeclaim and mislynch a blue. and i'm not really in a position to attack anyone with 70% confidence, anyway.

plus everyone knows you're not actually asking them to lynch you