[M][N] Generic Mini Mafia II - Page 17

On May 11 2017 06:57 Holyflare wrote:
My point of view is that rayn didn't like what you said and you had a massive boring snoozefest that I didn't read where you explained your post multiple times and rayn no doubt used dumb analogies to try and get his point across. You just repeatedly explained yourself and had no bite back and didn't even bother getting into my points on rayn. You were having an argument with rayn for the sake of having an argument rather than figuring it out with other people even though they were present.

Then rayn stopped pushing you and you didn't care and you did nothing more and qq left when palmar insulted you.

On May 11 2017 06:54 Grackaroni wrote:
Do you like what Palmar has contributed so far?

On May 11 2017 06:58 Grackaroni wrote:

I think the point here is that you have the red banana and everybody knows it.

On May 11 2017 07:00 Grackaroni wrote:
Palmar and DF have been making opposite points.

Palmar says I was being too prickly to Rayn

DF says I wasn't being prickly enough with Rayn

You like both of their contributions because they both dislike me?

On May 11 2017 07:02 Damdred wrote:


Actually i'm curious what do you make of Palmar and DF having the exact opposite conclusions at this point about that interaction.

Do you think there is some sort of connection in review? Or?

On May 11 2017 07:03 Grackaroni wrote:

No I think it's just been the most polarizing event in thread and people make different conclusions. I don't really think you can agree with both points, however.

On May 11 2017 06:58 Holyflare wrote:


Palmar is the same as vivax but with more sense and more fear. But I liked his posts, they made sense. I thought his tunnel post was good even if I don't agree with it.

On May 11 2017 07:04 Holyflare wrote:
That's not true. Palmar said you're prodding rayn (pointless fight with pointless questions) when what you wrote suggests you town read rayn.

DF says you have no backbone and aren't actually fighting, which is true because you were pointlessly submissive and not actually determining his alignment.

Both independently good points.

On May 11 2017 06:34 Damdred wrote:
I powered through the thread while I was up.

To start off questions

@PrisonBreak (I believe), my initial assessment of LS scum etc was a joke. My follow up post of Rayns towniness was not a joke, it came from sort of bad reasoning as he can fake it potentially as scum. But I really liked that his first post was trying to discern who you were so that (presumably) he could better read you and come to a better conclusion. I would generally see thi scome from more town than scum as scum would not want that information really to come to life. But as I said it is partially a bad reason at that point.

As to people who said Damdred can do this as scum, YES! I can, I have and I will do it as both alignments. I've always tried to shape my game where I can do whatever I want from solving the game (or trying to), giving up teammates etc as either alignment. Though I know I still have some ticks as mafia I have a hard time getting rid of. But kind of meh about DF (I believe it was) who only looked at me negatively because of it.

As for my reads here we are:

These are the people i'm ok reading town currently

LS
Rayn
Palmar
Prison Break
Skynx

Maybe town:
Grack
HF

I would normally want to make a call about tumble, and my initial reaction to some of his off the collar commentary I think would come from his town game rather than his scum game. But I am horrid at looking at him so i'm just kind of ignoring him currently.

I disliked DF so far, Vivax has been awkward in some of his postings so far but I am not sure that it makes him scum currently.

Fuba is someone also that I think might be worth a look into later, initial reaction was he might be town just as a gut feeling. His reasoning for following PB I felt was a bit lakluster and was something i've seen mafia do to shift the blame to the person they sheep instead of taking personal responbility for it. Also him refusing to post reads to push the game forward bothered me, or rather him thinking they wouldn't push the game forward. I still sort of see him as a big bag of blah null for now.

Currently I just kind of want to lynch DF for some below average postings for him and him picking on me :'(

On May 11 2017 04:22 fuba wrote:
Prison Break's stuff on sicklucker seems like the best "case" so far. Gonna vote him.

On May 11 2017 07:09 Grackaroni wrote:

Opposites.