|
On January 27 2017 17:07 Silverika wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2017 15:46 sicklucker wrote:On January 27 2017 11:57 Silverika wrote:On January 27 2017 10:43 sicklucker wrote:On January 27 2017 07:38 Chairman Ray wrote:On January 27 2017 07:19 Silverika wrote:
Hi all!! Who has played before? I have one time online and the first mission passed. I'd like to go on the mission since we are members of the Resistance so I'm volunteering. Also, I'll sign my posts, ika42 likely will not. Any high level missions-ones with higher numbers of people that we aren't on will be rejected by us because if one Town voice isn't there, the chances of it being all Town is not high enough to take the risk.
~SilverWolf77 I've played a few hundred games of this live, and I think I played once on TL. Yeah, if you are town, please reject mission 5 if you are not on that mission and most of the time reject mission 4 as well, but for the first three, please use your best judgement. Reason being that in mission 5, even if you think everyone on it is town, they can all just approve it and the mission goes ahead, but on the chance that at least one of them rejects, and people outside the group approves, you need to reject it. For the first three missions, if you are not in the group, please use your best judgement and approve missions you think will pass, because if you reject groups that you are not on, then mafia get to pick which mission passes. I've definitely had a lot of games thrown where town was being too cynical early game or too optimistic late game. I dont see how rejecting missions ever is a good idea for newbs Why not? ~SilverWolf77 because you need to complete missions to win? wtf No shit Sherlock, but your basicly saying "have no dicussion and approve anything and everything" So explain to me why any newbs should jsut blindly go "ok approve" without dicussion.
I understood you as saying a town should intentionally fail a mission which is kind of what you said but obvious not what you ment.. because that would be silly
|
On January 27 2017 18:13 Superbia wrote:
Since the 12 hour deadline is approaching. What would be your draft team at this point in time?
r n g.
rn g.
Day 1 is all rng lets be real
|
oh ya we go by order of the list and vote yes or no on a team submitted. its coming back to me
|
|
|
On January 27 2017 19:29 sicklucker wrote:
dumb tell ftw
thanks for the ez read sl
|
was told i'd have to read :/ he owns the second floor. my knee won't let me. but he got me water! \o/
also i guess i'm not town :/ cause i don't get free town points for getting what he's doing
although i kinda like tumble anyway
he's not making sense
a sense making tumble is so not town lol ><
also, hi hts!
also >> super...trying soooo hard. not sure what to make of it. first impulse, town, second impulse wtf, third impulse wobble wobble...also, get a sense of humor
yup
there, i read. now back to kosovo
|
or was it a sense making bf that isn't town?
@.@ why do i always confuse those two
i think it was a bf
disregard then
he's a loose cannon! <- referring to the Rtani not the not-participating bf...or the tumble
|
oh, he told me why now
i can be town again! \o/
|
Get a sense of humor uwot
|
985 Posts
Half the Sky is being replaced out.
We will make another announcement once we have confirmed who the replacement player is.
|
Half the Sky has been replaced by Calix.
|
On January 27 2017 19:27 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2017 17:07 Silverika wrote:On January 27 2017 15:46 sicklucker wrote:On January 27 2017 11:57 Silverika wrote:On January 27 2017 10:43 sicklucker wrote:On January 27 2017 07:38 Chairman Ray wrote:On January 27 2017 07:19 Silverika wrote:
Hi all!! Who has played before? I have one time online and the first mission passed. I'd like to go on the mission since we are members of the Resistance so I'm volunteering. Also, I'll sign my posts, ika42 likely will not. Any high level missions-ones with higher numbers of people that we aren't on will be rejected by us because if one Town voice isn't there, the chances of it being all Town is not high enough to take the risk.
~SilverWolf77 I've played a few hundred games of this live, and I think I played once on TL. Yeah, if you are town, please reject mission 5 if you are not on that mission and most of the time reject mission 4 as well, but for the first three, please use your best judgement. Reason being that in mission 5, even if you think everyone on it is town, they can all just approve it and the mission goes ahead, but on the chance that at least one of them rejects, and people outside the group approves, you need to reject it. For the first three missions, if you are not in the group, please use your best judgement and approve missions you think will pass, because if you reject groups that you are not on, then mafia get to pick which mission passes. I've definitely had a lot of games thrown where town was being too cynical early game or too optimistic late game. I dont see how rejecting missions ever is a good idea for newbs Why not? ~SilverWolf77 because you need to complete missions to win? wtf No shit Sherlock, but your basicly saying "have no dicussion and approve anything and everything" So explain to me why any newbs should jsut blindly go "ok approve" without dicussion. I understood you as saying a town should intentionally fail a mission which is kind of what you said but obvious not what you ment.. because that would be silly
Where the hell did you draw that conclusion?
|
I will not be around this evening btw bc of dnd
|
Ello there.
I've never played Resistance so I have a question. Why don't we just auto-reject the first few teams? lol
If we have 24 hour days then that's clearly the best strategy to ensure that we have enough info on everyone.
Unless it's actually better play to get Mission 1 over and done with. If Mission 1 is as useless as Day 1 in Mafia tends to be then I could see that as a possibility.
|
On January 27 2017 22:05 Silverika wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2017 19:27 sicklucker wrote:On January 27 2017 17:07 Silverika wrote:On January 27 2017 15:46 sicklucker wrote:On January 27 2017 11:57 Silverika wrote:On January 27 2017 10:43 sicklucker wrote:On January 27 2017 07:38 Chairman Ray wrote:On January 27 2017 07:19 Silverika wrote:
Hi all!! Who has played before? I have one time online and the first mission passed. I'd like to go on the mission since we are members of the Resistance so I'm volunteering. Also, I'll sign my posts, ika42 likely will not. Any high level missions-ones with higher numbers of people that we aren't on will be rejected by us because if one Town voice isn't there, the chances of it being all Town is not high enough to take the risk.
~SilverWolf77 I've played a few hundred games of this live, and I think I played once on TL. Yeah, if you are town, please reject mission 5 if you are not on that mission and most of the time reject mission 4 as well, but for the first three, please use your best judgement. Reason being that in mission 5, even if you think everyone on it is town, they can all just approve it and the mission goes ahead, but on the chance that at least one of them rejects, and people outside the group approves, you need to reject it. For the first three missions, if you are not in the group, please use your best judgement and approve missions you think will pass, because if you reject groups that you are not on, then mafia get to pick which mission passes. I've definitely had a lot of games thrown where town was being too cynical early game or too optimistic late game. I dont see how rejecting missions ever is a good idea for newbs Why not? ~SilverWolf77 because you need to complete missions to win? wtf No shit Sherlock, but your basicly saying "have no dicussion and approve anything and everything" So explain to me why any newbs should jsut blindly go "ok approve" without dicussion. I understood you as saying a town should intentionally fail a mission which is kind of what you said but obvious not what you ment.. because that would be silly Where the hell did you draw that conclusion?
Is there confusion between sabatoge a mission and not approve it? Town should, in some instances, vote against a mission if they aren't on it and they believe scum is. As far as sabatoging is concerned, town can't. They pass automatically without even having to say anything. Only scum has to actively decided if they will sabotage or not. So I find it interesting that sicklucker is even considering the possibility of anyone who is town failing missions. Keep in mind, they said newb shouldn't, now they say they were talking about town shouldn't when town can't. Doesn't seem to make sense to me right now.
~SilverWolf77
|
On January 27 2017 22:13 Calix wrote:
Ello there.
I've never played Resistance so I have a question. Why don't we just auto-reject the first few teams? lol
If we have 24 hour days then that's clearly the best strategy to ensure that we have enough info on everyone.
Unless it's actually better play to get Mission 1 over and done with. If Mission 1 is as useless as Day 1 in Mafia tends to be then I could see that as a possibility.
No, auto rejecting a mission gives us NO info whatsoever. Because then, no one goes on a mission, no one can pass or fail, and we sit around with nothing to go off of to determine who is scum and who should be kept off missions so town can win.
~SilverWolf77
|
On January 27 2017 22:17 Silverika wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2017 22:13 Calix wrote:
Ello there.
I've never played Resistance so I have a question. Why don't we just auto-reject the first few teams? lol
If we have 24 hour days then that's clearly the best strategy to ensure that we have enough info on everyone.
Unless it's actually better play to get Mission 1 over and done with. If Mission 1 is as useless as Day 1 in Mafia tends to be then I could see that as a possibility. No, auto rejecting a mission gives us NO info whatsoever. Because then, no one goes on a mission, no one can pass or fail, and we sit around with nothing to go off of to determine who is scum and who should be kept off missions so town can win. ~SilverWolf77
Yep. Vote what you believe in.
|
For the record, I don't understand what the problem is with the SL/ Swika discussion so if SW could explain that then I'd appreciate it.
The only thing that stuck out to me about SL on a skim-read was that he was trying to 'confirm' himself with that dumb tell thing.
|
On January 27 2017 22:17 Silverika wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2017 22:13 Calix wrote:
Ello there.
I've never played Resistance so I have a question. Why don't we just auto-reject the first few teams? lol
If we have 24 hour days then that's clearly the best strategy to ensure that we have enough info on everyone.
Unless it's actually better play to get Mission 1 over and done with. If Mission 1 is as useless as Day 1 in Mafia tends to be then I could see that as a possibility. No, auto rejecting a mission gives us NO info whatsoever. Because then, no one goes on a mission, no one can pass or fail, and we sit around with nothing to go off of to determine who is scum and who should be kept off missions so town can win. ~SilverWolf77
Wait, just realised that people can talk during the voting period. mb
So does that mean that we should accept that Rtanis nomination then? If it's truly random then mafia can't object to it if it has no mafia on it without sticking out like a sore thumb. Although the odds of that being the case are low.
FWIW I would have put in Superbia as he seems pretty townie but I don't know who I'd swap out.
|
I agree that I should be on the first team. And all teams.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
